
Canadian legal group rocked by 2nd high-profile resignation, as treasurer steps down over 'chilling effect'
Sheila Gibb, treasurer at The Advocates' Society since June 2024, who was set to take up the role of vice-president, has stepped down from the group's executive and board of directors.
In a statement posted online Wednesday, Gibb said cancelling an upcoming keynote speech by refugee-turned-entrepreneur Tareq Hadhad at TAS's upcoming event in June has caused "hurt and trauma to many members of our community."
"As an organization whose core value is to be a diverse and inclusive Society, it is TAS's responsibility to create spaces for all members to feel welcome and able to share their perspectives," wrote Gibb.
"We failed to create this space with the End of Term dinner this year."
Hadhad 'held to a standard' others weren't: ex-treasurer
Gibb's resignation comes just days after incoming president Sheree Conlon stepped down from the organization, saying in a letter obtained by CBC News that TAS had "abandoned its values" in rescinding Hadhad's invitation.
TAS has said it did so after concerns were raised by some members about Hadhad's stance on Gaza on social media, in which he has referred to Israel's actions there as "genocide."
As CBC News has previously reported, lawyer Jonathan Lisus was among those who wrote to the organization to flag what he described as Hadhad's "one-sided view" of the conflict, noting Hadhad did not appear to have posted in solidarity with the Israeli victims of Hamas's Oct. 7 attack or the hostages taken that day.
In her statement, Gibb says she believes Hadhad "was held to a standard which other speakers have not been held," adding the move has had "a chilling effect."
"In my view, it is necessary that TAS — and our bar — be able to hold space for different perspectives and difficult discussions," said Gibb.
"I see this as foundational to TAS's core values, and also critical given where we find ourselves in the world: with increasing polarization, diminishing opportunities for civil discourse on difficult topics, and the related risks to our bar, our system of justice, and our democracy — as we are seeing south of the border."
Meanwhile, in a statement Monday, Hadhad said he was moved by the outpouring of support he has received since the cancellation.
As for his stance on Gaza, he said: "to suggest that I am 'unsympathetic' or 'indifferent' to the suffering of Jewish people is both inaccurate and deeply hurtful."
"I believe that to grieve the suffering of one group does not mean the exclusion of another ... that includes civilians in Syria, in Gaza, in Israel, in Ukraine and in every corner of the world where people are caught in the crossfire of violence."

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Winnipeg Free Press
24 minutes ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Liberal MPs call for Canada to join France in recognizing Palestinian state
OTTAWA – Liberal members of Parliament are publicly calling on the Canadian government to follow France's lead in recognizing Palestine as a state. Toronto-area MP Salma Zahid said on a social media post that Canada must join France in announcing its recognition of a state for the Palestinian people MP Fares Al Soud, who also represents the Toronto area, posted a message on social media saying that justice for the Palestinian people 'demands recognition.' French President Emmanuel Macron says he intends to formally recognize a Palestinian state in September during the United Nations General Assembly. When asked whether Prime Minister Mark Carney would do the same, his team did not respond to the question. Carney's office instead referred The Canadian Press to a social media post by the prime minister on Thursday in which he said Canada supports a two-state solution that 'guarantees peace and security for Israelis and Palestinians.' This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 25, 2025.


Winnipeg Free Press
24 minutes ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Israeli ambassador rejects PM Carney's criticism of aid delivery in Gaza
OTTAWA – Israel's ambassador in Ottawa has issued a statement rejecting Canada's 'condemnation' of humanitarian aid delivery in Gaza. The statement from Ambassador Iddo Moed urges Canada to keep up pressure on Hamas to release hostages and support a comprehensive framework to end the war. It comes after Prime Minister Mark Carney on Thursday accused the Israeli government of failing to prevent a humanitarian crisis in Gaza and of violating international law by denying aid. In a post on X, Carney said Israel's control of aid distribution must be replaced by 'comprehensive provision' of humanitarian assistance led by international organizations. Moed insists in his statement that Israel is committed to upholding international law and is serving as an 'active partner' in facilitating the flow of aid into Gaza. Canada is among more than two dozen countries, along with the United Kingdom, Japan and Australia, that issued a joint statement earlier this week calling for an immediate end to the conflict in Gaza. This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 25, 2025.


Toronto Star
39 minutes ago
- Toronto Star
A Lebanese pro-Palestinian militant returns home after 40 years in a French prison
BEIRUT (AP) — A Lebanese pro-Palestinian communist militant returned to his hometown in Lebanon on Friday following his release after more than 40 years in prison in France. Georges Ibrahim Abdallah, 74, was serving a life sentence for complicity in the murders of two diplomats, one American and one Israeli, in Paris in 1982.