HSE paid medical products company €720,000 twice for the same invoice
The HSE said it was 'engaged with the liquidator to recover and resolve this overpayment, among other matters'. So far the overpayment has not been recouped.
The HSE said that, at the time of the liquidation, the company had maintained it was owed additional money by the health service but this was not paid 'pending the resolution of the double payment issue and other matters'.
The HSE identified the company that received the two payments as PMD Device Solutions Ltd.
READ MORE
In February, PMD Device Solutions Ltd petitioned the High Court for the appointment of provisional liquidators, acknowledging it was 'clearly insolvent', with more than €14.6 million in liabilities set against €4.6 million in assets.
The company claimed it was owed approximately €1.2 million by the HSE and had issued High Court proceedings against the health authority. This is being contested.
The liquidator did not respond to a request for comment.
The Irish Times reported on Friday that the HSE financial report for 2024 showed one company had been paid more than €720,000 from two different parts of the health service on foot of the same invoice. No cross-checking had been carried out.
'The payments were made from two legacy areas [that] were previously on separate ledgers managed by different HSE staff,' it said, adding that the HSE now has an integrated financial and procurement system.
[
Provisional liquidators appointed to Cork medical supplies company
Opens in new window
]
PMD Device Solutions was established in Co Cork in October 2011. It developed medical products for respiratory monitoring.
In early 2024 the then minister of state at the Department of Finance, Jennifer Carroll MacNeill, now Minister for Health, attended a ceremony to ring the bell at the Nasdaq Stockholm exchange in Sweden to mark an acquisition involving the company.
The HSE annual report, published last Friday, says the supplier paid twice had entered into an arrangement with the health service in 2020 for the supply of diagnostic devices, ancillary supplies and information technology. It says the overall system 'was considered to be of significant value in monitoring the condition of Covid-19 patients in hospital settings'.
The supplier received about €15 million between 2020 and 2024.
It says the arrangement was initially put in place on an emergency basis during the pandemic and was never then regularised through an appropriate competitive tendering process.
The report says different HSE units were invoiced from time to time.
'This included prepayment each quarter from mid-2022 to mid-2024 for supply of a standard number of devices, to be drawn down as required by individual hospitals.'
The report says the HSE did not maintain central records of the total number of units paid for, and the number of devices received by hospitals, or paid for and remaining undrawn from the supplier, is not known.
'The executive also does not know how many of the items paid for were actually used in its hospitals.'
Separately, the HSE this week provided more details on the write-off of what its financial accounts described as an 'asset' constructed in 2009 at a cost of €1.4 million. It was never used for its intended purposes and was written off last year at a cost of €800,000, according to the accounts.
The HSE said the write-off related to a planned initiative to develop a hydrotherapy pool.
'A number of factors arising meant that it could not come to fruition and the space was given over to the further capital development of essential clinical capacity. This capital development has delivered six additional outpatient consulting rooms, expanded clinical storage, and hot desk facilities for clinical staff,' the HSE said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
31 minutes ago
- Irish Times
One Night in Dublin ... with the bouncers at Copper Face Jacks: Once you're gone, you're gone
The Coppers bouncers see the dodgy man early and eye him as he snakes his way up the queue to the main door of Ireland's most famous nightclub. Before the middle-aged man in the tan leather jacket has any real notion of what's going on, the crash barriers part just wide enough for him to be ushered away from the entrance. He sways gently in the warm Saturday night breeze, his momentary confusion quickly replaced by annoyance. His protestations of sobriety – a bit too loud and a bit too indignant – fall on deaf ears as disinterested bouncers turn away. The scene is repeated occasionally outside Copper Face Jacks on a Saturday summer night but the security staff handle the odd drunk calmly and with little fuss. Once you're gone, you're gone – and protestations are stonewalled with a firm: 'Sorry, it's not happening.' READ MORE As the man in the tan jacket weaves away, a group of laughing young women in Dublin GAA jerseys carrying a small silver cup rock up. They're exuberant but sober(ish) and get to skip the queue when Cathal Jackson, the Coppers King, hears they're All-Ireland winners. Cathal Jackson, owner of Copper Face Jacks, with captain Aoife Deegan and Meadhbh Hicks of the Dublin under-23 camogie team. Photograph: Conor Pope Despite the fact that Coppers has made Jackson a millionaire many times over – it was nearly sold seven years ago for €40 million, andits cloakroom alone makes him a reported annual profit of more than €250,000 – the almost 70-year-old former garda from the midlands still stands at the door four nights a week watching folk file past his team of seasoned bouncers. [ From the archive: Copper Face Jacks reports surge in profits after pandemic lockdown rules lifted Opens in new window ] It's far from all this he was reared. On a leave of absence from the guards, this son of a garda, took a punt on an unfashionable street in Dublin 2 in early 1996. 'It was quiet enough for the first six weeks or so but after that it took off and it never really stopped,' he says, as the bag of chips bought for his dinner goes cold. There was a perception always that it was country people, guards and nurses who went to Coppers but its much more cosmopolitan now — Aidan McCormack The secret seems obvious now but it wasn't then. Coppers focused as much on Mondays and Tuesdays as on weekends and became hugely popular with weekend workers including – famously – guards and nurses. And it never got too hung up on being cool or exclusive. The music was always popular and familiar, and the craic was always 90. People went to Coppers to dance and to laugh and for the odd shift. By 12.30am the queue is long and the dance floors heaving. A couple in their 40s mill the faces off each other at the bar but pretty much everyone else seems happy to dance. It's not a place for heavy drinking, with the average spend per punter less than €20 or three pints of lager. Jackson's happy with that. He doesn't want messy drunks in his club; they cause more trouble than they're worth. Managing the staff is Aidan McCormack, a Coppers lifer who celebrates his 30th anniversary on the door next February. He likes working in what he says is the most famous nightclub in Ireland. 'It's known all over the world. There was a perception always that it was country people, guards and nurses who went to Coppers but its much more cosmopolitan now,' he says. What are the most important things to remember when working the door? 'We want people to say they had a good night,' he says. 'But the first thing people have to be is the proper age and they can't be intoxicated.' As he speaks, five lads shuffle up a bit too sheepishly. Almost everyone going to Coppers has their ID checked and this group is no exception. Of the five, one 18-year-old boy is refused. He looks heartbroken but his buddies rally round and they leave together, laughing. When it's pointed out to McCormack that most people going into a nightclub at midnight have drink taken, he acknowledges the point. 'We show common sense,' he says. 'You see those two steps at the doorway,' he adds, pointing downwards. 'They're very handy and if people can't manage them it's a sign, for sure.' Dublin Camogie players at the top of the queue heading into Coppers. Photograph: Conor Pope The bouncers don't just rely on the two-steps, though. 'We've layers of security as people come through,' McCormack continues. 'One looks at your face straight on and another watches as you walk past and then a third will cast an eye over you. You might get past one doorman, but you're not going to get past three of us. 'But we're not really here to refuse people. We're just here to make sure that no one is too young or likely to cause trouble.' Noel Holloway has been on the door for 18 years, while Michael Burke, standing beside him, has been here for 13 years. They're smiley rather than stony-faced and laugh and joke through the night. When Holloway is asked what the biggest challenges in his job are he doesn't skip a beat. 'It's working with these Muppets,' he says. As he talks, his eyes never leave the queue. 'We know people come with fake IDs so we sometimes ask to see a bank card to confirm names match,' he says. He pauses. 'But a lot of young people don't carry bank cards so we ask to see their social media accounts to be sure. But even then a lot of young ones have fake social media accounts to match the names on their fake ID. It can be tricky,' he says. Across from Coppers are two relaxed guards. 'This street is self-policing in some ways,' one says. 'All the nightclubs, but particularly Coppers, are well run. There's very little messing and the security staff know what they're doing. They've been doing it long enough anyway.' It's 1am and the queue is long. When Jackson is asked what he looks for in a bouncer he says first what he doesn't want – excessive physicality. 'It's much more important that we can talk people down,' he says. A young woman approaches and asks for paracetamol. She's ushered to the on-site medical room to be seen by the paramedic. Minutes later somebody else comes out and says she has a headache. She too is taken care of. Jackson shrugs when The Irish Times expresses amazement that people ask bouncers for painkillers and are looked after. Copper Face Jacks: 'All the nightclubs, but particularly Coppers, are well run,' says one of the gardaí on Harcourt Street. Photograph: Aidan Crawley 'It's what we do anyway,' he says. Minutes pass and a young woman wanders out lost and disorientated. Discreetly Jackson tells staff to make sure she isn't alone. 'We'd never leave a young woman out here on her own,' he says. The girl, it emerges, has pals to take care of her so the night goes on. By 2am more than 1,000 people are inside; it has a capacity of between 1,400 and 1,700 depending on which areas are opened up – and the mood is exuberant. The doors must close and the punters must be sent home by 2.30am. It infuriates Jackson who repeatedly expresses bafflement that the licensing laws in the State have yet to be updated to allow people if they so wish to dance later into the night. [ From the archive: Just how did Ireland end up with such weird licensing laws? Opens in new window ] 'We are not the same as the late bars so it makes no sense to me that we have to work under the same rules,' he says. 'People certainly aren't drinking as much as they used to,' he adds. 'Some are using other stimulants. There's a lot more cocaine around the city.' But he says there is a very strict policy when it comes to cocaine in Coppers. 'We have a zero-tolerance policy on that,' he says as the craic-fuelled dancing goes on behind him, with Sunday morning probably feeling like a long, long way away for the Coppers clubbers. Next in the 'One Night in Dublin' series - a night at the museum; a noctural walkabout at IMMA - on Tuesday
Irish Times
31 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Counting the cost of food waste: ‘People don't have enough to eat not due to lack of production, but lack of access'
In Ireland , each person throws out about 44kg of food in a year, which is, roughly speaking, a large supermarket trolley full of food. But, if you add in all the food that is wasted in shops , restaurants, catering companies, food processing plants and farms, that figure amounts to the equivalent of about 167kg per individual. The economic and environmental costs of such waste are often discussed. Food waste costs each household in the State around €700 annually and food loss and food waste account for 8-10 per cent of global greenhouse gas emissions. But the ethical dimension to wasting food is something that food banks also focus on. 'People don't have enough food to eat not because of lack of production but due to lack of access to food,' said Esteban Arriaga, chief executive of the European Food Banks Federation on a recent visit to Dublin. FoodCloud, an Irish food redistribution charity, reckons it shares out just over 1 per cent of the wasted food fit for human consumption that could be available for donation. READ MORE 'FoodCloud distributed about 3,900 tonnes of food last year, and if we want to reach about 5 per cent reduction in food waste through redistribution we will have to do seven times more than we currently do,' said Iseult Ward, co-founder of FoodCloud. [ AIB-FoodCloud partnership has prevented 15,000 tonnes of food from going to waste Opens in new window ] Surplus food donated by FoodCloud to Citywise Education, a charity in Tallaght, is used to promote healthy eating through its Ready Steady Cook challenges for young people. FoodCloud donations to Citywise also supply its cafe, with any extras left out for anybody to take. 'We are able to run an informal, discreet food bank for our members with anything we don't use ourselves. It's quite elaborate really – anything we won't use, we leave on a table in the cafe and by the next day, it's gone,' says Daire Hennessy, chief executive of Citywise, which provides after-school and out-of-school support for hundreds of young people. At their 2025 convention in Dublin, the federation of European food bank operators teased out measures to stimulate more food donation. These include the introduction of a so-called good-Samaritan law, which would introduce a special waiver for businesses making good-faith food donations to charity. With such a law, companies would not be liable if someone later became ill as a result of eating the food. Aoibheann O'Brien and Iseult Ward of Irish non-profit food-distribution social enterprise FoodCloud. Photograph: Matthew Thompson 'This will reassure potential donors and redistribution organisations, increasing food donations and reducing legal concerns that prevent participation in food recovery efforts,' said a recent report on food waste and donation in the EU by the Food Law and Policy Clinic at Harvard Law School. Anecdotal evidence suggests some retailers and food distributors hold back products perfectly suitable for donation for fear of reputational damage in the unlikely event someone gets sick from a batch of donated food. Still, the recent outbreak of listeriosis relating to ready meals illustrates the risks associated with contaminated food. Food waste costs the average Irish household about €60 per month, equating to an annual national cost of €1.29 billion — Harvard Law School study 'This is a fear that lots of food businesses have that we think will ultimately only be overcome if Ireland introduces a good-Samaritan law,' said Angela Ruttledge, head of policy at FoodCloud. Ruttledge was keen to point out that food safety protocols are followed for all food given to charities via FoodCloud hubs or its Foodiverse app, which links donors with recipients directly. Earlier this year, a Harvard Law School study examined Irish food policies, government grants and incentives, and food-waste strategies to see how food donation could be increased in the State. That paper noted how best-before and use-by date labels on food confuse people about what is safe and unsafe to eat and contributes to food waste. 'Most food waste occurred within three sectors: manufacturing and processing (31 per cent), households (29 per cent), and restaurants and food service (21 per cent),' the paper stated. Daire Hennessy: 'Anything we won't use, we leave on a table in the cafe and by the next day, it's gone.' Photograph: Bryan O'Brien 'Food waste costs the average Irish household about €60 per month, equating to an annual national cost of €1.29 billion.' Improving the policy landscape for food donation will support efforts for a more responsible food system, the paper added. 'EU regulations require foods to have either a safety-based (use by) date mark or a quality-based (best before) date mark. Food can be donated after its best-before date but not after its use-by date mark,' said Ruttledge. The policymakers behind Ireland's National Food Waste Prevention Roadmap 2023- 2025, which sets out priority actions to prevent waste, are currently considering the impact of introducing a good-Samaritan act. The Department of Climate, Energy and the Environment – which updates the roadmap – acknowledged that there needs to be more consumer awareness about the difference between best-before and use-by dates on food. A ban on the destruction of food on its best-before date is also under consideration. The Harvard paper also suggested tax credits to allay the costs of transporting food for donation, and a VAT exemption on food that is donated. In countries, such as France, financial penalties and legal obligations have reduced food waste significantly. 'In France 10 per cent of food waste is donated from primary production, manufacturing and retailers. Businesses risk fines or consumer mistrust if they don't donate in France,' said Chris Hill, operations director with FoodCloud. The mandatory donation of surplus food is another way to force retailers and processors to stop wasting food that is fit for human consumption. 'If we had mandatory donation of food here, we'd first have to respect the food-waste hierarchy to help businesses valorise food surpluses,' Ruttledge said. This means encouraging more food processors and retailers to sell surplus food at a reduced price first. And then to donate any food fit for human consumption that isn't sold. Food unfit for human consumption should be sent for animal feed and anything that is left sent for anaerobic digestion. However, preventing food waste in the first place should, of course, be the top priority of food producers, processors, distributors and retailers. [ How an Irish 'virtual food bank' is redistributing surplus food sustainably in Europe Opens in new window ] Positive Carbon, an Irish start-up company, has developed AI-powered sensors to track and ultimately eliminate food waste in hotels and restaurants. Its automated system allows kitchen staff, operations and management teams to see what is being wasted and make changes to purchasing, preparation and production practices. Revisions to the EU Waste Framework Directive , which are expected to be passed this autumn, will make it mandatory for food processors and manufacturers to reduce waste by 10 per cent by 2030. Householders, retailers, restaurants and cafes will have to reduce their food waste by 30 per cent by 2030. To meet these targets, much greater efforts to reduce food waste right across the food chain will need to be made.
Irish Times
31 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Barack Obama ‘should receive no welcome in Ireland': freedom of Dublin debate reopens
History is repeating itself in Dublin's City Hall. In 2017, a proposal to award the freedom of the capital to former US president Barack Obama and his wife Michelle faced some opposition before being approved by 30 to 23 votes. It had been proposed by then lord mayor Brendan Carr, of Labour, who cited the Democrat's Irish roots and support for peace in Northern Ireland, shortly after Obama was succeeded by Donald Trump. While he did not wish to 'canonise the Obamas' or declare his presidency 'a success', Carr said Obama was a 'stabilising and moderating' influence on US foreign policy. 'A similar era, unfortunately, will not be experienced again for some time,' he said. Eight years on, Trump is having a destabilising start to his second term, and debate about awarding the Obamas the freedom of the city has resumed. Dublin's Lord Mayor Ray McAdam, of Fine Gael, has written to the couple suggesting they accept the award in late September when visiting the city for a sold-out event at the 3Arena, An Evening with President Barack Obama, In Conversation with Fintan O'Toole . People Before Profit councillor Conor Reddy urged McAdam to withdraw the invite. 'Obama is just as complicit in the [Gaza] genocide and ethnic cleansing of Palestinians as his successors – Biden and Trump,' he said. 'For this reason alone, he should receive no welcome in Ireland.' Reddy and his colleague Hazel De Nortúin say they will bring an 'emergency motion' to September's council meeting calling for the award to be revoked should McAdam opt to proceed. Druid seeks new chief executive as it plans for next 50 years Anneliese Davidsen is leaving her role as Druid theatre company's as executive director in the autumn. Photograph: Druid Are you an energetic and results driven self-starter who can balance creative risk with sound financial management? Really? Well, there's a job going that might work for you. Druid Theatre Company is seeking a chief executive to succeed Anneliese Davidsen, who is stepping down as executive director this autumn and switching Galway for London after less than two years. In that time, Druid said, Davidsen delivered 'record-breaking national tours' of Sean O'Casey's The Shadow of a Gunman and Three Short Comedies; and won five-star ratings for productions of The House by Tom Murphy, Macbeth, and Samuel Beckett's Endgame. 'She leaves the company in great shape as it celebrates its 50th anniversary,' said Adrian O'Neill, chairman of the Druid board. Druid's production of Endgame by Samuel Beckett received five-star reviews. Photograph: Ros Kavanagh A post on the company's website says the new chief executive 'will join Druid at a time of great success' and when planning is under way for its '2026 programme and the next 50 years'. A separate job advert says responsibilities will include cultivating a culture of 'excellence in every aspect of the organisation' and ensuring Druid's purpose is 'inspiring, ambitious and clear'. Sensibly enough, a background and interest in the performing arts and 'a good understanding of, and empathy for, Druid and its vision' are desirable. A passion for and knowledge of the arts scene in Galway, and nationally, is preferable. A fixed five-year term contract and 'a competitive salary reflecting the significance of the position' are on offer. Good luck to the candidates, or should that be break a leg? Kevin 'Boxer' Moran in flood water in Athlone, Co Westmeath. Photograph: Brian Lawless/PA Wire Kevin 'General Custer' Moran faces exhausting trip to Kerry As someone based near the river Shannon, Minister of State for the Office of Public Works Kevin 'Boxer' Moran knows his onions when it comes to flooding. In early 2020 he posted a video of himself topless in a pair of waders in Athlone helping to connect a pump in an attempt to combat rising waters in Athlone. 'That's it – job done. I'm drowned f***ing wet though,' he says. 'I nearly got sick with the smell of it ... There's one sure thing, she won't kiss me tonight anyway.' Got a bit wet this morning trying to get a pump going down at the back of Parnell Square, no spare set of clothes but the people are protected that's the main thing. — Kevin 'Boxer' Moran (@kevinboxermoran) Kerry Fianna Fáil TD Michael Cahill was hoping for a sympathetic ear before the Dáil recess when he asked Moran if he would provide funding to tackle erosion and flooding in 10 places including his own 'neck of the woods', Rossbeigh, where there 'are huge problems'. Moran said the Government had committed €81 million for flood relief schemes in Kerry, naming several places, but Rossbeigh was not among them. 'Other areas in Kerry also need coastal protection works, for example, Waterville and my local beach in Rossbeigh,' Cahill pointedly replied. Moran again omitted mention of Rossbeigh in his next response, but he empathised and promised to visit Kerry, including the areas mentioned by Cahill. 'For many of the people affected, the Minister of State is General Custer making his last stand,' Cahill said. Leas-Cheann Comhairle John McGuinness said he feared that by the time the Minister of State 'finished that tour of Kerry' he might too 'exhausted' to make it to his own constituency of Carlow-Kilkenny. 'I will ask my line manager if he will organise a helicopter because I have had so many requests today that I will be flying,' Moran replied. Declan Ganley. Photograph: Cyril Byrne Chatbot laps up Ganley's alternative to solar power Businessman Declan Ganley , who has reportedly sounded out Oireachtas members about supporting a presidential run, is no stranger to a campaign. He opposed the Lisbon Treaty in 2008, an effort that succeeded for a while; came close to winning a European Parliament seat in 2009 under the Libertas banner; and spoke out against repealing the Eighth Amendment in 2018. More recently, he has railed against plans for a huge solar project near his Co Galway home. Power Capital Renewable Energy, a French-backed Irish firm, is preparing plans for what would be Ireland's largest solar farm/battery storage facility over hundreds of acres between Abbeyknockmoy and Monivea. Local opponents argue it would threaten local food production, biodiversity and rural heritage and Ganley has been using his X social media account to publicise his concerns about 'Absentee SolarLords' burying part of the parish under 'a desert of black glass'. 'The mobilisation of local resistance is unlike anything I have seen in my 30 years in this village,' he wrote. Ever the entrepreneur, Ganley then started a conversation with Grok, X's AI chatbot, about a patent for a tidal power system that has been 'sitting in my drawer of inventions since 2007'. 'Impressive patent, Declan,' Grok said. 'I was going to build a prototype but had too much else going on,' Ganley replied. 'Understandable – life gets busy…,' Grok added. The lengthy back and forth ended with Grok writing a letter to 'The Irish Government' saying Ganley's tidal patent would be 'superior to solar in reliability, impact, and long-term value'. If only convincing a planning authority, or an electorate, were so easy.
