Minister denies Sinn Féin's claim anti-terrorism Bill contains a ‘Kneecap' clause
Minister for Justice
Jim O'Callaghan
has rejected Opposition claims that
Kneecap
band member Liam Óg Ó hAnnaidh could be prosecuted under antiterrorism legislation being introduced in the Dáil.
Sinn Féin justice spokesman
Matt Carthy
described provisions of the Criminal Justice (Terrorism Offences) (Amendment) Bill as the 'Kneecap clause' in the
wake of the prosecution
in England of the Belfast band member whose stage name is 'Mo Chara'.
He was charged under UK antiterrorism legislation with showing support for a proscribed organisation. It is alleged he draped himself in a
Hizbullah
flag at a London gig last November and shouted 'up
Hamas
, up Hizbullah', referring to the Palestinian and Lebanese militant groups respectively. He is contesting the charge.
The proposed new Irish legislation broadens the category of terrorist offences to bring it in line with a 2017 EU directive, to include travelling or facilitating travel for the purposes of terrorism and receiving or providing training for terrorism.
READ MORE
The Bill also revises the definition of provoking terrorism, stating that the glorification of a terrorist activity, including by praise or celebration, 'may be considered publicly provoking the commission of a terrorist offence'.
Mr Carthy, who called this the 'Kneecap clause', said it is 'deeply problematic' because 'there is a real fear that this inclusion could lead to charges against political activism and legitimate freedom of expression, similar to the manner in which Mo Chara from Kneecap is currently facing terrorism charges in the UK'.
This sort of antiterrorism legislation 'undercuts civil liberties, free speech and the rule of law, with little or no effect on actual terrorist activity', he said.
'It is exactly the type of language that has been used, in the North in particular, to attempt to curtail the rights of families to remember loved ones killed in the conflict in the six counties. It has equally been used in arguments against commemorating the 1916 Rising or wearing an Easter lily,' he said.
But Mr O'Callaghan said 'what Kneecap is being prosecuted for in the UK would not happen here'.
[
Fans rally behind Kneecap after London court appearance: 'If you're supporting Ireland, you're supporting Kneecap'
Opens in new window
]
'Under this legislation, people would be entitled to say they support Hamas, although it has been involved in reprehensible behaviour,' he said.
Describing the UK legislation as 'alarmingly wide' and a provision 'that would not be enacted by this House', he said that under the UK law it is an offence if a person in a public place 'wears, carries or displays an article in such a way or in such circumstances as to arouse reasonable suspicion that he is a member or supporter of a proscribed organisation'.
Sinn Féin's Mark Ward said people singing republican songs about Irish heroes could be prosecuted under the legislation.
However, the Minister said the deputy could sing whatever songs he wants. 'People can sing songs about the Boys of Barr na Sráide and the Men Behind the Wire. In loyalist parts of Belfast, they can sing whatever they want.'
He said TDs' 'concern that this will have a restrictive impact on protest or freedom of expression is not accurate'.
'The only time your message is going to come within the criminal law and face criminal sanction is if it is being done with the intention of inciting someone else to commit criminal terrorist activity.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Government measures designed to drive apartment building are ‘not as effective in practice as envisaged'
Government measures designed to drive apartment building are 'not as effective in practice' as originally envisaged, the Department of Finance has been told. This includes the Croí Cónaithe (Cities) fund, which seeks to roll out €450 million in funding to support the construction of 5,000 new apartments. A Department of Finance paper on the future of the State-owned property development lender Home Building Finance Ireland (HBFI) outlines how this scheme and others have been criticised by market stakeholders it consulted with in recent months. While there was support for the intent of the measures, the report outlines that 'stakeholders advised that as currently designed, these schemes are not as effective in practice as envisaged'. READ MORE Developers want the Croí Cónaithe (Cities) fund to be restructured so that subsidies are paid earlier in the development cycle, rather than when an apartment is sold to an owner-occupier – which is currently the case. 'This means that even when a scheme is preapproved, there is no certainty that the subsidy will be made available,' the report outlines, citing feedback from the market. Only larger developers with healthy balance sheets can use it, according to the document, with small and medium-sized developers being effectively frozen out. At the moment, 'it is unlikely to become a scalable solution for the delivery of owner-occupier apartments,' the report notes. [ First-time buyers in Dublin now locked out of Help-to-Buy scheme, warns Savills Opens in new window ] Earlier this year, The Irish Times reported that the scheme is on track to deliver less than 20 per cent of the apartments it originally aimed to build. The report outlines that similar criticisms were made of another scheme, the Secure Tenancy Affordable Rental programme. The report outlines that Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe is to extend the lifespan of the HBFI body by another two years. Since inception, it has loaned out €2.7 billion in State-backed borrowing, equivalent to allow for the construction of 13,186 new homes. It will now be given another two years to continue its work before its effectiveness is reviewed again. The report also outlines a range of other concerns included in feedback from lenders, developers, investors and representative groups. This includes that while debt financing is available for viable developments, such opportunities are few and far between with sites held back by a variety of factors. These include a lack of certainty around planning timelines, the risk of judicial review of a planning decision and the provision of enabling infrastructure. These issues are particularly acute for smaller developers, it outlines. Feedback given to the authors also pinpoints an ever-shifting policy backdrop as a difficult, with uncertainty about what the Government may do next acting 'as a disincentive to investors committing capital to Ireland.'
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Record domestic violence calls to Free Legal Advice Centres
Domestic violence-related calls to the State's Free Legal Advice Centres (Flac) reached a record level of 539 last year and queries in relation to family law accounted for more than a quarter of all calls answered. The organisation received an estimated 53,103 calls to its information and referral line last year but only had the capacity to deal with about one in five of these queries, according to its annual report published today. Family law remained the area in which Flac received the most queries, at 3,180 of the 11,435 calls answered. Callers to the phoneline frequently reported being unable to access a family law solicitor from the Legal Aid Board 's private practitioner panel even though they had been approved for legal aid, Flac said. The phoneline answered 2,341 employment law queries. Queries about grievance procedures, dismissal, bullying or harassment, and discrimination were all higher than in any previous year, it said. READ MORE 'The overwhelming demand for Flac's services points to nothing less than a civil legal aid crisis,' Flac chief executive Eilis Barry said. 'As a small NGO, we cannot begin to meet this demand but the ways in which we work provide a blueprint for a new era of civil legal aid in this country.' A perception that civil legal aid was 'about more money for lawyers' had perhaps created a resistance to its provision she said. 'This ignores the very high cost of not providing legal aid to children, families and communities, and the growing body of international research that shows unequivocally that investment in legal aid saves States more money than it costs. Civil Legal Aid needs to be treated like the vital public service which it is.' Ms Barry said she hoped the example Flac provided would inform the Government's response. 'This response should include enabling and resourcing the Legal Aid Board to provide legal information and advice to address the huge unmet need for these services.' It should also involve enabling the board to provide representation in employment, discrimination, social welfare and housing cases, she said, and include the provision of dedicated legal services for disadvantaged communities, including a properly-resourced national Traveller legal service, and a national network of community law centres. Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan said Flac's funding had been increased by 12.6 per cent in 2025. 'The increase in calls relating to domestic violence, as highlighted in the report, is a stark reminder of the ongoing need for accessible legal information and support. I commend Flac for their tireless work in supporting vulnerable members of society and reaffirming the Government's commitment to tackling domestic and gender-based violence in all its forms.'
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Justice plan to overhaul local community safety partnerships to replace joint policing committees
Membership of key liaison groups between communities and gardaí focused on local policing and safety is to be expanded, under new regulations coming into force on Monday. Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan has signed regulations which will replace joint policing committees (JPCs) with new local community safety partnerships (LCSPs) and govern how the new structures will operate. The move comes after concerns were outlined by some on local authorities, including Dublin City Council , about the new structure. Government sources said there were measures to in the new system safeguard the position of local politicians, however. READ MORE There will be mandatory representatives among the membership from local authorities, with one LCSP set up in each of the 36 local authority areas around the country. Each one will also feature representation from An Garda Síochána , the Health Service Executive and a representative of child and family agency Tusla . Seven elected members from each local authority will be nominated to each partnership by the county or city council, with other local politicians given opportunities to engage with them directly. They will also include a wider membership than their predecessors, with residents, local councillors, members representing younger and older people and minority groups eligible to sit on the bodies. Business and education representatives will also be included, with up to 30 members allowed on each body. They will be mandated to hold at least six meetings per year, with no upper ceiling put on the number of times they can convene. Members of the public must be allowed to attend at least one of the meetings, and representatives of the Oireachtas and the relevant local authority will also be invited to attend at least one of the annual meetings. A voluntary chairperson and a vice-chairperson will be elected from among the membership, with each partnership required to develop and implement a tailored community safety plan. The decision to replace the JPCs had faced criticism from some local authority members, who claimed they would downgrade the role held by county and city councillors. In 2023 the then minister for justice Helen McEntee moved to reassure councillors that their role would not be marginalised, and that legislation and regulations underpinning the new structures would make it explicit that they could chair community safety partnerships. Mr O'Callaghan argued that the establishment of the partnerships 'marks a significant step toward a more collaborative, responsive and locally driven approach to community safety'. He added that while Ireland is generally regarded as a safe country with relatively low crime rates, the reality is different for some communities. 'We need the structures put in place at a local level so longer-term solutions which are not focused solely on policing can be put in place. Bad public lighting, waste collection, poor planning of public spaces, the location of services all contribute to feelings of safety in our towns,' he said.
