Why did ScotGov support award of ferry contracts to firms abroad
It has been confirmed successful sea trials means that MV Isle of Islay - one of the first of the four ferries being built in Turkey in the wake of Scotland's ferry fiasco - is on target to be delivered sometime between next month and September.
Meanwhile concerns have emerged that vital funding needed to have one key contract to build seven smaller ferries directly awarded to state-owned Ferguson Marine was not considered justified by ministers.
Why did CMAL award ferry contracts to shipyards in Turkey and Poland?
The Scottish Government -owned ferry and port owner CMAL awarded contracts to build ferries to Cemre Shipyard in Turkey and Remontowa Shipbuilding in Poland based on competitive procurement processes. These shipyards demonstrated the capability to deliver vessels that met technical specifications, timelines, and budgetary constraints.
The Cemre yard and (inset) one of the vessels it is delivering for Scotland (Image: .) Remontowa was awarded a £175 million contract to build seven all-electric ferries, having received the highest score during the bidding process .
The Turkish shipyard Cemre Marin Endustri was contracted to construct four new roll-on/roll-off passenger and vehicle ferries for Scotland's west coast ferry network. These vessels are intended to enhance services on routes to the Isle of Islay and the Little Minch corridor, which includes Skye, Harris, and North Uist. The deals together were worth £220m.
Why was Ferguson Marine, the Scots state-owned shipyard firm not awarded these contracts?
The Inverclyde firm had faced several challenges that affected its competitiveness in the bidding process.
Firstly a lack of experience. The shipyard had not completed any ferries in the past five years, failing to meet the tender's requirement to show recent experience in building at least three similar ferries.
READ MORE:
'Laughable': Turkey-built ferry to be delivered seven years faster than fiasco ship
Cost to repair CalMac ferry now £2m more than to buy replacement
Why has a 'rudderless' CalMac ferry been out of action for 16 months
'Final nail in coffin'. Scots fiasco firm loses out on big ferry contract to Poland
'Material uncertainty' over Scots ferry operator future amidst £45m funding hike
'Mismanagement': Public cost of Scots ferry fiasco firm hits £750m amidst overspends
It had financial and operational issues. Ferguson Marine's previous projects, such as the Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa, were significantly delayed and over budget, raising concerns about the yard's financial stability and project management capabilities.
CMAL's procurement process emphasized technical and financial suitability. Ferguson Marine is understood to have not scored as highly as other bidders in these areas.
What were the issues with the Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa projects?
The issues with Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa has become known as Scotland's ferry fiasco.
Glen Rosa and Glen Sannox's arrival to serve islands was scheduled to be online in the first half of 2018. Glen Sannox finally went into service on January but islanders are still awaiting the arrival of Glen Rosa.
Glen Sannox (Image: Andrew Milligan/PA) Both vessels were significantly behind schedule and over budget. Glen Rosa's delivery has been delayed until spring 2026, with costs soaring.
Costs of the entire project are currently expected to have multiplied at least five-fold from the original £96m price.
The delays were down to design and construction flaws. Problems included inadequate planning, quality issues, and a lack of detailed construction plans with CMAL and Ferguson Marine blaming each other for failings.
The contract also lacked adequate financial safeguards, such as a builder's refund guarantee, which would have protected public funds in case of project failures.
What are the implications of awarding contracts to overseas shipyards?
Awarding contracts to overseas shipyards has both advantages and disadvantages.
Overseas shipyards like Cemre and Remontowa, it is felt, have demonstrated the ability to deliver vessels on time and within budget.
These shipyards have experience building similar vessels, ensuring adherence to technical specifications.
But the disadvantages are the economic impact on Scotland.
Excluding domestic shipyards like Ferguson Marine can have negative effects on local employment and the Scottish shipbuilding industry.
Ferguson Marine has previously indicated that losing ferry contracts had an effect on its ability to continue as a going concern.
Ferguson Marine (Image: Colin Mearns) The decisions on the contracts have sparked political criticism and debates over the government's commitment to supporting domestic industries.
What lessons have been learned from these experiences?
While the decision to award ferry contracts to overseas shipyards was based on factors like cost, efficiency, and technical capability, it has raised important questions about the future of domestic shipbuilding in Scotland and the need for improved procurement practices.
The challenges faced in ferry procurement have highlighted the need for robust procurement processes and that contracts should include builder's refund guarantees to protect public funds.
It has also shown the requirement to balance the need for cost-effective procurement with the importance of supporting local industries.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
3 hours ago
- Daily Record
Braehead Arena drops merch charges to support grass-roots musicians and venues
They are also adding an optional £1 donation on every ticket sold to support grass roots music through the Live Trust. A Scots arena has become the largest venue in the UK to drop all fees on merchandise sold by artists at their shows, which will make a massive difference to the income of performers – commissions and fees can mean they hand over up to 25 per cent of merch sales. Braehead Arena is the first arena and the biggest venue to commit to not charging artists fees for selling merch - and is adding an optional £1 donation to every ticket sold to support grass roots music through the Live Trust. The Arena – home of the Glasgow Clan ice hockey team - has partnered with Ghostwriter Consultancy & Events to work on developing a programme of world class live music, entertainment, comedy and sporting shows and events. With a bigger focus on live music in the Arena set to bring even more big names, previous shows have included Oasis, Alice in Chains, Paul Weller, Kelly Clarkson, INXS, Blondie, SUM 41, Bob Dylan, Jean Michel Jarre, Snoop Dogg, Blink-182 and Beyoncé. New CEO Russ Smith insists it's vital that larger venues in particular throw their weight behind supporting artists to safeguard the future of music – so Braehead Arena has taken action to show its desire to help musicians is genuine. Russ said: 'Braehead Arena is the perfect venue for artists on their way to the very top of the game – with a capacity of 5,300 we are a vital bridge from theatre scale to the biggest arenas and stadiums. 'With the nature of record deals in the streaming era, we understand that merch has become an essential income source for artists at all levels. 'It's important that we demonstrate we're really for music and for musicians – we are not just trying to jump on a trend. We really care about this. 'That's why we have taken the decision to drop all fees and commission charges on merch sold here by or for artists playing the Arena. 'We hope this commitment will help ensure a bright future for music and musicians, especially here in Scotland where there's so much talent we should all be proud of.' The venue is also adding an optional £1 donation to every ticket sold for all live music shows, which will be donated in full to the Live Trust to help grass roots venues and artists survive, again ensuring future paths to arenas and a starting point for emerging talents. Russ said: 'Including the optional £1 donation is about making sure the incredibly rich culture of music in Scotland in particular is protected and encouraged. 'By supporting smaller venues our gig goers will be helping future stars take those early steps on the pathway to headlining arenas like Braehead. 'It is very much an optional donation though. I know times are tough for everyone right now but hope fans will see the benefit of adding the extra £1 – we offer free parking for all shows here which may help.' The huge moves by Glasgow's second largest arena come as they announce a strategic partnership with Ghostwriter Consultancy & Events, who manage venues around the UK and are committed to the fee-free merch sales pledge at their other sites too. Carl Bathgate, Commercial Director at Ghostwriter, said: "We are extremely proud to be the live music partners of Braehead Arena as it fills a clear gap in terms of capacity in Glasgow. 'Our aim is to deliver a much-needed versatile space that provides more opportunities for artists at this level to connect with their fans and create unforgettable live experiences. 'As the first arena in the UK to adopt our model, Braehead joins our growing family of venues committed to supporting artists by not charging commission on merchandise sales. 'With rising costs of touring and the shift to streaming, artists depend more on merchandise sales to let them earn money and continue touring. 'We're firmly committed to doing everything we can to support artists, promoters and our customers, helping to sustain live performance as a vital and accessible part of the music industry." Helen McGee, Ghostwriter's Head of Venues, added: 'We're delighted to partner with Braehead Arena and firmly believe there is a real need for a venue of this scale in Glasgow. 'As a member of the Music Venue Trust board, I'm especially pleased to see a venue of this size recognise the pivotal role that grassroots venues and the wider community play in the development of artists and industry professionals at every level.' Braehead Arena is now operated by TDL Media. These announcements mark the first steps into a bold and exciting new era for the Arena. The venue is also committed to Braehead Ambition, a strategic partnership between SGS UK Retail, TDL Media and XPE launched to align the marketing, management and leasing of Braehead Shopping Centre, Braehead Arena and XSite to boost visitor numbers by more than a million people annually. The retail and leisure complex currently attracts 16.3 million visitors annually, benefits from supporting road networks, ample free parking and a wide variety of pre-event on-site dining options. Braehead Arena also boasts fantastic transport links with Glasgow's international airport only 10 minutes away.
Scottish Sun
3 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Major Scots construction firm set to plunge into liquidation
The was formed back in 2016 and worked in construction of commercial buildings GONE BUST Major Scots construction firm set to plunge into liquidation Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A MAJOR Scottish construction firm is set to go into liquidation. Pittsburgh Fife Limited, based in the coastal town of Dalgety Bay, is on the brink of collapse. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up A petition was presented at Dunfermline Sheriff Court on July 14 for the company to close up and a liquidator to be appointed, the Dunfermline Press reports. This was then submitted by the Advocate General for Scotland for and on behalf of the Commissioners for HM Revenue and Customs. Liquidation is a legal process where a company's assets are sold to pay off its debts. It also ultimately leads to the company's closure and dissolution. The process essentially consists of winding up a company's affairs. Pittsburgh Fife Limited was formed back in 2016 and worked in construction of commercial buildings. The address for the company was given as 3 St David's Business Park, Dalgety Bay. Any parties claiming an interest were asked to contact the court within eight days. It is unknown how many employees have been affected. The Dalgety Bay company is the latest construction firm to collapse. Edinburgh Cybersecurity Giant Adarma Collapses with 173 Jobs Lost In April, dozens of workers have lost their jobs after a long-established Scottish painting and decorating firm went bust. All 32 staff members at the Lanarkshire-based business were made redundant after the company entered administration. And in May, a Scottish firm has plunged into administration after 41 years with over 20 jobs lost. Hospital Pipeline Installations Limited (HPI) in Paisley plunged into administration due to a 'marked downturn' in trade, rising operating costs and low-margin contracts.
Scottish Sun
9 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Popular fashion & homeware retailer with more than 80 UK stores suddenly closes branch in Scots city centre
Read on to find out if the branch is near you CLOSING TIME Popular fashion & homeware retailer with more than 80 UK stores suddenly closes branch in Scots city centre A POPULAR fashion and homeware chain has closed down one of its busy Scottish branches for good. Oliver Bonas, which has more than 80 stores across the UK, has shuttered a store in Glasgow city centre. 2 Oliver Bonas has closed down its branch inside Glasgow Central Station Credit: Alamy Founded in 1993, the quirky stores are known for their unique homeware, selling everything from diffusers to throws to wine glasses. They also sell furniture including arm chairs, sofas, cabinets and desks. The retailer also offers up a host of women's clothing like jeans, dresses and knitted cardigans. Accessories, bags and jewellery are also on sale. A 'closed' sign has been placed in the shop window at Glasgow Central Station, The Glasgow Times reports. It read: "It's been a pleasure. This store is now closed." The Oliver Bonas website also states that the branch is now shut. The company added: "Sadly, our Glasgow Central store will be closing on Friday July 18, but your nearest stores will be Glasgow, Glasgow Gordon Street and Edinburgh, so you're never far away from an Oliver Bonas." There are still two branches in Glasgow, with one just metres away on Gordon Street. The store opened back in 2023 and was expanded across two floors. Huge high street retailer makes Irish return with first shop opening five years after devastating eight store closure The company previously said it would bring it's "unique blend of contemporary fashion, homeware, and gifts to even more communities". The store was part of the companies commitment to expanding their presence in Scotland and adding to their growing list of stores across the UK. The other Glasgow branch can be found on Byres Road in the west end. There are also stores in Aberdeen, Edinburgh and St Andrews.
