Why did ScotGov support award of ferry contracts to firms abroad
It has been confirmed successful sea trials means that MV Isle of Islay - one of the first of the four ferries being built in Turkey in the wake of Scotland's ferry fiasco - is on target to be delivered sometime between next month and September.
Meanwhile concerns have emerged that vital funding needed to have one key contract to build seven smaller ferries directly awarded to state-owned Ferguson Marine was not considered justified by ministers.
Why did CMAL award ferry contracts to shipyards in Turkey and Poland?
The Scottish Government -owned ferry and port owner CMAL awarded contracts to build ferries to Cemre Shipyard in Turkey and Remontowa Shipbuilding in Poland based on competitive procurement processes. These shipyards demonstrated the capability to deliver vessels that met technical specifications, timelines, and budgetary constraints.
The Cemre yard and (inset) one of the vessels it is delivering for Scotland (Image: .) Remontowa was awarded a £175 million contract to build seven all-electric ferries, having received the highest score during the bidding process .
The Turkish shipyard Cemre Marin Endustri was contracted to construct four new roll-on/roll-off passenger and vehicle ferries for Scotland's west coast ferry network. These vessels are intended to enhance services on routes to the Isle of Islay and the Little Minch corridor, which includes Skye, Harris, and North Uist. The deals together were worth £220m.
Why was Ferguson Marine, the Scots state-owned shipyard firm not awarded these contracts?
The Inverclyde firm had faced several challenges that affected its competitiveness in the bidding process.
Firstly a lack of experience. The shipyard had not completed any ferries in the past five years, failing to meet the tender's requirement to show recent experience in building at least three similar ferries.
READ MORE:
'Laughable': Turkey-built ferry to be delivered seven years faster than fiasco ship
Cost to repair CalMac ferry now £2m more than to buy replacement
Why has a 'rudderless' CalMac ferry been out of action for 16 months
'Final nail in coffin'. Scots fiasco firm loses out on big ferry contract to Poland
'Material uncertainty' over Scots ferry operator future amidst £45m funding hike
'Mismanagement': Public cost of Scots ferry fiasco firm hits £750m amidst overspends
It had financial and operational issues. Ferguson Marine's previous projects, such as the Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa, were significantly delayed and over budget, raising concerns about the yard's financial stability and project management capabilities.
CMAL's procurement process emphasized technical and financial suitability. Ferguson Marine is understood to have not scored as highly as other bidders in these areas.
What were the issues with the Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa projects?
The issues with Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa has become known as Scotland's ferry fiasco.
Glen Rosa and Glen Sannox's arrival to serve islands was scheduled to be online in the first half of 2018. Glen Sannox finally went into service on January but islanders are still awaiting the arrival of Glen Rosa.
Glen Sannox (Image: Andrew Milligan/PA) Both vessels were significantly behind schedule and over budget. Glen Rosa's delivery has been delayed until spring 2026, with costs soaring.
Costs of the entire project are currently expected to have multiplied at least five-fold from the original £96m price.
The delays were down to design and construction flaws. Problems included inadequate planning, quality issues, and a lack of detailed construction plans with CMAL and Ferguson Marine blaming each other for failings.
The contract also lacked adequate financial safeguards, such as a builder's refund guarantee, which would have protected public funds in case of project failures.
What are the implications of awarding contracts to overseas shipyards?
Awarding contracts to overseas shipyards has both advantages and disadvantages.
Overseas shipyards like Cemre and Remontowa, it is felt, have demonstrated the ability to deliver vessels on time and within budget.
These shipyards have experience building similar vessels, ensuring adherence to technical specifications.
But the disadvantages are the economic impact on Scotland.
Excluding domestic shipyards like Ferguson Marine can have negative effects on local employment and the Scottish shipbuilding industry.
Ferguson Marine has previously indicated that losing ferry contracts had an effect on its ability to continue as a going concern.
Ferguson Marine (Image: Colin Mearns) The decisions on the contracts have sparked political criticism and debates over the government's commitment to supporting domestic industries.
What lessons have been learned from these experiences?
While the decision to award ferry contracts to overseas shipyards was based on factors like cost, efficiency, and technical capability, it has raised important questions about the future of domestic shipbuilding in Scotland and the need for improved procurement practices.
The challenges faced in ferry procurement have highlighted the need for robust procurement processes and that contracts should include builder's refund guarantees to protect public funds.
It has also shown the requirement to balance the need for cost-effective procurement with the importance of supporting local industries.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
16 hours ago
- The National
Labour's 'nuclear tax' to cost Scots £300m to fund Sizewell C
Energy Secretary Ed Miliband has imposed a new levy on energy bills to fund the spiralling costs of the Sizewell C power station in Suffolk. Billpayers will be charged an extra £12 per year to fund the project, which has almost doubled in price to £38 billion. The UK Government has also committed to a loan facility worth £36.6bn, which means the total cost could top £47.7bn. That is more than the final cost of Hinkley Point C, which Greenpeace once dubbed "the most expensive object on Earth". READ MORE: Quarter of Keir Starmer's Cabinet blasted Donald Trump's last UK trip It comes despite Labour's election pledge to cut energy bills, with the energy price cap rising consistently since October. Graham Leadbitter (below, left), the SNP's energy spokesperson, said 'This toxic overspend now totals £48bn and Anas Sarwar has serious questions to answer as to whether he thinks it's acceptable for Scots to foot the bill through higher energy bills – it is an absolute disgrace that energy rich Scotland will see Scots face higher energy bills because of a nuclear plant running over budget in Labour-run England. (Image: Jeff) 'The Labour Party promised they'd cut energy bills by £300 yet they've soared on their watch – now we have the absurd situation where they've chosen to pile money into extortionate nuclear energy and are asking Scots to pick up the tab. 'Independent analysis shows this will cost Scottish households £300m in higher bills through a decade-long 'nuclear tax' all the while Scottish Labour refuse to acknowledge the white elephant in the room that they support these disastrous plans.' Leadbitter said that Scotland 'produces far more electricity that we can hope to use and our future is in renewables' and so had no interest in nuclear power. READ MORE: Trans toilet rules 'may force Scottish museums to close' He added: 'We were told Grangemouth refinery in Scotland couldn't be saved, yet we see a refinery in England protected, a steel works in Scunthorpe bailed out and now a nuclear power plant running twice over budget – it's no wonder Scots are increasingly asking how long we stay tied to this so called 'Union of Equals'?' The UK Government was approached for comment.
Scottish Sun
a day ago
- Scottish Sun
Eye-watering sum Scottish Government spent on empty rooms for refugees revealed
More than 28,000 people with a Scottish sponsor have arrived in the UK so far EMPTY ROOM BILL Eye-watering sum Scottish Government spent on empty rooms for refugees revealed THE Scottish Government has spent up to £75million on empty hotel rooms for Ukrainian refugees, we can reveal. Figures show £294million of taxpayers' cash has been used to reserve shelter for those fleeing Russia's invasion since 2022. Advertisement 1 Scottish Tory shadow housing minister Meghan Gallacher called the bill 'eye-watering' Credit: Alamy But between 10 and 25 per cent of rooms were unoccupied at any given time, suggesting £30million to £75million has been wasted. Scottish Tory shadow housing minister Meghan Gallacher called the bill 'eye-watering'. She added: 'Like thousands of Scots, vulnerable Ukrainians are being forced to live in temporary accommodation because of SNP ministers' failure to build enough homes. 'That's unfair on them and unfair on taxpayers.' Advertisement The Russian invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 has sparked a major humanitarian crisis. And more than 28,000 people with a Scottish sponsor have arrived in the UK so far. The administration refused to name the hotel companies over 'potential risks' if the information became 'public knowledge'. But the 'vast majority of this money' was paid to a firm called Corporate Travel Management which organises accommodation and contracts. Advertisement A whopping £144million was paid out 2022-23, more than £108million in 2023-24, and almost £40million in 2024-25. Equalities Minister Kaukab Stewart said: 'Providing support and sanctuary to people fleeing Russia's illegal war against Ukraine continues to be a priority.' The Sun tracks down Ukrainian mother and child pictured fleeing Putin's war on our front page A Government spokesman said: 'Welcome accommodation occupancy rates were inevitably subject to daily fluctuations as some individuals left while others entered accommodation.'
Scottish Sun
2 days ago
- Scottish Sun
Popular gastro pub on scenic Scots island goes up for sale
The overall plot extends to approximately 0.5 acres, including a generous beer garden and car park. ISLE TAKE IT Popular gastro pub on scenic Scots island goes up for sale Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A POPULAR gastro pub in the Outer Hebrides is to go under the hammer. Cross Inn at Ness on the Isle of Lewis has been removed from open market sale and is now up for auction with bidding starting at £220,000. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 7 Cross Inn at Ness on the Isle of Lewis is going under the hammer next month Credit: RIGHTMOVE 7 The building has five en-suite bedrooms on the upper floor Credit: RIGHTMOVE 7 It also has a comfy lounge area Credit: RIGHTMOVE 7 And it even has a generous beer garden Credit: RIGHTMOVE The hostelry has been on the market for over a year and was listed in 2024 with an asking price of £400,000. It is now going under the hammer via Auction House Scotland livestream on August 21. The award-winning establishment comprises an established restaurant and bar, as well as a B&B. It has five en-suite rooms, plus three private rooms which were formerly used as owner accommodation. Detached from the main building is the Old Barn Bar with 30 covers, which can be run independently all year round. The established gastro pub is described as having "a strong reputation amongst locals and tourists alike", with a 4.7 rating on Google Reviews. And it is said to be a great "opportunity to grow an already successful restaurant and B&B". The auction listing states: "Within stunning surroundings, the property comprises a lounge/bar, restaurant and commercial kitchen on the ground floor. "The upper level offers five ensuite B&B rooms plus three private rooms, formerly used as owners' accommodation. "It's popular with locals and tourists, being one of the few pubs on the Hebrides. Rangers-daft pub goes up for sale in Scots town "Additionally, there is a one-and-a-half-storey garage which would be ideal for conversion into self-contained owner's accommodation or tourist accommodation (with necessary planning approvals.) "The overall plot extends to approximately 0.5 acre, including a generous beer garden and car park. "Indications have previously been given that the council would be amenable to planning for camping on the spaces available at the beer garden. 'High level' of tourist demand on Lewis THE LISTING also goes on to describe the local area and revealed that tourist demand on the island is at a "high level". It said: "The Cross Inn enjoys a prominent roadside location on the A857 towards the northern tip of the Isle of Lewis. " Cross Village is a small community offering local facilities, with Stornoway approximately 35 miles to the south. "The local economy is historically built on traditional businesses such as fishing, farming and Harris Tweed. "But tourism demand across the islands is always at a high level." "The business has undertaken very little marketing activity and currently operates on a successful seasonal basis in the peak April to September season. "There is an excellent opportunity to grow the visibility and trading hours of this popular business to a 12-month calendar. "The published rateable value is £16,000, but the business may qualify for rates relief under the Islands and Remote Areas Hospitality Relief scheme." The auction is being undertaken as the current husband-and-wife team is looking to retire, the listing states. It adds: "They are looking to retire from the business and pass the baton to an enterprising and enthusiastic new team." 7 Bidding for the gastro pub is set to start at £220,000 Credit: RIGHTMOVE 7 The award-winning establishment comprises an established restaurant and bar Credit: RIGHTMOVE
