The glaring gaps India must fill at the Edgbaston Test
In batting, Karun Nair's comeback and Sai Sudharsan's debut proved forgettable affairs. In bowling, Mohammed Siraj, Prasidh Kirshna and Shardul Thakur were found wanting in playing the support role to Jasprit Bumrah. These five have been left to rue how their inability to raise their game meant some superb performances by their teammates went in vain and India lost the Test after scoring five Test centuries.
The half which didn't do well will be battling confidence issues. Nair and Shardul are unlikely to get a long rope. They will have to get their act together quickly while Sudharsan, Prasidh and Siraj too have their task cut out.
As he reflected on his game during the long break between the games, Nair would have seen a pattern in the way his last series went in 2017, and his dismissals in Leeds last week – out playing loose shots.
Inability to capitalise on starts was his undoing in the 2017 home Test series against Australia. He played three Tests and started with a 39-ball 26 at Bengaluru (India won), scored a 47-ball 23 in Ranchi (draw) and was out for five in the final Test at Dharamsala. He looked comfortable in all the games but couldn't cash in and lost his place in the side. The Leeds Test was his first in eight years and he must guard against giving away his wicket, and focus harder.
Nair's challenge is also to adjust batting at No.6. Though against the Aussies in 2017 also he batted at No.6 and 7, he would have been more at ease from No.3 to No.5. In England, the team needs him in a different role. His triple hundred (vs England in Chennai, 2016) came at No.5. But Rishabh Pant is established at No.5 and Gill at No.4 while India decided to blood Sudharsan at No.3.
Batting at 6 also calls for the temperament to handle pressure and shepherd the lower order. Fingers were pointed at Nair for the Leeds defeat because the lower order failed in both innings. He fell for 0 and 20 and wasn't there to guide the tail. In the second innings, Jadeja (25*) tried, but ran out of partners.
SAI'S LEG-SIDE ISSUE
England exploited the weakness of left-hander Sudharsan's leg-side play, skipper Ben Stokes removing him for 0 and 30 caught on the leg side. In the first innings, he flicked to the wicket-keeper, and in the second he flicked off the pads to short midwicket.
Sudharsan is looking to play his strokes. In English conditions, playing forceful shots is fraught with risk. It is better to play with soft hands and under the eyeline. The ball moves late and it is unwise to look to muscle the ball like in the sub-continent. It demands mental skills, the right gameplan, and constant assessment of the weather and pitch conditions.
PACE ATTACK
Though spinners will have a role to play in Edgbaston, usually in English conditions the onus is on the pacers to lead the bowling. At Leeds, the pacers couldn't support Bumrah to let him be as effective as he could.
Compare it to the 2021 series – Bumrah had solid support from Ishant Sharma, Siraj, Mohammed Shami and Umesh Yadav. Even Shardul provided breakthroughs. In the Lord's victory, Bumrah went wicketless in the first innings but Ishant, Shami and Siraj shared nine wickets.
On batting pitches, channel bowling is key to build pressure. At Leeds, the pacers other than Bumrah were too inconsistent.
Siraj had figures of 27-0-122-2 (ER 4.51) and 14-1-51-0 (3.64). An India Test pacer for more than four years, more was expected from the Hyderabad bowler. Siraj was inconsistent at Leeds. His cross-seam deliveries were easily dealt with. In English conditions, there is more reward using an upright seam and getting the ball to move. He will have to set the tone for the other bowlers at Edgbaston if Bumrah is rested.
After forgettable figures of 20-0-128-3 (6.40) and 15-0-92-2 (6.13), Prasidh would have learnt that he can't overdo the short stuff in England. He was hammered from outside off-stump and pulled with disdain. His best chance to take wickets is by pitching it up, as his two second innings wickets at Leeds showed.
The striking thing with Shardul is that when the team is anxious for runs he will make a valuable cameo and when it is desperate for wickets he will provide breakthroughs, not an all-rounder who always hits a fifty and gets five wickets. The typical Shardul was missing at Leeds as spells of 6-0-38-0 (6.33) and 10-0-51-2 (5.10) and being dismissed cheaply (1 and 4 runs) show.
India will need a better team effort than Headingley if they are to come back in the five-Test series.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
23 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Shubman Gill gets 'Indian Rolls-Royce' crown, draws awe for ruthless hunger to join Sachin, Kohli as India's next 'GOAT'
Shubman Gill scripted history on Thursday by becoming the first Indian skipper to score a double century in England. The 25-year-old stamped his authority over England with a 269-run knock to put India in the driver's seat. Shubman was under the scanner as a batter before the start of the series, but the added captaincy responsibility has worked well in his favour. Shubman Gill etched his name in history books on Thursday with a double ton.(@BCCI X) The talented batter is finally making a mark in red-ball cricket, silencing his critics with consecutive centuries on English soil. His double hundred at Edgbaston was a breakthrough moment — not only easing the mounting pressure on him but also firmly establishing his credentials as a worthy successor to Virat Kohli at the crucial No. 4 spot. With these standout performances, he's proving that he belongs at the highest level and is ready to shoulder greater responsibility. Former India pacer Varun Aaron was also highly impressed with Gill's showing total control in a knock of the highest quality, comparing the Indian skipper to Rolls-Royce. "He's just a brilliant player. In a land where they produce all the Rolls-Royces, we saw an Indian Rolls-Royce operate. So smooth, didn't give them a single chance in 269 runs. Generally when someone plays that many balls in a place like England, you definitely see a few chances go down, you see a few loose shots," Aaron said on ESPNCricinfo. His marathon knock of 269 from 387 deliveries, laced with 30 boundaries and three sixes, drew admiration from both teammates and opponents alike. Several England players walked up to congratulate him, while the Edgbaston crowd rose to their feet, offering a well-deserved standing ovation for the masterful innings. Aaron talked about Shubman's mindset and said he wants to be the greatest Indian batter like Sachin Tendulkar and Virat Kohli, and he is working towards it. "Just shows his mindset and composure and it just shows that Shubman Gill wants to be the greatest batsman India has ever seen. That's how he's operating," the 35-year-old further added in praise of the elegant batter. 'Shubman Gill will be disappointed, he didn't get a triple hundred' Meanwhile, the former Indian paceman asserted that Shubman would not be happy after missing a chance to score a triple century. "He'll be disappointed that he didn't get a triple hundred. He was looking so good. Very soft dismissal. I was really rooting for him to get a bigger hundred. We were all talking about daddy hundreds and Gill getting a big one. It really looked like he was digging deep to get one of his big scores - did get his biggest score," Aaron commented.
First Post
23 minutes ago
- First Post
Gill Gets Booed By English Fans, Faces Heat From Experts
Gill Gets Booed By English Fans, Faces Heat From Experts | First Sports With Rupha Ramani | N18G
NDTV
23 minutes ago
- NDTV
Shubman Gill Says He 'Stopped Enjoying Batting', Then Did This Before England Tour
After his magnificent double hundred against England, India skipper Shubman Gill on Thursday said he had stopped enjoying his batting in pursuit of runs but going back to basics and making some technical changes helped him rediscover the joy in his craft. Gill struck 269 off 387 balls to become the first Indian and Asian captain to score a double hundred in a Test match in England as India posted a massive 587 on day two of the second Test. Asked if he worked on his technique ahead of the series, Gill told host broadcaster: 'Yes, absolutely. I think at the end of the IPL and before this series, I worked a lot on this. "I mainly worked on my initial movement and my setup. Before this, I felt my batting was going well. I was scoring 30-35-40 runs consistently in Test matches. But at some point, I was missing that peak concentration time. A lot of people say that when you focus too much, you sometimes miss your peak time. "So, in this series, I tried to go back to my basics. I tried to bat like I used to in my childhood. I didn't think about having reached 35-40 runs or about playing long innings. I just wanted to enjoy my batting." Gill posted the highest individual score by an Indian batter on English soil, surpassing Sunil Gavaskar 's 221 at The Oval in 1979. "Sometimes, when you aren't scoring runs fluently, you stop enjoying your batting. You focus too much on the need to score runs. I felt I had lost that in my batting. I was so focused that I wasn't enjoying my batting as much," he said. Gill's knock is also the highest by an Indian captain in Tests, surpassing Virat Kohli 's unbeaten 254 against South Africa in Pune in 2019. "When I went in to bat before lunch on the first day, at tea I was on around 35-40 runs off about 100 balls. I came out and spoke to GG (Gautam Gambhir) Bhai. I told him, 'I'm not getting runs freely, even though I have a lot of shots in my armoury.' I also felt the ball was a bit soft," the Punjab cricketer said. "In the last match, I was scoring more fluently, but here it wasn't coming as easily. Still, my mindset was that if the wicket is good and I am set, no matter how long I bat, I shouldn't leave the match halfway. "In the last match, I learnt that no matter how long you've been batting, under these conditions, there can be a collapse in the lower order at any time. So I tried to stay out there as long as I could. I wanted the bowler to get me out with a good ball and I shouldn't make mistakes. That was my approach," he said. Gill, who captained Gujarat Titans to the playoffs, was seen preparing for the England Test series by practising with the red ball during the IPL season in Ahmedabad. "Because the IPL setup, the white-ball setup, and what I wanted to do there were very different. So I thought that if I started my preparation from then itself, it would give me an edge when the time for the series came," he said. Gill admitted that it is tough to switch from one format to another. "It is very difficult. Especially with the way T20 is played nowadays, in the last 4-5 years, there has been a huge difference in technique, setup, and mindset. "It's easy to go from T20 to T20, but coming back from T20 to Tests is a bit difficult because you have been practising one way with your team and your instincts are tuned to that. "Controlling that and repeatedly telling your mind and body to adapt is challenging. That's why I started training for Tests during the IPL itself. That's when I began preparing my mind and body." Indian pacers also did well to reduce England to 77/3 at the end of the second day, and Gill said the key would be to bowl in the right areas to frustrate the batters. "I think once the ball gets a little old, it becomes difficult to take wickets. So, the more we consistently bowl in one area and frustrate their batsmen, the better it is for us." Gill also shed light on India's possible approach with the ball. "We will try to make them score in only one area. Because when a batsman is able to score all around the ground, it becomes difficult to control them... I think our bowlers executed their plans really well. "(The pitch) doesn't have a lot for bowlers, but enough that if a batsman tries too hard, there are chances of getting out. When the batsman tries to do something different, the chances of getting him out increase. "So, we will try to frustrate them while they bat, and wherever they try to score runs, we won't give them that opportunity. I think that will be the most important thing for our bowling," he noted.
