‘Entirely unsurprising': Issues with return-to-office mandates coming to light
Among the businesses that have issued these types of orders are Amazon, JPMorgan Chase, Tabcorp, AT&T and Dell.
Now, a few months on from many of these mandates being in force, it seems things may not be going as smoothly as decision makers would have hoped.
In the case of technology giant Dell, a new report from Business Insider has suggested the company is dealing with significant issues in the return-to-office rollout.
In March 2025, Dell began requiring all employees who live within an hour from an office to return to in-person work five days a week.
An internal memo stated all employees that met this criteria would be expected to do a 'regular working day in the office', though there would be 'flexibility as needed'.
It has been over three months since staff were ordered back to the office, with 10 Dell employees painting a very varied picture of how things are panning out.
Business Insider reported the degree of enforcement very much varies between managers, with some employees saying they were in eight hours a day, while others seemingly coming into the office to show their face and leaving soon after.
One employee, a program manager, said the lack of blanket enforcement was causing 'lots of in-office politics', with this 'haphazard' nature leading to friction among employees.
'So much of this is dependent on leaders,' they said.
A recent internal FAQ obtained by the publication laid out examples of when employees may be approved to work from home, such as a temporary medical condition, needing to provide temporary care, or adjusting in-office hours to avoid peak traffic.
However, of the five employees who claimed they sometimes work from home, none said it was due to any of the reasons listed above.
'I personally have not been adhering to eight hours a day,' one employee said, claiming they were aware they may be breaking the rules but have not yet been corrected.
Another said that, while their team was in the office full time, they usually only work about half the day in person before finishing the rest of their shift at home.
One staff member claimed they had intentionally been coming in less as the new policy made them feel like they were being 'treated like a child'.
Speaking to news.com.au, Rebecca Moulynox, ANZ General Manager of Great Place To Work, said the issues we are seeing arise from widespread return-to-office mandates were 'absolutely predictable'.
'Our data couldn't be clearer – when employers mandate work location, whether remote, hybrid, or onsite, productivity drops, retention plummets, and relationships with managers deteriorate,' she said.
'We found that employees who can choose where they work are three times more likely to want to stay with their company.
'When companies ignore this data and impose mandates anyway, the outcomes we're seeing at Dell and elsewhere are entirely unsurprising.'
Dell is far from the only company experiencing return-to-office issues.
Earlier this month, a leaked internal memo from JPMorgan showed morale had taken a hit in the wake of the RTO mandate.
Every year, employees are asked to complete a survey that asks them to assess aspects of the company culture, such as internal mobility, work-life balance and health and wellbeing.
An internal memo from CEO Jamie Dimon and Chief Human Resources Officer Robin Leopold, obtained by Barron's, revealed the company's health and wellbeing scores had dropped, with leaders attributing this to the return to office.
'Health and wellbeing scores remain favourable, though they dipped slightly year on year,' the memo stated.
'We know return full-time to the office has been an adjustment and one that not everyone agrees with, but we continue to believe in-person is how we do our best work and how we foster connections and mobility opportunities.'
Elsewhere, there have also been complaints of companies introducing RTO mandates but actually not having the capacity for everyone to come back.
Telecommunications giant AT&T required staff to come back to the office five days a week from January 2025.
In the wake of the return, several workers from the company's Atlanta offices told Business Insider that there was a shortage of available desks and the parking lots had become overcrowded.
There were also claims of increasingly long wait times for elevators, leading to the company posting signs with 'motivational quotes' encouraging staff to use the stairs.
Ms Moulynox said one of the key drivers behind the issues we are now seeing is a 'fundamental disconnect' between executive decision making and employee needs.
'The specific issues like desk shortages and inconsistent enforcement stem from companies trying to force a one-size-fits-all approach without understanding why employees value flexibility in the first place,' she said.
'When you mandate where people work without recognising that employees need flexibility for things like picking up children from school, managing family responsibilities, or avoiding toxic office dynamics, you're bound to face resistance and practical failures.'
Neal Woolrich, Director, Advisory in the Gartner HR practice, has also noticed that, not only are organisations struggling with unclear policies, there is also a lack of guidance for how leaders are meant to be applying the policies.
'So there's that lack of consistency, and that leads to feelings of inequity or unfairness,' he told news.com.au.
Mr Woolrich said some companies are also running into issues because they haven't established in advance how they are going to enforce the mandates.
'What we've seen over the last few years is that, where organisations have set a target for in-office attendance, on average, most organisations are just not getting close to that target,' he said.
This means that companies are now in the position where they have to get serious about their enforcement mechanism and how strict they want to be.
Mr Woolrich said the 'logical extension' is that not meeting in-office targets becomes a performance issue that could then impact promotions or pay rises.
On the extreme end of things, companies may be having to decide whether they exit people from the business for noncompliance to RTO mandates.
'Different organisations are taking different views to that. Some are using return-to-office mandates as a bit of a Trojan horse, and using it just as an excuse to exit people from the business quickly,' he said.
'Others don't necessarily want to go down that path, but then that might be where it leads to if they really want to be strict about in office attendance.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


7NEWS
an hour ago
- 7NEWS
Amazon's first colour Kindle arrives in Australia: Colorsoft offers ‘real paper' reading experiences
Calling all bookworms: Kindle's most anticipated launch to date has just arrived on Aussie shores — and you could be one of the first to get your hands on it. The Colorsoft Kindle, Amazon's first-ever colour device, is now available to purchase online, for as little as $399. More than just your average e-reader, Colorsoft offers an incredible display, allowing you to view images, book covers and even highlight text — all in colour. After launching back in 2024, Coloursoft has been declared as the 'best all-purpose e-reader' on the market, and shoppers are racing to get their hands on the newly-launched device at Amazon Australia. There's two sizes available, 16G ($399) and 32G ($449), meaning there's plenty of room to download and store all your favourite books from the Kindle store. Perfect for on-the-go reading without lugging around heavy books, get in quick to get your hands on the newly-launched Kindle device. Whether you're an avid reader or rely on a great book to keep you company on a daily commute, Kindle's new Colorsoft is changing the game when it comes to reading on the move. Lightweight, compact and easy to carry, this new arrival offers a high-contrast display that looks almost identical to reading a real paperback. 100 per cent distraction-free, with zero notifications or social media apps, it's great for delving into a great novel, with anti-glare tech to reduce eye stain. You can even read in the brightest light or late into the night with auto-adjusting features, perfect for flights or lounging in the sun. Not to mention that the new Kindle is waterproof, so you can you can even sit and read by the pool — or in the bath — without the worry. 'We're delighted to bring Kindle Colorsoft to our customers in Australia,' Jacqui Corbett, Amazon Devices Country Manager, Australia and New Zealand, tells Best Picks. 'This is a significant milestone for Kindle locally, offering readers the perfect blend of our beloved e-reader experience with high-contrast colour capabilities. 'Whether you're enjoying travel guides, children's books, graphic novels, or cookbooks, or simply want to personalise your reading with colourful highlights, Kindle Colorsoft delivers this, giving an enhanced reading experience anywhere, anytime.' To shop the Kindle Colorsoft, head to Amazon Australia her e. Shop Kindle Colorsoft Cases: Already got your hands on the new Kindle? Keep your device extra safe with a luxe-looking protective cover. Black, $69.95 Jade, $69.95 Raspberry, $69.95 Ruby, $99.95 Walnut, $99.95

AU Financial Review
5 hours ago
- AU Financial Review
Beware the coming crypto crisis
My heart sank last week when I read that JPMorgan Chase was looking into lending against clients' cryptocurrency holdings, even though we all knew the day was coming when crypto would make its way into the real economy. Bitcoin, one of the digital assets banks may lend against, has been nearly four times as volatile as major indices since 2020. It has also had ties to terror funding, and I have yet to read anything that made me think it is more than a tool for speculators and criminals.

News.com.au
15 hours ago
- News.com.au
Trump, EU chief seek deal in transatlantic tariffs standoff
US President Donald Trump and EU chief Ursula von der Leyen prepared to meet Sunday in Scotland in a push to resolve a months-long transatlantic trade standoff that is going down to the wire. Trump has said he sees a 50-50 chance of reaching a deal with the European Union, having vowed to hit dozens of countries with punitive tariffs unless they hammer out a pact with Washington by August 1. The EU is currently facing the threat of an across-the-board levy of 30 percent from that date. Von der Leyen's European Commission, negotiating on behalf of the EU's member countries, has been pushing hard for a deal to salvage a trading relationship worth an annual $1.9 trillion in goods and services. Any deal with the United States will need approval by all 27 member states. EU ambassadors, on a visit to Greenland, were to meet Sunday morning to discuss the latest negotiations -- and again after any accord. Sunday's sit-down between Trump and the EU chief was to take place at 4:30 pm (1530 GMT) in Turnberry, on Scotland's southwestern coast, where Trump owns a luxury golf resort. The 79-year-old American leader said Friday he hoped to strike "the biggest deal of them all" with the EU. "I think we have a good 50-50 chance" of a deal, the president said, citing sticking points on "maybe 20 different things". He praised von der Leyen as "a highly respected woman" -- a far cry from his erstwhile hostility in accusing the EU of existing to "screw" the United States. But late-night EU talks with US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick on Saturday to hammer out the final details were "combative at times," The Financial Times reported. As of Saturday evening, there were "still quite a few open questions" -- notably on pharmaceutical sector tariffs, said one EU diplomat. Tariff levels on the auto sector were also crucial for the Europeans -- notably France and Germany -- and the EU has been pushing for a compromise on steel that could allow a certain quota into the United States before tariffs would apply. - Baseline 15 percent - According to European diplomats, the deal on the table involves a baseline levy of around 15 percent on EU exports to the United States -- the level secured by Japan -- with carve-outs for critical sectors including aircraft, lumber and spirits excluding wine. The EU would commit to ramp up purchases of US liquefied natural gas, along with a series of investment pledges. Hit by multiple waves of tariffs since Trump reclaimed the White House, the EU is currently subject to a 25-percent levy on cars, 50 percent on steel and aluminium, and an across-the-board tariff of 10 percent, which Washington threatens to hike to 30 percent in a no-deal scenario. The EU has focused on getting a deal with Washington to avoid sweeping tariffs that would further harm its sluggish economy, with retaliation as a last resort. While 15 percent would be much higher than pre-existing US tariffs on European goods -- at 4.8 percent -- it would mirror the status quo, with companies already facing an additional flat rate of 10 percent. Should talks fail, EU states have greenlit counter tariffs on $109 billion (93 billion euros) of US goods including aircraft and cars to take effect in stages from August 7. Brussels is also drawing up a list of US services to potentially target. Beyond that, countries like France say Brussels should not be afraid to deploy a so-called trade "bazooka" -- EU legislation designed to counter coercion through trade measures which involves restricting access to its market and public contracts. But such a step would mark a major escalation with Washington. - Ratings dropping - Trump has embarked since returning to power on a campaign to reshape US trade with the world. But polls suggest the American public is unconvinced, with a recent Gallup survey showing his approval rating at 37 percent -- down 10 points from January. Having promised "90 deals in 90 days," Trump's administration has so far unveiled five, including with Britain, Japan and the Philippines. Early Sunday, ahead of his meeting with Von der Leyen, Trump was out again on the golf course, having spent most of Saturday playing at Turnberry amid tight security. The trip to Scotland has put physical distance between Trump and the scandal around Jeffrey Epstein, the wealthy financier accused of sex trafficking who died in prison in 2019 before facing trial. In his heyday, Epstein was friends with Trump and others in the New York jet-set, but the president is facing backlash from his own MAGA supporters demanding access to the Epstein case files. With the uproar refusing to die down, a headline agreement with the EU -- in addition to bolstering Trump's dealmaker credentials -- could bring a welcome distraction.