US appeals court revives antitrust lawsuit over Puerto Rican baseball league
The 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in a ruling, opens new tab on Monday revived part of a lawsuit that was filed in 2022 against the league and others by a former owner-operator of a franchise in Puerto Rico's professional baseball league, Liga de Béisbol Profesional de Puerto Rico.
The Boston-based appeals court, which hears federal cases from Puerto Rico, said that former owner Thomas Axon could pursue a narrowed antitrust and civil rights lawsuit against the league and others.
The appeals court upheld the dismissal of U.S. federal antitrust claims, but allowed antitrust and fair competition claims under Puerto Rican laws.
In a statement, Winston & Strawn's Jeffrey Kessler, a lead attorney for the plaintiffs, welcomed the 1st Circuit's order allowing the case to proceed and said they were weighing their options over the dismissal of the federal antitrust allegations.
Francisco Colón-Ramírez, a lawyer for the baseball league, did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Axon in the lawsuit said rival teams had worked to block his efforts in 2019 to restore his franchise through major new broadcast initiatives, better salaries, enhanced sponsorships and expanded merchandising.
He alleged that the baseball league seized his investor-operator interest without compensation or due process, and moved to box him out of the league.
The league and other defendants have denied any wrongdoing.
In dismissing the lawsuit, U.S. District Judge William Young in 2023 pointed to the 'baseball exemption' of federal antitrust law. The U.S. Supreme Court in a 1922 case concluded antitrust law does not apply to the business of baseball.
In the latest in a string of legal challenges involving the baseball exemption, Axon's lawyers argued it only applies to Major League Baseball and its direct affiliates, and not to the Puerto Rican league. Young disagreed.
The 1st Circuit panel — Chief Judge Barron, joined by Circuit Judges O. Rogeriee Thompson and Gustavo Gelpí — suggested the exemption is out of touch with the modern realities of baseball. But the Supreme Court, the panel said, has declined so far to overrule it.
The case is Cangrejeros de Santurce Baseball Club LLC et al v. Liga de Béisbol Profesional de Puerto Rico Inc et al, 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 23-1589.
For plaintiffs: Jeffrey Kessler of Winston & Strawn
For defendants: Francisco Colón-Ramírez of Colón Ramírez
Read more:
National Hockey League, Canadian hockey clubs defeat US class action
US judge approves NCAA baseball coaches' $49 million settlement
Bipartisan state coalition backs challenge to MLB's antitrust immunity
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
5 hours ago
- Scotsman
How much do England get for winning the Women's Euros? What is the prize money, and is it equal pay?
Full details on the Women's Euros 2025 prize money after England's penalty shootout win over Spain. Sign up to our Football newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... England left it late again, but retained their Women's Euros title after Sarina Wiegman's side edged out Spain in a tense penalty shootout following a 1-1 draw after extra-time in Basel. After downing Sweden on penalties in the quarter-finals, and Italy in the semis via a goal from Chloe Kelly in the final minute of extra-time, it was the Arsenal superstar who stepped up for England to take the winning spot-kick and seal a memorable Women's Euros win in Switzerland. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Fans have packed stadiums out across Switzerland over the summer, desperate to catch a glimpse of women's football's biggest names, with over half-a-million tickets sold during the tournament, alongside huge viewing figures on both the BBC and ITV, with supporters tuning in to catch a glimpse of England's Alessia Russo and Spain's Aitana Bonmati. A re-run of the Women's World Cup final two years ago, the Lionesses finally got revenge for their 1-0 defeat in Sydney two years ago, while also becoming the first England team to win a major tournament on foreign soil. But how much have they earned for winning the Women's Euros this summer - and how does it compare to the men's game? Here's everything you need to know following the Lionesses' memorable victory in Zurich. England are Women's Euros champions, again. What trophy do the winners of the Women's Euros 2025 get? England will receive a trophy, and up to 40 gold medals, with the Women's Euro trophy is provided by Milan-based company G.D.E. Bertoni. It stands at 150mm tall. Additionally, the Lionesses will qualify to face the winners of the 2025 CONMEBOL Copa América Femenina in the second UEFA-CONMEBOL Women's Finalissima, with the date and location to be announced in due course. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad What is the prize money for the Women's Euro 2025? The prize pot for the Women's Euro is the biggest ever in 2025, with national associations and players set to receive record rewards. In 2024, UEFA revealed they had approved a €41million prize money pot. Nations participating in the tournament will receive a participation payment of €1.8million, representing a 156% increase on the figure from the 2022 tournament held in England. In total, each nation was paid: Win in the group stage: €100,000 Draw in the group stage: €50,000 Reaching the quarter-finals: €550,000 Reaching the semi-finals: €770,000 How much do England get for winning the Women's Euros? England will be awarded a fee of €1.75million solely for winning the final, in addition to any prize money accrued earlier in the competition. Runners-up Spain were paid €850,000. With England having already earned €3,320,000 for their tournament performance, the total prize money they will receive is €5,070,000. Spain landed a figure of €4,150,000 despite their defeat, as they won one extra group game.
Reuters
6 hours ago
- Reuters
Alex Bregman, Red Sox take down Dodgers to win series
July 27 - Alex Bregman hammered a go-ahead two-run homer to help the Boston Red Sox defeat the visiting Los Angeles Dodgers 4-3 Sunday. Bregman's 13th home run of the year came against Los Angeles starting pitcher Dustin May to conclude a three-run fifth inning. Michael Conforto had three hits -- a solo home run and two doubles -- for the Dodgers, who also received two hits from Shohei Ohtani. The Red Sox prevailed twice in the three-game series. Los Angeles won 5-2 Friday, and Boston earned a 4-2 victory Saturday. Boston starter Walker Buehler pitched against the Dodgers -- his former team -- for the first time in his career, and was pulled with two outs in the fifth. Buehler gave up three runs on four hits, struck out four and walked five. Brennan Bernardino (4-2) earned the win for recording the final out of the fifth. Red Sox closer Aroldis Chapman left the game with one out in the eighth. He threw 11 pitches in the inning and walked two. Jordan Hicks got the final five outs for Boston for his second save. May (6-7) pitched the first five innings for Los Angeles. He surrendered four runs on five hits and struck out five without a walk. The Red Sox grabbed a 1-0 lead in the first inning when Roman Anthony was hit by a pitch, took third on Jarren Duran's single and scored on Trevor Story's sacrifice fly to center field. It was the second time the Red Sox have scored first in their nine games since the All-Star break. Los Angeles made it a 1-1 game in the third. Miguel Rojas scored when Freddie Freeman drew a bases-loaded walk against Buehler. The Dodgers led 2-1 after Conforto homered against Buehler leading off the fourth, and Mookie Betts drove in Rojas from second with an RBI single to make it 3-1 later in the inning. Boston regained the lead by scoring three times in the fifth. It was 3-2 after Roman Anthony hit an RBI triple that drove in Abraham Toro, and Bregman followed with his two-run home run that put Boston in front. --Field Level Media
Daily Record
6 hours ago
- Daily Record
Rangers make Oliver Antman transfer breakthrough with deal timeline emerging
Talks over a move for the Finnish international have been progressing and now a deal could be in sight for Russell Martin Oliver Antman is set to sign for Rangers after the Ibrox club agreed a fee with Go Ahead Eagles. Record Sport understands that an agreement has been reached with the Eredivise outfit for the Finnish wide man, with sources in the Netherlands suggesting that the 23-year-old could become Russell Martin 's latest signing within the next 24 to 48 hours. Talks have taken place over a switch to Ibrox and a breakthrough has been made with the Deventer-based outfit. A fee of around £5million has been reported, and now it's understood that progress has been made with both club and player, easing the way for a move to Govan to happen. Antman won't be eligible for Wednesday night's Champions League second leg showdown with Panathinaikos in Athens even if he signs in time. But he could well be in the squad Martin takes to Fir Park on Saturday as Gers begin their Scottish Premiership campaign with an evening kick-off away to Motherwell. Antman bagged 7 goals and an impressive 17 assists to help fire Go Ahead to Dutch Cup glory last term. Sheffield United had been strongly linked with Antman, along with Belgian outfit and recent Ibrox visitors Club Brugge. But it now looks as if Gers have won the race. Go Ahead Eagles director Jan Willem van Dop insisted Antman, along with Celtic-linked teammate Jakob Breum, wouldn't leave on the cheap. He told Oost: "We think Breum and Antman should be allowed to leave for more than six million," which would seem to be the threshold Rangers have met to get a deal over the line. Former PSV, Barcelona and Dutch international star Ibrahim Affelay predicted that Antman would bank Go Ahead good money. he said: "That Antman is really... I think the treasurer is rubbing his hands with glee. He's going to make a fantastic transfer at the end of the season."
