Appellate Court Sides with Property Owner in Condemnation Battle over Golf Course Facility
'The court rightfully recognized the multiple violations of state law in the city's attempted acquisition and proposed use for this property,' said Chad Baruch.
The ruling marks a significant turning point in Texas eminent domain law, as the court explicitly held that governments can no longer rely on courts to automatically accept their claims about public use when seizing private property.
In the appellate court's ruling, Justice Mike Wallach referenced and relied on state constitutional provisions limiting the government's right to condemn private property for economic development or tax revenue generation and disputed the city's contention that the golf course expansion qualified as a public use under state law.
The lawsuit challenging the city's action was originally filed in 2022 by Jim Burgess, the owner of the 3.548-acre property formerly owned by the United States Air Force as part of Carswell Air Force Base.
The city had announced an intent to acquire Mr. Burgess's land the previous year through the right of eminent domain and lease the property to UnderPar Life LLC, a Dallas-based golf course developer whose investors include 2024 U.S. Open champion Bryson DeChambeau.
In response to Mr. Burgess's lawsuit, the trial court appointed three special commissioners who assessed the property's value at $1.545 million. Mr. Burgess contested that valuation and was denied. The case then went to trial, where a jury awarded him $1.3 million under eminent domain statutes.
In his opinion, Justice Wallach reversed and remanded the case to the trial court. 'It is the constitutional limitation of transferring condemned property for an impermissible purpose that distinguishes this case,' he wrote.
He noted that the city executed the lease with UnderPar Life before it even entered the property condemnation process.
This is the first time a Texas appellate court has explicitly stated that legislative and constitutional changes enacted in response to a U.S. Supreme Court decision have eliminated judicial deference to governmental declarations of public use.
'The court rightfully recognized the multiple violations of state law in the city's attempted acquisition and proposed use for this property,' said Chad Baruch of Johnston Tobey Baruch, the lead attorney for Mr. Burgess in the appeal. 'We are delighted with the court's ruling, which will permit our client to continue his challenge to the taking in the trial court.'
The case is Jim Burgess v. City of Westworth Village No. 02-24-00252-CV, in the Court of Appeals for the Second District of Texas at Fort Worth.
About Johnston Tobey Baruch
Johnston Tobey Baruch is a dynamic law practice based in Dallas. Its trial and appellate attorneys have a broad range of litigation, arbitration, and appellate experience. They are pioneers in the handling of legal and accounting malpractice, investment fraud, and business disputes. They also have an enviable track record with insurance bad faith matters, commercial litigation, and fiduciary litigation, as well as civil, family, and criminal appeals for many prominent Texas companies and individuals.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
5 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Diamondback says it should be Permian's 'consolidator of choice' as oil outlook dims
By Arunima Kumar (Reuters) -Shale driller Diamondback Energy said on Tuesday it should remain the Permian Basin's "consolidator of choice" as shale activity slows and the company focuses on shareholder returns following its $26 billion merger with Endeavor Energy. "We should naturally be the consolidator of choice as we execute a lower-cost and better overall development strategy," a key company executive said in a post-earnings call. "Until someone else can prove they can do it better than us, we should be the consolidator of choice." Diamondback's shares fell 3.6% to $142.67 in morning trade after it posted second-quarter profit below analysts' estimates, hit by a 20% year-on-year drop in Brent crude prices amid weak global growth, OPEC+ supply increases and geopolitical tensions. The Midland, Texas-based company said it remains focused on reducing debt and share count in 2025, and may lean more into buybacks if market conditions weaken. The company said it was hard to be bullish on oil, adding that shale producers were increasingly running scenarios based on $50–$60 oil, versus $60–$80 in recent years. Diamondback dropped four rigs in the second quarter, reducing its activity to 13 rigs and lowered its 2025 capital budget around 3% at midpoint to $3.4–$3.6 billion. Error al recuperar los datos Inicia sesión para acceder a tu cartera de valores Error al recuperar los datos Error al recuperar los datos Error al recuperar los datos Error al recuperar los datos
Business Wire
6 minutes ago
- Business Wire
Families Report Spending More, But Also Missing Out on Opportunities to Make College More Affordable According to ‘How America Pays for College 2025'
NEWARK, Del.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Families reported spending an average of $30,837 on college during the 2024–25 academic year—up 9% from $28,409 last year and a return to pre-pandemic spending levels, according to 'How America Pays for College 2025,' the annual study by Sallie Mae and Ipsos. Family income and savings covered nearly half of costs (48%), followed by scholarships and grants (27%), borrowing (23%), and contributions from family or friends (2%). Families See Value in College and Remain Focused on Cost Nearly nine in 10 (89%) families said college is a worthwhile investment, and 82% are willing to stretch their finances to ensure the best opportunities for their students. Eight in 10 families (79%) reported eliminating a school based on cost, but nearly half (47%) of all families also reported paying less than the sticker price for college. Families most often cited proximity to home (40%), affordability (39%), and specific academic program (39%) as reasons for choosing a school. While 59% of families created a plan to pay for college before enrolling, just 38% considered starting salaries after graduation. 'While families continue to see college as a valuable long-term investment, they also remain cost-conscious,' said Annaleise Lohr, vice president, Ipsos. 'It's encouraging to see families are taking the time to plan for this significant investment but coupling that financial focus with expected post-college outcomes could lead to even more informed decisions.' Misconceptions Around FAFSA and Scholarships Could Be Costing Families Roughly two-thirds of families (64%) found the new Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) easier to complete, but overall completion rates dropped to 71% from 74% the year prior. In addition, just 21% of families knew the FAFSA is available beginning in October. That could mean families are missing out on financial aid that is limited or available on a first-come, first-served basis. In addition, 40% of families did not utilize scholarships to pay for college due to lack of awareness (34%) and the belief they wouldn't win (28%). Access to Loans Leads Some Families to Reach for Higher-Priced Schools Nearly half of families (48%) borrowed to help pay for college, consistent with prior years, and 72% of all families said they would rather borrow than miss out on attending. Roughly six in 10 families (59%) said the availability of federal student loans has driven up college costs, and 35% of those who borrowed said access to loans led them to consider more expensive schools. In addition, 42% of families with federal student loans expect their loans to be forgiven. 'Students and families navigating higher education today need greater transparency when it comes to the actual cost of college so they can make the most informed decisions about this significant investment,' said Rick Castellano, vice president, Sallie Mae. 'We also need to continue to promote FAFSA completion and reinforce the availability of scholarships, so families don't inadvertently leave free money on the table.' Free tools like Scholly Scholarships by Sallie and Scout College Search by Sallie help families plan smarter by finding thousands of scholarships and comparing schools based on majors, location, cost, and more—no registration required. In addition, the company offers responsible private student loans to cover any remaining financing gaps. "How America Pays for College 2025" reports the results of Ipsos' online interviews of 1,000 undergraduate students and 1,000 parents of undergraduate students between April 8 and May 8, 2025. Explore the full report and discover insights, trends, and free planning tools at Sallie Mae (Nasdaq: SLM) believes education and life-long learning, in all forms, help people achieve great things. As the leader in private student lending, we provide financing and know-how to support access to college and offer products and resources to help customers make new goals and experiences, beyond college, happen. Learn more at Commonly known as Sallie Mae, SLM Corporation and its subsidiaries are not sponsored by or agencies of the United States of America. Category: Research
Business Wire
6 minutes ago
- Business Wire
Wattch Secures $6 Million in Seed Round Led by Spero Ventures and Christopher Klaus to Expand Energy Management Solutions
ATLANTA--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Wattch, a leading monitoring and controls provider for commercial and distribution-scale solar and battery storage, has secured $6 million in Seed funding from prominent cleantech investors. The investment round was led by Spero Ventures with participation from cybersecurity pioneer Christopher Klaus. Additional energy industry investors include former CEO of GE Power Steve Bolze and Helioscope Founder Paul Grana. As part of this investment, Marc Tarpenning, co-founder of Tesla and Venture Partner at Spero Ventures, and Michael Chanin, the founder of Cherry Street Energy, have joined Wattch's board of directors. "Wattch is working to radically reduce deployment time and cost with the first hybrid SCADA platform purpose-built for DERs." The funding will accelerate Wattch's mission to transform how developers, utilities, and independent power producers operate and optimize their energy assets through its next-generation cloud platform and connected hardware solutions. Specifically, the capital will enable the company's strategic go-to-market expansion into the rapidly growing grid-scale battery storage market and support continued development of comprehensive Energy Management System (EMS) capabilities. "This investment represents a strong vote of confidence in our vision and technology," said Alex Nussey, CEO and co-founder of Wattch. "We are at an inflection point where the energy industry is experiencing increasing penetration of intermittent and distributed assets. This complexity demands unified digital control solutions that are both simple and repeatable enough to be deployed at scale. Wattch is working to radically reduce deployment time and cost with the first hybrid SCADA platform purpose-built for DERs." In its recent releases, the company has enhanced its platform with advanced EMS features, including autonomous economic optimization, scheduled operation, and manual dispatch. These new capabilities complement Wattch's legacy suite of monitoring, performance analysis, and diagnostic controls solutions, providing customers with an unprecedented level of visibility and control over their energy infrastructure. Wattch plans to use the funds to expand its engineering and project implementation teams, accelerate the time-to-market for its advanced controls capabilities, and drive customer acquisition across developers and independent power producers. About Wattch Wattch enables observability, intelligence, and control for renewable energy systems of all types and sizes. As an emerging leader in Grid Edge platforms, the company serves customers in the solar, battery storage, and hydroelectric spaces, with wide-ranging potential applications. Wattch aims to provide transparency and interoperability for every device in the world that produces, stores, or consumes energy. Learn more at and on LinkedIn. About Spero Ventures Spero Ventures is an early stage venture capital firm that invests in the things that make life worth living: wellbeing; sustainability; learning, work, and play. We're a team of former startup founders, operators, and investors from landmark companies including eBay, Tesla, and Stripe. We invest in determined founders building mission-driven technology companies. We are conviction-based investors who play the long game. About Christopher Klaus Chris Klaus is the founder and CEO of Fusen, a platform empowering college students to launch startups by connecting them with mentors, funding, and accelerators. A visionary entrepreneur, Klaus previously founded ISS (acquired by IBM for $1.9B), and he continues to drive innovation through education, technology, and mentorship.
