Super Bowl performances by Rihanna, Jennifer Lopez and Janet Jackson criticised as 'vulgar' by Republicans calling for more 'family friendly' shows

Sky News

29-01-2025

This year's famous Super Bowl half-time show needs to be more "family friendly", a group of critics has said - following what they describe as "vulgar" past performances by Jennifer Lopez and Rihanna, and the infamous Janet Jackson "wardrobe malfunction".
Republican politicians and campaigners in Louisiana have written a letter to organisers raising "serious concerns" ahead of this year's Super Bowl, which is due to take place at the Caesars Superdome in New Orleans in February.
Grammy-winning rapper Kendrick Lamar will headline the half-time show.
In a letter signed by 17 Republican senators and representatives for Louisiana, as well as 15 pro-family organisations, critics called out Lopez 's performance alongside Shakira in Florida in 2020, saying the star "wore little clothing and was groped by male and female dancers on stage", and also "made sexually suggestive gestures and performed on a stripper pole".
Criticising Rihanna 's performance at the 2023 half-time show in Arizona - when the star revealed she was pregnant with her second child - they said she was shown "groping herself" while singing lyrics "that were so offensive that few Louisiana adults could read those lyrics before an audience without shame".
The letter continued: "We realize that these past vulgar performances may have been acceptable to the residents of those states where those Super Bowls were held but, in Louisiana, these lewd acts are inappropriate for viewing by children, objectify women, and are simply NOT welcomed by the majority of Louisiana parents."
'It would have violated obscenity law'
Jackson 's performance with Justin Timberlake in Texas in 2004, during which he exposed one of her breasts, was also highlighted.
"Had that 2004 performance taken place in Louisiana and been proven to be intentional, it would have violated Louisiana's obscenity law," the letter said.
CBS, which aired that year's Super Bowl, was fined $550,000 by the Federal Communications Commission over the incident - but this was later overturned.
In 2021, following the release of the Framing Britney Spears documentary, which included details of Timberlake's relationship with the star and their break-up, conversation around his Super Bowl performance with Jackson was also reignited.
At the time of the incident, Jackson bore the brunt of the criticism, while Timberlake's solo career flourished. In 2021, Timberlake issued an apology, saying: "I specifically want to apologise to Britney Spears and Janet Jackson both individually, because I care for and respect these women and I know I failed."
The Republicans' letter did not mention Timberlake but said Jackson's "exposed bare breast was excused by one of her fellow performers as a 'wardrobe malfunction'."
Super Bowl half-time performances have become "increasingly vile", it continued, and therefore it could be "reasonably anticipated that the half-time performance this year in New Orleans will be inappropriate for children to watch".
Sky News has contacted the celebrities for a response to the criticism.
Senator Valarie Hodges, who signed the letter and shared details on X, said: "My hope is that Louisiana can set an example for future hosting states of the Super Bowl in advocating for entertainment suitable for viewers of all ages without needing a content rating."
It has also been shared by the Family Research Council. President Tony Perkins, a former Louisiana state representative who is also one of the signatories, said their complaint was "not only about protecting children, important as that is, but also upholding community standards".
The letter is addressed to Phillip Sherman, chairman of the Greater New Orleans Sports Foundation, and Robert Vosbein Jr, chairman of the Louisiana Stadium and Exposition District, which oversees the superdrome venue.
In a statement sent to Sky News, Jay Cicero, president and chief executive of the Greater New Orleans Sports Foundation, said: "We respect and value the comments of our legislators, who play a critical role in our ability to secure large events providing an economic boost to our city and state.
"We have shared the letter with the NFL and we are all in agreement that this year's half-time show will be a family-friendly event befitting New Orleans' storied history hosting Super Bowls."
Mr Vosbein told the Louisiana Illuminator news outlet it was "unfortunate" Ms Hodges had waited until less than a few weeks before the event to share her concerns.