DAN HODGES: The biggest problem is that we have a PM who doesn't want to stop the boats...
'I won't stand for it,' he continued. 'I promised to restore control and cut migration, and I'm delivering with tough new measures. British workers – I've got your back.'
But they were just that. Words.
Everyone knows the Tories betrayed the British people over their pledge to slash legal migration and 'stop the boats '. It's why they were so unceremoniously booted out of office less than 12 months ago.
Yet they know something else, too. Keir Starmer 's own pledge to 'deliver' on migration is equally empty.
There is nothing in Labour 's proposed White Paper that is remotely 'tough' or has the slightest chance of turning the tide of humanity crossing our borders legally and illegally.
Some tinkering over the time-limit for non-graduate work visas. A small reduction in the number of students staying in the UK after they have finished their courses. More lip-service to the idea of migrants having a better understanding of English. A bit of tweaking of Article B of the Human Rights Act.
After some initial success in targeting the small boats and increasing the number of deportations, normal service under Labour has been resumed. Actually, exceeded.
So far this year, more than 11,000 people have crossed the Channel to Britain's shores, a 40 per cent increase from the same time last year.
Yet again, the voters are being treated to the spectacle of a Prime Minister promising to 'take back control' of the borders. And yet again, those words are destined to die on his lips.
Meanwhile, more and more desperate people will die beneath the cold waters of the Channel. And the social fabric of the nation will continue to be rent asunder as another establishment politician's promise turns to dust.
If Starmer genuinely ' had the back' of Britain's workers, he would be taking serious, radical action.
An offshoring scheme for processing. Withdrawal from the European Convention on Human Rights that even ministers privately concede has hamstrung their efforts to get on top of the migration crisis.
An economic strategy that doesn't rely on the failed model of globalisation that has seen hundreds of thousands of those workers thrown to the wolves. Instead, the people of Britain must brace themselves for another stab in the back.
Within government, there has been an intense debate about how to respond to growing public fury over immigration and the accompanying populist backlash that has seen Nigel Farage surge into a double-digit lead in the polls.
Ministers, including Home Secretary Yvette Cooper, have been pushing for bolder action.
But Keir Starmer has rejected their entreaties. Partly this is because of complacency.
No 10 is expecting a significant fall in the legal migration figures once the measures implemented by outgoing Tory Home Secretary James Cleverly feed through into the system.
'Downing Street thinks that fall will be enough to diffuse the issue,' one minister told me. 'They don't think they need to go that much further.'
Then, there are the interventions from Chancellor Rachel Reeves, who believes every issue in government should be subordinated to her increasingly desperate attempts to stimulate growth.
'Rachel is terrified of the impact tougher measures will have on the economy,' a colleague reported.
Yet there is another reason why Keir Starmer is incapable of getting to grips with immigration – and it is a significant one. He just doesn't want to. The Prime Minister might appear deaf and blind to the mounting anger of the British people, but he is not completely dumb.
He knows full well the extent to which his failure to exert real control is fuelling the Reform insurgency.
But he simply cannot bring himself to issue the harsh instructions needed to bring order to the migration chaos.
There is no deep mystery to who Keir Starmer is or what he believes. Despite the efforts of his aides to construct another – more electorally viable – persona, he really is just a middle-class, liberal, human-rights lawyer from North London. Stopping the boats requires action that to him is anathema.
Smashing the gangs, even if it were operationally viable, is self-evidently not going to be enough.
What's needed is someone with the political vision, will and empathy to instinctively grasp the concern of working people over the ongoing migrant influx.
Someone who is prepared to introduce immigration policies that are not liberal, but are – on the contrary – overtly illiberal.
Someone prepared to confront with passion and energy the human-rights industry that is itself profiting from the trafficking in human misery.
Keir Starmer is not that man. And everyone knows it.
By pretending the Government's new White Paper is the answer to the immigration crisis, the Prime Minister is taking the British people for fools. And in the process, he is trying to fool himself.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Glasgow Times
9 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
MSP hits out at plans for new solar wind farm in Eaglesham
An application for the project at Bonnyton Golf Club has been lodged with East Renfrewshire Council. Contractors Advance Grid Solutions has proposed the installation of 41,000 Solar Photovoltaics, aiming for an anticipated export capacity of up to 28 megawatts (MW). Jackson Carlaw, MSP for Eastwood, has voiced strong opposition to the planned development, arguing that it would significantly erode greenbelt land in Eaglesham. The bid follows East Renfrewshire Council's decision in April to grant planning permission for a 40MW battery energy storage facility located just over two miles from the golf club on the east side of Glasgow Road. Carlaw said: 'There is a serious risk that large swathes of greenbelt land in Eaglesham could now be lost to development. 'The solar farm proposal suggests that the unacceptable decision of Labour and Independent councillors to grant planning permission for the battery plant may lead to a stream of applications for energy infrastructure projects on our local greenfield sites. 'There is no evidence in the planning support statement that the applicant has fulfilled a key requirement of Scotland's National Planning Framework 4 to identify and explore if the development can be on land that is not part of the greenbelt.' Carlaw said that while planning powers are devolved to Scotland, the position of the previous UK Conservative Government was that brownfield areas should be prioritised for solar development. He added: 'It is vital that the case continues to be made for protecting Eaglesham's green belt and I urge local residents to object to the solar farm planning application.' A statement accompanying the planning application for the solar wind farm states: 'The 28 MW array will supply ~29 GWh/yr of zero-carbon electricity, advancing national and Local Development Plan 2 goals. 'LVIA (Landscape and Visual Impact Assessment) confirms no significant landscape or visual effects from the well-screened site; LEMP (Landscape and Ecological Management Plan) secures native planting and a measurable biodiversity net-gain with no impact on designated habitats. 'Cultural-heritage, glint-and-glare and aviation assessments record no significant residual effects.' An East Renfrewshire Council spokesperson said: 'The application will be considered in due course.' Advance Grid Solutions has been approached for comment. Comments supporting or objecting to the proposal can be made by typing in the reference number – 2025/0405/TP – on the planning applications search page of East Renfrewshire Council's website.
BBC News
9 minutes ago
- BBC News
Kemi Badenoch: I don't identify as Nigerian any more
Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch has said she no longer identifies as Nigerian and has not renewed her passport since the early who was born in the UK, grew up in both Nigeria and the US. She returned to England aged 16 because of Nigeria's worsening political and economic climate, and to continue her on former MP and television presenter Gyles Brandreth's Rosebud podcast, she said she was "Nigerian through ancestry" though "by identity, I'm not really".Last year, Badenoch faced criticism from Nigeria's vice president who said she had "denigrated" the West African country. Badenoch, who lived in Lagos, spoke at length about her upbringing on the podcast. "I know the country very well, I have a lot of family there, and I'm very interested in what happens there. But home is where my now family is."On not renewing her passport, she said: "I don't identify with it any more, most of my life has been in the UK and I've just never felt the need to.""I'm Nigerian through ancestry, by birth, despite not being born there because of my parents... but by identity I'm not really," she added. Badenoch said when she visited the country when her father died she had to get a visa, which was "a big fandango".She said her early experiences in Nigeria shaped her political outlook, including "why I don't like socialism".As a child "I remember never quite feeling that I belonged there", she went on, saying she recalled "coming back to the UK in 1996 thinking this is home".At the end of last year, Badenoch was criticised for saying she had grown up in fear and insecurity in Nigeria, which was plagued by corruption. The country's vice president Kashim Shettima responded, saying his government was "proud" of Badenoch "in spite of her efforts at denigrating her nation of origin". A spokesperson for Badenoch rebuffed the criticism.
The Herald Scotland
35 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
'I hated how Sandie Peggie's daughter was used against her'
Jackie Baillie has sized up the situation too and moves across to exchange greetings with him. This jocund character is a constituent and he recognises her immediately, delighted that his MSP, the deputy leader of Scottish Labour, is giving him the time of day. I've been trying all morning to bring out the 'designated b****** in Ms Baillie, this being the locution Anas Sarwar once coined for her. He'd said it with a twinkle in his eye, but several Labour politicians and party retainers might have experienced a chill. Almost everyone involved in Scottish politics has, at some point, asked the question I'm about to raise with her: why did you never want to be leader of Labour in Scotland? It would have been there for the taking if she'd really wanted it. The party had turned to her twice to steady the ship when the leader's chair was temporarily vacant. She's possessed of a formidable political intellect which puts her in the Champions League bracket of UK politicians, so she could have done the job no danger. 'People should know their own limitations,' she says. 'I've never really been comfortable about some of the public-facing stuff. I'm not delusional about what I can and can't do.' I'm not buying that, though. 'Come on, Jackie: look at some of the clowns who currently hold down cabinet positions in Scotland.' She'll say only that there are a lot of people on the SNP's backbenches who 'have struggled to make a contribution'. 'You mean they're as thick as sauce,' is how I'm putting it. 'I'm not saying that,' she laughs in mock outrage. She pledges her support for Anas Sarwar as leader and, to be fair, they work well together when I've seen them out and about. 'Anas is probably one of the best leaders we've had. He is our real opportunity to do something this time round. He does a lot of front-facing stuff because he's good with people, both in the party and beyond. 'I love my constituents, I want to spend most of my time here with them. I'm rooted here. I'd much rather be behind the scenes getting things done: it suits me and I'm good at it.' Read more by Kevin McKenna: If you were being unkind though, you might suggest that this is just code for knowing where the bodies are buried, principally because most of them are buried in her back garden. 'I know I have a reputation for being as hard as nails and that Anas called me his 'designated b******', which I thought was very mean.' But she says 'very mean' in the manner of one of the Bennet sisters taking bashfully about that nice Mr Bingley. 'You just need a long memory,' she says. Now we're talking. I'm meeting Ms Baillie the day after the end of Sandie Peggie's employment tribunal versus NHS Fife in what's become Scotland's Dreyfus moment. I can't not ask her about it and she knows it too. Ms Baillie is currently in the process of selecting candidates for next year's Holyrood elections and has noted that more men are coming forward than women. She's putting twinning arrangements in place to ensure equality. This isn't surprising. When women see what happens to other women in public life or in the public eye – Sandie Peggie, Kate Forbes, Joanna Cherry, JK Rowling – it must make them less inclined to volunteer for the same treatment. And so we begin exchanging our most vivid recollections of the tribunal. I tell her that Sandra Peggie being questioned over her claim that she'd been having a heavy period when she'd asked Dr Upton to leave the female nurses' changing-room was just about the most sinister and malevolent statement I'd ever seen uttered in Scottish public life. Sandie Peggie brought the case against NHS Fife. (Image: PA) Jackie Baillie says: 'What I hated the most was how Sandie Peggie's daughter was used against her and forced to say twice that her mum was her best friend. I was utterly horrified by that. 'Let me be clear, though. If I was Health Secretary my position would be to improve waiting times at gender identity clinics. I've seen people who are experiencing gender dysphoria and all the physical and emotional torment that comes with that. Do I have a responsibility to do reduce waiting times in these cases? Absolutely. 'The Gender Recognition Certification process requires reform, but I wouldn't go as far as self-ID, because you then remove the kind of protections that I think are still needed.' From the evidence she's heard in Ms Peggie's employment tribunal, does she think there's enough alleged malfeasance to merit a public inquiry into the customs and practices of NHS Fife? 'I'm loathe to call for public inquiries,' she says, 'partly because they take so long; they're expensive and I've never been convinced that their recommendations are always followed. Do I think though, that there needs to be some kind of independent investigation into what's happened [at NHS Fife]: absolutely. 'I can't help but think of the 800,000 people on waiting lists across Scotland, many of whom are from Fife: the delayed discharges; the cancer waiting lists. All of them exert real pressures on the NHS and yet so much time of NHS Fife's senior management team has been devoted to this case. 'I note that Dr Upton doesn't have a gender recognition certificate and so why can't we – and I get the desire to be inclusive – be inclusive of all staff while respecting individual rights?' Read more Kevin McKenna: I ask Ms Baillie if it's as simple as building a third toilet and changing facility. 'The corporate body of the Scottish Parliament got it right,' she says, 'when they designated some spaces across the estate as women-only; some as men-only and some as unisex. This made sense. 'Sandra Peggie is a nurse and we should value our nurses. NHS Fife's primary responsibility is healthcare and dealing with patients, so why are they pitting staff groups against each other? I also question the sense of NHS Fife being joint defenders in this action and I question the amount of money that's been spent on this and every day. NHS Fife are not covering themselves in glory.' Does she have a view about the SNP repeatedly expressing confidence in NHS Fife throughout the tribunal? 'I know, having been around for so long, that there is no way on earth that Scottish ministers – and particularly the Health Minister – knew nothing about what was going to happen. I don't understand why we are still here. Some people believe it should play out, but to be frank, if I was the Scottish Government I would have ended this. 'The issue now is that Sandie Peggie won't be the only person. There will be other health boards and other public bodies. The government needs to move fast on this. It can't wait until after the election. 'Practically, we need to see where there has been institutional capture and fix that. That's what the Scottish Government should do without waiting. I'm now in a place that says we should be inclusive of everybody in society but that there's a way of doing it that safeguards the rights of others.' Yet, wasn't [[Scottish Labour]] party complicit in bringing us to this employment tribunal in Dundee by voting with the Government on the GRA? 'You all saw what was happening. Were you just listening to the wrong people or was it a case of not wanting to upset some activists,' I ask. 'None of the above,' she says forcefully. 'I was brought in late after Stage 2 of the GRA had passed to try and negotiate with the Scottish Government. We were particularly keen to place amendments in the bill that would protect single-sex spaces. 'I spent a lot of time trying to negotiate with [then Health Secretary] Shona Robison. 'What would happen though, is that having agreed something with me, she would then go to the Scottish Greens and Maggie Chapman and it would unravel.' 'Yet, you all – with a few noble exceptions – still voted for it,' I tell her. 'I had assurances on the record that they would discuss all of the detail with the UK Government (for Equality Act purposes),' says Ms Baillie. 'Nor did we impose a whip from the centre. We had group meetings where every single member was invited to speak and the group as a whole decided to take particular concessions. Some of them I didn't share, but I respected the process we went through which was the most inclusive route there had been about any piece of legislation. Well, perhaps. In mitigation, there was support for Michelle Thompson's amendment aimed at pausing applications for GRCs from men 'charged with a sexual offence but not yet convicted and placed on the sexual offenders' register'. The MSP, who is a survivor of sexual assault, had warned that allowing these risked traumatising and harming their female victims. Ms Baillie had also tabled her own amendment. 'If you look at what we tried to do with the amendment, we were trying to get to a position where there were more safeguards in the Bill. We were very clear about protecting single-sex spaces. 'I think then that reality hit them with the Isla Bryson case and the extent to which it could be manipulative was just laid bare.' 'Our fault was to believe the reassurances we'd been given that there were negotiations going on with the UK Parliament. I'm not really buying this either. In the world of Scottish politics, you'd trust rattlesnakes more than any assurances given by the [[SNP]] in the Nicola Sturgeon era. PART TWO ON MONDAY: The relationship between Holyrood Labour and Westminster Labour; seeking candidates with life experience and how the SNP have betrayed their own supporters.
