Court rejects tenant's claim landlord should have insured against arrears
The obligation extended to the specified insured risks and that definition does not refer expressly or by implication to losses caused by public-health restrictions, he said.
In those circumstances, the judge said Elite failed to meet the threshold that would persuade the court not to enter summary judgment against the company over rent arrears and refer the matter to full hearing.
He therefore made an order granting judgment for €276,041 in favour of the shopping centre landlord BVK Elektra 2 Liffey Phase 1 ICAV.
The case was also against Bunker Estates Ltd, which was the guarantor in the lease for Elite. The judge said since the case was initiated against Elite, Bunker has been dissolved and the application for summary judge against Bunker was adjourned generally.
The judge said while Elite had also raised arguments about the lack of a clear explanation in the accounts for the rent arrears claim and the status of BVK, the main issue was business interruption insurance.
The judge was satisfied the figures and explanations provided were accurate and reliable
Elite said the arrears were related to trading difficulties during Covid and the landlord had not activated a rent review clause in the lease, which would give rise to an adjustment in the figures claimed.
Mr Justice O'Donnell was satisfied that the figures and explanations provided were accurate and reliable.
The defendant accepted that it had not paid the rent and other charges for periods, he said. Its primary argument was that this was related to the trading difficulties during the period of Covid restrictions and was also excusable for reasons to do with the business interruption clauses in the lease.
The rent review issue was addressed by the parties and an agreed position was achieved with a consequent adjustment to the figure claimed, the judge said.
He granted judgment and adjourned the case to October for final orders and cost matters.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Agriland
6 hours ago
- Agriland
Watch: Galway organic farmer issues plea to buy produce amid bumper harvest
A Co. Galway organic farmer is pleading with the public to buy his organically grown fruit and vegetable produce following a bumper harvest. Kenneth Keavey is the founder of Green Earth Organics which is a 100% certified organic fruit and vegetable farm located in Corrandulla, Co. Galway. Kenneth and Jenny Keavey started a box delivery scheme in 2006 and employ 40 people. Currently, the pair are farming 40ac of organically certified land with another 10ac split between a wildlife biodiversity area, native woodland forestry, and red clover/grassland. The organic farmer said "conditions were just perfect" for this year's growing season and that "everything was aligned", leading to an excellent harvest of fruit and vegetables on the farm. Speaking to Agriland, Keavey said: 'A couple of weeks ago, we gave away 600 heads of lettuce to people because we had so much we didn't know what to do with it. 'We also gave away 700 bags of kale because there was that much and orders were dropping. 'We did this to give value back to our customers as a 'thank you' for ordering, and maybe to incentivise them to order again next week. 'At the moment we're harvesting a bucket-load of broccoli. We even had onions two weeks ago - that's unheard of in Ireland at the beginning of July." Unfortunately, Keavey stressed that these efforts have not been enough and orders are still dropping. The business experienced a similar scenario during Covid-19. He explained: "During the Covid lockdown, our customer levels expanded, then the restrictions eased and our order levels collapsed. 'That year we were forced to plough stuff back into the fields - it was just devasting to have to do that and such a shock to see. This year we had a glimpse of that again." Keavey started growing organic vegetables in 2004 on a third-generation family farm in Co. Galway. He said: "I wanted to do something that was environmentally sound, something in line with my values and passion to do something positive for the environment. "Our aim was to grow organically, sustainably, no chemicals, and deliver direct to the customer. "We started off with a quarter acre of vegetables and one polytunnel, when nobody had polytunnels in the west of Ireland. Everybody thought we were mad." The business now sells fruit and vegetables to homes around the country, with delivery to roughly 1,700 homes this week alone. Next year, Green Earth Organics will be in its 20th year of production, with Keavey highlighting that it has not always been plain sailing. He said: "During the recession, the business had to adapt and started selling to supermarkets. However this didn't remain sustainable for the business and we went back to focusing on home delivery." The organic farm also allows customers the opportunity to buy a "charity box", which means all the produce in the box will be sent to St. Vincent de Paul. Since issuing the plea, Keavey has thanked the public for their kind words and thoughts in response. He said: "The orders, the words, and energy, every single one meant a great deal."
Irish Independent
15 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Diageo looks to Guinness for boost with challenging times ahead
The London Stock Exchange listed firm, which also makes Johnnie Walker whisky and Gordon's gin, is among the FTSE 100 index's weaker performers this year, with its share price down 28pc since the start of 2025. Tariffs, cautious consumer demand and increased cost pressures have weighed down businesses across the drinks industry. Diageo is expected to reveal a drop in profits for the last year when it unveils its latest finances tomorrow, after seeing a slowdown in revenue growth. Analysts have predicted that Diageo will report an operating profit of $5.65bn (€4.87bn) for the year to the end of June. It would reflect a drop after posting a $6bn profit a year earlier. Meanwhile, it is also expected to reveal organic net sales growth of 1.4pc for the year. Diageo has been buoyed by strong sales of Guinness over the last year, particularly in the UK and Europe, helping to offset declines in some key spirits categories, such as vodka. The group's sales are mainly driven by spirits While Diageo is known in Ireland primarily for its beer business, the group's sales are mainly driven by spirits. Its portfolio includes global brands including Smirnoff, Tanqueray, Captain Morgan and Baileys, as well as a stake in Moet Hennessy. Top-shelf spirits had a run of success around the time of the Covid-19 pandemic, as people drinking at home experimented with time-consuming cocktails and opted for higher-priced brands. However, demand then fell off and cooled outright in some markets, including China and the US. The incoming tariff of 15pc on drinks shipped from Europe, Mexico and Canada into the US add a further headache. In its previous update to investors, Diageo reported that net sales grew by 2.9pc to $4.37bn for the three months to March 31, as it benefited from increased activity in North America, evidence of stockpiling before tariffs came into effect. In May, the group also launched a $500m cost-saving programme, in order to support further investment and improve its financial position. Last month, the company revealed Debra Crew had stepped down as chief executive with 'immediate effect' and by 'mutual agreement', amid the drop in the firm's value. AJ Bell's analyst Russ Mould said her departure 'does not provide a huge amount of confidence in the full-year figures to the end of June from the drinks giant'. Mr Mould added: 'That said, Crew and management stuck to their prior guidance for 2025 and 2026 alongside May's trading update, and that steer will provide the benchmark for these numbers, which will be presented by Nik Jhangiani, who is both interim chief executive and the chief financial officer.' Investors and analysts will also be holding out for a fresh update on how the company will deal with ongoing tariff costs amid efforts to mitigate the impact of the US administration's increases to import taxes. Aarin Chiekrie, equity analyst at Hargreaves Lansdown, said: 'Markets will be keeping a close eye on just how well Diageo is managing these ongoing tariff headwinds, which were expected to add around $150m in annual costs. 'The Johnnie Walker and Guinness maker plans to absorb half through operational efficiencies, with the rest likely passed on through price increases.'
The Irish Sun
2 days ago
- The Irish Sun
Dragon's Den star stripped of MBE after judge slams high-flyer as ‘selfish & untrustworthy' over £200k in unpaid bills
A FORMER Dragon's Den star has been stripped of her MBE after refusing to pay £200,000 in legal fees. Julie Meyer was slammed by a judge for being "selfish" after she failed to pay her lawyers or attend court hearings. 4 Julie Meyer from Dragons Den Online 4 Julie starred on Dragon's Den online in 2009 Credit: BBC 4 Julie Meyer on Dragon's den Online Credit: BBC In 2022, the 58-year-old venture capitalist became embroiled in a legal row with law firm Farrers & Co. She claimed she had received a poor service and refused to pay £197,000 after they represented her during a case in Malta. An arrest warrant was issued for the entrepreneur after she failed to turn up to court and provide documents for the case. Meyer claimed she was unable to travel from Switzerland as she was suffering with conjunctivitis and didn't have a Covid vaccine. Read more News But it was decided her reasoning was insufficient to avoid attending hearings in person. Meyer was later slapped with a six-month sentence after she was ruled to be in contempt of court. And last night, the Cabinet Office revealed that the businesswoman had been stripped of her MBE. Her name appeared on a recently updated list of shamed individuals who have forfeited their honours since 2023. Most read in The Sun Disgraced former Post Office CEO Paula Vennells also features on the list, after she was formally stripped of her CBE by the King. She had already committed to relinquish the gong following fury at her role in the Horizon postmaster scandal. The document said that Meyer's gong had been taken away after she brought "the honours system into disrepute". She was awarded the MBE in 2012 for services to entrepreneurship. Sara Davies breaks silence on shock Dragon's Den exit as star says she struggled to 'juggle' her busy career Meyer was chosen to star on the online version of Dragon's Den in 2009. After her appearance on the BBC Two show, she was appointed as David Cameron's Government a year later. She has previously supported huge tech brands such as and Skype. Handing her the six-month suspended sentence three years ago, Mr Justice Kerr slammed Meyer as "selfish and untrustworthy". He added: "I am satisfied there is every prospect that the defendant will continue to flout orders of the court unless coerced into obeying them." Later the same year, Meyer lost an appeal to overturn her suspended prison sentence. Three disgraced former submarine captains Top brass urged ministers to withdraw the prestigious gongs from the trio over sex and bullying scandals. One had The third was found guilty of bullying on nuclear-powered attack sub All three were commanders — James Bond's rank — and led crews of more than 130. The Navy asked the Cabinet Office Forfeiture Committee to strip the men of their awards and King Charles gave final approval. Last year, In 2020, he made a string of shocking comments on Twitter, branding Jewish people "too touchy," and saying Israel "is not yours." The Met confirmed they were investigating the tweets after he was dropped by his manager and banned from the website. 4 Julie Meyer on Dragon's den Online Credit: BBC
