Phantom cows spark $350m Uruguay scam
She has travelled 600 kilometres (370 miles) from the capital, Montevideo, to find 61 cattle she owns, at least on paper. The missing bovines were part of a "cow bond" scheme that has collapsed, causing one of Uruguay's biggest ever financial scandals.
The co-owner of one Uruguayan firm that took money from savers to invest in cows has died by suicide. Three companies have gone bust and are under investigation for fraud. "Hello moo-moo! Could one of you be mine?" Palleiro called out hopefully into a paddock in the border region of Artigas, her jeans caked in mud as she approached a wire fence to get a closer look at the cows.
Palleiro – like hundreds of other investors – is unable to find the animals she owns or prove they even exist, making them part of a herd of "phantom cows" that could number over 700,000 head of cattle. So far, the losses have mounted to some $350 million, roiling the stable farming nation, home to just 3.4 million people – but 12 million cows.
It has also sent shockwaves through bigger ranching neighbours Argentina and Brazil, which looked to Uruguay's cattle-tracking system as a model and where similar livestock investment schemes operate.
In March 2024, Palleiro put her life savings of over $50,000 into the livestock investment scheme offered by a local firm named Conexión Ganadera, lured by promises of fixed 7-10% dollar returns and investment materials with bucolic pictures of brown-and-white Hereford cattle.
When she went in search of her cows, Palleiro carried print copies from the cattle registry to see if she could match the 53 tracking numbers linked to this ranch with the tags of the cows staring at her on the opposite side of the fence.
Using her smartphone camera, she zoomed in on the tracking numbers pinned to their ears. It soon became clear few of the numbers matched. Then the cows started backing away. She couldn't get close enough. The exercise felt hopeless.
"It feels like falling into a nightmare," said Palleiro.
Tesla crash
Three of the biggest firms under investigation for fraud are Conexión Ganadera, República Ganadera and Grupo Larrarte, which between them persuaded nearly 6,000 people or investor pools to buy into the programme, investing millions of dollars.
Similar investment schemes exist throughout South America, in Argentina, Brazil and Colombia. Many are legitimate.
Martín Fablet, a local radio presenter in Montevideo, said he invested several times in Conexión Ganadera and other livestock schemes in Uruguay over the past 12 years: "This system of receiving fixed dollar returns worked fantastically well for at least 11 years. They paid me on time."
The first hint of the scandal at Conexión Ganadera came on November 28 last year, when a Tesla Model 3 car crashed at 211 kilometres per hour in the small central Uruguayan city of Florida.
Behind the wheel was Gustavo Basso, one of the co-owners of Conexión Ganadera, which had boomed since opening in 1999.
Weeks after he drove his car into a parked construction vehicle, investors started reporting their payments from the cattle scheme were late, and by January the company confirmed it was short of nearly $250 million. A coroner concluded in April that Basso had died by suicide.
By late January, investors were scrambling to withdraw savings amid reports of fraud. Some filed suits for fraud, leading to bankruptcy proceedings and an official investigation by Uruguay's Prosecutor's Office for Money Laundering Crimes, which remains ongoing. The prosecutor declined to comment to Reuters.
'Maybe the cows were fakes'
Politicians, radio hosts, pensioners and even priests are among the thousands now attempting to recover their savings – and their missing 'phantom' cattle, the number of which is proving hard to pin down.
An inventory of the biggest firm, Conexión Ganadera, carried out by a bankruptcy trustee estimated that as few as 70,000-80,000 of the 804,604 cattle the company claimed to manage actually existed.
In another court case into fraud allegations, Uruguay's Ministry of Agriculture and Livestock (MGAP) said in March that one of Conexión Ganadera's main cattle holding firms, Pasfer, had only 49 of the 3,740 cows that it put up as collateral to secure a loan.
Savers could own cows directly that would be reared and sold for profit by livestock firms, or take an investment stake in the overall scheme.
Palleiro, an urban professional, liked the idea of owning a tangible asset. It seemed a safe bet. She could track the cows via a state-backed online portal – for years an example globally for cattle tracking – which set out breed, age and location. Each cow was supposed to be branded with a symbol assigned by the government and documents listing her assets carried the crest of the agriculture ministry, which oversees the cattle registry.
Uruguay's national cattle registry declined to comment on the cases.
Reuters
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Khaleej Times
4 hours ago
- Khaleej Times
US stock market concentration risks come to fore as megacaps report earnings
Wall Street's reliance on a small number of high market-value stocks to keep momentum going for the U.S. equities bull market will be tested in coming days as major technology and growth companies report earnings. Concentration in widely followed market barometers such as the SP 500 and Nasdaq Composite means that weakness in just a few names can have broad ramifications as the indexes hover at record highs. "When a handful of stocks dominate the market ... if you do have a period of disappointment from those stocks, you could see disproportionate impacts on your portfolio from just a handful of company-specific issues," said Michael Reynolds, vice president of investment strategy at Glenmede. Drawing attention to such top-heavy market leadership on Wednesday will be earnings results due from Google parent Alphabet and Tesla, the first of the "Magnificent Seven" megacaps to report this period. That group - which also includes Nvidia, Microsoft , Apple, Amazon and Meta Platforms - earned the "Magnificent" moniker because of their dominant business positions and huge stock gains in 2023 and 2024. Stock performance this year among the Magnificent Seven has been mixed. But they have all rebounded since April from a selloff following President Donald Trump's "Liberation Day" announcement of sweeping global tariffs. The group amounted to one-third of the weight of the SP 500 as of Friday, due to their massive market caps, their largest combined presence since the start of the year, according to LSEG Datastream. Alphabet shares are up about 1% on the year, while shares of Elon Musk-led Tesla are down about 18%. Together, they account for over 5% of the SP 500's weight. Other data points also indicate market concentration becoming more extreme. The top 10 weights in the SP 500 last week hit 37.3% of the index, near the 38% level it reached in January, which had been its highest level on record, according to SP Dow Jones Indices, citing data since 1975. These massive stocks generally have higher valuations. The top 10 stocks have an average price-to-earnings ratio of about 26 times, compared to 20 times for the rest of the SP 500, said Lisa Shalett, chief investment officer at Morgan Stanley Wealth Management. "The biggest stocks are very expensive," Shalett said. "If the biggest stocks fall the most, the index is very vulnerable." The SP 500 technology sector recently accounted for 33.9% of the entire SP 500's market value, the largest share since March 2000 during the height of the dot-com bubble era, according to LSEG Datastream. The SP 500 is considered a benchmark for the stock market, but its top-heavy nature could mean investors who own funds that mirror the index are less diversified than they think. "If you are designing a portfolio, you really need to consider, OK, what are the weights there?" said Todd Sohn, ETF and technical strategist at Strategas. "It's not as diversified as it has been in the past. Then you have to consider some other means out there to keep that portfolio balanced." Nvidia, which recently became the first company to top $4 trillion in market value, had as of Tuesday a 7.83% weight in the SP 500. That is the most a single stock has ever accounted for in the index, topping the 7.7% that Apple reached last year, according to Sohn, who looked at 45 years of data. The weight of Nvidia - a semiconductor company that has symbolized the artificial intelligence boom - is greater than five entire SP 500 sectors out of 11 in the index, including consumer staples, which includes 38 stocks and has a 5.4% weight, and energy, a 23-company group with a total SP 500 weighting of slightly less than 3%. Heading into the heavy part of earnings season, the SP 500 is up over 7% this year, and becoming increasingly led by larger stocks. Since April 8, when the market hit its low point for the year following Trump's tariff announcement, the SP 500 has gained nearly 27%. The equal-weight version of the index - which is considered a gauge of the average SP 500 stock - has risen 21.5% in that time. Since the end of 2022, the SP 500 has gained over 60%, more than doubling the equal-weight version's gains in that time. "When the market gets really expensive and narrow ... the market becomes more vulnerable," said Matthew Maley, chief market strategist at Miller Tabak. "So it's a big concern for me."
Zawya
4 hours ago
- Zawya
Wall Street futures lifted by US-Japan trade deal
U.S. stock index futures jumped on Wednesday after President Donald Trump struck a trade deal with Japan, bolstering expectations of more such agreements as the August 1 deadline approaches. The agreement includes lowering tariffs on Japan's auto sector to 15% from the previous 27.5%, while duties on other Japanese goods will also be slashed to 15% from 25%. At 5:48 a.m. ET, S&P 500 E-minis were up 23.25 points, or 0.37%. Nasdaq 100 E-minis were up 37.25 points, or 0.16%, and Dow E-minis were up 216 points, or 0.48%. The benchmark S&P 500 closed at a record high on Tuesday, marking its eighth record close in nearly a month, boosted by easing trade tensions, signs of a resilient U.S. economy and largely upbeat second-quarter earnings. The blue-chip Dow ended 0.4% higher and was just 1.25% shy of its all-time high. The tech-heavy Nasdaq, however, was dragged lower by losses in Meta Platforms and Microsoft. Investors' attention is on earnings from "Magnificent Seven" group that have helped propel U.S. stocks to all-time highs, with Tesla and Alphabet set to report after the closing bell on Wednesday. Renewed optimism about artificial intelligence, coupled with stretched valuations, has led to elevated earnings expectations for these stocks, leaving little room for disappointment. Shares of Tesla and Alphabet were largely steady in premarket trading. Texas Instruments sank 11.7% after its quarterly profit forecast failed to impress investors, as it pointed to weaker-than-expected demand for its analog chips from some customers and underscored tariff-related uncertainty. The earnings also weighed on its peer analog chipmakers, with Analog Devices, NXP Semiconductors and ON Semiconductor falling between 4.7% and 6.3%. Automaker General Motors became a casualty of the trade war on Tuesday when it said Trump's tariffs took a $1.1 billion hit on its quarterly earnings, sending its shares down more than 8%. Other notable names reporting on Wednesday include Hasbro , Chipotle, and Mattel. In economic data, existing home sales numbers for June is due on the day. Thursday's weekly jobless claims numbers and S&P Global's flash PMI data will be closely assessed to gauge economic health in the wake of tariff uncertainties. Following a mixed set of economic data last week, traders have ruled out an interest rate cut by the Federal Reserve next week. Odds for a September reduction stand at 56.1%, according to the CME FedWatch tool. (Reporting by Nikhil Sharma in Bengaluru; Editing by Maju Samuel)
Zawya
a day ago
- Zawya
US Stocks: S&P 500 and Nasdaq notch record high closes, lifted by Alphabet
The S&P 500 and the Nasdaq notched record high closes on Monday, lifted by Alphabet and other megacaps ahead of several earnings reports this week, while investors bet on potential trade deals to blunt economic damage from the Trump administration's global tariffs. Google-parent Alphabet rallied 2.7% ahead of its quarterly report on Wednesday. It and Tesla, also reporting on Wednesday, kick off earnings from the so-called "Magnificent Seven", and their results may set the tone for other heavyweight companies reporting in the next several days. Tesla dipped 0.35%, while Apple gained 0.62% and Amazon rose 1.43%, both lifting the S&P 500 and Nasdaq. Verizon rallied over 4% after the telecommunications company boosted its annual profit forecast. Analysts on average expected S&P 500 companies to report a 6.7% increase in earnings for the second quarter, with Big Tech driving much of that gain, according to LSEG I/B/E/S. "So far, companies that have reported have, in general, met or beat guidance from the prior quarter, and we haven't seen any degradation either in corporate profits or consumer spending," said Tom Hainlin, national investment strategist at U.S. Bank Wealth Management in Minneapolis. With U.S. President Donald Trump's August 1 tariff deadline approaching, the S&P 500 is up about 8% year to date, with investors betting the economic damage from tariffs will be less than feared. U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said on Sunday he was confident the United States could secure a trade deal with the European Union, even as EU members explored possible countermeasures against the United States. Trump has threatened 30% tariffs on imports from Mexico and the EU, and sent letters to other trading partners, including Canada, Japan and Brazil, setting tariffs ranging from 20% to 50%. The S&P 500 climbed 0.14% to end the session at 6,305.60 points. The Nasdaq gained 0.38% to 20,974.18 points, while the Dow Jones Industrial Average declined 0.04% to 44,323.07 points. Seven of the 11 S&P 500 sector indexes rose, led by communication services, up 1.9%, followed by a 0.6% gain in consumer discretionary. Volume on U.S. exchanges was relatively heavy, with 19.7 billion shares traded, compared to an average of 17.7 billion shares over the previous 20 sessions. The S&P 500 has gained about 7% in 2025, while the Nasdaq has climbed almost 9%. Investors focused on how tariff uncertainty is impacting the U.S. economy will scrutinize jobless claims data and the July business activity report, expected on Thursday. They will also watch a speech by Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell on Tuesday for clues about when the Fed might cut interest rates, especially after mixed inflation signals last week. Traders have largely ruled out a July rate cut, and they now see a greater than 50% chance the Fed will cut by its September meeting, according to CME Group's FedWatch tool. Declining stocks outnumbered rising ones within the S&P 500 by a 1.7-to-one ratio. The S&P 500 posted 17 new highs and 9 new lows; the Nasdaq recorded 97 new highs and 56 new lows. (Reporting by Nikhil Sharma and Pranav Kashyap in Bengaluru, and by Noel Randewich in San Francisco; Editing by Maju Samuel, Shinjini Ganguli and Aurora Ellis)
