logo
Haitians with HIV defy stigma as they publicly denounce USAID cuts and dwindling medication

Haitians with HIV defy stigma as they publicly denounce USAID cuts and dwindling medication

Independent24-05-2025

A video showing dozens of people marching toward the office of Haiti's prime minister elicited gasps from some viewers as it circulated recently on social media. The protesters, who were HIV positive, did not conceal their faces — a rare occurrence in a country where the virus is still heavily stigmatized.
'Call the minister of health! We are dying!' the group chanted.
The protesters risked being shunned by society to warn that Haiti is running out of HIV medication just months after the administration of U.S. President Donald Trump slashed more than 90% of USAID's foreign aid contracts and $60 billion in overall aid across the globe.
At a hospital near the northern city of Cap-Haitien, Dr. Eugene Maklin said he struggles to share that reality with his more than 550 HIV patients.
'It's hard to explain to them, to tell them that they're not going to find medication,' he said. 'It's like a suicide.'
'We can't stay silent'
More than 150,000 people in Haiti have HIV or AIDS, according to official estimates, although nonprofits believe the number is much higher.
David Jeune, a 46-year-old hospital community worker, is among them. He became infected 19 years ago after having unprotected sex. 'I was scared to let people know because they would point their finger at you, saying you are infecting others with AIDS,' he said.
His fear was so great that he didn't tell anyone, not even his mother. But that fear dissipated with the support Jeune said he received from nonprofits. His confidence grew to the point where he participated in Monday's protest.
'I hope Trump will change his mind,' he said, noting that his medication will run out in November. 'Let the poor people get the medication they need.'
Patrick Jean Noël, a representative of Haiti's Federation of Associations of HIV, said that at least five clinics, including one that served 2,500 patients, were forced to close after the USAID funding cuts.
'We can't stay silent,' he said. 'More people need to come out.'
But most people with HIV in Haiti are reluctant to do so, said Dr. Sabine Lustin, executive director of the Haiti-based nonprofit Promoters of Zero AIDS Goal.
The stigma is so strong that many patients are reluctant to pick up their medication in person. Instead, it is sent via packages wrapped as gifts to not arouse suspicion, Lustin said.
Lustin's organization, which helps some 2,000 people across Haiti, receives funding from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. While their funding hasn't been cut, she said that shortly after Trump was sworn in, the agency banned prevention activities because they targeted a group that is not a priority. By that, Lustin said she understood they were referring to gay men.
That means the organization can no longer distribute up to 200,000 free condoms a year or educate people about the disease.
'You risk an increase in infections,' she said. 'You have a young population who is sexually active who can't receive the prevention message and don't have access to condoms.'
'We only have medication until July'
On a recent sunny morning, a chorus of voices drowned out the din of traffic in Haiti's capital, growing louder as protesters with HIV marched defiantly toward the office of Haiti's prime minister.
'We are here to tell the government that we exist, and we are people like any other person,' one woman told reporters.
Another marching alongside her said, 'Without medication, we are dying. This needs to change.'
Three days after Monday's protest, the leader of Haiti's transitional presidential council, Louis Gérald Gilles, announced that he had met with activists and would try to secure funding.
Meanwhile, nonprofit organizations across Haiti are fretting.
'I don't know what we're going to do,' said Marie Denis-Luque, founder and executive director of CHOAIDS, a nonprofit that cares for Haitian orphans with HIV/AIDS. 'We only have medication until July.'
Her voice broke as she described her frantic search for donations for the orphans, who are cared for by HIV-positive women in Cap-Haitien after gang violence forced them to leave Port-au-Prince.
Denis-Luque said she has long advocated for the orphans' visibility.
'We can't keep hiding these children. They are part of society,' she said, adding that she smiled when she saw the video of Monday's protest. 'I was like, whoa, things have changed tremendously. The stigma is real, but I think what I saw … was very encouraging to me. They can't be silenced.'
A dangerous combination
Experts say Haiti could see a rise in HIV infections because medications are dwindling at a time that gang violence and poverty are surging.
Dr. Alain Casseus, infectious disease division chief at Zamni Lasante, the largest non-governmental healthcare provider in Haiti, said they expected to see a surge in patients given the funding cuts, but that hasn't happened because traveling by land in Haiti is dangerous since violent gangs control main roads and randomly open fire on vehicles.
He warned that abruptly stopping medication is dangerous, especially because many Haitians do not have access or cannot afford nutritious food to strengthen their immune system.
'It wouldn't take long, especially given the situation in Haiti, to enter a very bad phase,' he said of HIV infections. And even if some funding becomes available, a lapse in medication could cause resistance to it, he said.
Casseus said gang violence also could accelerate the rates of infection via rapes or physical violence as medication runs out.
At the New Hope Hospital run by Maklin in Haiti's northern region, shelves are running empty. He used to receive more than $165,000 a year to help HIV/AIDS patients. But that funding has dried up.
'Those people are going to die,' he said. 'We don't know how or where we're going to get more medication.'
The medication controls the infection and allows many to have an average life expectancy. Without it, the virus attacks a person's immune system, and they develop AIDS, the late stage of an HIV infection.
Reaction is swift when Dr. Maklin tells his patients that in two months, the hospital won't have any HIV medication left.
'They say, 'No, no, no, no!'' he said. 'They want to keep living.'
___
Coto reported from San Juan, Puerto Rico.
____

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

From a cat losing its meow to a dog with hayfever – your pet queries answered
From a cat losing its meow to a dog with hayfever – your pet queries answered

The Sun

time3 hours ago

  • The Sun

From a cat losing its meow to a dog with hayfever – your pet queries answered

HE is on a mission to help our pets . . . and is here to answer YOUR questions. Sean, who is the head vet at tailored pet food firm has helped with owners' queries for ten years. 4 4 Q) MY cat Pickles has lost her meow. She is happy and eating, but she has gone hoarse. She's 16 years old and otherwise seems fit. Does she need a check-up? BOB CASTLE, Doncaster A) This isn't necessarily cause for alarm as it can happen for no obvious reason in many older cats. However, there are a few health issues that need to be ruled out. I wonder if Pickles has any other symptoms such as increased hunger or thirst, or any sudden or severe weight loss? Some hormonal disorders can lead to these symptoms, as well as affecting a cat's voice. Is she still eating well, or perhaps eating from one side of her mouth, avoiding hard foods in favour of wet food, gravies or jellies? You may guess I'm looking at dental disease or pain as potential causes, which would not surprise me at her age. In any case, I think the best course of action is to get her a vet check. If they find nothing wrong, great news. If they find something, you can discuss if it's best treated now, managed lightly or just monitored. Q) CAN dogs get hayfever? And if so, what might ease it? F1 stars' pets including driver with thirteen cats, Leclerc's yacht-loving pooch and Hamilton's dog Roscoe with own car Luna, our labrador, gets a runny nose and sneezes. She's three and otherwise in good health. She also gets hotspots on her coat in summer. Please advise. EM BLAKELY, Barnstaple, Devon A) They do get hayfever, but usually not with the same symptoms as us humans. In dogs, we use the term atopy or atopic dermatitis to describe 'hayfever', or allergies to pollen, as well as many other environmental allergens. This is because it usually manifests with itchy skin, leading to scratching, inflammation, hotspots, skin and ear infections. A small number of dogs will also get a runny nose or eye irritation and discharge but not many. So Luna is either quite unusual or it could be a coincidence. It's worth a vet visit to find out and to keep her more comfortable. Q) OUR rabbit Lopsy is all alone now his brother Teddy has died. I'm planning to get a companion, but how should they be introduced? JULIE COLEMAN, Brighton A) There's definitely some science to it but often it's more of a dark art. A good rescue charity or organisation will usually help you find a new bunny pal, giving great advice on the bonding process. It takes time and gradual introductions. But, generally, there is always a match out there for every bun. I'm sure Lopsy would love a girlfriend, which might be easier than trying to introduce him to a boy he has not grown up with. I definitely encourage you to explore these options as rabbits really do need the company of their own kind. But also make sure both are spayed/neutered, or you may end up with more rabbits than you expected. Q) I AM thinking of fostering an elderly dog to get me out walking more now I'm retired. I'd like it to be an older pet. Do I need to make considerations like raised food bowls and rugs for an OAP pooch as I have wood floors? KELLY BLACK, Orpington, Kent A) Yes Kelly, those are certainly things to consider for older dogs with reduced mobility, perhaps. Slippery floors can be very difficult to navigate and can exacerbate pain and discomfort. If the dog has neck issues, raised bowls can be of benefit. The rescue you foster from should be able to advise on good adjustments to help your companion settle and live out their days with you. Well done for considering an older dog, as many struggle to find homes. Star of the week 4 THE HUNGARIAN Mudi dog will become an official breed in the UK next week. The breed, which has existed for 300 years, will be the 225th to be recognised by The Kennel Club. Janos, a nine-year-old Mudi, came to the UK from Hungary in 2016 and takes part in obedience competitions. Owner Dorit Powell, 54, from Ipswich, said: 'He has been our loyal companion on many adventures since he joined us as a puppy. 'Janos is always happy and puts a smile on our faces.' Kennel Club spokesperson Charlotte McNamara said: 'We're pleased to officially recognise this versatile Hungarian herding dog as a pedigree breed in the UK.' WIN: Chew Mees toys worth £39.96 DO you want a chance to try the brand new Chew Mees toys by Original Squishmallows? The four loveable character duo sets crinkle and squeak. We have six bundles to give away, each worth £39.96. For a chance to win, send an email headed Squishmallows to sundaypets@ by July 13. T&Cs apply. Search Squishmallows Pets on Amazon UK. TOP TEN POOCH-FRIENDLY STAYCATIONS 4 NEARLY a third of stay- cationers want to bring a dog, reports a holiday rentals firm. 'Pet-friendly' is the most frequently searched term on It also named the Cornish village of Crantock as the UK's No1 pet-friendly destination. A spokesman for Sykes Cottages said: 'Known for its dog-friendly beach and eateries that welcome four-legged friends, Crantock had the highest proportion of bookings with dogs. 'The village also boasts several pubs and cafes which welcomes dogs and offer them free treats.' Wales scored highly, too. New Quay in Ceredigion, with its coastal paths and dog-friendly pubs and cafes, placed second. Next was Rhosneigr in Anglesey where treats include beaches, the Oyster Catcher restaurant and Beaumaris Castle. The study's Top 10 staycations for dogs: Crantock, Cornwall; New Quay, Ceredigion; Rhosneigr, Isle of Anglesey; Carnforth, Lancs; Newborough, Isle of Anglesey; Beadnell, Northumberland; Filey, North Yorks; Cardigan, Ceredigion; Nefyn, Gwynedd; Amble, Northumberland.

This 10-year plan may be the last chance to save the NHS
This 10-year plan may be the last chance to save the NHS

The Independent

time4 hours ago

  • The Independent

This 10-year plan may be the last chance to save the NHS

The 10-year plan for the National Health Service that Sir Keir Starmer is expected to publish in the next few days is likely to be a somewhat incoherent document. From the advance publicity, it would seem to have a lot of disconnected ideas in it, some good, some not so good and some irrelevant. The government hopes that weight-loss drugs will offer the hope of a big advance against obesity-related illnesses – but this comes after new figures raised concerns about their safety. If large language models can speed up the development of new pharmaceuticals, so much the better. But we remain sceptical about whether supermarkets ought to be recruited into policing their customers' calorie intakes. What will decide the success or failure of the NHS over the next decade, however, will be the design of the structural reforms to the service. Wes Streeting, the health and social care secretary, has made a good start in two respects. He has welcomed private-sector providers to help deliver NHS services free at the point of need, and he has taken an axe to the central bureaucracy of NHS England. The test for the 10-year plan will be the extent to which it brings in further changes to incentives throughout the NHS so that it becomes responsive to patients. Sir Jim Mackey, the new chief executive of the NHS, says many of the right things. 'It feels like we've built mechanisms to keep the public away because it's an inconvenience,' he says in his first interview since taking up the post three months ago. He says of the current NHS: 'It takes forever. It costs a fortune. We need to 'de-layer it' because it's expensive, it slows decision-making down, it de-powers people who need to make decisions.' The sentiment is right, but again, some of his ideas seem better than others. We are not convinced that using patient satisfaction surveys to decide how much money NHS trusts receive is going to work. The evidence of reform under the last Labour government was that the mere existence of competition from private-sector providers had a dramatic effect on the performance of NHS units. Already, there are the very early signs that the extra resources put into the NHS are bearing fruit, less than 12 months after the change of government. Luke Tryl, the opinion pollster for More in Common, reported on BBC's Newsnight on Friday that people in focus groups are starting to report positive experiences of the NHS for the first time since the pandemic. 'If there is a bright spot for the government, it's the NHS,' he said. One of the biggest challenges for Sir Jim and Mr Streeting, however, is more political than structural. They have to send the starkest message to doctors: please do not go on strike; take responsibility; show leadership; it is up to you to make the NHS work, because if it cannot be turned round this time, then it probably is the end of this model of healthcare. Sir Jim appears to understand this. He says that his 'big worry' is that if the NHS cannot deliver a service that is better at listening to patients – the particular example he gave was maternity care – 'we'll lose the population; if we lose the population, we've lost the NHS; for me, it's straightforward: the two things are completely dependent on each other.' He is absolutely right. Universal healthcare free at the point of need is a noble idea, but it desperately needs Labour's reforms to work if it is to survive.

US supreme court ruling sets stage for more politicized science under RFK Jr
US supreme court ruling sets stage for more politicized science under RFK Jr

The Guardian

time5 hours ago

  • The Guardian

US supreme court ruling sets stage for more politicized science under RFK Jr

A US supreme court decision affirming the constitutionality of Obamacare sets the stage for more politicized science in the future, health law experts said about the court's decision. The court's majority opinion in Kennedy v Braidwood Management found that an expert panel – the preventive services taskforce – convened under the Affordable Care Act is under the direct oversight of the health secretary. 'This is your classic good news, bad news,' said Lawrence Gostin, a professor of global health law at Georgetown Law. 'In a sane world, with a secretary of health that believes in science and doesn't bring in conspiracy theories and agendas, you would applaud this decision.' With health policy now in the hands of the Trump administration, 'it gives Secretary [Robert F Kennedy Jr] complete power about what to recommend and what not to recommend,' Gostin said. The court issued the opinion only hours after an expert vaccine advisory panel (ACIP) handpicked by Kennedy subverted the scientific consensus by recommending against vaccines containing thimerosal, a preservative overwhelmingly considered safe. Thimerosal has been a subject of misinformation and anti-vaccine advocacy for decades. Much like the expert panel in question in the Braidwood case, the recommendations of the vaccine advisory committee are a key link in the treatment distribution pipeline. Recommendations from both panels are typically affirmed by the leadership of the health department, and then become the basis on which insurers base coverage decisions. In the case of the ACIP, those recommendations typically concern vaccines. In the preventive taskforce context, they include a wide range of treatments – from statins to cancer screenings to HIV prevention. It was widely recognized that Kennedy had the authority to hire and fire people for the vaccine panel – but legal controversy existed about whether health secretaries have the same power over the preventive services taskforce. 'The president and the Senate are accountable 'for both the making of a bad appointment and the rejection of a good one',' wrote Justice Brett Kavanaugh for the six-vote majority. In other words, the court said, if you don't like it, go to the ballot box. MaryBeth Musumeci, an associate professor of health law management at the George Washington University Milken Institute of Public Health, told the Guardian: 'We have that structure in place – and that is a really great structure if the folks in charge are actually deferring to the experts and the science and what the evidence says.' She added: 'To the extent that we are going to make decisions based on bad science – that has really serious public health implications.' The panel at the center of the vaccine decision is the ACIP vaccine panel. Until June, the advisory panel was made up of 17 experts vetted by CDC career scientists. Their recommendations, while not binding, were almost always approved by CDC leadership. Kennedy fired all 17 members unilaterally in June and stocked the panel with eight ideological allies – including vaccine skeptics and medical professionals with little experience in vaccines. One panelist withdrew after a government financial review, and after it was widely publicized that the secretary's claims about the panelist's affiliation with two universities was false. Wayne Turner, a senior attorney for the National Health Law Program, which advocates for the medically underserved, said that he and others were 'certainly breathing a sigh of relief with the court's decision today' because a key provision of Obamacare was found to be constitutional. 'But that sigh of relief is really short-lived,' Turner said. 'We have long anticipated with the appointment of RFK Jr, and certainly with his actions with the ACIP, that we can fully expect the preventive services taskforce to be the next battleground in the ideological war this administration seems to be waging. And the war is against science.' The subject of the Braidwood case provides a salient example. Plaintiffs were suing the government to claim that the taskforce was wrongly appointed. Although their legal argument was thorny, one treatment they specifically cited as wrong was insurance coverage of pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP), an HIV prevention drug. Although the plaintiffs' claim that the taskforce was unconstitutional was swatted down, it provides activists with a roadmap to get what they want – if they can convince Kennedy to appoint more ideological allies to the taskforce. The preventive services taskforce may have one protective mechanism: a requirement that they be guided by evidence written into Obamacare, the legislation that impaneled them. Gearing up for another fight, Turner said: 'That's going to be an important thing for us to point to in the weeks and months ahead, and years, quite frankly.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store