‘Kremlin' councils need to go
Shaun Jones. PHOTO: ODT FILES
Resource Minister Shane Jones has called the Otago Regional Council "the Kremlin of the South Island" after an application to expand the Macraes gold mine ran into trouble.
Mr Jones, who is also the regional development minister, said the council was full of "KGB green zealots" and the episode showed why regional councils needed to be scrapped.
The Otago council's assessment of environmental effects — which recommended Oceana-Gold's application to expand its mine be declined in full — was "ideological scribbling".
Any other investor or miner in New Zealand would now quickly conclude they had to join the fast-track application process, "which will enable these economic saboteurs to be marginalised", he said.
Council chairwoman Cr Gretchen Robertson said "name-calling" was unhelpful and the council's views were evidence-based, not ideological.
OceanaGold has been granted more time to prepare for a hearing for its proposed expansion at Macraes after the regional council said its application should be declined and the Waitaki district and Dunedin city councils also raised concerns.
The regional council's view of the company's Macraes Phase 4 (MP4) Project was troubling, Mr Jones said.
"It confirms the worst of my prejudices, that the regional council in the South Island, that the Otago Regional Council is the Kremlin of the South Island," he said.
"These are the reasons why people should be backing me to disestablish regional councils in New Zealand.
"Their role is as catchment boards and looking at the discharge and the allocation of water, water take.
"I am astounded at a time where the economy is still recovering from the Covid experience, a record number of New Zealanders are moving to Australia, and we have these Politburo apparatchiks destroying hundreds of jobs, undermining scores of millions of dollars in the local economy.
"For a dead moth.
"It's an ideological attempt to defeat mining.
"It truly is unbelievable.
"This is a part of New Zealand where no-one goes.
"There are some easy mitigative steps that can be taken, but the Kremlin and its KGB green zealots completely and utterly show me why regional councils need to be disestablished."
The "nationally vulnerable" moth Orocrambus sophistes, which lives in short tussock grasslands, was found at Golden Bar, one of three open pits about 55km north of Dunedin that OceanaGold has applied to expand.
The regional council's recommending report highlighted the moth alongside the proposed expansion's actual and potential effects on surface water quality, aquatic ecology, natural inland and ephemeral wetlands, and lizard habitat.
The effects would be "significantly adverse" and could not be avoided, minimised, remedied, offset or compensated for.
It would also have significant adverse cumulative effects on cultural values, "and it is not yet known if these can be managed by conditions", the report said.
Cr Robertson said the report was prepared by qualified professionals under the Resource Management Act.
"It is a technical, evidence-based assessment — not a political statement.
"Our staff are simply doing their jobs within the law as it stands.
"Name-calling only undermines confidence in both central and local government."
Regional councils across New Zealand welcomed "meaningful dialogue" on how to best deliver the services they were intended to — flood protection, biosecurity, civil defence, environmental management and public transport, she said.
"Here in Otago, we remain focused on our responsibility to protect the environment while supporting sustainable economic development.
"That balance is not ideological — it reflects the law, and we believe it reflects the values of our region: caring for both our environment and our livelihoods."
A minute issued by independent commissioner Rob van Voorthuysen this week said the hearing for OceanaGold's proposed expansion had been postponed from next month to December at the mining company's request.
The company's lawyers advised more time was required to consider the recommendations from the councils, he said.
OceanaGold senior vice-president Alison Paul said adjourning the MP4 hearing, originally scheduled for next month, would give the company more time to prepare its evidence, including addressing all three councils' reports and recommendations.
hamish.maclean@odt.co.nz
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
3 hours ago
- Scoop
Energy Access Has Improved, Yet International Financial Support Still Needed To Boost Progress And Address Disparities
Washington, New York, Paris, Geneva, Abu Dhabi, 25 June 2025 – Tracking SDG 7: The Energy Progress Report 2025 finds that almost 92% of the world's population now has basic access to electricity Although this is an improvement since 2022, which saw the number of people without basic access decrease for the first time in a decade, over 666 million people remain without access, indicating that the current rate is insufficient to reach universal access by 2030. Clean cooking access is progressing but below the rates of progress seen in the 2010s, as efforts remain hobbled by setbacks during the Covid-19 pandemic, following energy price shocks, and debt crises. Released today, the latest edition of the annual report that tracks progress towards Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 7 highlights the role of distributed renewable energy (a combination of mini-grid and off-grid solar systems) to accelerate access, since the population remaining unconnected lives mostly in remote, lower-income, and fragile areas. Cost-effective and rapidly scalable, decentralised solutions are able to reach communities in such rural areas. Decentralised solutions are also needed to increase access to clean cooking. With an estimated 1.5 billion people residing in rural areas still lacking access to clean cooking, the use of off-grid clean technologies, such as household biogas plants and mini-grids that facilitate electric cooking, can provide solutions that reduce health impacts caused by household air pollution. Over 2 billion people remain dependent on polluting and hazardous fuels such as firewood and charcoal for their cooking needs. Notable progress was made in different indicators. The international financial flows to developing countries in support of clean energy grew for the third year in a row to reach USD 21.6 billion in 2023. Installed renewables capacity per capita continued to increase year-on-year to reach a new high of 341 watts per capita in developing countries, up from 155 watts in 2015. Yet regional disparities persist, indicating that particular support is needed for developing regions. In sub-Saharan Africa – which lags behind across most indicators – renewables deployment has rapidly expanded but remains limited to 40 watts of installed capacity per capita on average which is only one-eighth of the average of other developing countries. Eighty-five percent of the global population without electricity access reside in the region, while four in five families are without access to clean cooking. And the number of people without clean cooking access in the region continues to grow at a rate of 14 million people yearly. The report identified the lack of sufficient and affordable financing as a key reason for regional inequalities and slow progress. To build on the achievements to date and avoid any further regressions on access to electricity and clean cooking due to looming risks in global markets, the report calls for strengthened international cooperation of public and private sectors, to scale up financial support for developing countries, especially in sub-Saharan Africa. Urgent actions include reforms in multilateral and bilateral lending to expand the availability of public capital; more concessional finance mobilisation, grants, and risk mitigation instruments; improvement in risk tolerance among donors; as well as appropriate national energy planning and regulations. Key findings across primary indicators Almost 92% of the world's population now has access to electricity, leaving over 666 million people without electricity in 2023, with around 310 million people gaining access since 2015. Eighteen of the 20 countries with the largest electricity access deficits in 2023 were in sub-Saharan Africa. The greatest growth in access between 2020 and 2023 occurred in Central and Southern Asia, with both regions making significant strides towards universal electricity access, reducing their basic access gap from 414 million in 2010 to just 27 million in 2023. Little to no change was observed in access to clean fuels and technologies for cooking between 2022 and 2023. Although the number of the world's population with access to clean cooking fuels and technologies increased from 64% in 2015 to 74% in 2023, around 2.1 billion people remain dependent on polluting fuels and technologies. If current trends continue, only 78% of the global population will have access to clean cooking by 2030. In 2022, the global share of renewable energy sources in total final energy consumption (TFEC) was 17.9% as TFEC continued to increase gradually, while installed renewable energy capacity reached 478 watts per capita in 2023, indicating almost 13% growth from 2022. But progress is not sufficient to meet international climate and sustainable development goals. In addition, global efforts must address significant disparities. Despite progress in expanding renewable capacity, least developed countries and sub-Saharan Africa had only 40 watts per capita in installed renewables capacity, compared to developed countries which had over 1,100 watts installed. Global energy efficiency experienced sluggish progress in recent years. The global trend shows that primary energy intensity, defined as the ratio of total energy supply to gross domestic product, declined by 2.1% in 2022. Although it is an improvement of more than four times the weak 0.5% improvement rate of 2021, it is insufficient to meet the original SDG 7.3 target. Going forward, energy intensity needs to improve by 4% per year on average. International public financial flows to developing countries in support of clean energy increased by 27% from 2022, reaching USD 21.6 billion in 2023. However, the report reveals that the developing world received fewer flows in 2023 than in 2016, when commitments peaked at USD 28.4 billion. Despite gradual diversification, funding remained concentrated, with only two sub-Saharan African countries in the top five recipients. Debt-based instruments drove most of the increase in international public flows in 2023, accounting for 83% in 2023, while grants made up only 9.8% of flows. The report will be presented to decision-makers at a special launch event on 16 July 2025 at the High-Level Political Forum on Sustainable Development in New York, which oversees progress on the SDGs. QUOTES Fatih Birol, Executive Director, International Energy Agency ' Despite progress in some parts of the world, the expansion of electricity and clean cooking access remains disappointingly slow, especially in Africa. This is contributing to millions of premature deaths each year linked to smoke inhalation, and is holding back development and education opportunities. Greater investment in clean cooking and electricity supply is urgently required, including support to reduce the cost of capital for projects.' Francesco La Camera, Director-General, International Renewable Energy Agency ' Renewables have seen record growth in recent years, reminding the world of its affordability, scalability, and its role in further reducing energy poverty. But we must accelerate progress at this crunch time. This means overcoming challenges, which include infrastructure gaps. The lack of progress, especially on infrastructure, is a reflection of limited access to financing. Although international financial flows to developing countries in support of clean energy grew to USD 21.6 billion in 2023, only two regions in the world have seen real progress in the financial flows. To close the access and infrastructure gaps, we need strengthened international cooperation to scale up affordable financing and impact–driven capital for the least developed and developing countries.' Stefan Schweinfest, Director, United Nations Statistics Division ' This year's report shows that now is the time to come together to build on existing achievements and scale up our efforts. Despite advancements in increasing renewables-based electricity, which now makes up almost 30 percent of global electricity consumption, the use of renewables for other energy-related purposes remains stagnant. While energy intensity improved in 2022, overall progress remains weak, threatening economic growth and the energy efficiency goals agreed upon at COP28. The clock is ticking. The findings of this year's report should serve as a rallying point, to rapidly mobilize efforts and investments, so that together, we ensure sustainable energy for all by 2030.' Guangzhe Chen, Vice President for Infrastructure, World Bank 'As we approach the five-year mark to achieve the SDG7 targets, it is imperative to accelerate the deployment of electricity connections, especially in Sub-Saharan Africa, where half of the 666 million people lacking access reside. As part of the Mission 300 movement, 12 African nations have launched national energy compacts, in which they commit to substantial reforms to lower costs of generation and transmission, and scale up distributed renewable energy solutions. Initiatives such as this unite governments, the private sector, and development partners in a collaborative effort. Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, WHO Director-General, World Health Organization ' The same pollutants that are poisoning our planet are also poisoning people, contributing to millions of deaths each year from cardiovascular and respiratory diseases, particularly among the most vulnerable, including women and children,' said Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, WHO Director-General. 'We urgently need scaled-up action and investment in clean cooking solutions to protect the health of both people and planet—now and in the future.' About the report This report is published by the SDG 7 custodian agencies, the International Energy Agency (IEA), the International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA), the United Nations Statistics Division (UNSD), the World Bank, and the World Health Organization (WHO) and aims to provide the international community with a global dashboard to register progress on energy access, energy efficiency, renewable energy and international cooperation to advance SDG 7. This year's edition was chaired by IRENA. The report can be downloaded at Funding for the report was provided by the World Bank's Energy Sector Management Assistance Program (ESMAP).
Scoop
11 hours ago
- Scoop
Statement From Dr Kiki Maoate ONZM, FRACS, Chair – Pasifika Medical Association Group
We strongly reject any claim that public funds have been used in an inappropriate manner. Moana Pasifika became part of the Pasifika Medical Association Group (PMA) on 1 July 2024. At that time, the Moana Pasifika Charitable Trust was formally established to hold both the professional rugby team and the Moana Pasifika Community Sports Programme. Moana Pasifika has always been more than a rugby team. From the outset, it was established as a platform for social good and long-term transformation for Pacific people. That founding purpose made it a natural strategic fit for PMA, which recognised the opportunity to strengthen and expand Moana Pasifika's reach. With that alignment of values and mission, PMA invested to optimise the organisation's positive impact, capability and connection to Pacific communities. In 2021, a small amount of funding was provided to the Pacific Business Trust to support the development of a business case for the establishment of the Moana Pasifika Charitable Trust. This was consistent with broader support for Pacific-owned and delivered initiatives under the economic domain of Pasifika Futures. Since that time, any public or Whānau Ora funding has been directed solely to the Moana Pasifika Community Sports Programme. No public funding has been used to support the professional rugby team. The Moana Pasifika Charitable Trust holds a Super Rugby franchise licence issued by NZ Rugby. The professional rugby team operates independently of public funding. The team is funded through commercial rugby revenue streams, including: NZ Rugby World Rugby Broadcast revenue (e.g. Sky) Since the franchise was brought in-house, PMA has also provided internal financial support. None of this support has come from Whānau Ora or other public funding sources. PMA generates its own income and is not reliant solely on government funding. It has built significant equity over 28 years, including savings and a property portfolio. This financial strength has enabled it to support the franchise without drawing on public money. Our investment decisions - including those relating to sport and youth development - are shaped by evidence and consultation. During the COVID-19 period, and again through formal consultations in 2024 involving Pacific families across multiple regions, sport and physical activity were identified as priority areas for investment linked to improved health outcomes, youth development and long-term wellbeing. The benefits of investing in community sport programmes are well documented - with a return of $12 for every $1 invested, through increased health, educational engagement and future employment outcomes. Since joining PMA, Moana Pasifika has increased its focus on community impact - evolving from a professional sports team into a broader platform for sport, connection and social purpose. While its community ethos has always been present, this aspect has been deliberately strengthened and expanded under PMA's stewardship. The Community Sports Programme was developed in response to community demand for greater investment in sport and youth wellbeing. It includes programmes across multiple codes such as rowing, netball and tennis, and initiatives supporting young men's wellbeing and young women's leadership in sport. The programme is now fully operational and financially sustainable. Moana Pasifika's reach extends well beyond the field. Its Community Sports Programme delivers initiatives across Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch, including school outreach, grassroots sports development, mentoring and youth leadership. A core focus is reducing barriers to participation in sport and physical activity, with lasting wellbeing benefits for Pacific families and communities. Moana Pasifika is a celebration of identity, resilience and potential. Sport has long been a wave that carries Pasifika people forward - into education, enterprise, leadership and service. As both a team and a movement, Moana Pasifika exists to lift up our people and strengthen our communities. For 28 years, The Pasifika Medical Association has supported thousands of Pacific families through health, education and wellbeing programmes - grounded in cultural connection, service and measurable outcomes. That legacy continues to shape the way we work, the partnerships we build and the outcomes we seek. We remain deeply focused on improving long-term health and wellbeing across Aotearoa — guided by Pacific values, trusted by our communities and driven by real need. We welcome scrutiny - but it must be informed, balanced and grounded in fact. We stand by the integrity of our decisions, the strength of our governance and the value of our work across Aotearoa.
1News
17 hours ago
- 1News
Tainui to host Te Matatini 2027 after festival pulled from Nelson
Te Matatini 2027 will now be hosted by Tainui in Waikato, after hosting duties for the event were pulled from Nelson. The festival was taken away from Te Tauihu o Te Waka-a-Māui as organisers held concerns that its rapid growth would lead to smaller regions being unable to accommodate the burgeoning numbers of kaihaka and supporters. The 2027 competition, named Tākiri Tū Te Matatini, would now be held at Hopuhopu — a former military camp turned iwi hub. This would be the first time the event has been held in the region and hosted by Tainui since 2000. The decision to give Tainui hosting rights came after a two-day tono (application) process that included a joint proposal from Te Whare Haka o Tainui and Tainui waka iwi. Te Matatini chairman Tā Herewini Parata said the board had been "overwhelmed" by the "depth and thought" that had gone into the proposal. ADVERTISEMENT "It centred on the key values of Kingitanga and was presented with the grace and strength of kotahitanga that this area is renowned for,' Tā Herewini said. He said the bid received unanimous support from the board. Waikato-Tainui executive chair Tukoroirangi Morgan said: 'As a waka, we have a proud history of hosting the motu and we will pivot every resource we have and work with our partners to make sure it is a resounding success.' Te Whare Haka o Tainui delegate Tony Walker said it was an opportunity to "remind ourselves of how mana motuhake can evolve on a regional, national and international level". Walker said it was an "exciting time" for the Tainui waka community as it provided "stability for this kaupapa". 'I reflect on the words of our late Kiingi Tuheitia Potatau Te Wherowhero VII when he challenged us all to think about the virtues of unity as a pathway to reconnect and flourish in this challenging world." Tā Herewini said some logistical issues needed to be worked through before a date could be set. ADVERTISEMENT The festival schedule was established over a decade ago, with Te Tauihu initially confirmed as the host for 2025 in 2013. The Covid-19 pandemic forced the cancellation of the 2021 festival in Tāmaki Makaurau which pushed the event in Te Tauihu out to 2027. In May, Tā Herewini said the event had experienced unprecedented growth since then and was not a significant event on the national calendar. "While Te Tauihu had worked hard to find solutions to deliver the festival at its current size, concerns remained, particularly around accommodation, transport and freight capabilities." Glossary Tainui – ancestral waka, often used to refer to iwi or people who descend from this waka Waikato – an iwi based in the region of the same name ADVERTISEMENT Te Tauihu (o Te Waka a Maui) – region at the top of the South Island kaihaka – haka performer tono – apply/application Tainui waka iwi – iwi that descend from the ancestral waka Tainui Tā – Sir kotahitanga – unity Waikato-Tainui – iwi authority named after iwi and waka ADVERTISEMENT mana motuhake – self-governance
