Bengali or Bangladeshi? Calcutta HC questions Centre for targeting Bengali-speakers, ‘sends wrong message'
A division bench of Justices, Tapabrata Chakraborty and Reetobroto Kumar Mitra, who were hearing the case, questioned, "What were the reasons? Was this pre- planned?"
"Let these issues be cleared. Else, it will send out a wrong message. This could be a wrongful act. Allegations have been made that people are being illegally deported to Bangladesh just because they speak Bengali," it said.
The Court was hearing a Habeas Corpus petitions filed by the family members of Birbhum migrants deported to Bangladesh last month.
Senior Advocate Kalyan Bandyopadhyay, who appeared for the State of West Bengal before a Division Bench, noted that the Delhi Police cannot detain people for speaking Bengali, and further said, 'This is a family from Birbhum district... Who will decide if someone is Bangladeshi? Not the police, but the appropriate authority… All these cases, I have gone through the reports, it is very alarming,'He also demanded that the Centre report how many people have been deported to Bangladesh so far.
Responding to it, the counsel representing the Central government asserted that no individual has been deported solely for speaking Bengali. 'Around 165 people in Kashmir, including some who spoke Bengali, were detained after Pahalgam attack but all of them were released later.'
He also pointed out that the relatives of those who were deported have already moved the Delhi High Court, a detail that, he argued, has been deliberately withheld in the present case.
The Bench pulled up the petitioner's counsel for hiding this fact, warning that the Court process cannot be misused. 'Don't play tricks on us,' the Bench said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NDTV
11 minutes ago
- NDTV
President's Rule In Manipur To Be Extended, Amit Shah To Move Resolution In Rajya Sabha
Imphal: Union Home Minister Amit Shah has moved a statutory resolution in the Parliament seeking approval for the extension of the President's rule in Manipur for another six months. The Centre had imposed the President's rule in Manipur on February 13, three days after Chief Minister N Biren Singh resigned. It will now be extended till February 13, 2026, after Parliament's nod. The state assembly, which has a tenure till 2027, will remain under suspended animation. Manipur has been witnessing ethnic conflict between the Meitei and Kuki-Zo communities since May 2023, in which over 250 people have been killed. Officials, however, have said that there has been a significant decline in violence since the imposition of President's rule. The move by the Centre comes at a time when there has been a massive crackdown against recovering illegal weapons and the armed groups in the state. The Centre is now also focusing on the return and resettlement of the internally displaced people from both communities and aims to shut down relief camps by the end of this year. The extension of President's rule, however, has come as a setback to the Manipur unit of the BJP, which had been pushing for the reinstatement of a popular government. However, the 10 Kuki-Zo community MLAs have said that they want President's rule to continue until their core demand of a separate administration like a union territory is thoroughly discussed. The Centre is also engaged in back-channel talks with the civil society groups.
NDTV
11 minutes ago
- NDTV
PM Narendra Modi Becomes 2nd Longest Serving Prime Minister In India
New Delhi: Prime Minister Narendra Modi, on Friday, completed 4,078 days in office, surpassing former Prime Minister late Indira Gandhi's record of 4,077 consecutive days as Prime Minister of the country from January 24, 1966, to March 24, 1977. This means, a single and uninterrupted tenure as the Prime Minister of India. With this milestone, PM Modi becomes the second longest consecutively serving Prime Minister in India's history, behind only the country's first Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru. As PM Narendra Modi marks 4,078 consecutive days in office on July 25, 2025, he also holds several historic distinctions. PM Modi is the first and only Prime Minister born after Independence, the longest-serving non-Congress PM, and the longest-serving Prime Minister from a non-Hindi-speaking state. He is also the first and only non-Congress leader to have completed two full terms and to be re-elected twice with a majority, making him the only non-Congress Prime Minister to secure a majority on his own in the Lok Sabha. Additionally, he is the first sitting Prime Minister since Indira Gandhi in 1971 to return to power with a full majority. PM Modi is the only Prime Minister, apart from late Jawaharlal Nehru, to win three consecutive elections as leader of a political party in India. He is the only leader in India, among all Prime Ministers and Chief Ministers, to win six consecutive elections as the leader of a party -- Gujarat (2002, 2007, 2012), Lok Sabha polls (2014, 2019, 2024). This will be another milestone in PM Modi's almost 24 years as head of a democratically-elected government, either in the state or Centre. The record for the unbroken stint is held by first Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru. PM Modi has matched Nehru in leading their respective parties to victory in three consecutive Lok Sabha elections. Born into a modest family in Vadnagar, Gujarat, Narendra Modi helped his father sell tea at a railway station before rising through the ranks of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) and later the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). Known for his grassroots connect and strong communication style, PM Modi served as Gujarat's chief minister for over a decade before leading the BJP to a historic national victory in 2014. Since then, he has positioned himself as a key global leader, projecting India as a confident, assertive voice on the world stage.
Indian Express
11 minutes ago
- Indian Express
July 25, 1985, Forty Years Ago: Historic Accord
The problem of Punjab, which has spawned some of the bloodiest events in the country's history in the last four years, has at long last been solved. PM Rajiv Gandhi and Akali Dal chief Harchand Singh Longowal signed an agreement that includes the transfer of Chandigarh to Punjab and some Hindi-speaking areas to Haryana, rehabilitation of those discharged from the Army and reference of the Anandpur Sahib Resolution to the Sarkaria Commission. Scenes of Joy Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi's announcement regarding the Punjab accord was generally welcomed by the common man. Scenes of jubilation were witnessed outside the Indian Express office, where Sikhs were seen embracing Hindus with joy. There were reports from different parts of the Capital of people distributing sweets after the announcement. Leaders Hail Accord Leaders of several political parties, parliamentarians and eminent citizens hailed the accord. Punjab Governor Arjun Singh, who was present in the Speaker's gallery when the announcement was made, expressed his 'deepest pleasure'. More than 50 MPs from different parts of the country in a joint statement said the accord would put an end to the era of confrontation and uncertainty and usher in an era of peace, prosperity and progress. Sacking Staff The Supreme Court has held that a government servant can be dismissed, removed or demoted without an opportunity to explain his case under Article 311 (2) (b) of the Constitution if it was in public interest. The principle that a person should get an opportunity to be heard before action is taken against him ('natural justice') can be modified and in exceptional cases even excluded, a Constitution bench has ruled.
