Supreme Court lets South Carolina block Medicaid funds from Planned Parenthood
The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 in the case of Medina v. Planned Parenthood South Atlantic to find that Planned Parenthood and a patient cannot sue the state of South Carolina to enforce a provision of the Medicaid Act that aims to ensure a patient can obtain medical care from the provider of their choosing. Justice Neil Gorsuch delivered the opinion for the court. The three liberal justices, Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan and Ketanji Brown Jackson, were in dissent.
The court's conservative majority reversed a decision from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit that allowed Planned Parenthood's lawsuit against state officials to move forward. It is likely to pave the way for more states to exclude Planned Parenthood from their Medicaid programs, a move that anti-abortion rights have been pushing for several years.
Medina v. Planned Parenthood South Atlantic
The question before the court was a narrow one, involving whether a Medicaid beneficiary could sue to enforce their ability to seek care from the qualified and willing provider of their choosing, known as the any-qualified-provider requirement.
The legal wrangling over South Carolina's attempt to stop public dollars from going to a Planned Parenthood affiliate in the state began in 2018, four years before the Supreme Court overturned Roe. v. Wade.
In South Carolina, abortion is banned after six weeks gestation, and Planned Parenthood provides abortion services outside of Medicaid only as allowed under state law. Additionally, federal law bars Medicaid from paying for abortions except in cases of rape or incest, or to save the life of the mother.
But seven years ago, South Carolina's Republican governor, Henry McMaster, issued an executive order that directed the state's health department to deem abortion providers unqualified to provide family-planning services under Medicaid and terminate their enrollment agreements.
In response, the South Carolina Department of Health and Human Services notified Planned Parenthood South Atlantic that its provider agreements were being cancelled because it was no longer qualified to provide medical services to Medicaid beneficiaries. The affiliate has clinics in Charleston and Columbia, and offers prenatal and postpartum services, along with physical exams and screenings for cancer and other health conditions.
In the wake of the state's decision to boot Planned Parenthood from its Medicaid program, Julie Edwards, a patient who received medical services from the organization, and Planned Parenthood filed a lawsuit under federal civil rights law to challenge the move.
Edwards argued that South Carolina's termination of Planned Parenthood's agreement violated her right to choose her provider under the Medicaid Act.
A federal district judge ruled in favor of Planned Parenthood, finding that South Carolina likely violated the any-qualified-provider provision when it excluded Planned Parenthood from its Medicaid program. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit ultimately allowed the suit to proceed and prevented South Carolina from keeping Planned Parenthood out of its Medicaid program.
The dispute before the Supreme Court did not involve abortion, but it came to the high court amid a push by several Republican-led states to block Planned Parenthood from receiving Medicaid funds.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
31 minutes ago
- Boston Globe
Millions could lose health insurance after the ‘Big Beautiful Bill.' Here are three ways states can prevent that.
These changes will worsen health outcomes for people who lose coverage while leading to higher costs for both patients and hospitals. It will overburden Advertisement How bad will the damage be? Well, a lot depends on how states respond. By streamlining enrollment systems, investing in community partnerships, and making targeted investments to protect at-risk populations, states can soften the worst effects of this bill, reduce how many eligible people lose coverage, and ultimately ensure millions of people still get the care they need. Advertisement Simplify enrollment so more people can keep their coverage First, states must make it as easy as possible for eligible people to stay covered. States can do this by simplifying their enrollment systems. That starts with expanding automatic verification and leveraging electronic records, like tax data and Social Security information, to confirm eligibility and income status automatically. These steps will reduce paperwork, minimize errors, and ensure that people don't lose coverage because of a missed deadline or procedural mistakes. Massachusetts, for example, is already One area that needs particular attention is Medicaid work requirements. They are currently used in a few states, and the new bill expands this policy nationwide despite When Arkansas implemented such requirements in 2018, To avoid repeating that failure, state legislators should explore adopting broad exemptions for caregivers, students, and individuals with disabilities unable to meet requirements. Reporting systems should be easy to access, mobile and online friendly, and supported by staffed help lines. States can also invest in voluntary job training and community service programs that assist people both in meeting work requirements and gaining valuable skills. Steps like these can reduce coverage losses, offer real support, and strengthen communities. Advertisement States with their own ACA marketplaces should extend open enrollment periods beyond the shorter federal window, giving families more time to understand their options and enroll. Small changes like this can make a big difference, especially for people with limited internet access or nontraditional work hours. Tap community resources to help people navigate the complexities of health care coverage Next, states should better engage local communities, their leaders, and their trusted institutions. Local health providers, advocacy groups, and faith-based organizations can educate people about their rights and offer assistance in navigating the entire enrollment process. In California, the state's health insurance program worked with local libraries to Information sessions at community centers, multilingual assistance, and text message reminders are valuable tools in helping the most vulnerable populations, including legal immigrants who are eligible to meet documentation requirements and avoid unnecessary coverage loss, especially out of fear or confusion. It's part of why health care providers, who stand to lose substantial amounts of money in reimbursements, should lead outreach efforts to ensure that people who are eligible for Medicaid get or keep their insurance. Use targeted investments to strengthen the safety net Finally, targeted investments by states can minimize the impact of health coverage loss. Wholesale replacement of lost federal funds won't be possible. Massachusetts, for example, has used an uncompensated care fund known as the Health Safety Net to support hospitals serving the uninsured, but that fund has become Advertisement States should also consider expanding cost-sharing reductions to lower deductibles and out-of-pocket costs for low-income residents who might otherwise forgo care. Reinsurance programs are another proven tool, and states like At the end of the day, the greatest threat to sustainable health coverage in America isn't paperwork, policy, or a new bill — it is cost. Health care in the United States remains extraordinarily expensive, and the new federal bill does nothing to address it. States could do more to address the root of the problem, including exceedingly high prices and lack of competition among health care providers. Too few states have put much attention on these fundamental issues. The bill is now law, but as with any law, implementation will play a critical role in its impact. States have a lot of leverage and leeway in ensuring that it is implemented in ways that minimize coverage loss, through simplifying hurdles, outreach to communities, and targeted investments that can make a difference. If states do their job right, we can substantially reduce the number of eligible Americans who will find themselves without coverage.
CNET
31 minutes ago
- CNET
That Cup of Coffee and Glass of Wine Are Staining Your Teeth. Here's How to Keep Your Smile Bright Without Giving Up Your Favorite Drinks
If you're anything like me, morning coffee is non-negotiable. It's the one thing I look forward to every morning and gets me out of bed. The same can be said about wine. Some can't seem to forgo that nightcap, whether it's a crisp white on a patio or a bold red on a date night. As much as these drinks off us joy, they can also secretly sabotage our smiles. Over time, you might start noticing that your once bright teeth are looking a little dull. So that begs the question: How do you enjoy coffee and wine without turning your teeth a few shades darker? I asked Dr. Anjali Rajpal, board-certified dentist at Beverly Hills Dental Arts, to break it down and offer dentist-approved ways to prevent staining without sacrificing your favorite drinks. Why do coffee and wine stain your teeth? The short answer is a combination of chromogens (a substance that can be colorless but can be converted into a colored compound, often through a chemical reaction), tannins and acidity. "Coffee and red wine stain teeth because they contain dark pigments called chromogens that stick to enamel. Tannins in these drinks help the pigments bind more strongly to the teeth. Their acidity also weakens enamel, making it easier for stains to set in," Rajpal told CNET. She explains that darker roasts and concentrated coffee like espresso tend to stain teeth more than lighter brews. Likewise, red wine stains more than white, especially darker, tannin-rich varieties like cabernet sauvignon and malbec. "The longer these drinks stay in contact with your teeth, the more likely they are to cause staining," Rajpal said. Read more: The 8 Best Coffee Subscriptions of 2025, Tested by Coffee Lovers Does some coffee or wine stain your teeth more than others? It turns out that, yes, certain types of coffee and wine can stain your teeth more. "Darker roasts and concentrated coffee like espresso tend to stain teeth more than lighter brews. Red wine stains more than white, especially darker, tannin-rich varieties like cabernet sauvignon and malbec," Rajpal explains. She also mentions that the longer these drinks stay in contact with your teeth, the more likely they are to cause staining. The type of coffee and wine isn't the only thing you should consider when trying to keep your teeth white. The temperature of a drink can influence how much it can stain your teeth. Hot beverages are more likely to cause stains than iced ones. "Heat can slightly expand enamel, making it more porous and allowing pigments to penetrate more easily," Rajpal said. "While iced drinks may have less impact due to quicker consumption and lower enamel exposure, the type and frequency of the drink matter more overall." Boy_Anupong/Getty Images Tips to keep your teeth white without sacrificing your favorite drinks, according to a dentist Protecting your teeth from stains doesn't mean you have to give up your morning cup of Joe. Follow these dentist-approved tips to keep your pearly whites healthy and bright: Sip your drink through a straw Straws help the liquid bypass your front teeth, minimizing the contact that leads to visible staining. Rajpal recommends using a straw for iced drinks and rinsing your mouth with water afterward" to reduce staining from coffee or wine. Drink your coffee or wine in one sitting One of the worst things you can do is sip your coffee or wine slowly for hours. "Sipping slowly throughout the day constantly exposes your enamel to staining compounds and gives your teeth less time to recover, making stains more likely to build up over time," Rajpal says. Try to enjoy your drink over a 15- to 30-minute period, then rinse with water after. Rinse, don't brush, right after I know this one seems counterintuitive, but brushing your teeth right after you have coffee or wine can actually do more harm. "Avoid brushing immediately after drinking, as acids can soften enamel and make it more vulnerable," Rajpal recommends. "Wait at least 30 minutes before brushing to protect softened enamel, and give a break between snacking or eating to boost natural cleansing by saliva." Pair your drink with enamel-friendly foods Certain foods can help neutralize acid and reduce the length of time pigments stay on teeth. Rajpal recommends crunchy foods like apples, carrots and celery, which gently scrub teeth and boost saliva, which helps wash away pigments. Cheese and leafy greens create a protective layer on enamel, while strawberries contain natural acids that can mildly brighten teeth. kiboka/Getty Images Maintain teeth-whitening habits It's best to wait at least 30 minutes before brushing to protect softened enamel. Timing also matters -- give your teeth a break between snacking or eating to boost natural cleansing by saliva. Rajpal also recommends products like remineralizing toothpaste and minimal intervention paste (a topical tooth cream that protects teeth and can improve overall oral hygiene). How to whiten teeth stained by coffee or wine If your teeth are already showing signs of staining, there are things you can do to whiten your teeth at home or at the dentist's office. Get a professional cleaning Before trying whitening products, Rajpal recommends scheduling a professional cleaning to remove surface stains and plaque buildup. For deeper stains, you can consider whitening treatments like in-office whitening or custom take-home trays. Maintaining results requires good oral hygiene and limiting staining habits. Try gentle at-home whitening products One of the easiest and most affordable ways to whiten your teeth at home is to use whitening toothpaste or kits. "Whitening strips use peroxide-based gels to lift surface stains, but they may contain other ingredients and preservatives, which may increase sensitivity," Rajpal said, adding that "LED kits often enhance this process with light to accelerate results."
Medscape
31 minutes ago
- Medscape
Helping Your Patients Manage COPD in the Workplace
Your patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) may need help not just coping with their condition but also managing it in their workplace. The symptoms of COPD, a lung and airway condition that causes shortness of breath, fatigue, and persistent cough, may interfere with some job responsibilities, according to several pulmonologists Medscape Medical News consulted as well as studies published in the past few years about COPD in the workplace. The Mayo Clinic reported that symptoms for most patients with COPD begin when they are at least 40 years, so well into their working years. Patients with COPD must continuously monitor if their condition affects their job performance and how potential workplace exposures to toxic chemicals or dust, and hazards such as stairs, worsen their breathing issues, the pulmonologists told Medscape Medical News . Several recent studies evaluated how workplace exposures to gases, vapors, dust, and fumes raised employees' risks of developing COPD, worsened their symptoms, or increased their chances of complications from the chronic disease. To combat such outcomes, pulmonologists share ways they teach their patients about navigating their workplace environment, recognizing hazards, understanding workplace protections, and seeking help. Weighing Work Options Whether a COPD patient can keep up with the job requirements depends on the person and their worksite experience, said David Mannino, MD, a pulmonologist and chief medical officer for the COPD Foundation, and chair of the Department of Occupational Medicine and Environmental Health at the University of Kentucky, Lexington, Kentucky. 'Some jobs are more physically demanding than others,' he said. 'Every patient has a unique situation and there's never a one-size-fits-all approach. It's very individualized.' Mannino said he's had patients who worked in coal mines or warehouses, and had to navigate those dusty and dirty environments, which can be difficult for patients with COPD. David Mannino, MD If they can't function reasonably well or keep up with the demands of the job, they may need to ask their employer for special accommodations such as switching to a different position or changing worksites, said Mannino, who sees patients several times. 'Some of my patients are on oxygen and that's fine if you're at a desk job. You can wear oxygen and that's not a problem.' In other settings, it might be more difficult or impossible, he said. 'If you have a patient who is a woodworker and he is self-employed and he uses respiratory protection, that he can do reasonably well. I've had some older patients who work at the university in desk jobs and so they can continue to work with no real changes in their responsibilities or schedules.' Some people with COPD may choose to retrain for careers where there aren't as many physical demands, he said. Mannino treated an older patient who was a plumber and could no longer keep up with some of the physical aspects of his job, so he was able to retire. Environmental Triggers Cleveland Clinic Pulmonologist Maeve MacMurdo, MD, said she spends time with patients with COPD evaluating their job, their challenges in the workplace with the disease, and potential triggers. 'So often people find that common triggers are things like strong perfumes or chemical cleaners,' she said. Incense and candles might also trigger COPD for some. Weather also plays a major role in the lives of patients with COPD. 'The humidity definitely impacts a lot of patients, so the air quality is one thing I tell them, when you wake up in the morning, look at the humidity for the day,' said Rohan Mankikar, MD, a pulmonologist with NYU Langone Health, New York City. 'The sweet spot for my COPD patients is like between 40%-70%, so if the humidity is above 70%, they might feel it more.' Maeve MacMurdo, MD On cold days, humidity < 20% might also affect patients with COPD, he said. 'But even days that it rains, snows, [they are] exposed to environmental changes such as wildfire smoke, I have patients that come in with COPD flares or exacerbations.' Patients should also check the allergen, pollen counts, and the air quality index for the day, Mankikar said. 'This is just something simple they can do before driving to work because sometimes you drive with the windows down and you might be inhaling pollen. The job site could be construction and there's exposure to dust,' he said. Potential workplace hazards are myriad, he said. From copy machines that accumulate dust to beauticians who get exposed to different chemicals and smells, it all could possibly trigger an episode. Mankikar said some of his patients wear a mask when they can. Patients should note what triggers their COPD and if it improves in different environments, Mankikar said. They should survey their work area to ensure it's safe for them. For instance, the air quality or humidity in the room. If it's a confined space with poor ventilation or an old building with mold that might require mold remediation. One of the most important triggers to address is smoking, which is the primary cause of COPD, he said. 'That's the biggest allergen for them and they might not realize it because they're saying: 'Well I'm used to this and did this [most of] my life.' But it weakens the immune system when you're actively smoking and creates more mucus production, which then acts like a glue for dust and pollen exposure.' Workplace Protections The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) protects employees with substantial breathing difficulty and requires employers to provide 'reasonable accommodations' or adjustments to the employee's role. Though the ADA doesn't list specific medical conditions such as COPD, it considers breathing a physical impairment that substantially limits or restricts a major life activity covered under the act. Major life activities include respiratory functions along with performing manual tasks, working, learning, reading, thinking, and communicating. To be protected, an employee must have a record of or be regarded as having a substantial impairment. If an employee's COPD stops or limits their ability to work effectively, they can apply for disability benefits through the Social Security Administration (SSA). COPD is listed among the respiratory disorders covered under the SSA's list of covered impairments. Monthly SSA disability benefits can be used to pay for food, clothing, housing, medical bills, medications, childcare, and training if an employee wants to return to work. To qualify, the government requires medical evidence to document the severity of the respiratory disorder such as with pulmonary function tests, including spirometry, which measures ventilation of the lungs, or pulse oximetry, which measures oxygen saturation of peripheral blood hemoglobin. What Help Patients May Need In addition to portable oxygen, patients may have to request access to therapeutic options to help them perform their job functions, Mannino said. Those might include access to medications that can be used at work, such as handheld inhalers or nebulizers. If a patient becomes short of breath when they climb stairs and that's a job requirement, they may have to ask their employer to modify their duties or look for another position within the company, resign or retire, he said. It's up to the employer to decide whether the request for accommodation is reasonable, Mannino said. If you're a welder and you need to be on oxygen, that's not really safe because it can create a fire hazard, he said. 'I think employers want to typically work with their employees…and that it's possible to make the workplace better for that person who has COPD.' If the company has an occupational health specialist in their human resources department, they may be able to assess the employee's needs and offer suggestions, said Francesca Polverino, MD, PhD, a pulmonologist and medical spokesperson for the American Lung Association. For some employees, access to a wheelchair may help them navigate the distances they might have to traverse at work, especially if they are carrying oxygen, said Polverino, who is also a professor of medicine at the Baylor College of Medicine. Francesca Polverino, MD, PhD Patients with COPD also would benefit from further education of their coworkers and supervisors about the disease because there's often a stigma associated with it, Polverino said. Compared with asthma, which tends to be inherited or unintentionally acquired, COPD is often caused by a preventable addiction — smoking. It's also not considered as alarming as other chronic diseases because COPD worsens slowly over a longer period, she said. For these reasons, workers with COPD may be reticent to ask for help, she added. MacMurdo said 'reasonable accommodation' from an employer might include a private office, an air purifier, working from home or having a flexible schedule. She agreed that not all work adaptations will be possible, but employees can brainstorm solutions with their doctors. Patients should keep a log of what they are doing and when they experience symptoms to help doctors identify triggers and come up with workarounds they can suggest to their employers, MacMurdo said. Ideally, patients should discuss with their doctors what they recommend and decide what's practical for the particular job to control COPD symptoms, she said. How to Ask for Help Mankikar said he's written letters for patients to take to their employer asking if it's possible for them not to be exposed to certain chemicals or dust that might exacerbate their COPD. 'For example, if the patient is a teacher and has COPD and they're doing construction [nearby], then I might have them try to teach a different class that's away from the construction site, so they're not in the hallways inhaling the dust.' Patients often request a doctor's note to leave early from work for pulmonary rehabilitation, Mankikar said. 'Unfortunately, those facilities are only open Monday through Friday from 9 to 5…so that's an example of writing a letter to make that accommodation happen to strengthen their lungs.' Employers tend to be very responsive to his notes, he said. 'The moment they know that some of these dust exposures can increase their [employee's] risk of COPD they want to make accommodation for them because they don't want the employee to miss work due to the illness.' Employers know that if their employees are exposed to chemicals or allergens, there's also a financial burden they might face, Mankikar said. If the employer is willing to work with the patient, they might move them to an administrative role instead of a direct occupational one. He cited a patient who worked for a landscaping company and managed other landscapers. The exposure to allergens raised his risk for COPD flareups, so his employer agreed to move him to an area that's well-ventilated and on days when the pollen count was high, he was able to work at a different site. These resources also may help patients navigate COPD in the workplace: How to Manage COPD's Impact on Your Job Early Warning Signs of Work-Related COPD | American Lung Association Lung Health on the Job | NHLBI, NIH
