Senior Edinburgh councillors to get £4k pay rise despite pledge to freeze wages
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info
Senior Edinburgh councillors have backed giving themselves a pay hike, with only one member speaking out in opposition.
In February, Edinburgh Council agreed to freeze pay for senior councillors – including political group leaders and committee conveners – at the previous year's levels.
But at Thursday's meeting all political groups except the SNP voted in favour of raising pay for senior councillors, with most getting an uplift of £4,637 to their annual pay packets – an 11.6% jump.
Council committee conveners, as well as the SNP, Conservative and Liberal Democrat group leaders, will all get £4,637 added to their annual pay, bringing them to £44,644 per year, up from £40,027 from the previous year.
And the depute council leader, Labour's Mandy Watt, will also get a £4,637 pay hike, bringing her total compensation to £52,669, up from £48,032 before.
A council spokesperson said the increase in pay for senior councillors was intended to match the pay hike given to non-senior councillors by the Scottish Government.
While local authorities have the power to set the pay of senior councillors, the rates for all other councillors are set by the Scottish Government, including the council's leader and Lord Provost, based on the fidings of the Scottish Local Authorities Remuneration Committee (SLARC).
Earlier this year, it mandated that the salary for most councillors be raised to £25,982 per year, up £4,637 from their previous pay of £21,345, which stood unchanged for several years.
Labour councillor and council leader Jane Meagher is paid £71,519 per year, while Lord Provost Robert Aldridge is paid £53,640.
Depute council leader, Labour councillor Mandy Watt, said: 'I sat down and read the guidance, and it does say that in your approach to this, you should be doing councillor remuneration from the bottom up, not the top down.
'I very much appreciate the support that I've had [from officers] to get all this together.'
An SNP source said: 'Councillors have been chronically underpaid for decades, and normally I'd take the view that we remunerate the position held, rather than the individual holding it.
'But the current crop of administration conveners are so inept that we could not support them getting a pay hike.'
A council spokesperson said: 'While we don't set the rates of pay for non-senior councillor roles it's appropriate that we publish them and provide elected members with the opportunity to scrutinise rates for full transparency.
'The increase in Senior Councillors' remuneration was agreed by Council yesterday, and now includes the increase to the Councillor basic pay set by the Scottish Government.'
Only one member, Labour councillor Katrina Faccenda, spoke out against the pay hikes.
She said: 'I think you should take note of which councillors are getting extra money, and you should work out whether you are getting value for money from those councillors.
'Since this is public money, and I don't think anyone in here would support the misuse of public money, I'd ask the public to have a look at that, and work out if they think that in Edinburgh Council, the extra money they have to spend to subsidise councillors is being used in the right way.'
Cllr Faccenda, who will not financially benefit from the pay increase for senior councillors, voted to support the hike.
Meanwhile, independent councillor Ross McKenzie voted with the SNP to oppose the pay hike.
Green co-convener, councillor Chas Booth, said: "Greens think it is right that people are paid appropriately for the work they do, and we welcomed the recommendations of the Scottish Local Authority Remuneration Committee around councillors' salaries.
'Pay is a significant barrier to people from marginalised groups entering politics, and if we want to see more diversity in our councillors to reflect the rich diversity of the communities we serve, then we need to ensure people without independent income can become elected representatives.
'However, we acknowledge that while so many people in Edinburgh continue to face a cost-of-living crisis caused by years of austerity which is now being continued by the Labour government at Westminster, the Labour council administration doesn't feel that big increases in senior councillor pay were not appropriate.
'Therefore Green councillors were happy to support their proposals around this."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
From Hong Kong to Kirkcaldy: Meet Scotland's new Street Food Champions
Minor condiment crises aside, Cheung is in high spirits following a weekend which saw her and business partner/fiancé, Rick Tai, come out on top when competing against fellow street food chefs from across the country. 'I'm still feeling quite emotional about it all,' she continues. 'I had been so nervous ever since first sending our application, and when we found out we were finalists while working a pop-up on Leith Walk, I was just jumping up and down on the street for what felt like five whole minutes. 'When we got there for the competition weekend, there were so many amazing traders with all of this professional equipment – one of them had a fridge that looked like my closet at home. 'We tried so much food and the finalists were all fantastic, but I was nervous because we come from a different culture and don't have as much market experience. 'When they announced we had won, I cried straight away.' Read more: Though they are relative newcomers to the Scottish street food scene, this Perth-based couple previously achieved success in Hong Kong, where in 2016 they founded a permanent Smoked Tamago shop serving a signature dish of Tamagoyaki. These traditional Japanese-style egg rolls wowed judges at last weekend's awards and ultimately secured their win, but Cheung admits to having some initial doubts over whether their menu would catch on in a new country. 'We moved to Scotland around four years ago, which was a really difficult time because of Covid', she explains. 'We both had other jobs, but always knew that we wanted to start our food business again. "It was only late last year that we found the courage to say, 'ok, let's do it'. 'We had a takeaway in Kirkcaldy at the beginning, but then realised that we needed to be meeting people face to face so that we could properly explain our signature dish because it's not very common in Scotland. 'That's why we started doing markets and have stuck with it since.' Pictured: Vincci Cheung and Rick Tai celebrate their win (Image: Supplied) Adapting their business to suit market events proved to be the key to Smoked Tamago's new venture in Scotland, with the team able to 'test the water' before getting in too deep. It also allowed them to reinvent their menu of contemporary Japanese-Korean dishes weekly to include the likes of Tteobokki, Takoyaki, and Japchae. 'The markets in Scotland really did make everything possible for us, because back in Hong Kong, opening a shop was a huge investment 'The city is tiny, the rent is crazy, and the housing prices are terrible. 'But here, we realised that we could try things out in a new environment without having to give up our full-time jobs. 'After a while, we started to feel like people were really loving our food, and I decided that I should probably just go for it.' Pictured: The Smoked Tamago team and British Street Food Awards Champions, Choola (Image: Supplied) Working markets around Scotland also introduced Cheung and Kai to fellow talented vendors like husband-and-wife team Nicole and Ameer Limbu of Choola, who took home the British Street Food Award Champion Title in 2023. 'We owe a big thanks to Choola for being so supportive of us right from the start,' the street food chef says of their first encounter at The Pitt in Edinburgh. 'I had just put in my application for Street Food Awards, and they were able to share so much of their experience with us. 'From then on, any time I had a question, they were happy to answer it and even helped us to pack up all of our stuff after the competition last weekend when we were totally exhausted." With a busy summer schedule ahead, there's little time for Smoked Tamago to stop and celebrate their Street Food Award win before moving on to the next stage of the competition in London this September. There, alongside Scottish People's Choice Award winners, Fire Bowl, they will serve up Tamagoyaki once again in the hopes of advancing to the European final in Munich. Pictured: A selection of contemporary Japanese-Korean dishes from Smoked Tamago (Image: Supplied) Proud to have made it to this stage, Cheung concludes: 'We are just one couple from Hong Kong, but there are actually a lot of people from the city in Scotland right now "Many of them will have been working just as hard, but might not be able to get back into the same industry as they were in before. 'It's difficult to start a new life or business somewhere new, and we're not the only ones trying. 'We just happen to be lucky enough that our hard work has been seen.' You can find Smoked Tamago at the Errol Sunday Market and at the Leith Walk Police Box on Tuesdays. For further updates, follow them on social media @smoked_tamago.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Judge me on my record, 18-year-old Warwickshire council leader says
An 18-year-old acting leader of a county council has urged people to judge him on his actions rather than his age. George Finch took temporary charge of Warwickshire County Council after the Reform UK leader stood down on Wednesday. He now oversees a local authority with £1.5bn of assets and a revenue budget of about £500m. The unusual situation has sparked debate, with his party calling it a proud moment and Labour and the Conservatives questioning his experience. Finch, a councillor for Bedworth and the local Reform UK chairman, has not ruled out running for the top job on a permanent basis. He said his track record was pretty good. Reform made unprecedented gains in Warwickshire in May's local elections, mainly at the expense of the Conservatives. They became the largest party and formed a minority Howard, who had been leader for 41 days, said he was quitting as council leader with "much regret" due to health reasons. Finch had been his deputy and will serve as interim until a new leader has been chosen, as per the council's constitution. Finch, who also serves as portfolio holder for children and families, said he hoped people would be able to see past his age. "The people of Bedworth Central elected me with a thumping majority of 1,100," he told the Local Democracy Reporting Service. "Don't judge me on my age, judge me on what I do. At the moment, my track record is pretty good."As party chairman I got 13 out of 13 candidates elected. "All of the things we needed to do to prepare for the elections, they speak volumes." Jaymey McIvor, an Essex county councillor and Reform UK local government spokesperson, praised Finch for taking over and getting on with the job. He said Warwickshire councillors were focused on issues such as fixing potholes and improving access to skills in deprived areas. "I was able to see councillor Finch in action," he told the BBC's Politics Midlands programme. "He was very professional."I think we should actually be quite proud that a young British man, who has been elected to office to represent his community, has found himself in a very senior position."Labour MP for Birmingham Edgbaston Preet Gill said the people of Warwickshire "frankly deserve better". "This is not work experience," she said. "This is not about learning on the job. "With all due respect, at 18 you will not know how to deliver adult social care, children social care [and] SEND services." Mike Wood, the Conservative MP for Kingswinford and South Staffordshire, was more apprehensive. He said he had previously been a local councillor, and it was a tough job."It really would take a quite remarkable 18-year-old to go straight from sixth form to running a large local authority with a half a billion pound budget with no previous experience," he said. Watch Politics Midlands on BBC One in the West Midlands at 10:00 BST on Sunday. The show will be available on iPlayer BBC Coventry & Warwickshire on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
Telegraph
2 hours ago
- Telegraph
Britain's mad planning system is becoming more and more absurd
Across the political spectrum, we don't agree on much. But we can all agree that the UK needs more homes and must start building in earnest. So why is Labour-run Birmingham City Council demanding that Mark Jones rip down the £180,000 two-bedroom 'granny flat' he built in his back garden for his dying father? With bin strikes, rat plagues and near bankruptcy, one might imagine that this particular local authority would have different matters on its mind. Mr Jones said he believed the building complied with planning laws and lodged a retrospective planning application. But the council's officious officers found that the Sutton Coldfield IT engineer has fallen foul of their regulations as it was 'over-intensive', and have ordered it to be demolished by the end of the month. The case shows in microcosm what is wrong with Britain's planning system. Like so much that is wrong on our island, from the NHS to the post-war explosion in council housing, its origins lie with the 1945 Clement Attlee Labour government. The 1947 Town and Country Planning Act established our system of planning permission, as well as the modern system of needing consents to build on land. It also meant that all planning authorities had to come up with a comprehensive development plan. Green belts, the listing of buildings and the anathematising of building in the open countryside can all be dated back to this legislation. In some regards, we should be grateful for Attlee's innovation. Anyone who has taken the seven-hour trip from Boston to Washington DC on the Acela Amtrak train will see why. Apart from a stretch along the Connecticut coastline, the prospect out of the windows is of virtually unending urban sprawl. Or contrast the west coast of Ireland with the west coast of Scotland. While the Irish views are endlessly interrupted by the tackiest imaginable McMansions, complete with fake colonnades and naff statuary, the Caledonian vista is virtually uninterrupted. Our planning system has made large-scale developers hugely powerful to a far greater extent than in most other developed countries. Building your own house is straightforward in much of the United States. But then America is a large country with plenty of space, as defenders of the British status quo might point out. The rules in much of Europe, however, are also vastly more flexible. In France, for example, it is relatively straightforward to buy a plot of land on the fringes of a village and build a family home on it. By contrast, in the UK, to build a new single dwelling in the isolated countryside is extraordinarily difficult. One of the very few routes is via what is now called Paragraph 84 consent. This is a rule, first introduced in 1997 in the dying days of John Major's government, allowing for new country houses to be built, but only if they are of 'truly outstanding' design and 'reflect the highest standards of architecture'. We would all, I am sure, like to live in such houses – but to meet such benchmarks requires money, plenty of it. It is not something that rural Mr Joneses, middle-earning IT engineers and their like, will ever be able to afford. The British system places all the cards in the hands of the vast corporate builders, with their new housing developments. Angela Rayner's Planning and Infrastructure Bill, which is now being pushed through the House of Lords, will only make this problem even worse. It will make development easier, and that is indeed a worthy goal. It will make it easier to overrule Nimby-style objections, but its mechanisms are not there to help people who want to do their own projects. It is all about pushing through large-scale plans in the face of local opposition, be they for new homes, wind or solar farms or the latest railway wheeze dreamt up in Whitehall. It is not about allowing Sir Keir Starmer's much-touted 'working people' to realise their own building ambitions. Our planning system might seem to have been more of a success if our post-war homes were exemplars of design. But that is far from the case. Probably the only country in Western Europe that has uglier townscapes than those found in much of Britain is Germany. Walk through Cologne, and outside of its Cathedral and Romanesque churches you would be hard put to find an uglier city with less inspiring buildings. Colognians have a very good excuse. When their city was rebuilt in the 1950s from the ashes the RAF had reduced it to, beauty was not foremost on their minds. We have no such excuse for some of the horrors that urban planning has imposed on our towns and cities. And our planning laws did little to protect us from these missteps. When Nick Boles was housing minister in the Cameron government, he was evangelical about relaxing planning rules in urban and suburban areas. He wanted to allow thousands upon thousands of Mr Joneses to do pretty much as they pleased with their own land and property, and thought this would make a huge difference to our housing shortage. It would also empower local people. Such an approach would clearly be a disaster if applied to, say, the Victorian garden square of London or the Georgian terraces of Bath. They would soon be scarred with endless glass boxes and extensions which would now be on trend, but soon look very dated. If Labour really wants to empower working people, allowing the Mr Joneses to build on their back gardens could be just the thing. But don't hold your breath.
