2 Hour Lead Time For Tornadoes Is Possible But Do We Want It?
We are in the peak of the U.S. severe weather season, and tornadic storms have been particularly prevalent this season. During my tenure in the meteorological field, one of the 'holy grail' research challenges has been to improve tornado warning lead times. A NOAA research program has demonstrated that we may be able to give up to two hours of advance warning of a tornado. Here's how it is possible as well as some thoughts on whether we want it.
Two Hours of Lead Time Is Now Possible
Of course, we want to give as much lead time as possibly for tornadoes, but it is complicated. Tornadoes can be life-altering events that affect families, businesses, and communities for years. I will explore, however, some of the caveats with additional lead time a bit later, but let's explore the Warn-on-Forecast System developed by NOAA's National Severe Storms Laboratory.
The NOAA Warn on Forecast System has evolved from years of research. NOAA NSSL
According to a NOAA website, the system, 'Seeks to equip forecasters with critical information between watches and warnings to allow them to offer longer lead times in the face of severe weather and tornadoes.' In March, a long-track, strong tornado hit Carter County, Missouri. This storm caused significant damage as the tornado tracked along the ground for more than 50 miles. According to NOAA, 'The emergency manager immediately shared information from the 7:40 p.m. phone call with other safety officials and on social media, he sounded the sirens well before any warnings were issued, and ultimately credits the advanced messaging, derived from WoFS, as having saved lives.' People had nearly two hours of lead time before the EF-3 tornado touched down in the county at 9:51 pm.
Even prior to that issuance, the NWS issued a Special Weather Statement at 8:34 pm that, 'A significant and long-track tornado was likely in the area.' This was all based on the WoFS output. According to NOAA, forecasters spoke highly of the coordinated guidance provided by the NSSL scientists as the event unfolded.
Timeline of warnings and tornado activity in Carter County, Missouri (March, 2025). NOAA NSSL
What is WoFS
According to the NOAA webpage, NSSL developed the system. They noted that it is, 'A rapidly updating, high-resolution computer model designed to predict the probability and location of severe weather like tornadoes.' That night the system predicted two hours in advance that supercell storms would cross Carter County. As a meteorologist myself, we often see guidance in the model that suggests tornadic storms. However, what strikes me is the confidence forecasters had to 'act' on the information so early. Given the path of destruction with this tornado, those early phone calls and Special Weather Statements likely saved lives.
Are There Down Sides Of Too Much Lead Time?
NOAA reported that in this example, 'The two-hour lead time given by the NWS Paducah Weather Forecast Office was invaluable…. Carter County emergency manager reported the number of people checked into a designated shelter in Van Buren rose from four to 125 well before the tornado arrived.' However, some studies have found mixed messages when it comes to lead time. A 2008 study published in the scientific journal Weather and Forecasting found that up to 15 minutes lead time led to a reduction in fatalities, but beyond that time threshold, there was an increase in fatalities compared to the absence of a warning.
JOPLIN, MO - MAY 24: Damage is seen one day after a tornado tore through Joplin killing at least ... More 122 people on May 24, 2011 in Joplin, Missouri. The tornado that ripped through the town of about 50,000 people May 22, is being called the deadliest single tornado in the U.S. in 60 years. (Photo by) Getty Images
In 1999, legendary severe weather expert Chuck Doswell wrote in Weatherzine , 'It's hard to imagine any real need for warnings with lead times longer than 32 minutes! In fact, it's possible that longer lead times would be less effective because they might not convey a strong enough sense of urgency.' The first tornado of the day, according to studies tends to have the lowest lead time, and it increases for subsequent tornadoes. Average lead time is around 13 to 15 minutes. In a 2002 study of schools and assisted living facilities, the response to the question, 'What is the ideal lead time?' ranged from a median of 15 minutes (schools) to 30 minutes (assisted living). A 2011 study found that the public ideally wanted about 34 minutes of lead time, which is less than the one to two hours now possible with the WoFS system.
Why It All Matters
That 2011 study suggested that too much lead time may lead to a reduced sense of urgency. I can see scenarios in which people said, 'Oh, I still have time to pick up groceries or the dry cleaning.' There is complexity and nuance to this discussion. There are likely many factors including the type of population, time of day, perceived vulnerability, and so forth. NOAA made the point that, 'Outdoor events, hospitals, schools, and people with no access to a tornado shelter need much more time to evacuate or find safe shelter.'
Overall, the Missouri story is important because WoFS did not appear overnight. It evolved from years of research, development, and evaluation. Steven Thur is NOAA's Assistant Administrator for Research. In a social media post on LinkedIn accompanying the NOAA press release, he said, 'This new system will save lives. In 2024, NOAA: National Oceanic & Atmospheric Administration confirmed 1,796 tornados, the 2nd highest total since record-keeping began in 1950. Those storms killed 54 individuals across 17 states. So far in 2025, there have already been 35 fatalities across 16 states.'
Henryville Elementary School staff greet returning students Wednesday, March 21, as they disembark ... More from school buses at temporary classrooms the school district is renting from Graceland Baptist Church in New Albany, Ind. Wednesday was the kindergarten through sixth grade students' first day back at school since a tornado heavily damaged Henryville, Ind.'s three-school campus. That March 2 storm was part of a wave of tornadoes that killed 13 Indiana residents. (AP Photo/Rick Callahan) Copyright 2012 AP. All rights reserved.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
24 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Why is Ohio seeing more summer downpours than usual?
Central Ohio Weather and Radar COLUMBUS (WCMH) — The familiar phrase 'when it rains, it pours' applies to our weather in recent weeks. More than 15 inches of rain have fallen on Columbus since May 1, nearly five inches above normal, and double what fell during last year's drought (June-October). Some areas in southern Ohio had upwards of two feet of rain in the past three months, resulting in flooding. On the evening of July 17, a small shower over northern Fairfield County blew up into a narrow line of torrential rain that spread east along the Licking County border and across Buckeye Lake. Nearly five inches of rain was measured at Sellers Point, much of it falling in a little more than an hour. Inevitably, low-lying areas were swamped, and water entered the lower floors of several homes and buildings and flooded roads, and closed a portion of State Route 13 just south of Interstate 70 in southern Licking County. The pattern of storm deluges began at the start of July. On June 30-July 1, 3.85 inches fell at Bainbridge in Ross County. Rockbridge in northern Hocking County received 7.72 inches from June 24 through July 1. On July 9, localized downpours dropped nearly three inches of rain around the Newark area in eastern Licking County. Historic Columbus building with French bistro sold for $2 million Through July 15, a record 3,045 flash flood warnings were issued by the National Weather Service across the U.S., exceeding the 1998 record for an entire year (3,033). Four historic floods occurred in one week in the eastern part of the country. Catastrophic flooding took more than 135 lives along the Guadalupe River in south-central Texas on July 4. Later in the holiday weekend, up to a foot of rain swamped the Raleigh-Durham, North Carolina, area from the remnants of Tropical Storm Chantal, taking six lives. On July 7-8, parts of Chicago were soaked with more than 5 inches of rain. Ruidoso, New Mexico, experienced a deadly flash flood after several inches of rain over a burn scar raced downhill, killing three people and carrying a home downstream on July 8. The New York City area, and neighboring New Jersey and southeastern Pennsylvania region, were swamped with more than six inches of rain on July 14, inundating some subways and flooding neighborhoods and roads. Two people died in New Jersey when their car was swept away in floodwaters. Reason for excessive rainfalls Areas east of the Rocky Mountains and south of the Great Lakes have been caught in soggy pattern due to near-record high levels of atmospheric water vapor. The seasonal northward shift of the jet stream around the periphery of high pressure in the Southeast has been the focus for rounds of showers and storms feeding off the extra available energy derived from stagnant tropical moisture. Frequent disturbances or waves in the mid-level flow drive thunderstorm clusters that tend to congeal into self-sustaining complexes, bringing torrential rain and strong winds. Light steering currents, typical of summer, allows storms to linger longer, or 'train' over the same areas like railroad cars filled with moisture following the same section of track. In the case of the tragic Texas Hill Country flood, the remnants of Tropical Storm Barry played a major role in the rainfall totals that reached 10 to 20 inches on July 3-4. Successive periods of heavy rain in the past two week, totaling five to 10 inches locally in some events, stalled search and recovery efforts. Heavy rainfalls increasing in most of U.S. A recent U.S. study conducted by Climate Central reported that 88 percent (126) of the nation's 144 sampled cities since 1970 have recorded heavier rainfall rates. In the Ohio Valley, the average increase in hourly rainfall intensity was 15 percent, which can add a few additional inches in intense storms, often the difference between ponding and more widespread flooding. More intense rainfalls falling on complex, hilly terrain and in urban areas with poorer drainage (storm drains, sewers become clogged) promote channeled runoff that is conducive to flash flooding–the nation's deadliest severe weather event. The primary reason for the long-term wetter trend is warmer air and sea surface temperatures, which causes more moisture to evaporate into the atmosphere. A one degree Fahrenheit rise in the temperature allows the air to store 4 percent more water vapor. The ocean absorbs about 90 percent of the excess heat generated by greenhouse gas emissions (coal, oil, natural gas) from human activities, which have been steadily increasing globally. Higher ocean temperatures contribute to stronger tropical cyclones capable of bringing copious rain and high winds during and following landfall. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Every Australian state in the firing line as wild weather sweeps nation
A major weather system is on the move — and it's going to leave very few parts of the country untouched. From Western Australia to Tasmania, most Australians will see rain this week, and in many alpine areas, that'll soon turn to snow. For some, it'll be the biggest downpour in over a year. For others, the best skiing conditions in recent memory. In an interview with Yahoo News, Dean Narramore, Senior Meteorologist at the Bureau of Meteorology, gave an overview of what's coming this week. Western Australia Western Australia will be the first to feel the full force of the system, and it's expected to arrive with intensity. Thunderstorms, strong winds and widespread showers will push across the west and south of the state from midweek, fuelled by tropical moisture. Perth is forecast to cop 35mm of rain on Wednesday. "It's going to move into Western Australia on Wednesday, bringing widespread storms in western and southern parts of WA," Narramore said. "As it moves across WA, it's going to pull down some moisture from the tropics, and that's going to develop a very large band of rain." South Australia From Thursday night, South Australia will be soaked. For many communities, it could be the best rain they've seen in years. After months of dry, dusty paddocks and stubborn rainfall deficits, farmers and residents are set to get long-overdue relief. "This is definitely a very good news story, particularly for South Australia — eastern South Australia — where we've had pretty large rainfall deficiencies over the last couple of years. It's been very, very dry," Narramore said. "Depending on where you are, if they get 20 or 30 millimetres — which is looking pretty good — it'll be the wettest they've seen in 12 to 24 months." Victoria Central and eastern Victoria are shaping up as the epicentre of this event. With saturated air pushing through the Great Dividing Range and soaking already dry ground, some regions could see torrents of rain — with snow falling thickly over the peaks. "Central and eastern Victoria could see another 50 to 80, maybe even up to 100 millimetres there," Narramore said. "And half of that could fall as snow for our alpine areas," Narramore said. "Outside the Mount Lofty Ranges, central and northeast ranges of Victoria, and northern Tasmania — everyone else is probably going to be in that 20 to 40 millimetre range." Tasmania The Apple Isle is forecast to cop a serious drenching, with the system dragging moist air across the Bass Strait. The state's north in particular could see some of the highest rainfall totals, before lingering showers stretch into Sunday. "Northern parts of Tasmania could be in that 50 to 100mm range as well," Narramore said. "And continuing showers likely into Sunday, probably easing by the end of the weekend or early next week." NSW and ACT While the rain won't arrive in NSW and the ACT until later in the week, when it does, it'll come in force in some regions. Widespread falls are expected from Friday through Saturday, with a mix of steady rain and bursts of intense showers, especially in the south and east. "Friday to Saturday through Queensland, New South Wales, Victoria, and Tasmania, with continuing showers on Sunday, probably easing by the end of the weekend or early next week," Narramore said. On Saturday, Canberra is expecting up to 25mm of rain and Sydney up to 10mm. Queensland Eastern and southern Queensland will get their turn as the system rolls east, with downpours reaching inland farming communities and coastal hubs alike. Totals will vary — but many places can expect a long-awaited soaking. "Much of southern and eastern Queensland could see anywhere from 20 to 40 millimetres of rain as well," said Narramore. Northern Territory It's one of the few parts of the country that will escape the worst of the weather. The Top End remains dry, and even central areas will be on the fringes of the system. "If you drew a line from Carnarvon to Birdsville to somewhere around Mount Isa, everywhere south and west of that line is going to be impacted by this system," Narramore explained. "Pretty much northern WA and that's it — Broome will be fine, but everywhere else will see some rain or wind." Snowfall could be the 'best in years' Behind the rain, a blast of cold air will sweep up the ranges, and for alpine regions in NSW and Victoria, it could deliver the kind of snow totals skiers dream about. Resorts that started the season slowly could be transformed by the weekend. "We're looking at probably 30 to 50 centimetres for alpine areas — Falls, Hotham, up through Perisher and Thredbo — through our highest peaks," Narramore said. "That should bump them up to well over a metre of base so far this season. It's really good news, particularly coming off such a bad last few years for ski seasons, because it was such a warm and dry winter." The Bureau doesn't officially keep snowfall records, but Narramore said this event could rank among the most significant of the past decade. "This is definitely the best in the last few years, because 2023 and 2024 were really bad," he said. Some higher peaks could even push past 50 centimetres by the end of the weekend. Weather system is good news, but will create dangerous conditions For the most part, this system is being welcomed, but that doesn't mean it's without risk. Damaging winds and alpine hazards could still present challenges, particularly for travellers heading into the snow. "We've got some pretty severe weather with this front at the moment, mostly it's a good news story in terms of widespread soaking rainfall," Narramore said. "Obviously, the dangerous part could be very heavy snowfall for alpine areas — and driving or getting up and down the mountains. There could be some dangerous and treacherous driving conditions, and you could see some damaging wind through our elevated areas and coastal parts of southeastern Australia." Love Australia's weird and wonderful environment? 🐊🦘😳 Get our new newsletter showcasing the week's best stories.
CBS News
3 hours ago
- CBS News
Mostly sunny, beautiful Tuesday in Philadelphia region. Here's the weather forecast.
What a gorgeous start to the new week! Temperatures on Monday in the Philadelphia region ended up topping out in the mid-upper 80s, but the lower humidity levels were noticeable all day. In fact, we'll be below normal temp-wise the next two days along with plenty of sunshine. Make it a point to spend time outside. Even if you work indoors, try to get your lunch outside. It's a gorgeous mid-July break. By Thursday, we warm to 90 again, and on Friday it certainly becomes hotter and more humid with highs heading back into the stifling mid-90s. The next chance of storms arrives late Friday or early Saturday, with the weekend once again looking unsettled. No organized weather systems are expected at this point, so we remain weather alert-free, but we'll keep you posted. Tuesday: Stunning sun. High 84, Low 66. Wednesday: Picture perfect. High 86, Low 67. Thursday: Heating up. High 90, Low 69. Friday: Hot and humid. High 95, Low 73. Saturday: Scattered storms. High 92, Low 77. Sunday: Scattered storms. High 89, Low 76. Monday: A few showers. High 86, Low 72. NEXT Weather Radars Hourly Forecast
