Lack of proof, procedural lapses: Mithi scam accused's bail order
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
Ketan Kadam, director of Woder India LLP, and
, who allegedly supplied equipment like silt pusher machines to various contractors assigned to desilting the Mithi River, were both arrested on May 6 this year. While Joshi was granted bail on June 5, Kadam is yet to move the sessions court for bail.
In a detailed order made available on Wednesday, the judge said that the material on record shows that instead of Joshi, Kadam dealt with the transactions on behalf of M/s Virgo Specialties Pvt Ltd.
"Hence, prima facie it appears that there is no material showing that the applicant compelled contractors or bidders to hire the machines on rent and caused wrongful loss to BMC," judge NG Shukla said. Also, stating that prima facie there was no material showing his role in the conspiracy, the judge said that a copy of the resolution appointing Kadam as CEO and statements of witnesses show that it was Kadam who dealt with them for hiring the machines.
"Considering the agreement signed by Ketan Kadam and dealing with the contractors to hire the machines by him, there is no role of the applicant (Joshi) as a director in compelling the directors of contractor companies to hire the machines. In the absence of such a specific role as a director of the company, there is no strong reason to deny bail to the applicant," the judge said. The judge also said that the charge of criminal breach of trust is not made out against Joshi.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
The judge also referred to rulings which emphasised that written communication of arrest grounds to both the accused and their nominated contacts is crucial, and failure to do so can render the arrest illegal.
The charges against Joshi include Sections 406 (criminal breach of trust), 409 (criminal breach of trust by public servant, or by banker, merchant, or agent), and 420 (cheating and dishonestly, etc.) of the Indian Penal Code. According to the FIR, the BMC awarded contracts for desilting the Mithi River between 2019 and 2024. It is alleged that Joshi, along with other co-accused, including directors of contractor companies and BMC officials, conspired to alter tender terms.
These altered terms allegedly mandated the use of specific machines for waste removal from the river.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India.com
4 minutes ago
- India.com
Not Mukesh Ambani, Akash Ambani or Anant Ambani, but this person owns India's most expensive car of Rs 1000000000, it is…, she is…
Mukesh Ambani is in headlines for his expensive Antilia house, cars and luxurious lifestyle. But he is not the owner of India's most expensive car despite having the world's best cars collections. Who Is Owner Of India's Most Expensive Car? According to a report by ABP Live, Nita Ambani owns the Audi A9 Chameleon, a luxury car estimated at Rs 100 crore. It is an ultra-exclusive vehicle and has color-shifting paint technology that can change colors electronically at the press of a button. It also gives a unique driving experience. Only 11 units of this cars are sold worldwide, the Audi A9 Chameleon is among the rarest and most innovative cars ever built. Its blend of cutting-edge design and sheer exclusivity makes it a symbol of both wealth and technological sophistication. Nita Ambani's Cars Collection The Audi A9 Chameleon is powered by a 4.0-litre V8 engine with an impressive 600 horsepower. The vehicle's two-door design spans five meters in length with better presence on the road. It is a unique car with a single-piece windshield and roof. It also has a design rarely seen in conventional luxury cars. It is equipped with next-generation technology available only in this model, the car embodies the pinnacle of modern automotive innovation. Nita Ambani's Cars Collection Rolls-Royce Phantom VIII EWB: This extended model is celebrated for its opulent interiors and a commanding V12 engine. Mercedes-Maybach S600 Guard: Engineered for maximum protection, this armored sedan is bulletproof and blast-resistant, offering top-tier security. Ferrari 812 Superfast: A high-performance sports car has a mighty V12 engine, delivering both speed and style. Bentley Continental Flying Spur: A refined grand tourer, known for its elegant design, advanced features, and robust engine performance. Rolls-Royce Cullinan: This ultra-luxurious SUV combines off-road capability with Rolls-Royce's signature comfort and power. BMW 7 Series 760Li Security (2004 model): Luxury sedan designed for discreet security gives protection and prestige.
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
4 minutes ago
- Business Standard
Sebi's AMC-family office plan sparks concerns over regulation and parity
Sebi's plan to let AMCs manage non-broad-based pooled funds without PMS licences has sparked debate over regulatory parity, competitive fairness, and market safeguards New Delhi The Securities and Exchange Board of India's (Sebi's) recent proposal to permit asset management companies (AMCs) to manage family office funds has stirred debate, with concerns surfacing around regulatory overlap and market parity. On July 7, Sebi released a consultation paper suggesting major relaxations to existing regulations. The key proposal includes allowing AMCs to manage non-broad-based pooled funds—such as family offices and certain offshore vehicles—without obtaining a separate portfolio management services (PMS) licence, provided strict checks and balances are implemented. 'If AMCs are allowed to offer segregated mandates to large clients under a new category, the lines between PMS and mutual funds (MFs) will blur further. This raises regulatory parity questions,' said Sonam Srivastava, founder and fund manager at Wright Research PMS. She argued that PMS managers operate under stricter minimum investment thresholds, compliance costs, and client suitability obligations. 'If AMCs are allowed to offer similar services under the MF umbrella but with lighter-touch regulation or brand-driven advantages, it could lead to competitive imbalance and arbitrage,' she added. Uneven playing field and a new revenue stream Until now, AMCs interested in offering management and advisory services to such funds were required to hold a PMS licence, a layer of regulation the AMC sector contended created an uneven playing field compared to other intermediaries. Sebi's latest proposal opens up a new revenue stream for the domestic mutual fund industry, which handles assets worth Rs 75 trillion. 'The proposals could enable AMCs to engage with a wider spectrum of pooled vehicles which are non-broad-based, such as family offices or select offshore funds, which were earlier outside the regulatory scope,' said Swarup Mohanty, vice-chairman and chief executive officer, Mirae Asset Investment Managers (India). Safeguards, definitions and structural implications Under the proposal, non-broad-based funds are defined as those with fewer than 20 investors, or where a single investor holds more than 25 per cent of the corpus. Sebi has outlined safeguards to address potential conflicts of interest, including caps on fee differentials, resource allocation norms, and clear firewalls between mutual fund and private mandates. Pradeep Gupta, executive director and head of investments at Lighthouse Canton India, said a new set of investors would benefit from an experienced and well-resourced buy-side investment architecture that has proven itself across multiple market cycles. Market structure, HNIs and the competitive landscape A recent Jefferies report indicated that the high-net-worth investor (HNI) segment is already crowded, with revenue streams layered through various commissions and fees. Professional wealth managers now oversee assets exceeding Rs 65 trillion, and the space is witnessing strong competitive momentum for deepening service offerings. The report noted a likely trend towards advisory-led models as wealth managers look to tap larger-ticket clients. Despite concerns over increased competition, several PMS managers believe their established expertise in serving ultra-HNI requirements will remain a key differentiator. Divam Sharma, co-founder and fund manager at Green Portfolio PMS, said AMCs entering this space will heighten overall competition, but will also be subject to tighter controls on fees and operations. 'We've already built the systems and expertise needed for personalised, complex wealth solutions, so most family offices will continue to seek out hands-on, bespoke service,' he added. To allay concerns, Sebi has proposed permitting ancillary activities for AMCs, including fund distribution and global marketing. Public comments on the consultation paper are open until July 28, with market participants expecting a final framework before the end of the year.
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
4 minutes ago
- Business Standard
Aarthi Scans to invest Rs 350 crore, expand strongly in North India by 2030
Chennai-based Aarthi Scans and Labs, a leading diagnostic imaging services provider in South India, is preparing to aggressively expand its presence in the North Indian market. The company plans to add 90 per cent of its upcoming centres in the region by 2030. As part of this expansion, it will invest around Rs 350 crore to increase its total number of branches from 85 to around 150 over the next five years. Now in its 25th year of operations, Aarthi Scans is also planning to launch an initial public offering (IPO) within the next three years. Simultaneously, the company is preparing to foray into the fitness diagnostics segment to cater to a wider audience. 'We are planning our IPO in the next three years. Every year, we are clocking a growth of around 20 per cent. In FY25, our turnover was around Rs 320 crore, which is slated to cross Rs 375 crore during the current financial year,' said V Govindarajan, founder of Aarthi Scans and Labs. The company has set a target of achieving a turnover of Rs 600 crore in the next four to five years. Pan-India footprint with a northern focus Aarthi Scans currently operates 85 branches and 150 collection centres across 18 cities in 11 states, including Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, Telangana, Maharashtra, Delhi, West Bengal, Gujarat, Puducherry, Andhra Pradesh, Kerala, and Haryana. Around 25 branches are located in Chennai alone, with 18 clustered in and around the city. 'Our aim is to add an average of around 10 branches every year. Within three months, we will be starting operations in Uttar Pradesh as well. Of the total branch expansions in the next five years, 90 per cent will be in North India,' Govindarajan said. From outpatient clinic to diagnostic leader Govindarajan entered the healthcare sector in the late 1980s by starting a small clinic, Aarthi Clinic—named after his daughter—for his doctor wife in Kovilpatti, Tamil Nadu. The family launched a multispeciality hospital in 1995, followed by a foray into diagnostics in 2000 and the opening of its first centre in Chennai's Vadapalani in 2003. Today, Aarthi Scans is managed by a family-run team of radiologists: Prasanna Vignesh, Aarthi Prasanna, and Arunkumar Govindarajan. AI-led transformation and new service verticals Arunkumar, Govindarajan's son, is spearheading the company's technological transformation. From X-rays and CT scans to brain volumetric analysis, the company has adopted artificial intelligence (AI) across several operations. 'AI is making the job of radiologists easier. Globally too, India has adopted AI better than even some developed nations,' said Arunkumar. He added that the company is in the process of launching fitness diagnostics, a fast-growing segment in India. Private equity talks and future outlook Aarthi Scans came into the spotlight in 2022 when reports emerged that Tata Capital Growth Fund, a mid-market private equity fund, was in talks to acquire a minority stake in the company. 'We were in talks with Tata Capital during Covid. We were doing some extremely good business and wanted to rope in a minority investor. Finally, the valuation did not match,' Govindarajan said.
