China's collateral demands curbing emerging countries' ability to manage finances: study
[NAIROBI] China's practice of securing its loans to low-income nations through commodity revenue streams and cash held in restricted escrow accounts is curbing their ability to manage their finances effectively, a study published on Thursday showed.
China has lent hundreds of billions of dollars for infrastructure and projects in developing countries, but has been criticised for using earnings of commodity exports from borrower nations as security for the loans, sometimes arranged during times of economic strife for the borrower.
China's government has repeatedly denied that its lending practices towards poorer countries are unscrupulous.
China's total public and publicly guaranteed lending to low and middle-income countries totals US$911 billion, said the report by AidData, the Kiel Institute for the World Economy and Georgetown University, together with other partners.
Of that, nearly half - or US$418 billion across 57 countries - is secured with cash deposits in Chinese bank accounts, it said.
'As security, Chinese lenders strongly prefer liquid assets - in particular, cash deposits in bank accounts located in China. They also want visibility and control over revenue,' said Christoph Trebesch of the Kiel Institute.
BT in your inbox
Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox.
Sign Up
Sign Up
The deposits in accounts located in China and controlled by the lending entities can average more than a fifth of the annual payments low-income commodity-exporting countries make to service their external debt, the research found.
'Some of these revenues remain offshore beyond the control of the borrowing government for many years,' the report said, adding the lack of access or transparency compromises debtor governments' ability to monitor and steer their fiscal affairs.
China applies the practice to its lending to borrowers in Africa, Asia, Latin America and the Middle East, the study, which covered 2000-2021, found.
'Our research reveals a previously undocumented pattern of revenue ring-fencing where a significant share of commodity export receipts never reach the exporting countries,' said Brad Parks, executive director of the AidData research lab.
The International Monetary Fund and the World Bank have in the past raised concerns about the impact of collateralised lending to developing countries.
The practice has the potential to cause debt distress to the borrowers, the two institutions said in a joint paper published in 2023, by constraining their fiscal space, increasing the risk of over-borrowing, and curbing the financing from unsecured creditors available to them.
In cases where countries have had to restructure their external debts due to distress, China's practice of securing infrastructure loans using unrelated commodity revenue flows has complicated the restructuring, the report said. REUTERS
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
an hour ago
- Business Times
China's Zijin Mining to acquire Kazakh gold mine in US$1.2 billion deal
CHINA'S biggest gold and copper producer Zijin Mining said on Monday it had agreed to buy one of the largest gold mines of Kazakhstan, the Raygorodok Gold Mine, for US$1.2 billion. Zijin said its unit Zijin Gold International and Jinha Mining, a subsidiary of Zijin Gold, had inked a deal to acquire the rights of RG Gold and RG Processing, the Kazakhstan-based gold mining firms that currently own and operate the Raygorodok gold mine. The gold mine comprises the mine assets held by RGG and the processing plant assets held by RGP, Zijin said in a statement. The timing of the deal aligns with a surge in global gold prices amid ongoing uncertainty around US-China trade tensions. Earlier in April, Zijin laid out its intention to spin off its unit, Zijin Gold International, and list it in Hong Kong as part of a reorganisation of its overseas gold assets.
Asia News Network
an hour ago
- Asia News Network
30-cent bubble tea, US$7.7k EVs: China updates law to curb cutthroat price wars
June 30, 2025 SINGAPORE – China has introduced legal measures to halt businesses' race to the bottom, as it continues to crack down on price-cutting practices that are hurting the economy. The country's top legislative body on June 27 passed amendments to a law against 'unfair competition', including one that prohibits platform operators from compelling their vendors to sell items at below cost price. The amended law, state broadcaster CCTV said on June 28, will regulate 'involutional competition' such as the 'frenzied lowering of prices' on e-commerce platforms, and food delivery platforms' use of hefty subsidies to wrest a share of the market. Coffee and bubble tea, for instance, can sell for as little as 1.68 yuan (30 Singapore cents) after discounts on on the 18th day of each month, as the retail giant doles out 10 billion yuan in subsidies to muscle into the food delivery business. Platform operators found to have compelled vendors to sell items at less than cost price could now be fined as much as 2 million yuan in serious cases. 'Involution', or neijuan in Chinese, refers to unproductive competition in a crowded field that results in diminishing returns – in this case the vicious circle of lowering prices and product quality, which the authorities aim to curb. Instead, industry players will be guided towards upgrading their services, CCTV said. 'A major economic challenge China faces is the risk of sustained deflation, which is exacerbated by neijuan,' said economics professor Hu Guangzhou of the China Europe International Business School in Shanghai. Macquarie economists said in a note in June that China is contending with its longest deflationary streak in the past four decades. This reflects cautious consumer spending and how factories have been churning out more goods than are needed. The country's gross domestic product deflator, which measures broad changes in prices of goods and services across the economy, has fallen for eight consecutive quarters. Prices of goods leaving factories have been dropping for more than two years. Aside from deflation, Prof Hu said that weak demand and price competition resulting from involution were forcing firms to live with lower profit margins. This, in turn, deprives companies of the resources needed to innovate, and to pay their workers adequately. In the fiercely competitive electric vehicle sector, for instance, Chinese automakers have been slashing prices to vie for a slice of the domestic market. The latest round of price cuts was sparked in May by industry leader BYD, which reduced prices by as much as 34 per cent. Its cheapest model now costs just 55,800 yuan (S$9,900). In Prof Hu's view, platform operators have been singled out in the revised law because their market dominance can give them an unfair advantage in dealing with vendors. Most of these vendors are small or micro enterprises that generate many jobs, he said. 'When their profit margins are squeezed by the platform operators, it generates a detrimental knock-on effect on the economy.' The new regulations, reported by the Xinhua news agency on June 27, include a provision mandating that big companies avoid setting unreasonable payment terms and methods for smaller players. Local media outlet Yicai reported in June that small companies serving the car industry have been facing significant delays in receiving payments from the large firms they work with. According to the outlet's research, it took eight listed battery manufacturers an average of 255 days to pay their suppliers, even though they themselves got paid in an average of 103 days. Prof Hu believes that the new law, which takes effect in October, will help make China's economy more efficient, but adds that more will need to be done to combat involution and break the deflationary cycle. 'Greater fiscal stimulus and higher household income are necessary to raise the levels of consumption and start the reflation process,' he said.
Business Times
2 hours ago
- Business Times
Oil falls on prospect of more Opec+ supply, easing risks in Middle East
[SINGAPORE] Oil prices fell 1 per cent on Monday as an easing of geopolitical risks in the Middle East and the prospect of another Opec+ output hike in August boosted the supply outlook. Brent crude futures fell 66 cents, or 0.97 per cent, to US$67.11 a barrel by 0031 GMT, ahead of the August contract's expiry later on Monday. The more active September contract was at US$65.97, down 83 cents. US West Texas Intermediate crude dropped 94 cents, or 1.43 per cent, to US$64.58 a barrel. Last week, both benchmarks posted their biggest weekly decline since March 2023, but they are set to finish higher in June with a second consecutive monthly gain of more than 5 per cent. A 12-day war that started with Israel targeting Iran's nuclear facilities on June 13 caused Brent prices to surge above US$80 a barrel after the US bombed Iran's nuclear facilities and then slump to US$67 after President Donald Trump announced an Iran-Israel ceasefire. The market has stripped out most of the geopolitical risk premium built into the price following the Iran-Israel ceasefire, IG markets analyst Tony Sycamore said in a note. Further weighing on the market, four delegates from Opec+, which includes allies of the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries, said the group was set to boost production by 411,000 barrels per day in August, following similar-size output increases for May, June and July. Opec+ is set to meet on July 6 and this would be the fifth monthly increase since the group started unwinding production cuts in April. In the US, the number of operating oil rigs, an indicator of future output, fell by six to 432 last week, the lowest level since October 2021, Baker Hughes said. REUTERS
