logo
'That is business suicide': IIT Kanpur graduate shares lessons from his failed investment that once looked promising

'That is business suicide': IIT Kanpur graduate shares lessons from his failed investment that once looked promising

Time of India21 hours ago
What happens when a well-funded startup, backed by top VCs and built around a high-impact mission, still fails to survive?
Harsh Pokharna
, an IITian and CEO, recently took to Instagram to share the harsh lessons he learned after a
health-tech startup
he invested in shut down. His brutally honest post has since gone viral, not just for its candour, but for the clarity it offers to anyone trying to crack India's notoriously complex healthcare market.
He revealed that he invested in the health-tech start-up in 2020. The startup aimed to be an aggregator for cancer hospitals, giving patients a platform where they could browse treatment options, consult doctors online, and choose where to receive care. With over $7 million raised from investors and a strong organic reach of 25,000+ monthly visitors and over 1,000 unique cancer patient leads, the start-up had all the signs of a high-potential venture. But even with these numbers, it couldn't survive. 'We really thought hospitals would see the value in owning or partnering with a brand like this,' Pokharna wrote. 'But it didn't work out that way.'
Critical lessons he learned
According to Pokharna, the failure wasn't due to a lack of vision or execution—it was rooted in the structural reality of Indian healthcare. In his post, he listed three critical lessons that founders (and investors) should take seriously:
- Hospitals hold all the power
According to Harsh, aggregator platforms may look good on paper, but in reality, they're completely at the mercy of hospitals. Payments get delayed, contracts are disregarded, and any profit margin gets wiped out by compliance and collection costs. Hospitals simply don't need middlemen.
Digital-only doesn't work (yet)
The Indian market isn't ready to pay for purely online healthcare services, claims Harsh. Digital tools are useful for generating leads, but they can't sustain a business.
Offline is necessary—and expensive
Indian patients still prefer in-person consultations and physical centres. But building offline infrastructure is a heavy lift. According to Pokharna, each centre takes 12–24 months to break even and requires massive upfront investment. If a startup can't afford to scale offline, it stalls.
His biggest takeaway?
For Pokharna, the biggest takeaway is simple but sobering: startups trying to be aggregators in healthcare are walking a dangerous line. Without strong differentiators or leverage, they risk becoming powerless middlemen—with no margins, no sustainability, and no way out. He cautioned that building an aggregator-only business in Indian healthcare is a risky move. Without solid solutions to the structural challenges of the sector, founders risk setting themselves up for failure from the very start.
In Pokharna's own words, it may look like a promising pitch deck, but if you're not careful, it could be business suicide.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Jane Street slams Sebi allegations, plans to contest ban and impounding order
Jane Street slams Sebi allegations, plans to contest ban and impounding order

Indian Express

time40 minutes ago

  • Indian Express

Jane Street slams Sebi allegations, plans to contest ban and impounding order

New York-based global proprietary trading firm Jane Street has strongly criticised India's market regulator Sebi over its recent enforcement action, calling the accusations 'extremely inflammatory' and stating it is 'beyond disappointed' by the order. The firm, which is among the largest players on Wall Street, said in a mail to its employees that it is preparing a formal response to the Securities and Exchange Board of India's (Sebi) decision, which includes a ban on the firm's market participation and an order to impound Rs 4,843 crore in what the regulator described as 'unlawful gains'. Jane Street rejected the market watchdog's charge that it was involved in 'an intentional, well planned, and sinister scheme' to manipulate Indian markets through its derivatives trades, especially in Nifty Index futures. The firm asserted it would contest the order through appropriate legal channels. In a memo sent to its roughly 3,000 employees on Sunday and reported by the Financial Times newspaper, Jane Street said, 'it's deeply upsetting to see the firm mischaracterised this way.' 'We take pride in the role we serve in markets around the world, and it's painful to have our firm's reputation tarnished by a report based on so many erroneous or unsupported assertions,' the memo said. Jane Street is yet to respond to a mail about the Sebi allegations sent by The Indian Express. Last week, the market regulator granted Jane Street 21 days to file an objection to its order and request a hearing. Jane Street, one of the most prominent and successful proprietary trading firms to emerge in the past two decades, has grown into a major force across global financial markets. In its internal memo, Jane Street criticised Sebi for relying on 'a metric for market impact and trading aggressiveness which seems disconnected from actual market dynamics.' The firm argued that its trading activity on January 17, 2024 — one of the days singled out in Sebi's report — reflected routine 'basic arbitrage trading,' a widely accepted strategy in the industry. Jane Street has sharply contested Sebi's claim that it disregarded concerns raised by the National Stock Exchange (NSE), an allegation the regulator used to justify its sudden and unprecedented ban on the firm's trading operations in India. In the internal memo, Jane Street described the charge as 'especially far from reality,' stating that it had promptly halted its trading activity at the time to better understand the exchange's concerns. The firm added that it subsequently adjusted its strategies to align with the NSE's stated preferences. 'Once again, we left this process feeling that we had reached an understanding of the concerns and reflected them in modifications to our trading behaviour,' the memo said. 'Since February, we have made ongoing efforts to communicate with Sebi and have been consistently rebuffed.' According to the FT report, the US firm nearly doubled its net trading revenues to $20.5 billion last year, outpacing several of Wall Street's biggest banks. In the first quarter of 2025, Jane Street notched up net trading revenues of $7.2 billion, more than Morgan Stanley. 'Sebi's investigation was triggered by revelations from a lawsuit launched by Jane Street last year against Millennium Management and two former traders that had moved to the hedge fund. Jane Street's complaint alleged that the traders had stolen a hugely valuable trading strategy, which was later revealed to revolve around Indian options trading,' FT report said. According to the regulator's findings, Jane Street's trades, particularly in Nifty index futures, showed a clear pattern. The firm wasn't trading passively or reacting to the market — it was nudging prices upward, consistently placing orders at or above the last traded price (LTP). This pattern intensified in the final hours of trading, a critical window that often shapes the day's closing price. Sebi described it as a 'non-neutral trading behaviour', a strategic attempt to influence prices rather than simply engage with the market. And the tactic wasn't random; it followed a well-known play in the trading world: 'marking the close.' Jane Street, regulators say, was executing what's known as an extended 'marking the close' strategy — placing large and aggressive buy or sell orders near the end of the trading session, with the intention of artificially moving the closing price of a stock or index. The closing price is critical, especially on derivatives expiry days, as it determines the settlement value for futures and options contracts.

Tally's game plan: Deepening roots in Bharat, bold moves in the Gulf
Tally's game plan: Deepening roots in Bharat, bold moves in the Gulf

Time of India

time42 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Tally's game plan: Deepening roots in Bharat, bold moves in the Gulf

As Indian MSMEs accelerate their digitisation efforts after the Covid-19 pandemic, the home-grown accounting software solutions company, Tally, is doubling down on its commitment to ensuring technology adapts to businesses, rather than the reverse. With the launch of TallyPrime 6.0 , the accounting software giant is embedding live banking, UPI payments, and automation features to eliminate friction from finance workflows. In an interview with ET Online, Tejas Goenka, Managing Director of Tally Solutions Pvt. Ltd , talks about the company's latest offerings, its approach to addressing India's last-mile technological gaps, the influence of markets like Saudi Arabia and Africa on its growth trajectory, and more. Edited excerpts: ET: What specific challenges do MSMEs face with traditional accounting and banking workflows that led to the development of Connected Banking in TallyPrime 6.0? Tejas Goenka (TG): MSMEs often struggled with fragmented workflows across accounting, banking, and payments, resulting in delays, errors, and poor visibility into their financial health. Traditional systems expected businesses to conform to the software's structure rather than adapting to the way MSMEs actually operate. With TallyPrime 6.0, we wanted to flip that equation—offering flexibility, reducing friction, and enabling business owners to work the way they prefer. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Bank Owned Properties For Sale In An Khanh (Prices May Surprise You) Foreclosed Homes | Search ads Search Now Undo By integrating banking directly into Tally, we are empowering MSMEs to view balances, make payments, and reconcile accounts without switching systems; whether it's collecting payments via UPI or managing cash flow intuitively, the platform is designed to fit their rhythm, not disrupt it. ET: How do real-time banking insights and features, like smart reconciliations, help SMEs prepare for audits and optimise their working capital? TG: Audit preparation and cash flow management can become taxing for small businesses, not due to lack of discipline, but because legacy tools don't support real-time insights. Smart reconciliation automates what used to be a tedious task, saving up to 30-50% of the time spent. Tally supports over 145 bank formats, ensuring seamless reconciliation across banking partners. Live Events ET: With features like UPI links and QR codes now embedded in the invoicing process, how is Tally transforming collections for MSMEs? TG: Getting paid on time is critical for small businesses. By embedding UPI payment links and QR codes into invoices, we're drastically reducing the payment cycle. The process becomes smoother, faster, and more secure. Businesses no longer need to rely on follow-ups or paper-based processes. With just a few clicks, customers can pay, making it easier for MSMEs to manage cash flow and focus on growth. ET: Security remains a concern with any digital financial tool. What measures has Tally taken to ensure a safe and flexible banking experience? TG: We understand that for businesses to truly embrace digital workflows, trust must be built in. TallyPrime 6.0 includes end-to-end encryption, real-time fraud detection, and granular access controls. Business owners have full control over who can see and do what. Security doesn't come at the cost of usability; we ensure protection runs silently in the background without interrupting daily operations. ET: MSMEs are not always known for rapid digital adoption. How are you convincing business owners, especially the traditional ones, to embrace Tally's new features? TG: Surprisingly, MSMEs in India are more open to digital tools than they're given credit for. What holds them back isn't resistance; it's misalignment. If you present technology that respects their workflows and delivers tangible benefits, they're quick to adopt it, and that's our mission. ET: You're investing in a big expansion across smaller towns. What's driving that push, and what support do you need? TG: While we have a large partner network, there are still 200-300 towns where we lack presence. For the next 3-4 years, the goal is to deepen our reach in these markets. Wherever we have strong partners, adoption is high; where we don't, we see clear gaps. One structural challenge we face is the classification of software as a service rather than a product. That triggers compliance hurdles like TDS deductions and complicated reconciliations, even for start-ups. If the government recognised software products as a distinct category, it would ease go-to-market efforts for companies like ours and reduce the cost of compliance. Additionally, restoring R&D tax credits would fuel innovation—our core technology (Tally Definition Language or TDL) requires significant investment. ET: You have spoken about India-first innovation with global relevance. Tell us more about your overseas strategy. TG: We believe Indian tech can be globally competitive if it's designed with flexibility and adaptability in mind. We're seeing tremendous interest in regions like the Middle East and Africa, driven by the same value proposition—robust, easy-to-use accounting that respects how businesses operate locally. We have launched a native Arabic version of Tally and are now investing heavily in Saudi Arabia. We've also opened an office in Africa and continue experimenting in the UAE, which already contributes significantly to our overseas revenues. The ASEAN and MENA regions are high on our radar. Our expansion is not just about localisation—it's about exporting a proven product-market fit. In India, we serve around 3 million paid users. That depth of experience is shaping how we go global—starting from India, built for the world.

UAE Golden Visa at Rs 23 lakh: Know eligibility, fees, requirements and more
UAE Golden Visa at Rs 23 lakh: Know eligibility, fees, requirements and more

Time of India

time44 minutes ago

  • Time of India

UAE Golden Visa at Rs 23 lakh: Know eligibility, fees, requirements and more

UAE Golden Visa requirements: The UAE Golden Visa has always been a symbol of long-term security for foreigners looking to live, work, or study in the Emirates. Many Indian celebrities, including legendary actors like Rajinikanth, Chiranjeevi, Shah Rukh Khan, Sanjay Dutt, Allu Arjun and others, have this visa. Earlier, it was not easy to get for everyone. But now, the United Arab Emirates has introduced a new nomination-based Golden Visa scheme that makes it more accessible, especially for Indian and Bangladeshi citizens. Instead of investing crores in property or business, eligible individuals can now get the visa by paying a one-time fee of AED 1,00,000 (approx. Rs 23.3 lakh). But while this sounds simple, there are still strict rules and eligibility criteria. Let's break down the UAE Golden Visa fees, eligibility, requirements, and how to apply. What is the UAE Golden Visa? The UAE Golden Visa is a long-term residence permit that allows foreign nationals to live, work, study, and build a life in the UAE. It is offered for 5 or 10 years, and in most cases, it is automatically renewable. Key benefits include: No local sponsor required Multiple entry visa Ability to stay outside the UAE for extended periods Full family sponsorship (spouse, children, parents) Can sponsor domestic staff Eligible to apply for Emirates ID and open a business What's New in 2024? The Nomination-Based UAE Golden Visa Previously, applicants had to invest at least AED 2 million (around Rs 4.66 crore) in property or business. But with the nomination-based system, things are changing. Now, Indians and Bangladeshis can be nominated for a Golden Visa by approved UAE agencies and get the visa by paying AED 1,00,000 (around Rs 23 lakh), according to TOI report. However, here's the catch: You can't just pay the fee and get the visa. You still need to meet specific eligibility and vetting requirements. UAE Golden Visa Eligibility Criteria Eligibility for the UAE Golden Visa depends on your background—whether you're an investor, entrepreneur, student, talented professional, or humanitarian worker. Here's a detailed look: 1. Investors Must invest AED 2 million (Rs 4.66 crore approx.) in a UAE-accredited investment fund or property. Must prove the money is not borrowed. Medical insurance is mandatory. Should pay AED 250,000 per year in UAE taxes. 2. Entrepreneurs Must own a business worth at least AED 500,000 (Rs 1.17 crore approx.) in tech or innovation. Approvals are needed from UAE-approved incubators and auditors. 3. Specialised Talents Includes doctors, scientists, artists, executives, and athletes. Need endorsement from a UAE government body. Executives must earn at least AED 50,000/month (Rs 11.69 lakh approx.) and have 5+ years of experience. 4. Outstanding Students High school students with 95%+ marks or university students from top institutions with high GPAs. Eligible for 5–10 year visas. 5. Humanitarian Workers and Frontline Heroes Must show long-term service and achievements. Recognised contributions to society are required. What is the Rs 23 Lakh Option? The new nomination-based Golden Visa for Indians and Bangladeshis is being offered through approved agencies like: Rayad Group VFS Global One Vasco This visa type: Waives the need for property or business investment Still requires vetting based on profession, contribution to society, and economic potential Involves criminal background checks, AML (Anti-Money Laundering) verification, and social media screening Final approval rests with UAE government authorities. Rayad Kamal Ayub, Managing Director of Rayad Group, called it 'a golden opportunity for Indians' but stressed that it's not a guarantee just because someone can afford the fee. How to Apply for the UAE Golden Visa? Whether through the traditional or nomination route, the application process follows these basic steps: Step 1: Choose the Right Category Decide if you're applying as an: Investor Entrepreneur Student Skilled professional Humanitarian worker Step 2: Prepare the Documents Depending on your category, you will need: Academic certificates Salary slips or business ownership documents Medical insurance Bank statements and investment proof Passport copy and photos Government endorsements (for talents) Step 3: Submit the Application For traditional routes, visit the ICP Website ( or use the ICP App. For nomination-based visas, contact agencies like Rayad Group, VFS, or One Vasco. You can also opt for the 'One Touch' Golden Visa service, a convenient option that combines application, biometrics, visa issuance, and Emirates ID registration in one step. Step 4: Background Checks Authorities will verify: Criminal history Financial compliance Online activity and social media Step 5: Get Approval Once approved, you'll receive your UAE Golden Visa, which allows you to live, work, and sponsor family or domestic help in the Emirates. Need Help? Contact UAE Officials If you're unsure about your eligibility or the documents needed: ICP (Federal Authority for Identity and Citizenship) handles general inquiries GDRFAD (General Directorate of Residency and Foreigners Affairs - Dubai) for Dubai-specific applications The UAE Golden Visa is More Than Just a Fee Although the Rs 23 lakh UAE Golden Visa sounds like a fast-track option, it's still merit-based. Whether you're applying through investment, skills, or the new nomination route, meeting the eligibility requirements is essential. This new policy is expected to boost applications, with over 5,000 Indians projected to apply in the first three months alone. If you believe you meet the criteria, this could be your golden ticket to building a life in one of the world's most dynamic countries. To stay updated on the stories that are going viral, follow Indiatimes Trending.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store