Kerala opposes maintainability of presidential reference on SC timeline verdict
In May, President Droupadi Murmu exercised a rare constitutional provision and sought the Supreme Court's advisory opinion on 14 questions to settle the law on whether the president and governors need to follow timelines on state bills referred for consent when the Constitution does not prescribe it.
The April 8 order struck down Tamil Nadu governor RN Ravi's move to reserve 10 re-enacted bills for presidential assent after withholding their approval. The court said if a governor withholds assent or reserves a bill for the president's consideration, this must be done within three months of its presentation. It added that a governor must grant assent 'forthwith' or within a month if a state legislature re-enacts an identical bill.
The court said the president must decide within three months of receiving a bill from a governor, as it laid down such a timeline for the first time. It asked that the president's office convey reasons to the concerned state if there is any delay beyond this period.
The court used its extraordinary powers under the Constitution's Article 142. It called the withholding of consent on the bills 'illegal'. The court said that the bills would be 'deemed' to have been assented to.
The Kerala government moved an application in the reference proceeding ahead of the hearing of the case on Tuesday. It cited the absence of a review petition challenging the April 8 decision. It argued that in such a scenario, the reference cannot 'obliquely' challenge a ruling of the court, which amounts to 'serious misuse' of Article 143 under which the reference has been sought.
The state government said that the reference makes no mention of the April 8 judgment. 'The reference loses its legitimacy and seeks to mislead the court into setting aside its own judgment, the existence of which, as mentioned, has been suppressed. The reference therefore deserves to be returned unanswered.'
The application, filed through advocate CK Sasi said, the reference is being used as a device to obtain decisions on vital issues, without disclosing and by suppressing the final findings already rendered on these issues, and to get to deliver inconsistent judgments on the issue of time frame under Article 200, which is not res integra.
The state submitted that the foundation of the reference is that Article 200 does not stipulate any time frame for the governor to exercise powers and functions thereunder. 'This is amazing, and it is difficult to believe that the Council of Ministers, in advising the President, have not even cared to read the proviso to Article 200, which states that the Governor shall act 'as soon as possible after the presentation to him of the Bill for assent'.'
The application said the Supreme Court's three judgments settle the timeline under Article 200. It added that they affirmed that action on bills sent for consideration should be done 'as soon as possible'. 'If the reference itself is based on an erroneous statement, the entirety of the reference, which mainly relates to the time factor, should stand rejected,' the state said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
39 minutes ago
- Time of India
VHP demands comprehensive anti-conversion law, UCC
Kochi: Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) state unit demanded that central and state govts come up with a comprehensive anti-conversion law and a uniform civil code that would be applicable to all states and union territories in the country. "A Christian priest's call for the repeal of anti-conversion laws in eleven states of the country is part of a pressure tactic and a move to facilitate conversion efforts," said Anil Vilayil, VHP state general secretary. He said similar laws existed during British rule. This law was introduced in many states during Congress's rule, he said. "Large-scale religious conversions are taking place in strategic places and tribal areas of India by misusing the freedom enshrined in the Constitution. Riots that have been taking place in northeastern states after Hindus became a minority are evidence of this," said Vilayil. "The ongoing protests and discussions are a clear example of the fact that Kerala is the epicentre of religious conversion efforts in the country. Strong religious conversion efforts are taking place in about 70 taluks of Kerala. Efforts are being made successfully by distorting ancient images and pouring money into them," he said in a statement.
Indian Express
40 minutes ago
- Indian Express
10 judicial officers appointed as Additional Judges of Punjab and Haryana High Court
In a major boost to the judicial strength of the Punjab and Haryana High Court, the Central government Thursday appointed 10 judicial officers as Additional Judges of the court. The appointments were made by the President of India under Article 224 of the Constitution, following consultation with the Chief Justice of India. The newly appointed Additional Judges are: Virinder Aggarwal, Mandeep Pannu, Amarinder Singh Grewal, Parmod Goyal, Rupinderjit Chahal, Shalini Singh Nagpal, Subhash Mehla, Surya Partap Singh, Aradhna Sawhney, and Yashvir Singh Rathor. The appointments were announced by Union Law Minister Arjun Ram Meghwal, who shared the list on social media. Under Article 224, Additional Judges are appointed for a term of two years to help manage rising caseloads and vacancies. Based on performance and requirement, they are made permanent judges later.
Mint
40 minutes ago
- Mint
Ukrainian soldier escapes from Russian soil on e-bike delivered by drone
A video has surfaced on social media showing an injured Ukrainian soldier escaping on an electric bike from Russian soil. The soldier, identified by the call sign 'Tanker", had been holding the line for 5 days at position 360 near the front line in Siversk, in Ukraine's eastern Donetsk region. As the soldier was unable to evacuate on his own due to injuries, he was delivered a 40-kilogramme electric bike by a drone directly to his position. In the video released by Ukraine's Rubizh Brigade, a heavy-lift drone can be seen lowering the electric bike directly to Tanker's position. According to media reports, rescue attempts by the Ukrainian forces were too risky, as Russian troops were positioned on all fronts. 'Our drones covered us from above as best as they could," Tanker said. 'Then they threw two gas cylinders straight into our hole and a lighter. We caught fire." The escape took place as Russian forces launched deadly missile attacks on Kyiv, killing at least 16 people. Mykola Hrytsenko, the Ukrainian brigade's Chief of Staff, said the ground rescue was impossible due to the terrain and active fighting in the area. So, his team devised an alternative: airlifting the 40kg bike to help the soldier escape. The first two delivery attempts were unsuccessful as one drone was shot down, while another overheated due to the weight. On the third attempt, the drone successfully delivered the bike to Tanker, Hrytsenko added. 'The enemy was in front, behind, and on both flanks. Completely surrounded," Hrytsenko said. Russia's military advance in Ukraine accelerated for a fourth straight month in July, its greatest since November, reported news agency AFP. In one month, the Russian army took 713 square kilometres of Ukrainian territory, while Kyiv reclaimed 79 square kilometres. This has resulted in a net gain of 634 square kilometres for Russia compared with 588 square kilometres in June, 507 square kilometres in May, 379 square kilometres in April, and 240 square kilometres in March.
