Western Australia's Shire of Coolgardie faces uncertain future following audit report, ‘significant doubt' on viability
The Shire of Coolgardie is under fire for 'shocking mismanagement and poor governance' amid revelations that employees were improperly dismissed and one contractor worked remotely from a Caribbean island.
The report, from WA's Auditor General, found the shire was in a precarious financial position after incurring a net loss of more than $4.6m in the year ending 30 June 2024.
Liabilities exceeded the council's assets by more than $14.2m.
'These conditions indicate a material uncertainty that may cast significant doubt about the ability of the Shire to continue as a going concern,' the report states.
During the review, auditors found that a Senior Project Officer employed by the council from October 23, 2023 to October 2, 2024 had been working remotely from the Caribbean island of Montserrat.
A Senior Project Officer employed by the council had been reportedly working remotely from the Caribbean island of Montserrat, the audit found. Picture: Visit Montserrat
'The Project Officer appeared to be located in Montserrat, a British Overseas Territory in the Caribbean,' the report read.
'The offer of employment stated that the duties were to be performed at home, in the office in Kalgoorlie, or Kambalda.
'We inquired but did not receive a response from Shire management on how the staff member performed their duties efficiently while being in a different jurisdiction with a 12-hour time difference from Perth.'
The staff member was also found not to be in compliance with their working holiday visa, which stipulated they could not work more than six months overseas.
The staff member was recruited directly by the Shire's former chief executive.
The regional council faces allegations of 'potential cultural issues'. Picture: Coolgardie Visitors Centre
The review also found that the council had 'potential cultural issues' that stopped employees from raising concerns without facing the threat of termination from senior management.
Two former employees filed claims against the council for 'termination without cause' - one alleging that a senior executive appeared to be manipulating the tendering process for Shire projects in favour of certain tenderers.
WA's Local Government Minister Hannah Beazley spoke to the state parliament last week about the potential of merging the Coolgardie Shire with the neighbouring City of Kalgoorlie–Boulder.
She said she had arranged a meeting with representatives from both councils and the local member to address 'serious concerns about the financial viability of the shire'.
'Although I am assured that no malice has been intended by elected members, nevertheless, shocking mismanagement and poor governance has occurred at the shire.
Malcolm Cullen, President of the Shire of Coolgardie, said it was too early to discuss a potential merger due to how close the council elections were. Picture: Supplied
'I would urge the shire to do what is right for its community and region and be cooperative in speaking with its neighbouring council at Kalgoorlie–Boulder and jointly support a boundary adjustment.'
Local member Ali Kent also spoke in parliament, and noted previous scrutiny faced by the council over financial mismanagement.
'So many of my constituents have met with me as they are upset and concerned about the future of the shire when it is faced with this ongoing uncertainty,' Ms Kent said.
The Coolgardie Shire's President Malcolm Cullen told the ABC that the announcement of a potential merger had come to close to council elections.
'The three-week time-frame for these discussions provided by the minister does not allow time for genuine and open negotiations,' Mr Cullen said in a statement reported by the ABC.
'Such a decision deserves careful consideration and should not be made at a time of transition.'
Brendan Kearns
Cadet Journalist
Brendan Kearns is a cadet journalist with News Corp Australia. He has written for The Australian, the Herald Sun, the Geelong Advertiser, CHOICE, Cosmos, and The Citizen. He won Democracy's Watchdogs' Student Award for Investigative Journalism 2024 and hosted the third season of award-winning podcast Uncurated. He studied as Master of Journalism at The University of Melbourne, before that he worked as a video producer and disability worker.
@brendandkearns
Brendan Kearns
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
2 hours ago
- ABC News
Fears for WA's energy grid as Griffin Coal slides almost $1 billion further into debt
A key foreign-owned WA coal mine has fallen almost a billion dollars further into debt, even as the government prepares to pour more money into the insolvent company. Griffin Coal has been propped up by WA taxpayers since 2022 when the company was placed into receivership, amid fears its collapse could place the Perth and South-West electricity system at risk of blackouts and jeopardise hundreds of local jobs. The company's biggest customer is Bluewaters Power — a coal-fired generator with capacity to supply about seven per cent of the grid's needs. After initially providing $40 million in support, the following year Premier Roger Cook announced a $220 million lifeline would be extended to Griffin Coal, describing it as payments "we just need to make". This year's state budget contains provision for up to another $49 million for the company, taking the total bill to $308 million. "We just want the parties to sort themselves out so that they can get on and mine coal at a commercial rate, and that people can produce power at a commercial rate," Premier Roger Cook told budget estimates on Thursday. "Quite frankly, the fact that the parties haven't been able to come to an agreement is a disgrace." Shadow energy minister Steve Thomas didn't take to that argument kindly. "How dare the premier attack the two companies that have been left to pick up the pieces of years of government mismanagement," he said. "The government's so-called solution to the problem is a joke because the price that Griffin Coal needs to become viable is the same price that bankrupts Bluewaters Power. "If there was a commercial solution available, the government has had a decade to deliver it and save that $300 million." Bluewaters' future is so uncertain as a result of those tensions that when the independent Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO) published its 10-year outlook last week, it assumed Bluewaters would be unavailable from mid-2027. It said that was due to the risk of Griffin being unable to supply coal once its government support ends. AEMO said while energy capacity would be "largely balanced" until mid-2027, "there is a need for further investment" beyond that point, in part because of the issues at Bluewaters. The depth of Griffin's difficulty was further highlighted in answer to questions asked by Dr Thomas, which show the company's debts have now reached $2.4 billion — some $800 million higher than a liquidator reported in 2022. Most of that debt — some $1.9 billion — is owed to ICICI Bank, India's biggest private bank. Other secured creditors are the Export Import Bank of India ($146 million), the Bank of Baroda ($144 million) and India Overseas Bank ($115 million). "That [money] should have refinanced and put new administration into Griffin Coal so that it could continue to supply Bluewaters, at least for the next 5-10 years. "That would have been a better investment because it would have left the state with a viable asset at the end, rather than simply throwing a quarter of a billion dollars down a black hole that ultimately still results in the failure of the companies and the power system." A spokesperson for Griffin said: 'The receivers and managers are actively engaging with customers, government, unions and other stakeholders on a commercial solution for Griffin Coal beyond 30 June 2026.' Independent corporate analyst Peter Strachan agreed that, in hindsight, it could have been better for the state government to have purchased Griffin when it was sold to its current owners. "From the state's point of view it was a fraught deal because these are critical assets, critical to the state of Western Australia," he said. With that option well and truly in the past though, Mr Strachan said pouring in money to keep it running was one of few options. "The state's got no option but to do that, or they could close it down and just import coal," he said — something the government did in late 2022. With coal on its way out of the energy grid as the rise of renewables continues, Mr Strachan said time was of the essence. Dr Thomas's questions also revealed $13.5 million of the government's money had been paid directly to those secured creditors under a 'business continuation agreement'. "The government's focus is on ensuring the continued operation of the mine to 30 June 2026," Mr Cook said in answer to those questions. "The government entered into a business continuation agreement with the secured creditors and the receivers and managers to ensure the continued support of the secured creditors for this period. "The [agreement] provides performance-based payments to the secured creditors, linked to the continued operation of the mine." Mr Cook said those payments to secured creditors could reach $31.5 million by mid-2026. He told estimates the current support regime would not continue beyond mid-2026. "If the parties related reach a commercial decision in relation to the way that the Griffin mine and the Bluewaters power station function, well then we'll consider any proposals from that point," Mr Cook said. "But we've made it quite clear that we will not be funding the arrangements beyond the June 30, 2026."
ABC News
16 hours ago
- ABC News
EV buses join Perth's wider suburban network, 'milestone' for diesel phase-out
The first fleet of electric buses has entered Perth's wider suburban network, with the WA Transport Minister Rita Saffioti labelling it an important milestone in the government's push to phase out diesel. Eleven of the electric vehicles are ready to operate out of Transperth's Malaga depot, which is undergoing a $12 million upgrade to allow for the new infrastructure. Sixteen chargers have already been installed at the depot and a further 90 are expected to be added by the end of September. According to the government, the upgrade will see the depot become the state's largest EV bus charging complex, and has already included the installation of solar panels and batteries to power the facility. "A few weeks ago we announced the last diesel bus to come out of the Malaga depot in relation to its manufacture, so the last diesel bus produced in WA has already occurred." The minister said it was hoped the final diesel bus would exit the network by 2043. The electric buses use imported parts from Sweden, before being locally assembled at another facility in Malaga. Ninety of them set to be deployed across Perth over the next eight months. Each electric bus can travel up to 300 kilometres on a single charge, which the government said saved about 40 tonnes of carbon dioxide emissions a year. High frequency bus routes, like the 960 and 950, will be among the first to be serviced by the fleet at the Malaga depot, alongside routes passing through the Morley Galleria shopping centre and Ballajura and Morley train stations. An initial rollout of the vehicles began in Perth's CBD last September, with 18 added to the CAT Bus routes, which also saw Elizabeth Quay Bus Depot fitted out with new charging infrastructure. Ms Saffioti said EV upgrades to other depots were already underway, or planned for, at the Karrinyup and Claisebrook bus depots, with a new EV bus depot set for Bayswater. "Not only are electric buses cleaner and better for the environment, they're also cheaper to operate in the long term, which means better value for money for WA taxpayers," Ms Saffioti said. "It's 22,000 litres of diesel per bus per year, so massive savings." The Liberals said they would be watching the rollout of the new buses closely. "We are obviously looking to see how that rollout goes, noting there have been some concerning issues with the C-series trains that have been manufactured on this government's watch," shadow cabinet minister Liam Staltari said. Mr Staltari was referring to a recent union survey of train drivers that highlighted concerns over the comfort and braking ability of the C-series trains. In response, the Public Transport Authority said there were no braking issues on the trains, stating the C-Series had excellent acceleration and braking features. In parliament, Ms Saffioti defended the C-series and said there was always going to be an adjustment period for the drivers.
ABC News
19 hours ago
- ABC News
Lithium mine closure shines light on Ravensthorpe community's resilience
For the first time in almost a decade, Ravensthorpe is without a working mine. The start of the new financial year saw the lithium mine at Mt Cattlin, just north of the town and about 500 kilometres south-east of Perth, placed into care and maintenance. It was the another casualty of market volatility that claimed a number of mines across Western Australia, and triggered the loss of hundreds of jobs. It is the second hit Ravensthorpe has taken, with 300 local jobs lost when the town's nickel mine was shuttered last year. But disruption isn't unusual for the community. It's the second time in 15 years the lithium mine has been mothballed. Beyond the mine closure, there have been floods, fires, a plane crash and a sex scandal that engulfed the local council. Lifelong Ravensthorpe local and shire president Tom Major said the run of adversity highlighted the strength of people in the town. "Look, we are a resilient community and it's just another page in the chapter of where we live," he said. "We'll soldier on. The agricultural industry is going really well, we're having a reasonable season, and the tourists just keep coming, so that industry is doing well. This most recent mine closure hasn't come as a surprise, with former owners Arcadium Lithium flagging the project for care and maintenance in September last year. Mr Major said unlike previous project closures, which happened almost overnight, the extended process had allowed the council to assess its priorities. The long lead time has given about 110 workers time to look for other jobs, with many staying in the community thanks to an improvement in services like NBN. "There have been people leave the community and school numbers are down a little bit, so I wouldn't say we've come through unaffected," Mr Major said. "We've got some of the some of the best fibre-to-the-premise internet you can get. "So we are seeing people move here that can work remotely or have online businesses, that sort of thing." Cheap and available housing, strong agriculture and a burgeoning tourism sector are also keeping the local economy ticking along. The influx of new people and a move towards showing off the region's unique features is spurring on Sue Leighton, chair of the newly formed Ravensthorpe tourism advisory group. "The community is sort of used to mining coming and going … and we have been eased into this," Ms Leighton said. She said the tourism sector would be pivotal in ensuring the region's survival. The Hopetoun local said now there was no active mining in the region, there was a chance to re-focus, and that the community remained open to new possibilities. "There's always activity for mining, for exploration and research," Ms Leighton said. "The townspeople are very resilient and look if new new mine starts up, we'll welcome all those people to come into town. "Then if they go again, we'll be sad that they're gone, but we've made good friends." Community consultation over the shutdown began almost 12 months ago, before any announcement that the project would be placed on care and maintenance. Shortly after Arcadium Lithium announced the closure, the company was snapped up by mining giant Rio Tinto. While Rio Tinto's reputation in WA has suffered in recent years, its approach in Ravensthorpe has been hailed within the community and the company as best practice. "I haven't seen a relationship between a mine and a community as strong as the one that I've seen here between the Mt Cattlin mine and the town of Ravensthorpe," said Rio Tinto's general manager of technical services Leigh Slomp. While Mt Cattlin's operating future remains uncertain, Mr Slomp said they were proud of how they had worked with the community. "That strong community consultation group … that's the sort of thing we want to be doing while we're in operation, not just when we get to a point where we might have to make a difficult decision," he said. "We've always been very open with the community … we need to be as transparent as we can be and that transparency then is reciprocated because the community understands the situation." Mr Slomp said Rio Tinto would remain active in the community while the project was on care and maintenance, and other miners could benefit from a similarly transparent approach. "Not only just to gain that social licence to operate, it's because we're operating within the community," he said. "We we need to be working with the community, we're not separate to the community. "I think this exercise that we've gone through in this care and maintenance phase with the town of Ravensthorpe should be held up as a model for other companies."
