logo
Osprey came back from the brink once. Now chicks are dying in nests, and some blame overfishing

Osprey came back from the brink once. Now chicks are dying in nests, and some blame overfishing

GLOUCESTER POINT, Va. (AP) — Stepping onto an old wooden duck blind in the middle of the York River, Bryan Watts looks down at a circle of sticks and pine cones on the weathered, guano-spattered platform. It's a failed osprey nest, taken over by diving terns.
'The birds never laid here this year,' said Watts, near the mouth of Virginia's Chesapeake Bay. 'And that's a pattern we've been seeing these last couple of years.'
Watts has a more intimate relationship with ospreys than most people have with a bird — he has climbed to their nests to free them from plastic bags, fed them by hand and monitored their eggs with telescopic mirrors.
The fish-eating raptor known for gymnastic dives and whistle-like chirps is an American conservation success story. After pesticides and other hazards nearly eliminated the species from much of the country, the hawk-like bird rebounded after the banning of DDT in 1972 and now numbers in the thousands in the U.S.
But Watts has documented an alarming trend. The birds, which breed in many parts of the U.S., are failing to successfully fledge enough chicks around their key population center of the Chesapeake Bay. The longtime biologist blames the decline of menhaden, a small schooling fish critical to the osprey diet. Without menhaden to eat, chicks are starving and dying in nests, Watts said.
Osprey are an environmental indicator
Watts's claim has put him and environmental groups at odds with the fishing industry, trade unions and sometimes government regulators. Menhaden is valuable for fish oil, fish meal and agricultural food as well as bait.
U.S. fishermen have caught at least 1.1 billion pounds of menhaden every year since 1951. Members of the industry tout its sustainability and said the decline in osprey may have nothing to do with fishing.
But without help, the osprey population could tumble to levels not seen since the dark days of DDT, said Watts, director of the Center for Conservation Biology at The College of William & Mary in Williamsburg, Virginia.
'The osprey are yelling pretty loudly that, hey, there's not enough menhaden for us to reproduce successfully,' Watts said. 'And we should be listening to them to be more informed fully on the fisheries side, and we should take precaution on the fisheries management side. But that hasn't won the day at this point.'
Decline linked to menhaden in studies
Watts, who has studied osprey on the Chesapeake for decades, has backed his claims of population decline by publishing studies in scientific journals. He said it boils down to a simple statistic — to maintain population, osprey pairs need to average 1.15 chicks per year.
Osprey were reproducing at that level in the 1980s, but today in some areas around the main stem of the Chesapeake, it's less than half of that, Watts said. In particularly distressed areas, they aren't even reproducing at one-tenth that level, he said. And the decline in available menhaden matches the areas of nesting failure, Watts said.
Also called pogies or bunkers, the oily menhaden are especially important for young birds because they are more nutritious than other fish in the sea. Osprey 'reproductive performance is inextricably linked to the availability and abundance' of menhaden, Watts wrote in a 2023 study published in Frontiers in Marine Science.
Conservationists have been concerned for years, saying too many menhaden have been removed to maintain their crucial role in the ocean food chain. Historian H. Bruce Franklin went so far as to title his 2007 book on menhaden 'The Most Important Fish In The Sea.'
Fishing industry pushes back
Menhaden help sustain one of the world's largest fisheries, worth more than $200 million at the docks in 2023. Used as bait, the fish are critical for valuable commercial targets such as Maine lobster. They're also beloved by sportfishermen.
The modern industry is dominated by Omega Protein, a Reedville, Virginia, company that is a subsidiary of Canadian aquaculture giant Cooke. The company pushed back at the idea that fishing is the cause of osprey decline, although it did acknowledge that fewer menhaden are showing up in some parts of the bay.
Federal data show osprey breeding is in decline in many parts of the country, including where menhaden is not harvested at all, said Ben Landry, an Omega spokesperson. Climate change, pollution and development could be playing a role, said Landry and others with the company.
Blaming fishing 'just reeks of environmental special interest groups having an influence over the process,' Landry said.
New rules could be on the way
The menhaden fishery is managed by the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission, an interstate body that crafts rules and sets fishing quotas. Prompted by questions about ospreys, it created a work group to address precautionary management of the species in the Chesapeake Bay.
In April, this group proposed several potential management approaches, including seasonal closures, restrictions on quotas or days at sea, and limitations on kinds of fishing gear. The process of creating new rules could begin this summer, said James Boyle, fishery management plan coordinator with the commission.
The osprey population has indeed shown declines in some areas since 2012, but it's important to remember the bird's population is much larger than it was before DDT was banned, Boyle said.
'There are big increases in osprey population since the DDT era,' Boyle said, citing federal data showing a six-fold increase in osprey populations along the Atlantic Coast since the 1960s.
Environmentalists says bird's decline could worsen
To a number of environmental groups, any decline is too much. This irritates some labor leaders who worry about losing more jobs as the fishing industry declines.
Kenny Pinkard, retired vice president of UFCW Local 400's executive board and a longtime Virginia fishermen, said he feels the industry is being scapegoated.
'There are some people who just don't want to see us in business at all,' he said.
But Chris Moore, Virginia executive director for Chesapeake Bay Foundation, said the country risks losing an iconic bird if no action is taken. He said Watts's studies show that the osprey will fail without access to menhaden.
'Osprey have been a success story,' Moore said. 'We're in a situation where they're not replacing their numbers. We'll actually be in a situation where we're in a steep decline.'
___
Whittle reported from Portland, Maine.
___ This story was supported by funding from the Walton Family Foundation. The AP is solely responsible for all content.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Plane Passenger Who Refused to Do This Common Airport Favor Says They Got 'Stink Eye' — But Were They Wrong?
Plane Passenger Who Refused to Do This Common Airport Favor Says They Got 'Stink Eye' — But Were They Wrong?

Yahoo

time33 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Plane Passenger Who Refused to Do This Common Airport Favor Says They Got 'Stink Eye' — But Were They Wrong?

A Reddit user broke down the incident in a viral post and divided the comment section A plane passenger is asking if they were really in the wrong for refusing a favor to a fellow flyer They took to the popular "Am I the A------?" Reddit on July 18 to air their grievances about a fellow traveler who asked what they felt was a 'big favor:" to watch her bags in the boarding area while she used the bathroom. The original poster (OP) claims they were made into the 'bad guy' for saying no to the common request. 'Yesterday I was sitting next to a woman with a young son who needed to go to the bathroom (10 minutes before boarding started),' the OP writes. 'She turned to me and asked… could I watch her bags while she took her son to the bathroom?' The OP replied, 'I'm not really supposed to." The poster claims the mom gave a 'stink eye' before another woman nearby offered to watch the luggage. They explain their technically sound reasoning in the post: 'Not only is this a safety issue (probably not in this case, but in theory), but also I wouldn't have wanted to miss my boarding group." In U.S. airports, TSA announcements regularly warn passengers to keep their belongings with them at all times, not to leave luggage unattended and not to accept any items from strangers. The mother and son returned in time to make it on the plane, but not before boarding started. Part of the reason for their refusal, the OP claims, is that this wasn't the first time they had been asked for the same favor — and had a different outcome. They detailed another experience where they allege they were 'bawled out' by a gate agent when they offered to watch someone's bag. They claim the gate agent overheard and interrupted, saying it wasn't allowed. The situation divided Redditors, who sounded off in the comments. 'If the woman and son were your wife and child, you'd be the [a------],' someone quipped in the comments. 'Otherwise you're good.' Another said: 'I'm more surprised that she trusted a stranger enough to watch her bags.' Others discussed the possible safety concerns. 'You're never supposed to take responsibility for someone else's bags [because] you don't know what could be in them,' someone explained. 'May sound crazy considering it's a lady and a kid but you never know and that's what airports advise.' Never miss a story — sign up for to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. Though, not everyone was convinced. 'I guess it might be situational but do you really think a woman with a young child has packed contraband and gotten through security? And somehow you'll be blamed for it?' one commenter asked. 'It's not your bag.' They added: 'You can say 'I'll try to stop anyone from taking it,' but what the woman is really asking is 'Would you be okay if I leave my bag so I don't have to deal with that and a fussy toddler in the bathroom?' " Read the original article on People Solve the daily Crossword

She Gave Her Son a Magical Bedroom. Her Stepdaughter Accused Her of 'Playing Favorites'
She Gave Her Son a Magical Bedroom. Her Stepdaughter Accused Her of 'Playing Favorites'

Yahoo

time43 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

She Gave Her Son a Magical Bedroom. Her Stepdaughter Accused Her of 'Playing Favorites'

After pouring time and money into her biological son's nature-themed bedroom, a woman faces emotional fallout when her stepdaughter calls out the difference A woman seeks advice from the Reddit community following tension in her blended family over how she decorated her children's bedrooms. In her post, the 40-year-old mom opens up about feeling torn between honoring family boundaries and showing equal love to her stepdaughter and biological son. 'I had a very specific vision for my son's room that I'd planned well in advance,' she writes. Her 3-year-old son, her only biological child, now enjoys a whimsical, nature-themed room with ombre-painted walls, a sun-shaped ceiling light, and a tree-shaped bookshelf. The space is filled with thoughtful touches, like a grassy rug and a floor bed that looks like a tent, designed in a Montessori style. 'I paid for all of this myself,' she explains, emphasizing how important this project was to her. Her 13-year-old stepdaughter's room tells a different story. Though the woman says she was careful to involve her stepdaughter in the design process, she admits, 'I didn't have much say in that space.' From the start, she says, her husband, who shares his daughter with an ex, was clear about her role. 'He made it very clear that she already had parents and didn't need another one—what she needed was an advocate and mentor,' she recalls. She says she respected those boundaries from the beginning and believes they've built a good relationship. 'She's a great kid,' the woman adds, expressing her admiration for the teen. When it came time to decorate the stepdaughter's room, the woman says they asked what the teen wanted. 'She said she wanted a reading nook, so we created one with a small round mattress, a ton of cushions in her favorite colors, and a mosquito net canopy.' Her stepdaughter also chose her own wall colors, opting for solid block shades. 'We did the room together,' she says, adding, 'We split the cost 50/50.' However, the existing furniture in the teen's room, purchased by the father before the woman entered the picture, was left untouched. 'He doesn't see any point in replacing it since it's still in good condition,' she explains, noting that her involvement was limited by both practicality and family dynamics. Despite her intentions, the woman says her stepdaughter recently got upset after seeing her younger brother's fully finished room. 'She said I clearly put way more effort into his space than hers and accused me of playing favorites because he's 'actually mine.' ' Trying to explain, the woman tells her stepdaughter that she was simply trying to respect her space and not overstep. 'I didn't want to overstep when it came to her room and… she made most of the choices herself.' But her stepdaughter now feels hurt, and the woman admits, 'I do feel guilty because I can see how, from her perspective, it looks unfair.' She adds that her goal was never to create a divide or make anyone feel unloved. Yet she's now grappling with how to fix the situation without crossing any emotional or parental boundaries set years ago. 'I'm not her parent,' she reflects, 'and I didn't want to push decisions onto her room.' The guilt, however, is real, and she's left wondering if she should've done more. 'At the same time, I now wonder if I should have tried harder or been more involved.' Never miss a story — sign up for to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. Many Reddit users sympathized with both the woman and the teen. One commenter offered a possible explanation for the teen's reaction, writing, 'Also if she's generally polite and not demanding, she may not have asked for things that seemed too difficult or hard to execute (like the ombré).' They also suggested a solution that might ease the tension and restore balance. 'It seems like a simple resolution would be to ask the daughter what she'd like to change and for dad to cover the costs (since mum paid for all of the son's room).' Read the original article on People Solve the daily Crossword

This Tennessee bachelorette party had a bear-y unexpected guest. Watch the video
This Tennessee bachelorette party had a bear-y unexpected guest. Watch the video

Yahoo

time43 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

This Tennessee bachelorette party had a bear-y unexpected guest. Watch the video

This guest didn't RSVP to the party. A black bear wandered into an outdoor bachelorette party in Gatlinburg, Tennessee. The video was posted to TikTok by Brooke Willman on July 24. While the party took place on a nearby balcony, the women spotted a small black bear coming near their area. The bear approached the parked car before heading towards the open grill, where several steaks were set out. Though the bear was not on the guest list, it enjoyed a big steak anyway. After all, it was a bear-beque! The bear stayed in the area for about 20 minutes before ascending to the outdoor balcony where the celebration was taking place. Of course, the small bear had to stop to appreciate the paw-some decor before trying to take a seat at the bride's table. Ironically, the theme of the party? "She Found Her Honey." So, at least the Gatlinburg bear's presence was on theme. Viral bear videos can come at a cost Often, you'll see a viral video circulating online about a black bear entering a store, a house or somewhere else it ought not to be. In some cases, such sightings might lead to the bear's death. In 2024, the Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency was forced to euthanize 31 bears. That's 12 more bears than East Tennessee's four-year average of 19. Not all bears are euthanized because of their behavior. The TWRA's figure also includes putting down injured animals. The TWRA will put down any potential threats to people, bears that grab food directly from people or that enter houses. "Public safety is going to come ahead of bears," said TWRA's bear program leader Dan Gibbs. Even though it ensures safety for people, it's never easy for Gibbs or his team to euthanize a bear. "Just because we are putting the people over the bears doesn't mean it's not hard for us to do it," Gibbs said. What to do if you see a black bear If you see a black bear in East Tennessee, do not approach it. Maintain your distance with adult bears and especially with cubs. In June, you're more likely to see a black bear cub in East Tennessee. Even if you don't see the cub's mother, don't pick a cub up or touch it. recommends a few basic guidelines to help keep people safe in a black bear encounter, depending on where you see the bear. If the bear is indoors or near a dumpster or building, back away and give it a clear escape route. If it's inside leave doors open. If the bear is in your backyard, remain a safe distance away and make loud noises to scare it away. Be sure it's gone before letting any pets out or removing items that might have attracted it. If the bear is in the woods, back away slowly and quietly. Never run, as that might trigger the bear's chase response. If you are approached by the bear, stand your ground and try to appear as large as possible. Make loud noises. If a black bear charges you, use bear spray. If it makes contact, fight back using your surroundings. Do not play dead. This article originally appeared on Knoxville News Sentinel: Black bear crashes bachelorette party in Gatlinburg, Tennessee. Watch the video Solve the daily Crossword

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store