logo
Why an Ohio ban on settlements to close ​‘base load' power plants matters for clean energy

Why an Ohio ban on settlements to close ​‘base load' power plants matters for clean energy

Yahoo10-06-2025
Aerial photograph of the OVEC-operated Kyger Creek Power Plant in Cheshire. (Getty Images.)
This story was originally published by Canary Media.
A decade ago, the Sierra Club and other environmental groups, trade organizations, and companies found themselves in a regulatory standoff with American Electric Power over operating costs for six coal-fired power plants in Ohio.
The utility's opponents objected to letting the company collect more money from customers to keep the unprofitable plants running, while the utility argued the charges were a hedge against even higher costs.
Before state regulators made a decision, the utility and some of its opponents announced a compromise. As part of the deal, the Sierra Club would drop its opposition in exchange for AEP's commitment to add more solar and wind to its portfolio as well as move up its timeline for closing or converting several coal plants to natural gas.
A Sierra Club representative at the time described it as ​'nowhere near a perfect deal' but as one that would significantly reduce carbon emissions and accelerate the state's clean energy transition.
Such compromises will now be prohibited in Ohio under a new state law that forbids settlements involving the closure of ​'base load' power plants.
Proponents of House Bill 15, signed by Republican Gov. Mike DeWine in mid-May, say it will support the state's ever-growing power needs and promote competition within its energy sector.
Yet critics are questioning the law's definition of ​'base load' generating facilities: It only covers electricity sources that run primarily on nonrenewable fuels such as natural gas or nuclear. The definition excludes wind or solar power, even when combined with battery storage.
Negotiating special deals in settlements has long been common in utility regulatory cases. Industry groups or companies have gotten discounts and other benefits in return for dropping opposition to utilities' added charges. Parties in court cases often settle before trial, too.
For example, the same year that the Sierra Club reached a settlement with AEP, a trade group representing industrial customers negotiated a special rate with FirstEnergy's Ohio utilities in exchange for dropping opposition to a customer-funded bailout of that company's unprofitable coal and nuclear plants. (The secret terms of that agreement were part of a criminal case filed last year against Ohio's former chief utility regulator, Sam Randazzo. They also became part of a House Bill 6-related regulatory case on which regulators will finally hear evidence this month.)
HB 15 will still allow settlements with special deals, as long as terms are part of the public record, there's no cash payment, and they do not close or limit ​'base load' electricity-generating facilities.
Neil Waggoner, who heads the Sierra Club's Beyond Coal campaign for the Midwest region, suspects the provision is likely a backlash to the environmental group's 2015 settlement with AEP.
That deal didn't end up delivering all of the expected clean energy benefits. State rules requiring wind turbines to be a certain distance from other properties ultimately made it impossible for AEP to add the planned 500 megawatts of wind generation, and the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio refused to allow the utility to charge customers the cost of building 400 MW of solar energy.
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
The ​'base load' provisions weren't part of HB 15 as it originally passed the House, nor were they in the initial versions of the companion Senate bill, SB 2. The language appeared in a substitute version of SB 2 introduced on March 11, the same day that Ed Spiker, chair of the Ohio Coal Association, submitted written testimony pleading the state to enact ​'guardrails to ensure current coal power plants are not forced to close.'
The terms used in SB 2 included natural gas and nuclear in the definition of a ​'base load electric generating facility' but not renewables. The Senate then added the provisions to HB 15 before passing it this spring.
The law suggests Republicans' continuing willingness to prop up conventional power plants, even when their electricity may cost more than cleaner sources of power.
'How would you replace base load power generation, given the amount of megawatts that they produce that we certainly require?' Sen. Jerry Cirino, R-Kirtland, challenged one witness who spoke against nuclear power plants during a March 11 hearing held by the Senate Energy Committee.
Yet electricity from coal and nuclear plants remains relatively expensive, compared to that from renewables or natural gas.
Ashley Brown, a former state utility regulator, questioned the constitutionality of the new settlement restrictions. ​'I don't know how they can tell somebody you can't shut down a plant,' he told Canary Media.
Two weeks ago, the Trump administration ordered a retiring Michigan coal plant to stay open, although it's unclear whether the mandate will face a court challenge. Separately, regional grid operator PJM Interconnection has sometimes issued orders to keep power-generation facilities running to maintain grid reliability, as it did for former FirstEnergy coal plants. In that case, however, the company was paid to keep the plants open.
Waggoner noted that HB 15's language only applies to settlements. Its terms wouldn't stop a company from closing an unprofitable plant on its own accord.
HB 15 also finally revokes subsidies for two 1950s-era coal plants, which had been put in place by HB 6, the 2019 law at the heart of an ongoing public corruption scandal in Ohio. Yet Beth Nagusky, an adjunct law professor at Case Western Reserve University, wonders whether the provision preventing settlements that close ​'base load' power plants is meant to lay the groundwork for new subsidies down the road for nuclear and coal plants, which might become involved in regulatory or judicial cases.
'I don't think that's even being hidden,' Waggoner said. Along the same lines, environmental groups have criticized laws from 2023 and 2024 that include natural gas and nuclear power in the state's definition of ​'green energy.'
As Waggoner sees it, utilities and policymakers who claim to be worried about maintaining enough ​'base load' or ​'dispatchable' electricity are concerned less about real reliability issues and more about minimizing the importance of renewable energy in the face of climate change, even when renewables are paired with storage.
'They're looking at how do you frame this argument so you're not just saying, ​'We don't want renewables,'' Waggoner said. ​'They're trying to find a way to justify what they want, as opposed to what the moment demands.'
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Photos this week: July 17-24, 2025
Photos this week: July 17-24, 2025

CNN

time27 minutes ago

  • CNN

Photos this week: July 17-24, 2025

A man stands at the broken windows of his house after a Russian attack in Kyiv, Ukraine, on Monday, July 21. Residents of Kyiv and other major Ukrainian cities faced another sleepless night on Sunday as Russia launched 450 missiles and drones overnight into Monday, Ukraine's Air Force said. The majority were shot down, the Air Force said, but 23 struck across three locations and debris from intercepted missiles landed in 12 areas. Efrem Lukatsky/AP A machine gun and flak jacket, belonging to a Ukrainian serviceman, hang on a wall near the Ukrainian town of Chasiv Yar on Tuesday, July 22. Chasiv Yar is on the front lines of the country's war with Russia. Oleg Petrasiuk/Ukrainian Armed Forces/Reuters People gather in Folkestone, England, to dance to Kate Bush's 1978 hit song 'Wuthering Heights' on Sunday, July 20. They wore red dresses to re-enact Bush's iconic music President Donald Trump, second from left, tours the renovation site of the Federal Reserve headquarters in Washington, DC, on Thursday, July 24. He was joined by US Sen. Tim Scott, left, and Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell, right. The long-simmering clash between Trump and Powell was on full public display during the tour. Andrew Caballero-Reynolds/AFP/Getty Images Children in Sanaa, Yemen, react as protesters, predominantly Houthi supporters, show solidarity with Palestinians on Friday, July 18. Khaled Abdullah/Reuters Lovely Jean Baptiste, a 16-year-old who was shot in the mouth by armed gangs, poses for a portrait Thursday, July 17, at the Argentine Bellegarde School, which has been turned into a shelter for displaced people in Port-au-Prince, Haiti. Claraens Siffroy/AFP/Getty Images Mario Barrios, left, tries to avoid a punch from Hall of Fame boxer Manny Pacquiao during their welterweight title bout in Las Vegas on Saturday, July 19. Pacquiao, 46, was making his first appearance in the ring in nearly four years. He fell just short of taking the title of Barrios, who retained the WBC belt with a majority draw. John Locher/AP Miami Marlins outfielder Kyle Stowers, right, celebrates with teammates after he hit a walk-off home run to defeat the Kansas City Royals on Friday, July 18. He hit two homers in the Aguilar prepares to enter the flooded Barasoain church for her wedding in Malolos, Philippines, on Tuesday, July 22. The church flooded due to heavy rain from Typhoon Wipha, but she and her fiancé pushed through with their wedding anyway. Aaron Favila/AP This aerial photo, taken on Tuesday, July 22, shows surfers swimming past waves in the Atlantic Ocean near Carcans, France. Christophe Archambault/AFP/Getty Images Dylan Mortensen gets a hug after speaking at the sentencing hearing of Bryan Kohberger at the Ada County Courthouse in Boise, Idaho, on Wednesday, July 23. Kohberger, who murdered four University of Idaho students in 2022, was sentenced to life in prison without parole. Kyle Green/Pool/AP Late-night talk show host Stephen Colbert speaks to his audience on Monday, July 21. It was his first night back on 'The Late Show' since the shocking news that CBS is canceling it. The network, citing financial pressures, said the cancellation will take effect in May 2026, the normal end of the broadcast TV season. Scott Kowalchyk/CBS/Getty Images Scottie Scheffler hugs his wife, Meredith, and their son, Bennett, after he won the Open Championship in Portrush, Northern Ireland, on Sunday, July 20. It's the fourth major title for Scheffler, the world's top-ranked player who also won the PGA Championship earlier this season. Oisin Keniry/R&A/Getty Images Crime scene tape cordons off part of the area where a Bangladeshi Air Force jet crashed into a school in the capital of Dhaka on Monday, July 21. At least 27 people, mostly children, were killed, according to officials. Munir Uz Zaman/AFP/Getty Images Aidan Keen and Mark McGlaughlin rest at Neebel Park in Hartley, Iowa, on Sunday, July 20. They were taking part in the first day of RAGBRAI, or Register's Annual Great Bicycle Ride Across Iowa. See last week in 32 photos. Ayrton Breckenridge/The Register/Imagn Images

Tim Walz leading Dem effort to turn bipartisan group against President Trump: report
Tim Walz leading Dem effort to turn bipartisan group against President Trump: report

Fox News

time27 minutes ago

  • Fox News

Tim Walz leading Dem effort to turn bipartisan group against President Trump: report

Progressive governor and failed vice presidential candidate Tim Walz is leading a Democratic effort to turn one of the country's most influential bipartisan groups against President Donald Trump, according to a report by a mainstream media outlet. Walz, the governor of Minnesota and one-time running mate of former Vice President Kamala Harris, is threatening to pull out of the bipartisan National Governors Association (NGA) over concerns it is not doing enough to push back against Trump, according to The Atlantic. The Atlantic reported that two unnamed people "familiar with the governors' thinking" shared that at least two Democratic governors — Walz and fellow Democratic Gov. Laura Kelly, who is head of the Democratic Governors Association — are opting to stop paying their NGA dues this month. The two governors will not renew their membership in the organization out of frustration with its inaction against perceived violations of states' rights by the Trump administration. The concerns raised included the Office of Management and Budget briefly pausing disbursements of federal funds in January, the clash with Democratic Gov. Janet Mills over transgender athletes and Trump's deployment of the California National Guard to respond to the anti-ICE riots in Los Angeles. The outlet reported three other unnamed sources saying that Walz and Kelly are not alone and that the offices of other Democratic governors are similarly frustrated with the NGA. One of the unnamed sources said "when you are also paying dues with taxpayer dollars, it has got to be worth it, and they are going to have to demonstrate that. Right now, they are not doing that," the outlet reported. The source also claimed "there have been ongoing concerns about the NGA among the Democratic governors and staff, off and on, for years." The NGA has existed as a forum for bipartisan collaboration among governors since 1908. The organization lists all 50 governors as well as leaders of five U.S. territories as members. Eric Wohlschlegel, NGA communications director, told Fox News Digital the group "exists to bring governors from both parties together around shared priorities." Amid the Walz-led controversy, Wohlschlegel said NGA's "mission hasn't changed." "Every public statement NGA issues reflects bipartisan consensus," he said. "So far this year, all but one statement has had that consensus, and when governors don't agree, we simply don't issue one. That's how we preserve our role as a bipartisan convener, a principle we won't compromise." A source familiar with the situation blamed the controversy on "Democratic infighting, unspoken campaign jockeying and a few anonymous voices looking to reshape a nonpartisan institution into a political one." That source pointed out that, despite all the noise about controversy, the NGA's summer meeting in Colorado Springs this weekend is expected to have "record turnout" with 13 Republican and seven Democratic leaders attending. They also noted that "no governors are on the record expressing discontent with the NGA. No allegations of misconduct, governance failure or mismanagement have been raised." "What's behind the noise?" the source added. "There's an internal power struggle currently and no consensus among Democrats right now on how to lead, how to message or how to govern in a divided environment. "Several Democratic governors are vying for national attention, testing messages for future campaigns rather than collaborating on consensus governance," the source added. "The NGA's bipartisan model is working exactly as it's supposed to. "When a party can't agree with itself, it becomes easy to take shots at bipartisan institutions that don't serve short-term political goals." Fox News Digital reached out to the offices of Democratic Colorado Gov. Jared Polis, the outgoing NGA chair, and Republican Gov. Kevin Stitt of Oklahoma, the incoming chair, for comment on the Walz mutiny. Though not addressing the controversy directly, Conor Cahill, a spokesperson for Polis, told Fox News Digital the governor "has been honored" to lead the NGA and to "work across the aisle with governors on education, permitting reform, standing up to federal efforts to strip away gubernatorial authority around the National Guard and elevating the priorities of states." He added that "during this polarizing time, bipartisan organizations are needed more than ever, and NGA must continue to demonstrate value to all governors and effectively communicate governors' opinions on various matters with the public and the federal government." Abegail Cave, a spokesperson for Sitt, who will become NGA chair this weekend, told Fox News Digital "people seem to forget NGA is a bipartisan organization, not a political one." "Coming to bipartisan consensus is difficult, but governors from across the political spectrum are addressing the real challenges facing Americans every day," Cave said. She said that Stitt "looks forward to leading this organization and finding more areas of collaboration in the coming year." Fox News Digital also reached out to the offices of Walz and Kelly but did not receive responses by the time of publication.

Paramount-Skydance merger approved after companies agree to government speech demands
Paramount-Skydance merger approved after companies agree to government speech demands

The Verge

time27 minutes ago

  • The Verge

Paramount-Skydance merger approved after companies agree to government speech demands

The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) has approved Skydance's $8 billion purchase of CBS-owner Paramount after the companies agreed to end diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs but feature a 'diversity of viewpoints from across the political and ideological spectrum.' In light of the Trump administration's critiques of CBS's alleged anti-conservative bias — including collecting a $16 million settlement over the president's lawsuit over an allegedly deceptively edited video of then-Democratic presidential candidate Kamala Harris on 60 Minutes — the companies' commitment to address bias in the lawsuit likely means featuring more conservative programming. Skydance agreed to employ an ombudsman for at least two years, 'who will receive and evaluate any complaints of bias or other concerns involving CBS.' 'Americans no longer trust the legacy national news media to report fully, accurately, and fairly. It is time for a change,' Republican FCC Chair Brendan Carr said in a statement announcing the agency's approval. 'That is why I welcome Skydance's commitment to make significant changes at the once storied CBS broadcast network.' He said the commitments 'would enable CBS to operate in the public interest and focus on fair, unbiased, and fact-based coverage,' and mark 'another step forward in the FCC's efforts to eliminate invidious forms of DEI discrimination.' Carr also boasts that Skydance 'reaffirms its commitment to localism as a core component of the public interest standard,' and that the approval will 'unleash the investment of $1.5 billion into Paramount.' Carr has made no secret of his distaste for news coverage he sees as disproportionately unfavorable to the right and DEI policies he believes contribute to unfair treatment. He's opened investigations into all three major networks as well as NPR and PBS (NBCUniversal and its owner Comcast are investors in The Verge parent company Vox Media). A week ago, CBS announced it was retiring The Late Show, hosted by Trump critic and comedian Stephen Colbert. The network said it was 'purely a financial decision.' The FCC's only remaining Democratic commissioner, Anna Gomez, dissented, writing that, 'In an unprecedented move, this once-independent FCC used its vast power to pressure Paramount to broker a private legal settlement and further erode press freedom … Even more alarming, it is now imposing never-before-seen controls over newsroom decisions and editorial judgment, in direct violation of the First Amendment and the law.' Still, she gave Carr credit for calling a vote on the matter, rather than rubber-stamping the merger through one of the agency's bureaus, like it did for the Verizon-Frontier merger, which similarly required an end to DEI programs. Gomez warns that this agreement is just the canary in the coal mine. 'The Paramount payout and this reckless approval have emboldened those who believe the government can—and should—abuse its power to extract financial and ideological concessions, demand favored treatment, and secure positive media coverage,' she writes. 'It is a dark chapter in a long and growing record of abuse that threatens press freedom in this country. But such violations endure only when institutions choose capitulation over courage. It is time for companies, journalists, and citizens alike to stand up and speak out, because unchecked and unquestioned power has no rightful place in America.' Posts from this author will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All by Lauren Feiner Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All Business Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All Entertainment Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All Film Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All News Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All Policy Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All Streaming Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All TV Shows

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store