logo
Why an Ohio ban on settlements to close ​‘base load' power plants matters for clean energy

Why an Ohio ban on settlements to close ​‘base load' power plants matters for clean energy

Yahoo10-06-2025
Aerial photograph of the OVEC-operated Kyger Creek Power Plant in Cheshire. (Getty Images.)
This story was originally published by Canary Media.
A decade ago, the Sierra Club and other environmental groups, trade organizations, and companies found themselves in a regulatory standoff with American Electric Power over operating costs for six coal-fired power plants in Ohio.
The utility's opponents objected to letting the company collect more money from customers to keep the unprofitable plants running, while the utility argued the charges were a hedge against even higher costs.
Before state regulators made a decision, the utility and some of its opponents announced a compromise. As part of the deal, the Sierra Club would drop its opposition in exchange for AEP's commitment to add more solar and wind to its portfolio as well as move up its timeline for closing or converting several coal plants to natural gas.
A Sierra Club representative at the time described it as ​'nowhere near a perfect deal' but as one that would significantly reduce carbon emissions and accelerate the state's clean energy transition.
Such compromises will now be prohibited in Ohio under a new state law that forbids settlements involving the closure of ​'base load' power plants.
Proponents of House Bill 15, signed by Republican Gov. Mike DeWine in mid-May, say it will support the state's ever-growing power needs and promote competition within its energy sector.
Yet critics are questioning the law's definition of ​'base load' generating facilities: It only covers electricity sources that run primarily on nonrenewable fuels such as natural gas or nuclear. The definition excludes wind or solar power, even when combined with battery storage.
Negotiating special deals in settlements has long been common in utility regulatory cases. Industry groups or companies have gotten discounts and other benefits in return for dropping opposition to utilities' added charges. Parties in court cases often settle before trial, too.
For example, the same year that the Sierra Club reached a settlement with AEP, a trade group representing industrial customers negotiated a special rate with FirstEnergy's Ohio utilities in exchange for dropping opposition to a customer-funded bailout of that company's unprofitable coal and nuclear plants. (The secret terms of that agreement were part of a criminal case filed last year against Ohio's former chief utility regulator, Sam Randazzo. They also became part of a House Bill 6-related regulatory case on which regulators will finally hear evidence this month.)
HB 15 will still allow settlements with special deals, as long as terms are part of the public record, there's no cash payment, and they do not close or limit ​'base load' electricity-generating facilities.
Neil Waggoner, who heads the Sierra Club's Beyond Coal campaign for the Midwest region, suspects the provision is likely a backlash to the environmental group's 2015 settlement with AEP.
That deal didn't end up delivering all of the expected clean energy benefits. State rules requiring wind turbines to be a certain distance from other properties ultimately made it impossible for AEP to add the planned 500 megawatts of wind generation, and the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio refused to allow the utility to charge customers the cost of building 400 MW of solar energy.
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
The ​'base load' provisions weren't part of HB 15 as it originally passed the House, nor were they in the initial versions of the companion Senate bill, SB 2. The language appeared in a substitute version of SB 2 introduced on March 11, the same day that Ed Spiker, chair of the Ohio Coal Association, submitted written testimony pleading the state to enact ​'guardrails to ensure current coal power plants are not forced to close.'
The terms used in SB 2 included natural gas and nuclear in the definition of a ​'base load electric generating facility' but not renewables. The Senate then added the provisions to HB 15 before passing it this spring.
The law suggests Republicans' continuing willingness to prop up conventional power plants, even when their electricity may cost more than cleaner sources of power.
'How would you replace base load power generation, given the amount of megawatts that they produce that we certainly require?' Sen. Jerry Cirino, R-Kirtland, challenged one witness who spoke against nuclear power plants during a March 11 hearing held by the Senate Energy Committee.
Yet electricity from coal and nuclear plants remains relatively expensive, compared to that from renewables or natural gas.
Ashley Brown, a former state utility regulator, questioned the constitutionality of the new settlement restrictions. ​'I don't know how they can tell somebody you can't shut down a plant,' he told Canary Media.
Two weeks ago, the Trump administration ordered a retiring Michigan coal plant to stay open, although it's unclear whether the mandate will face a court challenge. Separately, regional grid operator PJM Interconnection has sometimes issued orders to keep power-generation facilities running to maintain grid reliability, as it did for former FirstEnergy coal plants. In that case, however, the company was paid to keep the plants open.
Waggoner noted that HB 15's language only applies to settlements. Its terms wouldn't stop a company from closing an unprofitable plant on its own accord.
HB 15 also finally revokes subsidies for two 1950s-era coal plants, which had been put in place by HB 6, the 2019 law at the heart of an ongoing public corruption scandal in Ohio. Yet Beth Nagusky, an adjunct law professor at Case Western Reserve University, wonders whether the provision preventing settlements that close ​'base load' power plants is meant to lay the groundwork for new subsidies down the road for nuclear and coal plants, which might become involved in regulatory or judicial cases.
'I don't think that's even being hidden,' Waggoner said. Along the same lines, environmental groups have criticized laws from 2023 and 2024 that include natural gas and nuclear power in the state's definition of ​'green energy.'
As Waggoner sees it, utilities and policymakers who claim to be worried about maintaining enough ​'base load' or ​'dispatchable' electricity are concerned less about real reliability issues and more about minimizing the importance of renewable energy in the face of climate change, even when renewables are paired with storage.
'They're looking at how do you frame this argument so you're not just saying, ​'We don't want renewables,'' Waggoner said. ​'They're trying to find a way to justify what they want, as opposed to what the moment demands.'
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Massie: DOJ ‘hiding behind' victim protection in Epstein controversy
Massie: DOJ ‘hiding behind' victim protection in Epstein controversy

The Hill

time4 minutes ago

  • The Hill

Massie: DOJ ‘hiding behind' victim protection in Epstein controversy

Rep. Thomas Massie (R-Ky.) on Sunday accused the Department of Justice (DOJ) of 'hiding behind' the argument of protecting victims as it faces calls to release files related to convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein. 'The Department of Justice says they will not be releasing further Epstein material in order to protect what they say is more than 1,000 victims, many of whom were underage,' NBC News's Kristen Welker said during an interview with Massie Sunday on 'Meet the Press.' 'I want to read you a little bit of a DOJ memo which writes, quote, 'Sensitive information relating to these victims is intertwined throughout the materials. One of our highest priorities is combatting child exploitation and bringing justice to victims. Perpetuating unfounded theories about Epstein serves neither one of those ends.' What is your response to the concern that releasing these files could ultimately hurt the victims, Congressman Massie?' Welker asked. 'Well, look, that's a straw man. Ro and I carefully crafted this legislation so that the victims' names will be redacted and that no child pornography will be released. So, they're hiding behind that,' Massie responded, referring to an effort he and Rep. Ro Khanna (D-Calif.) are undertaking to force a vote in Congress on releasing Epstein-linked files. 'But we're trying to get justice for the victims and transparency for America,' the Kentucky Republican added in an interview highlighted by Mediaite. 'And so, you know, we've redacted things before. We don't want to hurt the victims. We're doing this for the victims.' President Trump and his administration have been facing heavy criticism over their handling of information related to Epstein in recent weeks, with the controversy also causing chaos in Congress. Last Wednesday, the House broke for its weeks-long August recess, shutting down a day earlier than planned as the Epstein controversy brought the chamber to a standstill.

Project 2025 author Paul Dans will challenge Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham in South Carolina
Project 2025 author Paul Dans will challenge Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham in South Carolina

San Francisco Chronicle​

time4 minutes ago

  • San Francisco Chronicle​

Project 2025 author Paul Dans will challenge Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham in South Carolina

WASHINGTON (AP) — A chief architect of Project 2025, Paul Dans, is launching a Republican primary challenge to Sen. Lindsey Graham in South Carolina, joining a crowded field that will test the loyalties of President Donald Trump and his MAGA movement in next year's midterm election. Dans told The Associated Press the Trump administration's federal workforce reductions and cuts to federal programs are what he had hoped for in drafting Project 2025. But he said there's 'more work to do,' particularly in the Senate. 'What we've done with Project 2025 is really change the game in terms of closing the door on the progressive era," Dans said in an AP interview. 'If you look at where the chokepoint is, it's the United States Senate. That's the headwaters of the swamp." Dans, who is set to formally announce his campaign at an event Wednesday in Charleston, said Graham has spent most of his career in Washington and 'it's time to show him the door.' Challenging the long-serving Graham, who has routinely batted back contenders over the years, is something of a political long shot in what is fast becoming a crowded field ahead of the November 2026 midterm election that will determine control of Congress. Trump early on gave his endorsement of Graham, a political confidant and regular golfing partner of the president, despite their on-again-off-again relationship. Graham, in announcing he would seek a fifth term in the Senate, also secured the state's leading Republicans, Sen. Tim Scott and Gov. Henry McMaster, to chair his 2026 run. He has amassed millions of dollars in his campaign account. Other candidates, including Republican former South Carolina Lt. Gov. André Bauer, a wealthy developer, and Democratic challenger Dr. Annie Andrews, have announced their campaigns for the Senate seat in an early start to the election season, more than a year away. Graham, in an appearance Sunday on NBC's 'Meet the Press,' did not discuss his reelection campaign but fielded questions on topics including his push to release 'as much as you can' from the case files on Jeffrey Epstein, something many of Trump's supporters want the government to do. Dans, an attorney who worked in the first Trump administration as White House liaison to the office of personnel management, said he expects to have support from Project 2025 allies, as well as the ranks of Trump's supporters in the state who have publicly tired of Graham. After Trump left the White House, Dans, now a father of four, went to work at the Heritage Foundation, often commuting on weekdays to Washington as he organized Project 2025. The nearly 1,000-page policy blueprint, with chapters written by leading conservative thinkers, calls for dismantling the federal government and downsizing the federal workforce, among other right-wing proposals for the next White House. 'To be clear, I believe that there is a 'deep state' out there, and I'm the single one who stepped forward at the end of the first term of Trump and really started to drain the swamp,' Dans said, noting he compiled much of the book from his kitchen table in Charleston. Among the goals, he said, was to 'deconstruct the administrative state,' which he said is what the Trump administration has been doing, pointing in particular to former Trump adviser Elon Musk's work at the Department of Government Efficiency shuttering federal offices. Dans and Heritage parted ways in July 2024 amid blowback over Project 2025. It catapulted into political culture that summer during the presidential campaign season, as Democrats and their allies showcased the hard-right policy proposals — from mass firings to budget cuts — as a dire warning of what could come in a second Trump term.

Mike Collins launches Georgia Senate bid
Mike Collins launches Georgia Senate bid

Politico

time5 minutes ago

  • Politico

Mike Collins launches Georgia Senate bid

Mike Collins participates in Georgia's 10th Congressional District republican primary election runoff debates on June 6, 2022, in Atlanta. | Brynn Anderson/AP Photo By Nicole Markus 07/28/2025 08:50 AM EDT Rep. Mike Collins (R-Ga.) on Monday announced his bid for the Senate in next year's midterms, joining a now-contested GOP primary of hopefuls attempting to unseat Democratic Sen. Jon Ossoff. 'We need a Senator who works for Georgia, not the California crazies or New York nutjobs,' Collins said in the announcement, posted to X . 'I don't know who Jon Ossoff really works for, but it sure as heck isn't Georgia.' Collins is the second Republican to hop in the party's primary, joining Rep. Buddy Carter. Both Carter and Collins are courting President Donald Trump's endorsement, with Collins including clips of Trump singing the representative's praises in his announcement.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store