CERC rejects CESC's 300 MW hybrid power tariff bid over procedural lapses
The power utility had failed to obtain prior approval for deviations in the bidding process from the appropriate authority, which in this case should have been the Centre and not the West Bengal government, the CERC said in its report.
Kolkata, Jul 15 (PTI) The Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (CERC) has rejected a petition by CESC Ltd seeking approval for the adoption of tariff for the long-term procurement of 300 MW power from grid-connected wind-solar hybrid projects, citing non-compliance with competitive bidding guidelines.
'We reject the adoption of the tariff so discovered, as the petitioner has not complied with the bidding guidelines under Section 63 of the Electricity Act. The petitioner may go for re-bidding, if so advised, strictly in accordance with the guidelines issued under Section 63 of the Act,' the CERC said in the order.
CESC had floated the tender on November 8, 2024, for procuring 150 MW wind-solar hybrid power with a greenshoe option for an additional 150 MW, aiming to meet its renewable purchase obligations. The project was proposed to be located in Mandsaur in Madhya Pradesh.
The final tariff was discovered through competitive bidding and an e-reverse auction conducted on December 27, 2024. Purvah Green Power Pvt Ltd, a subsidiary of CESC, emerged as the successful bidder for the entire 300 MW capacity.
CESC did not respond to requests for comments till the time of filing of this report.
The Commission noted that despite being aware from a previous case (Petition No. 365/AT/2024) that approval for deviations in inter-state transmission system (ISTS)-connected projects must be obtained from the central government, CESC proceeded with approvals from the West Bengal government.
The Commission also observed that CESC had misled the state government by not disclosing the ISTS nature of the project and continued the tender process despite being aware of the requirement to approach the Centre.
'The Commission had condoned this requirement once as an exception, but cannot make the exception a rule,' the order said, referring to a previous instance where similar deviations were allowed in view of exigencies.
'Acceptance of the petitioner's prayers in the instant petition would not be in consonance with the principles as contained in Section 63 of the Electricity Act, 2003,' it added.
CESC defended the higher-than-average tariff by citing two key advantages in the winning bid. First, the project promised a higher Capacity Utilisation Factor (CUF) of 50 per cent, well above the usual 30 per cent for comparable hybrid projects.
Additionally, the bidder committed to completing the project within 20 months, shorter than the standard 24-month timeline, which CESC claimed could result in potential savings of Rs 0.02 per kWh.
The Commission further pointed out that awarding the entire 300 MW capacity to a related party.
'Another interesting point to note is that in response to the RfS in Petition 365/AT/2024 as well as the present petition, the bidders participating in the bids are precisely the same, and the winning bidder, being a wholly owned subsidiary of the petitioner, is also the same. While this could be a coincidence, it raises a question mark on transparency,' the order noted.
The Commission also rejected CESC's justification of the higher tariff on the grounds of higher capacity utilisation and project timelines, noting that the company's comparison of the discovered tariff with short-term prices in the Green Day-Ahead Market (G-DAM) was misplaced.
CERC clarified that such comparisons are not valid under the guidelines, which require benchmarking against tariffs discovered through long-term competitive bidding.
The July 9 order advised CESC to go for re-bidding strictly in accordance with the guidelines issued under Section 63 of the Electricity Act. PTI BSM NN
This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
30 minutes ago
- Time of India
MRPL to offer Rs 80 lakh per acre for acquisition of land
Mangaluru: A decision has been taken to provide suitable compensation to those displaced by the acquisition of 27 acres for the proposed green zone project by Mangalore Refinery and Petrochemicals Limited (MRPL). The decision was made during a meeting chaired by Dakshina Kannada MP Brijesh Chowta at the DC's office on Saturday. MRPL submitted a proposal to the district administration to offer compensation of Rs 80 lakh per acre, along with Rs 20 lakh in cash and a plot of land for each family instead of employment. The MP said this longstanding issue must be resolved satisfactorily for everyone. The severity of the displaced people's problem is understood, and a good package must be provided, he said. There are 408 door numbers on 27 acres, and according to the survey, land acquisition and other expenses might amount to Rs 93.9 crore, as reported by the Karnataka Polytechnic (KPT) that conducted the survey. Deputy commissioner Darshan HV said that a final decision on the package submitted by MRPL will be made soon. The 27 acres to be acquired fall within the jurisdiction of Jokatte, Bala gram panchayats, and Bajpe Town panchayat, and the DC instructed that no new door numbers should be issued in these areas. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Free P2,000 GCash eGift UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo Moodbidri MLA Umanath Kotian, MRPL MD Mundkur Shyamprasad Kamath, officials of the Karnataka Industrial Area Development Board (KIADB), and leaders of the displaced, including Muneer Katipalla, among others, were present. MRPL records decline in profits The MRPL reported a net loss of Rs 272 crore for the first quarter of the 2025–26 financial year, a sharp decline from a net profit of Rs 66 crore during the same period last year. The board of directors approved the standalone and consolidated financial results for Q1 on Friday. Revenue from operations fell to Rs 20,988 crore, down from Rs 27,289 crore in Q1 of 2024–25. The company's gross refining margin (GRM) also declined to $3.8 per barrel from $4.7 per barrel in the corresponding quarter last year. Total throughput at the refinery dropped to 3.5 million tonnes (MT), compared to 4.3 MT in the same period last year. However, MRPL recorded its highest-ever crude processing in a single month, with 1,512 thousand metric tonnes (TMT) processed in April 2025—surpassing the previous record of 1,481 TMT in April 2022. A company release said the major units in the phase-2 complex were shut down for maintenance during the quarter.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
GVMC approves Rs 31.03 crore worth development works
Visakhapatnam: Development works worth Rs 31.03 crore under the engineering department were approved during the GVMC standing committee meeting held on Saturday, said mayor and standing committee chairperson P Sreenivasa Rao. The mayor presided over the meeting conducted at the GVMC main office. He said that a total of 93 agenda items were presented, including 60 main agenda items and 33 tabled items. All proposals were thoroughly discussed and unanimously approved by the committee members, he added. Srinivasa Rao also noted that the committee addressed several matters related to the revenue department, such as the collection of dues and lease extensions, along with multiple issues concerning the public health department. Meanwhile, foundation stones were laid for development works worth Rs 5.89 crore in Vadlapudi, Ward 87 of the Gajuwaka zone on Sunday. The mayor was joined by TDP state president and Gajuwaka MLA Palla Srinivasa Rao, along with ward corporator Bonda Jagannath, during the inauguration.
The Print
an hour ago
- The Print
HDFC Bank Q1 net profit dips 1.31 pc, makes Rs 9k cr contingent provisioning
On a standalone basis, the country's largest private sector lender reported a net profit of Rs 18,155 crore for the quarter, up from Rs 16,174 crore a year ago. The lender had reported a net profit of Rs 16,475 crore in the year-ago period. Mumbai, Jul 19 (PTI) HDFC Bank on Saturday posted a 1.31 per cent decline in its consolidated net profit to Rs 16,258 crore for the June 2025 quarter. The core net interest income growth moderated to 5 per cent to Rs 31,400 crore during the quarter, as the net interest margin narrowed to 3.35 per cent from 3.46 per cent in the quarter-ago period amid a 6.7 per cent growth in gross advances. The bank's chief financial officer Srinivasan Vaidyanathan said about 70 per cent of its assets are linked to external benchmarks, which are directly exposed to rate revisions by the RBI, and declined to give an outlook on how it sees the key number going ahead. He said the bank, which has previously disclosed its target to grow advances in sync with the industry, is set to grow its deposit market share this fiscal year. The overall provisions jumped to Rs 14,442 crore from Rs 2,602 crore a year ago, the bank said, adding that this includes a floating provision of Rs 9,000 crore. Vaidyanathan clarified that the excess provisions, which are at par with the gains made by share sale in the HDB Financial Services' initial public offering, are not done keeping any specific event in mind or any build of stress. The gross non-performing assets ratio inched up to 1.4 per cent as of June 30 from 1.33 per cent three months ago, largely because of cyclical reverses in the agricultural portfolio. The fresh slippages increased to RS 9,000 crore from Rs 7,500 crore in the quarter-ago period, including agri advances, while excluding the agri portfolio, the same increased to Rs 6,800 crore from Rs 6,200 crore. The bank seemed to be continuing with its 'circumspect' view on the home mortgage front, where it grew by 9 per cent. The CFO stressed that top cities are seeing home loan finance coming at 7.2 per cent, which HDFC Bank finds very low. At present, 80 per cent of the bank branches sell home loans, and the aim is to take it up to 100 per cent. The overall capital adequacy of the bank was at 19.9 per cent, including the core buffers at 17.4 per cent, as of June 30. PTI AA BAL BAL This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.
