Wimbledon call is wrong because the electronic system wasn't on during a Centre Court match
And, because the replay review procedure that used to be in place also has been scrapped, the chair umpire decided to have a do-over on the point at 4-all in the first set — much to the dismay of Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova, the player who would have won the game if the proper call had been made originally.
Pavlyuchenkova wound up getting broken there to trail Sonay Kartal, but she eventually did manage to come back to win the match 7-6 (3), 6-4 and reach the quarterfinals at the All England Club for the first time since 2016.
'You took the game away from me,' 2021 French Open runner-up Pavlyuchenkova told chair umpire Nico Helwerth at the changeover after the game ended.
She was serving and had a game point when Kartal hit a backhand that landed beyond the opposite baseline — clearly out, TV replays showed. But there was no sound of one of the recorded voices being used for the first time at Wimbledon to reflect when the technology being used in place of human officials determines that a ball landed out.
Kartal said she couldn't see where her shot went.
'That situation is a rarity. I don't think it's really ever happened — if it has. It's tough. What can you do? The umpire's trying his best in that situation, and he handled it fine,' Kartal said. 'I think the system just malfunctioned a little bit, and the fairest way was what he did: replay the point.'
Helwerth delayed play while he made a phone call from his stand. Eventually, play resumed, Pavlyuchenkova missed a forehand on the replay, then lost the game a few points later.
The explanation offered by an All England Club spokesman: 'Due to operator error, the system was deactivated on the point in question. The chair umpire followed the established process.'
The French Open is now the only Grand Slam tournament
that still uses line judges instead of electronic calls
.
From 2007 through last year, players were allowed to challenge in-or-out calls at Wimbledon; a video review was employed to decide whether a line judge's — or chair umpire's — ruling was correct. That challenge system was removed for the current tournament, but there immediately were demands on social media from some tennis fans or observers to bring that back to aid chair umpires.
Taylor Fritz, who reached the quarterfinals with a win at a different court Sunday, didn't see what happened. But when it was explained by a reporter, his biggest question was why the chair umpire didn't just make the call himself if it was so clear what actually happened on Kartal's shot.
'The chair umpire has to make the call,' 2024 U.S. Open finalist Fritz said. 'Why is he there if he's not going to call the ball?'
___
More AP tennis:
https://apnews.com/hub/tennis
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC Sports
12 minutes ago
- NBC Sports
Taylor Fritz beats Karen Khachanov for his first semifinal at Wimbledon
LONDON (AP) — Taylor Fritz recovered from a mid-match lull during which he was treated by a trainer for a foot problem and reached the Wimbledon semifinals for the first time with a 6-3, 6-4, 1-6, 7-6 (4) victory over Karen Khachanov on Tuesday. The No. 5-seeded Fritz, an American who was the runner-up at last year's U.S. Open, came in with a 1-4 record in major quarterfinals, 0-2 at Wimbledon. He'll now meet either two-time defending champion Carlos Alcaraz of Spain or unseeded Cam Norrie of Britain for a berth in the final. Fritz powered his way to a big early lead against No. 17 Khachanov, taking 40 of his 47 service points across the initial two sets and never facing a break chance in that span. But then two-time major semifinalist Khachanov grabbed eight of nine games. It was during that stretch that Fritz took a medical timeout, removing his right shoe and sock so the trainer could retape the foot. Khachanov broke to begin the fourth set, in a game in which Fritz's top serve was 117 mph, 18 mph slower than his fastest of the match to that point. He looked up at his guest box and tapped his racket against his thighs, perhaps indicating that he was dealing with some fatigue. From 2-0 down in the fourth, though, Fritz began to regain his strength and touch, and was just two points from victory a total of three times while up 5-4 and 6-5. But Khachanov got things to the tiebreaker, where the score was 4-all, before Fritz claimed the final trio of points. Fritz finished with 16 aces and reached a top speed of 138 mph by the end. Khachanov, never past the quarterfinals at Wimbledon, fell to 0-11 in Grand Slam matches against opponents ranked in the top five.
Chicago Tribune
21 minutes ago
- Chicago Tribune
American Taylor Fritz reaches his 1st Wimbledon semifinal with a 4-set victory
LONDON — Taylor Fritz recovered from a mid-match lull during which a trainer treated him for a foot problem, and the American reached the Wimbledon semifinals for the first time with a 6-3, 6-4, 1-6, 7-6 (4) victory over Karen Khachanov on Tuesday. The fifth-seeded Fritz, who was the runner-up at last year's U.S. Open, came in with a 1-4 record in Grand Slam quarterfinals, including 0-2 at Wimbledon. He'll meet either two-time defending champion Carlos Alcaraz of Spain or unseeded Cam Norrie of Britain for a berth in the final. Fritz powered his way to a big early lead against No. 17 Khachanov, taking 40 of his 47 service points across the initial two sets and never facing a break chance in that span. But then two-time major semifinalist Khachanov grabbed eight of nine games. It was during that stretch that Fritz took a medical timeout, removing his right shoe and sock so the trainer could retape the foot. Khachanov broke to begin the fourth set in a game in which Fritz's top serve was 117 mph — 18 mph slower than his fastest of the match to that point. He looked up at his guest box and tapped his racket against his thighs, perhaps indicating he was dealing with fatigue. From 2-0 down in the fourth, though, Fritz began to regain his strength and touch and was just two points from victory a total of three times while up 5-4 and 6-5. But Khachanov got things to the tiebreaker, where the score was 4-4 before Fritz claimed the final three points. Fritz finished with 16 aces and reached a top speed of 138 mph by the end. Khachanov, who never has gone past the quarterfinals at Wimbledon, fell to 0-11 in Grand Slam matches against opponents ranked in the top five.
Yahoo
21 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Who is Laura Siegemund? Women's tennis player taking on No. 1 Aryna Sabalenka at Wimbledon
Wimbledon is heating up on both sides of the men's and women's singles brackets. Tuesday's women's quarterfinal between No. 1 seed Aryna Sabalenka and Germany's Laura Siegemund turned out to be a thriller, reaching a deciding third set. Advertisement Siegemund, the 37-year-old veteran, took the first set 6-2, but Sabalenka responded by taking the second and third sets 6-2, 6-4 to advance to the women's semifinal. Jul 4, 2025; Wimbledon, United Kingdom; Laura Siegemund of Germany reacts to a point during her match against Madison Keys of the United States on day five at the All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club. Mandatory Credit: Susan Mullane-Imagn Images Here are three things to know about Siegemund, who gave Sabalenka all she could handle on Tuesday: Laura Siegemund's big Wimbledon showing The 37-year-old Siegemund was playing in her first Wimbledon singles quarterfinal this year. She is the oldest woman to make it this far in the Open Era. Doubles titles Siegemund has won 14 Women's Tennis Association doubles titles, including the 2020 U.S. Open with doubles partner Vera Zvonareva. She also won mixed titles at the 2016 U.S. Open and 2024 French Open. Advertisement Highest singles ranking Siegemund was ranked as high as No. 27 in the world in August 2016. This article originally appeared on Who is Laura Siegemund? Women's tennis player vs. No. 1 Aryna Sabalenka at Wimbledon
