logo
5 faulty flyovers, but action taken only in 1 in Ahmedabad

5 faulty flyovers, but action taken only in 1 in Ahmedabad

Time of India2 days ago
Ahmedabad: Despite recurring structural and safety issues in five major flyovers built in the last decade by the Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation (AMC) and the Ahmedabad Urban Development Authority (Auda), municipal authorities on Thursday took action in only one case — the Hatkeshwar flyover.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
On Thursday, AMC's standing committee approved the demolition of the Hatkeshwar flyover in Khokhra, just five years after its Rs 34 crore construction. This marks the first such demolition in the city's 152-year civic history. The remaining four cases continue without punitive action against contractors or consultants, raising serious concerns over accountability and public safety. Deputy municipal commissioner Mirant Parikh confirmed that the Hatkeshwar bridge will be dismantled from the pile cap bottom level at a cost of Rs 3.90 crore.
"The process will take six months, and the cost will be recovered from Ajay Eng Infra Pvt Ltd, the original contractor, by withholding payment for the Pallav Junction flyover in Naranpura," said Parikh.
AMC has blacklisted both the contractor and the project management consultancy, suspended four officials, and initiated inquiries — measures almost absent in other similar cases.
A series of structural failures and quality lapses have repeatedly raised questions about oversight, accountability, and long-term safety in public infrastructure projects executed by the two civic bodies.
In 2015, a portion of the Khokhra Railway flyover collapsed, injuring one person, yet no formal investigation into negligence was carried out. Two years later, Auda's Vakil Saheb flyover developed a significant pothole days after opening — again, with no punitive action taken.
In 2021, the slab of the under-construction Mumatpura flyover collapsed, but no significant action has followed, even after four years.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
Likewise, in July 2022, a pothole appeared on the Khodiyar Container Overbridge on SG Highway, but there was no public disclosure of any disciplinary measures. In yet another case, Auda's Rs 96 crore Sanathal flyover on SP Ring Road developed potholes merely three months after its May 2023 inauguration.
Though resurfacing work was ordered, no penalties were imposed on the contractor.
Flyover Faults Persist, Action Remains Rare
1. Khodiyar Container Overbridge (July 2022):
A large pothole appeared under the Khodiyar Container Overbridge just a year after opening, exposing soil erosion likely caused by drainage leakage.
Temporary fixes were applied, but no investigation, penalties, or repair audits were made public.
2. Mumatpura Flyover Slab Collapse (Dec 2021):
A slab of the under-construction Auda's Mumatpura flyover collapsed in Dec 2021. Though an inquiry was initiated, no report was released. The contractor resumed work despite an order that he won't be allowed to participate in Auda tenders for three years, facing only limited restrictions.
3. Vakil Saheb Flyover, Bopal (2017):
Days after its inauguration, a major pothole appeared on the Vakil Saheb Flyover. Auda dismissed it as minor and unrelated to structure. No inspection report was released, and the contractor faced no penalties or blacklisting.
4. Khokhra Railway Flyover Collapse (Oct 2015)
The 50-year-old Khokhra Railway Flyover partially collapsed, injuring one person. Though it was later rebuilt at Rs 75 crore, no inquiry was conducted into why the deteriorating structure remained operational or how the collapse occurred.
BOX 2
Tumultuous decade (2015-2025)
Project Overview: Cost Rs 34 crore; Contractor: Ajay Eng. Infra Pvt Ltd
Work order issued : April 2015
Construction completed : Oct 2017
Structural Issues: Six cracks appeared between 2017 and 2022; a major crack in July 2022 led to its closure. The bridge has remained shut for three years
Material Testing: Core cutting tests in Mumbai and Ahmedabad labs showed only 20% compression strength
Official Action: AMC issued over 10 notices to the contractor and PMC SGS India Pvt. Ltd.; SVNIT, Surat recommended demolition
Expert Review: A panel including an IIT Roorkee professor and two consultants reviewed the case; pillar strength was also tested
Accountability : AMC blacklisted the contractor and the project management consultant (PMC), approved cost recovery, and filed a police complaint in April 2023
Demolition Plan: Tenders for demolition and reconstruction (Rs 51 crore) were floated in March 2024; approved on July 10, 2025 after multiple failed attempts
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

FSSAI shuts down popular Meghalaya bakery for using newspapers to wrap bread, cakes
FSSAI shuts down popular Meghalaya bakery for using newspapers to wrap bread, cakes

The Print

time22 minutes ago

  • The Print

FSSAI shuts down popular Meghalaya bakery for using newspapers to wrap bread, cakes

In a sweeping crackdown to ensure public food safety, four other eateries were also ordered to close, including Arun Hotel, Maa Kali Hotel, and two fast food outlets. The RB Store outlet is in Police Bazaar area in the state capital. The family-owned bakery has been functioning since 1950. Shillong, Jul 16 (PTI) The Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) have shut down the popular bakery RB Store here for allegedly using newspapers to wrap its items like bread and cakes, in violation of norms, officials said here on Wednesday. Officials said the action was taken following inspections that revealed gross violations of hygiene and food safety regulations. 'These establishments were found to be compromising public health by flouting basic standards. Using newspaper for baking is strictly prohibited as it contains harmful chemicals that can seep into food,' an FSSAI official said. The FSSAI has intensified its drive across the state in recent months, clamping down on shops and eateries found violating safety norms. Several outlets have faced fines, warnings, or closures as part of the regulatory body's efforts to ensure food safety and public health. Under the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006, violators can face penalties ranging from fines of up to Rs 5 lakh to imprisonment in cases involving unsafe or adulterated food. Repeat offenders may face cancellation of licenses and prosecution under relevant provisions of the law. Further investigations are underway, and officials indicated that more surprise inspections are expected in the coming days. PTI JOP NN This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.

CM Mann urges Union food minister to release Punjab's share of Rs 9,000 crore under RDF, market fees
CM Mann urges Union food minister to release Punjab's share of Rs 9,000 crore under RDF, market fees

The Print

time22 minutes ago

  • The Print

CM Mann urges Union food minister to release Punjab's share of Rs 9,000 crore under RDF, market fees

Mann raised the issue of non-allowance of RDF since Kharif Marketing Season (KMS) 2021-“22 and insufficient allowance of market fees since Rabi Marketing Season (RMS) 2022-“23. During a meeting at Joshi's residence here, the chief minister also requested for quick movement of rice grains from the state to enable space for the current season. New Delhi, Jul 16 (PTI) Punjab Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann on Wednesday sought the intervention of Union Food Minister Pralhad Joshi for the release of state's pending share of over Rs 9,000 crore related to the Rural Development Fund (RDF) and market fees. He emphasized that the purpose of RDF is to promote agriculture and rural infrastructure, including the development of rural roads, marketing infrastructure, storage facilities in mandis, and automation and mechanization of mandis. The chief minister said that despite amending the Punjab Rural Development Act, 1987, in accordance with the Department of Food & Public Distribution guidelines, the Punjab's share in RDF has not been released since KMS 2021-“22. Mann stated that Rs 7,737.27 crore under RDF and Rs 1,836.62 crore under market fees are yet to be released by the Centre, a Punjab government's statement said. The chief minister noted that this non-reimbursement has severely impacted the development and maintenance of rural infrastructure and the rural economy in the state. He also highlighted the persistent shortage of covered storage space in the state over the past two years. During KMS 2023-“24, he said that the shortage of space led to the extension of the delivery period for milled rice up to September 30, 2024. Mann said that this caused concern among millers during the last Kharif season, making them initially reluctant to lift and store paddy, adding that the issue was later resolved with the cooperation of central government. The chief minister said that for KMS 2024-“25, out of 117 lakh metric tonnes (LMT) of rice to be delivered to the Food Corporation of India (FCI), only around 107 LMT had been delivered by June 30, 2025. Mann said that only 80 LMT of rice has been moved out of the state in the last 12 months. He further said that although FCI had planned to move 14 LMT in June 2025, only 8.5 LMT was actually lifted. The chief minister stressed the need for the movement of at least 15 LMT of rice in July 2025 to complete milling by July 31. He said that delays may trigger unrest among millers and hinder paddy procurement for KMS 2025-“26, . To optimize storage, he urged the Union minister to adopt a proactive approach to identifying, approving, and hiring covered godown. Mann said that a strategy of converting covered godowns of wheat to rice needs to be implemented. This strategy could free up 7 LMT of capacity for rice storage in KMS 2025-“26, he said, adding that this model be adopted nationwide to mitigate space shortages. Raising the issue of 'arthia' (agent) commission, the chief minister said that the Union government had de-linked the commission from MSP in Kharif season 2020-“21. PTI SKC KVK KVK This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store