Secret Mathematical Rule Has Shaped Bird Beaks For 200 Million Years
Bird beaks come in almost every shape and size - from the straw-like beak of a hummingbird to the slicing, knife-like beak of an eagle.
We have found, however, that this incredible diversity is underpinned by a hidden mathematical rule that governs the growth and shape of beaks in nearly all living birds.
What's more, this rule even describes beak shape in the long-gone ancestors of birds - the dinosaurs. We are excited to share our findings, now published in the journal iScience.
By studying beaks in light of this mathematical rule, we can understand how the faces of birds and other dinosaurs evolved over 200 million years. We can also find out why, in rare instances, these rules can be broken.
When nature follows the rules
Finding universal rules in biology is rare and difficult - there seem to be few instances where physical laws are so pervasive across all organisms.
But when we do find a rule, it's a powerful way to explain the patterns we see in nature. Our team previously discovered a new rule of biology that explains the shape and growth of many pointed structures, including teeth, horns, hooves, shells and, of course, beaks.
This simple mathematical rule captures how the width of a pointed structure, like a beak, expands from the tip to the base. We call this rule the "power cascade".
After this discovery, we were very interested in how the power cascade might explain the shape of bird and other dinosaur beaks.
Dinosaurs got their beaks more than once
Most dinosaurs, like Tyrannosaurus rex, have a robust snout with pointed teeth. But some dinosaurs (like the emu-like dinosaur Ornithomimus edmontonicus) did not have any teeth at all and instead had beaks.
In theropods, the group of dinosaurs that T. rex belonged to, beaks evolved at least six times. Each time, the teeth were lost and the snout stretched to a beak shape over millions of years.
But only one of these impeccable dinosaur groups survived the mass extinction event 66 million years ago. These survivors eventually became our modern-day birds.
The early bird catches the rule
To investigate the power cascade rule of growth, we researched 127 species of theropods. We found that 95% of theropod beaks and snouts follow this rule.
Using state-of-the-art evolutionary analyses through computer modelling, we demonstrated that the ancestral theropod most likely had a toothed snout that followed the power cascade rule.
Excitingly, this suggests that the power cascade describes the growth of not just theropod beaks and snouts, but perhaps the snouts of all vertebrates: mammals, reptiles and fish.
The rule followers and breakers
After surviving the mass extinction, birds underwent a period of incredible change. Birds now live all over the world and their beaks are adapted to each place in very special ways.
We see beak shapes for eating fruit, netting insects, piercing and tearing meat, and even sipping nectar. The majority follow the power cascade growth rule.
While rare, a few birds we studied were rule-breakers. One such rule-breaker is the Eurasian spoonbill, whose highly specialised beak shape helps it sift through the mud to capture aquatic life. Perhaps its unique feeding style led to it breaking this common rule.
We are not upset at all about rule-breakers like the spoonbill. On the contrary, this further highlights how informative the power cascade truly is. Most bird beaks grow according to our rule, and those beaks can cater to most feeding styles.
But occasionally, oddballs like the spoonbill break the power cascade growth rule to catch their special "worms".
Now that we know that most bird and dinosaur beaks follow the power cascade, the next big step in our research is to study how bird beaks grow from chick to adult.
If the power cascade is truly a foundational growth rule in bird beaks, we may expect to find it hiding in many other forms across the tree of life.
(Author: Kathleen Garland, PhD Candidate, School of Biological Sciences, Monash University and Alistair Evans, Professor, School of Biological Sciences, Monash University)
(Disclaimer Statement: Kathleen Garland receives funding from the Australian Government, Monash University and Museums Victoria.
Alistair Evans receives funding from the Australian Research Council and Monash University, and is an Honorary Research Affiliate with Museums Victoria.)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
10 hours ago
- Time of India
Meet the Goblin Prince: Newly discovered dinosaur-era lizard looks like it crawled out of a myth
Sometimes, groundbreaking scientific discoveries don't come from deep digs in far-off deserts. Sometimes, they're hiding in plain sight—in this case, in a tiny jar sitting in a dusty museum drawer in Utah. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now That's where a new species of prehistoric armored lizard—yes, armored—was just identified, and it's got a name straight out of Middle-earth. Meet Bolg amondol, a spiky, tank-like lizard that lived around 76 million years ago during the Late Cretaceous period. It was about three to four feet long, covered in body armor, and definitely not the kind of lizard you'd want to mess with. Think of it as a mini dinosaur-age monster, one that roamed ancient Utah alongside T. rex and other big-name dinos—and held its own. From 'lizard' drawer to lizard legend The story of Bolg amondol started not in the field but at the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County, where paleontologist Dr. Hank Woolley was going through drawers labeled with basic terms like 'lizard.' Inside one drawer, he found a small jar filled with fossil fragments—skull pieces, limb bones, vertebrae, and those signature osteoderms (bony plates under the skin). The fossils had been sitting there for decades, unstudied and unlabeled beyond the generic tag. But once Woolley took a closer look, he realized he was holding something special. The bones were surprisingly well-preserved—enough to piece together a nearly complete picture of the animal. And it was unlike anything paleontologists had seen before. What kind of creature was Bolg? Bolg amondol wasn't your average lizard. It belonged to a group called Monstersauria—the ancient ancestors of today's Gila monsters and beaded lizards. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now These creatures weren't massive like the dinosaurs they lived beside, but they were tough. Bolg had sharp, spiked teeth, armored skin, and a bony, ridged skull that looked like it was built for battle. Its name reflects its fierce look. 'Bolg' is a nod to the goblin prince in The Hobbit, while 'amondol' comes from Tolkien's Elvish, meaning 'mound head'—a reference to its thick, armored skull. Nerdy? Absolutely. Fitting? Even more so. Scientists believe Bolg was a bold little predator, probably snacking on insects, small vertebrates, and even dinosaur eggs when it could. Its armored body would have offered protection while it slinked around ancient floodplains on the hunt. A peek into prehistoric ecosystems What makes Bolg's discovery even cooler is the context. It was found in southern Utah's Kaiparowits Formation, a fossil hotspot that paints a detailed picture of life in Late Cretaceous North America. In the same region, scientists have uncovered several large lizards, suggesting a diverse and thriving community of mid-sized predators living alongside the giants. One of the most fascinating details? Bolg amondol has close relatives in Asia, suggesting these monstersaurs weren't just local legends—they were international travelers. This supports the idea that, back in the day, animals could move freely between continents using land bridges that connected North America and Asia. And the fact that this amazing creature was sitting in a museum drawer for years, unnoticed? It's a perfect reminder of just how much we still have to learn from fossils that have already been found but never fully studied. So next time you walk past a museum display or peek into an old collection, remember: the next great discovery might not require a shovel—just a closer look.
Time of India
7 days ago
- Time of India
10 birds from the time of dinosaurs and how they looked like
The article explores the evolutionary link between dinosaurs and modern birds, highlighting various bird-like creatures from the Mesozoic Era. Fossils reveal a mix of reptilian and avian traits in these early birds, showcasing the gradual development of flight. These ancient species, though now extinct, provide crucial insights into avian evolution and the origins of modern birds. When we think of dinosaurs, massive creatures like Tyrannosaurus rex or Triceratops come to mind. But what many don't realize is that modern birds are direct descendants of dinosaurs. In fact, some bird-like creatures lived alongside the giant reptiles of the Mesozoic Era. These early birds were part of an interesting evolutionary journey, gradually shifting from reptilian ancestors to the feathered friends we know today. Fossils from millions of years ago reveal that bird-like dinosaurs and early birds coexisted, with many of them showing a mix of traits, like feathers, wings, claws, and teeth. Some could glide, others may have just flapped, and most of those avian ancestors looked far more bizarre than any bird we see now. Though they're extinct, these ancient birds left behind clues that have helped scientists understand how flight evolved and how birds became what they are today. Here are 10 bird species from the age of dinosaurs Archaeopteryx Archaeopteryx lived around 150 million years ago and is often called the first true bird. It had feathered wings like modern birds but also sharp teeth, claws on its wings, and a long, bony tail, clear signs of being dinosaur ancestors. Confuciusornis Confuciusornis appeared around 125 million years ago in China. It had a beak with no teeth and long tail feathers, probably for display. Though it resembled modern birds, it still had clawed fingers and likely wasn't a strong flier. Ichthyornis Living about 90 million years ago, Ichthyornis looked a lot like today's seabirds but with one key difference that it had sharp teeth. Its strong wings and sleek body suggest it was a skilled flier, likely hunting fish by diving into waters from the air. Hesperornis Hesperornis lived in the Late Cretaceous and was more like a prehistoric penguin. It couldn't fly but was an excellent swimmer, using its strong legs and teeth-filled jaws to catch fish in the seas of ancient North America. Jeholornis Jeholornis, from around 120 million years ago, had a long, feathered tail and teeth in its beak. Though it had wings, it probably didn't fly well. It may have used its feathers more for gliding or display than for a stable flight. Rahonavis Rahonavis was a small, feathered creature from Madagascar that lived about 70 million years ago. Though it was tiny, it had strong legs and arms with claws, suggesting it may have been flexible and comfortable in trees and possibly capable of powered flight. Sapeornis Sapeornis lived about 125 million years ago and had a mix of bird and dinosaur traits. It had long wings and could glide or fly short distances. With claws on its wings and a primitive tail, it looked like a bird in making. Enantiornithes This entire group of birds survived during the Cretaceous period but went extinct with the dinosaurs. They had teeth, clawed wings, and varied in size and shape. They were widespread and successful, but no direct descendants survive today. Anchiornis Anchiornis had feathers and wings but wasn't quite a bird. It lived about 160 million years ago and had four feathered limbs both arms and legs, which could be a hint at an early stage in the evolution of flight. It likely glided more than flew. Patagopteryx Patagopteryx lived around 80 million years ago and was completely flightless. About the size of a chicken, it had strong legs for running and small wings that couldn't support flight. It's one of the earliest examples of a bird that adapted to life on the ground.
Time of India
20-06-2025
- Time of India
Meet the 'Dragon Prince': New dinosaur discovery rewrites the Tyrannosaur family tree
A fascinating fossil discovery in Mongolia has uncovered a new species of dinosaur that could reshape everything we thought we knew about the evolution of Tyrannosaurs. Named Khankhuuluu Mongoliensis, or "Dragon Prince of Mongolia", this 86-million-year-old predator is now considered the closest known ancestor of the fearsome Tyrannosaurus rex. With its transitional traits and smaller size, the find reveals a crucial evolutionary chapter between small, agile hunters and the massive apex predators that ruled the Late Cretaceous. Scientists say the discovery, buried for decades in a museum collection, offers fresh insight into how Tyrannosaurs evolved their powerful bite, skull shape, and dominant ecological role in both Asia and North America. A dinosaur fossil of 'Dragon Price' hidden in plain sight The partial skeletons that led to this discovery were actually excavated in Mongolia back in the 1970s. At the time, they were thought to belong to a species called Alectrosaurus. It wasn't until PhD student Jared Voris took a closer look, decades later, that the unique features of this new species began to emerge. Working alongside Professor Darla Zelenitsky from the University of Calgary, Voris spotted key differences in the skull and nasal bones that clearly separated it from other known dinosaurs. What is Khankhuuluu Mongoliensis Named after the word for 'dragon' in Mongolian and the region it was found in, Khankhuuluu Mongoliensis bridges a crucial gap in the Tyrannosaur timeline. Weighing around 750 kilograms, it was far smaller than the T. rex, which could tip the scales at over 6 tonnes. But it had key traits that hint at the future kings of the dinosaur world. Its skull showed signs of strengthening, and its jaw was developing the structure needed for the bone-crushing bite Tyrannosaurs are known for. The evolution of Tyrannosaurs Early members of the Tyrannosaur family were small, quick-footed hunters living in the shadows of larger meat-eaters. Khankhuuluu represents a shift from these agile predators towards the bulkier, more powerful giants of the Late Cretaceous. With stronger jaws and a larger build than its predecessors, it shows how evolution favoured size and strength over time. These adaptations eventually led to the dominance of species like T. rex, which could take down massive prey and even crush bones. A journey across continents Another important insight from this discovery is the role of ancient land bridges between Asia and North America. During the Late Cretaceous period, areas like Siberia and Alaska were connected, allowing species like Tyrannosaurs to migrate and evolve in new environments. This movement helped spark the emergence of distinct groups on different continents, explaining how similar predators could be found in both Asia and North America. Rewriting the family tree With the addition of Khankhuuluu Mongoliensis to the record, palaeontologists now have a clearer picture of how Tyrannosaurs evolved. It fills a key gap between the small early forms and the gigantic predators that came later. The findings, published in the journal Nature, could prompt scientists to revisit other old fossils that may have been misclassified. This discovery serves as a reminder that sometimes the answers to big questions have been waiting quietly in storage. What museum collections can still teach us What makes this story even more remarkable is that the fossil had been sitting in a Mongolian museum for over 40 years. It highlights how valuable museum collections are and how new techniques, fresh perspectives and even young researchers can uncover major breakthroughs from existing specimens. Not every discovery requires a dig, some are hidden in plain sight. Before the kings, there were princes The discovery of Khankhuuluu Mongoliensis gives us a rare look at the early days of a dynasty. While this dinosaur didn't have the size or fearsome presence of its famous descendants, it carried the building blocks of what would become one of Earth's most iconic predators. As Professor Zelenitsky put it, 'Before Tyrannosaurs became the kings, they were princes.' And this dragon prince may just be the missing link we didn't know we needed.
