Can taxis and ride-hailing services co-exist in Hong Kong under new rules?
Industry insiders added that the Transport and Logistics Bureau faced several challenges in achieving all three objectives.
Secretary for Transport and Logistics Mable Chan, who took office last December, told lawmakers on Friday of her determination to resolve the long-standing conflict between taxis and ride-hailing services. Taxi drivers have repeatedly raised concerns that many Uber drivers do not hold valid hire-car permits while platforms have argued they provided better service.
The bureau unveiled its regulatory blueprint earlier last week, outlining a comprehensive framework for governing drivers, vehicles and platform operators.
Besides listing the necessary licences and permits that operators and drivers must hold, the proposal also includes a yet to be specified cap on the number of vehicles providing ride-hailing services and a levy imposed on platforms for each trip.
Officials have cited the experience of the Australian state of Victoria, which introduced a levy to compensate cabbies affected by the legalisation of ride-hailing platforms.
The government will also charge platforms a licensing fee based on the number of vehicles they operate.
US-based Uber started operating locally in 2014 and had taken a dominant position until recent years as Tada, Amap and Didi Chuxing entered the market. Amap is operated by Alibaba Group Holding, which also owns the South China Morning Post.
'Once the ride-hailing sector is opened up and legalised, it will be the beginning of a new era,' lawmaker Michael Tien Puk-sun said. 'I think that the demand is very big, especially with how severe extreme weather is nowadays.'
Tien added that he believed demand in the city in the next five years could support a similar number of ride-hailing vehicles seen in Singapore. The city state currently has 59,371 such cars as of 2024, according to official data.
Observers also noted that the government aimed to take a slice of the lucrative ride-hailing sector, curb the influence of platforms through regulation and charges, and support the taxi trade, a move which comes amid the launch of a premium cab fleet.
Although the planned legal framework is pending further details, Ringo Lee Yiu-pui, governor and honorary life president of the Hong Kong, China Automobile Association, said the effectiveness of these strategies depended on whether the government could balance the different interests of all sides.
Lawmaker Tien said he believed that the regulatory regime could meet the government's multiple goals.
He said he did not think that cabbies would be forced out of the market as they still had the advantage of being able to pick up customers on the street, despite competition from ride-hailing operators.
The bureau's survey conducted between November last year and January led to an estimate that showed ride-hailing services accounted for 22 per cent of 880,000 point-to-point trips with passengers a day, with the rest being taxis.
In response to complaints about taxi drivers from tourists, who often cited cherry-picking of passengers and overcharging, the government issued its first of five taxi fleet licences earlier this week. The premium taxi fleets are designed to offer enhanced services at a higher fare.
Walter Theseira, associate professor of economics at the Singapore University of Social Sciences, said that the ride-hailing sector had expanded rapidly with legalisation in Singapore and other markets, and he expected that the situation would be similar in Hong Kong.
'When ride-hailing becomes either legal or more tacitly endorsed, it expands very quickly and it [does so] largely because ride-hailing offers a superior consumer experience to traditional taxis,' he said.
'The main innovations actually being the online booking systems, tracking of your vehicle and everything, feedback, as well as fixed fares that are based on supply and demand.'
He added that in Singapore's experience, many drivers had also decided to switch to ride-hailing after realising the greater earning potential afforded by these platforms.
Whether ride-hailing platform operators could stay ahead, however, depended on if the taxi sector could implement practices such as app-based bookings, ratings and driver management.
The academic said that taxis were unlikely to disappear from Hong Kong's transport landscape. Instead, he expected cabbies might prefer ride-hailing systems or apps to find customers.
Theseira also raised concerns about the fairness of potentially only charging a levy on the ride-hailing sector, as well as how the taxi industry should be supported by authorities.
'Taxi drivers and operators, if you're going to support them, they should be supported to adapt to whatever market practices have been proven to be commercially successful by commuters in terms of those ride-hailing practices,' he said.
'It is not to support them to do the same old thing, unless that is really what commuters want.' -- SOUTH CHINA MORNING POST
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
17 minutes ago
- The Star
Police detain former eFishery CEO who faked data
Police have detained the co-founder of eFishery Pte, investigating a startup whose collapse shook up South-East Asia's investment and tech community. Gibran Huzaifah was detained last week by the white-collar crimes division, the police said. He and two other former eFishery executives have remained in custody since July 31, according to a text message from Helfi Assegaf, director of special economic crimes at the National Police's Criminal Investigation Agency. The three have been 'officially named as suspects,' according to the police, though it was unclear if any have been officially charged with wrongdoing. Apart from Gibran, they detained and named two other suspects in the probe, Angga Hadrian Raditya and Andri Yadi. Both are former vice-presidents and had been interviewed by internal investigators. Gibran's detention comes months after he gave a detailed account of how he inflated revenue at a startup once valued north of US$1bil (RM4.2bil). Its ultimate collapse dealt a blow to several of the world's highest-profile investors from SoftBank Group Corp and Temasek Holdings Pte to Peak XV (formerly Sequoia India) and Abu Dhabi's 42XFund. The company, which deployed feeders to fish and shrimp farmers in Indonesia, incurred several hundred million dollars in losses between 2018 and 2024, Bloomberg News has reported. EFishery, which was valued at US$1.4bil (RM5.9bil) after a 2023 funding round, had been one of the highest-profile startups to emerge from Indonesia. — Bloomberg
The Star
an hour ago
- The Star
Oil prices fall on Opec+ output hikes
Brent crude futures settled US$1.12, or 1.63%, lower to US$67.64 a barrel, while US West Texas Intermediate crude slipped US$1.13, or 1.7%, to US$65.16. NEW YORK: Oil prices slipped on Tuesday as rising Opec+ supply and worries of weaker global demand countered concern about US President Donald Trump's threats to India over its Russian oil purchases. Brent crude futures settled US$1.12, or 1.63%, lower to US$67.64 a barrel, while US West Texas Intermediate crude slipped US$1.13, or 1.7%, to US$65.16. Both benchmarks settled to their lowest in five weeks. The Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries and its allies, together known as Opec+, agreed on Sunday to raise oil production by 547,000 barrels per day for September, a move that will end its most recent output cut earlier than planned. "The significant increase in Opec supplies is weighing on the market," said Andrew Lipow, president of Lipow Oil Associates. Also weighing on prices, US services sector activity unexpectedly flatlined in July with little change in orders and a further weakening in employment even as input costs climbed by the most in nearly three years, underscoring the ongoing drag of uncertainty over the Trump administration's tariff policy on businesses. "The market now is going to see if India and China agree to substantially reduce the purchases of Russian crude oil, thereby looking for alternative supplies elsewhere," Lipow said. Trump on Tuesday again threatened higher tariffs on Indian goods over the country's Russian oil purchases over the next 24 hours. Trump also said declining energy prices could pressure Russian President Vladimir Putin to halt the war in Ukraine. New Delhi called Trump's threat "unjustified" and vowed to protect its economic interests, deepening a trade rift between the two countries. Oil's move since Trump's threat indicates that traders are sceptical of a supply disruption happening, John Evans of oil broker PVM said in a report. He questioned whether Trump would risk higher oil prices. "I'd call it a stable market for oil," said Giovanni Staunovo, an analyst at UBS. "Assume this likely continues until we figure out what the US president announces in respect to Russia later this week and how those buyers would react." India is the biggest buyer of seaborne crude from Russia, importing about 1.75 million bpd from January to June this year, up 1% from a year ago, according to data provided to Reuters by trade sources. US crude inventories fell by 4.2 million barrels last week, sources citing American Petroleum Institute figures said on Tuesday. The US Energy Information Administration is due to release weekly U.S. inventory data on Wednesday, respectively. — Reuters
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
13MP – RM1 trillion semiconductor exports by 2030 target ‘ambitious yet achievable'
PETALING JAYA: Malaysia's plan to boost semiconductor exports to RM1 trillion by 2030, a centrepiece of the 13th Malaysia Plan (13MP), has been hailed as ambitious yet achievable by industry leaders, though economists warn that structural reforms will be key to ensuring the benefits translate into broader economic gains. Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, in tabling the 13MP, identified semiconductors as one of the flagship high-growth, high-value industries vital to Malaysia's transition to high-income status and deeper integration into global technology supply chains. Malaysia Semiconductor Industry Association president Andrew Chan said the nation's recent performance and policy direction provide a solid foundation for the RM1 trillion export target. 'Malaysia's E&E exports reached RM601 billion in 2024, and with the global semiconductor market projected to double to US$1 trillion (RM4.23 trillion) by 2030, driven largely by the surge in demand for AI chips, Malaysia's RM1 trillion export target is both ambitious and attainable,' Chan told SunBiz. He highlighted RM319 billion in approved investments between 2021 and 2024, alongside the rollout of the National Semiconductor Strategy (NSS), launched in May 2024 and updated in July 2025, as pivotal enablers for the industry. 'These developments lay a strong foundation for growth,' he said, pointing to foreign direct investments from global giants like Intel and Infineon as well as the rapid scaling of local champions such as Inari and Vitrox. Chan stressed, however, that incremental growth would not be enough. 'Success will require us to make hard choices and sacrifices,' he said. 'It demands a deliberate pivot into high-value segments such as IC design, advanced packaging, semiconductor equipment manufacturing, wafer fabrication and particularly the design and production of AI chips and servers, where global demand will be most pronounced.' Chan noted that Malaysia's current strength lies in outsourced semiconductor assembly and testing services but argued that capturing greater value will require moving into front-end manufacturing and design, areas currently dominated by economies like Taiwan, South Korea and the United States. 'One area for greater focus is on a more coordinated talent development strategy, especially skills for the new growth areas. What got Malaysia to where we are today will not get us to RM1 trillion in E&E exports by 2030.' While agreeing that semiconductors will be a key growth engine, economist Professor Geoffrey Williams cautioned against viewing the sector's success as a panacea for Malaysia's broader economic challenges. 'These high-value sectors are largely market-driven, and government interference is often unnecessary,' he said. 'The most important features of 13MP are actually the social and structural elements, the extension of the minimum wage, the review of the retirement age and reforms to pensions and healthcare.' Williams argued that without parallel reforms to raise incomes, address underemployment and open up opportunities for SMEs, semiconductor gains risk being concentrated among larger corporations and global players. 'Technology and green growth are already unfolding organically,' he added. 'Structural reforms are needed to ensure these gains benefit the wider economy and address long-standing issues like wage stagnation and job quality.' The 13MP's semiconductor strategy builds on the NSS's targets to create 10 local companies with revenues exceeding US$210 million each, nurture 100 firms approaching US$1 billion revenue and train 60,000 skilled engineers by 2030. Economists say the combination of surging global demand, particularly for AI chips and Malaysia's established role in the electronics supply chain creates a unique opportunity. However, they warn that talent bottlenecks, infrastructure gaps and uneven SME participation must be addressed for the RM1 trillion target to translate into inclusive growth.
