Bring back the whip, says Minister Groenewald
Should a person who steals ten loaves of bread be sent to prison for years, or given a painful walloping and sent home?
That's the debate Correctional Services Minister Pieter Groenewald has ignited after suggesting South Africa consider bringing back corporal punishment for petty criminals who can't afford bail. Speaking during a parliamentary discussion on the country's 2025 correctional services budget, Groenewald said the justice system was collapsing under the weight of overcrowded prisons, and bold ideas were needed.
'There are people sitting in prison for stealing food,' Groenewald said. 'Some wait up to three years for sentencing. Isn't it time we asked ourselves — should we bring back corporal punishment?'
He was referring to more than 2,500 detainees who are stuck in prison simply because they can't afford a bail of R1 000 or less.
These are often people accused of small, non-violent crimes. And they're part of a bigger crisis: South Africa has over 104 000 people in prison, in facilities built for far fewer. Beds are limited. Staff is stretched thin.
And many of those awaiting trial don't need to be behind bars at all. But Groenewald's solution, physical punishment, has divided the country.
For some, the idea is too close to South Africa's dark history. Human rights groups and political opponents quickly pushed back, saying the suggestion reminded them of the harsh justice handed out under apartheid, where the state used caning and other physical punishments as tools of control.'
This isn't just about crime and punishment,' said a human rights lawyer. 'This is about dignity. This is about a state choosing whether to treat people as human beings or not.'The mention of corporal punishment immediately brought comparisons to apartheid's security forces, who were notorious for using violence under the name of justice.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The South African
6 hours ago
- The South African
Popcru rejects call to bring back corporal punishment in prisons
The Police and Prisons Civil Rights Union (Popcru) has rejected Correctional Services Minister Pieter Groenewald's call to reintroduce corporal punishment in South African prisons, calling it a dangerous step backwards for human rights and justice reform. Groenewald suggested the return of corporal punishment during a parliamentary budget debate, claiming it could address prison overcrowding caused by inmates who cannot afford bail. Over 60 000 people are in custody awaiting trial, with more than 2000 unable to pay bail amounts of less than R1000. 'We reject in the strongest terms the notion of using violence as a tool of correction,' said Popcru spokesperson Richard Mamabolo, according to Jacaranda FM News. ADVERTISEMENT Constitutional Rights, which abolished corporal punishment under threat Mamabolo warned that the proposal undermines decades of legal progress, particularly the Constitutional Court ruling in State v Williams and Others (1995), which abolished corporal punishment in South Africa. 'Groenewald proposes not only a reversal of legal progress but an erosion of a rights-based society,' he said. Popcru argues that the justice system should uphold rehabilitation and reintegration, not corporal punishment. The union emphasised that correctional centres are not institutions for revenge or dehumanisation, but places meant for safe custody and positive transformation of offenders. Rising Costs and Overcrowding Groenewald told Parliament that overcrowding continues to place severe pressure on prison infrastructure and budgets. He revealed that the state spends more than R11 million daily to accommodate 24 000 foreign nationals in prisons. The union called for long-term solutions that address socioeconomic inequalities and the backlog in court processes rather than reverting to corporal punishment. ADVERTISEMENT Mamabolo stated, bringing back corporal punishment is unconstitutional, dangerous and a direct violation of human rights. Should the state prioritise cost-cutting and crowd control, or defend constitutional principles even in the face of growing pressure on the justice system? Let us know by leaving a comment below or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1. Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
The Citizen
a day ago
- The Citizen
2 Evaton cops and civilian charged in constable's murder
Two police constables appeared in the Sebokeng Magistrate's Court on Tuesday in connection with the murder of Constable Gift Mokoena, who was fatally shot in May 2021. Vaalweekblad reports that Constables Piet Matsoso (38) and Siyabonga Kunene (31), both stationed at Evaton Police Station in Gauteng, and their friend Hofney Morobe (36), face multiple charges, including murder, assault with intent to cause grievous bodily harm, robbery with aggravating circumstances, defeating the ends of justice, and handling a firearm while under the influence of alcohol. According to information provided by the National Prosecuting Authority, the incident occurred on the night of May 16, 2021, in the Golden Gardens area. Matsoso and Kunene were off duty and driving with Morobe when they pursued a vehicle suspected of involvement in a house robbery. The vehicle stopped at a BP petrol station, where the accused allegedly assaulted the four occupants. During the altercation, a cellphone and car keys were reportedly taken from one of the victims. The trio then allegedly drove the victims around before handing them over to members of the CPF. While the victims were in the custody of the CPF, Morobe and Mokoena, who had by then joined the group, allegedly continued the assault. In the course of events, Morobe allegedly fetched Matsoso's service firearm from a vehicle and shot Mokoena. The wounded officer was taken to Nkanyezi Private Hospital in Sebokeng, where he died. The accused surrendered to police on June 30. During their bail application, the state did not oppose release, citing their co-operation and the fact that witnesses are unknown to them. Bail was granted at R1 000 each. The matter was postponed to September 4 for a directive from the Director of Public Prosecutions. At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
The Citizen
2 days ago
- The Citizen
Former Sassa employee jailed for corruption after bribe sting
Limpopo official sentenced to six years for soliciting R1 500 bribe from grant applicant. Sentencing of former Sassa employee for corruption in Polokwane.. Picture: iStock The South African Social Security Agency (Sassa) has welcomed the six-year direct imprisonment sentence. It was handed down to a former employee who was convicted of corruption for soliciting a bribe from a disability grant applicant. Tebogo Floyd Tleane, formerly stationed at Sassa's office in Polokwane, in Limpopo, was sentenced this week by the Specialised Commercial Crimes Court in Polokwane. The case stemmed from a 2014 incident. In that event, a disability grant applicant reported Tleane for demanding R1 500 to process her application. Successful sting operation According to Sassa, its Fraud Management and Compliance Unit launched an internal investigation after receiving the complaint. The matter was swiftly referred to the Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation, known as the Hawks. 'A successful entrapment operation was carried out, resulting in Mr Tleane's arrest on 12 November 2014,' Sassa said in a statement. 'He was subsequently subjected to an internal disciplinary hearing, which led to his dismissal.' After numerous court appearances spanning over a decade, Tleane was found guilty of corruption on 14 March 2025. His bail was increased from R500 to R10 000, and he remained out on bail until sentencing. On Tuesday, the court sentenced him to six years of direct imprisonment. He was also declared unfit to possess a firearm. ALSO READ: Sassa grants: Here are the July payment dates and amounts Zero tolerance for corruption Sassa welcomed the conviction, saying it was a clear demonstration of accountability. 'This conviction sends a clear message that corrupt practices will not be tolerated. Those who abuse their positions of trust will face the full might of the law,' the agency said. Sassa reaffirmed its commitment to 'integrity, transparency, and accountability in all its operations'. It reiterated its zero-tolerance approach to fraud and corruption. NOW READ: Sassa cracks down on beneficiaries flagged for not disclosing income
