YouTuber Tests Tesla's Autopilot Against LiDAR System Musk Once Dismissed
Popular YouTube personality Mark Rober, a former NASA engineer and founder of CrunchLabs, recently compared Tesla's camera-based Autopilot system to a LiDAR-equipped vehicle, reigniting debate about the effectiveness of different autonomous-driving technologies.
Rober, known for engaging science-based experiments, tested the two autonomous technologies side-by-side to evaluate their abilities to detect obstacles on the road. Tesla CEO Elon Musk has previously dismissed LiDAR (Light Detection and Ranging), a system using laser sensors to map surroundings, famously calling it a "fool's errand." Instead, Musk argues that camera-based systems are sufficient and superior for self-driving capabilities.
However, Rober's test highlighted challenges faced by Tesla's Autopilot under difficult driving conditions. When subjected to dense fog, heavy rain, and unusual obstacles like painted walls, Tesla's camera-dependent system struggled to consistently recognize hazards. By contrast, the LiDAR-equipped vehicle reliably detected obstacles in nearly all test scenarios, demonstrating clear advantages under adverse conditions.
In one dramatic demonstration reminiscent of cartoon antics, Rober's setup featured brightly colored, cartoon-like obstacles intended to clearly challenge both systems' detection capabilities. While visually whimsical, the results were eye-opening, prompting a renewed discussion about the practical limitations of camera-only solutions for autonomous driving.
Tesla maintains that cameras and advanced software algorithms, coupled with artificial intelligence, provide sufficient real-world autonomous driving capabilities, avoiding the high costs associated with LiDAR systems. Critics, however, argue that relying solely on cameras compromises safety, particularly in low-visibility conditions.
Rober's findings underscore an ongoing technological debate within the automotive industry: is Musk's commitment to camera-based autonomy visionary or overly optimistic? For now, the experiment provides compelling evidence suggesting that LiDAR may offer critical advantages in ensuring safety and reliability in challenging driving scenarios.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
30 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Tesla's German car sales continue to fall in June
(Reuters) -Tesla's sales volume in Germany fell by 60% in June, the German road traffic agency KBA said on Tuesday, although sales of battery electric vehicles rose overall. KBA said Tesla sold 1,860 cars in Germany in June, down 60% from a year earlier. The number of Teslas sold in the first half of 2025 dropped 58.2% to 8,890 units, compared with the same period last year. By contrast, the total number of newly registered electric vehicles increased by 8.6% in June, KBA added. Error while retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Tesla sales plunge as Elon Musk rages at Trump
Sales at Elon Musk's Tesla have fallen to a three-year low amid the billionaire's public spat with Donald Trump. The electric carmaker said customer deliveries fell by 13.5pc in the second quarter of the year, a period in which Mr Musk left his role in the White House and publicly fell out with the US president over his tax and spending bill. Sales were 384,122 between April and June, down from 443,956 compared to the same quarter a year ago. It is the second straight double-digit drop in quarterly deliveries for Tesla, meaning sales for the year so far are at their lowest since 2022. The figures put Tesla on track for a second successive year of declining sales. Falling demand in recent months has been blamed partially on a political backlash against Mr Musk over his support for Mr Trump. However, growing competition from low-cost Chinese manufacturers has also threatened Tesla's grip on the electric vehicle (EV) market, with Shenzhen-based BYD overtaking Tesla in sales across Britain and Europe in recent months. Meanwhile, Mr Musk has also increasingly focused on Tesla's efforts on his Robotaxi project. The company last week started offering driverless taxi rides in Texas, and Mr Musk has said Tesla will begin production of a Cybercab next year. The decline in Tesla's sales led to heightened scrutiny of Mr Musk's work at the White House, where he sat in on cabinet meetings and spearheaded the department of government efficiency (Doge). This prompted some Tesla investors to raise concerns that Mr Musk was not focused enough on running the company. In April, Tesla revealed that quarterly sales had fallen by 13pc – its biggest drop since 2012. Investors had hoped that an upgrade to its best-selling Model Y would revive sales, but the drop in the second quarter was almost as severe. Tensions between Mr Musk and Mr Trump exploded in the last month, shortly after the South African-born businessman stepped down from the White House. The Tesla boss, who described Mr Trump's 'big beautiful bill' as a 'disgusting abomination', previously claimed the president should be impeached. Mr Trump hit back by threatening to cancel federal contracts for Mr Musk's rocket company, SpaceX. The two briefly held a truce, but the row was reignited this week when Mr Musk threatened to start a new political party and Mr Trump suggested he could deport him. Mr Musk has publicly criticised Mr Trump's bill for adding to the ballooning US deficit, but the legislation also cuts incentives for electric cars and renewable energy, which have boosted Tesla sales. The company's shares fell by 5pc on Tuesday amid the widening rift between the pair, although they rose on Wednesday because the sales drop was less severe than some analysts had feared. Mr Musk has predicted that Tesla will have millions of robotaxis in operation this year. Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Tesla sales slump once again as Musk pays price for Trump ties
Tesla saw its sales fall to a three-year low as the electric car maker continues to suffer from Elon Musk's political views. Customer deliveries fell by 14 per cent in the second quarter of the year, marking one of the company's biggest ever year-over-year declines. Analysts have attributed the drop in demand for Tesla vehicles to Mr Musk's allegiance to US President Donald Trump, which has seen the company's share price drop by more than a quarter since he took office. There have been dozens of protests at Tesla dealerships in the US over Mr Musk's association with the Trump administration, while the tech billionaire's backing of far-right politicians in Europe has also prompted boycotts of the brand. 'Tesla continues to face persistent headwinds in key markets, particularly in China and Europe, where sales have softened due to intensifying competition and growing concerns over brand reputation,' Liz Lee, an associate director at Counterpoint Research, told The Independent. 'In parts of Europe, the political backlash associated with Elon Musk has further dampened demand, prompting localised boycotts.' Tesla's CyberTruck, often referred to as the 'MagaMobile' due to the type of customers it typically attracts, recorded roughly 5,000 sales between April and June, despite the automaker planning for a production capacity of over 250,000 units per year. The Tesla boss has seen his relationship with Mr Trump turn sour in recent weeks, having stepped down from his role at the White House and criticised the US president's 'big beautiful bill'. Mr Musk described the legislation last month as a 'disgusting abomination' for adding to the growing US deficit, while also cutting incentives for electric cars. The feud between the two continued this week, with Mr Trump claiming that Mr Musk has received more government subsidies 'than any human being in history'. He also hinted that Tesla and Mr Musk's other companies should be reviewed by the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE). Tesla's closest rival, the Chinese car manufacturer BYD, saw its sales hit a new high in June. A regulatory filing posted to the Hong Kong stock exchange on Wednesday revealed that BYD's electric vehicle sales have already topped 1 million in 2025. Tesla, which outsold BYD as recently as last year, has only managed 720,803 sales in the first six months of the year. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data
