What are the risks of the government's proposed ‘mixopathy' move?
The Central government recently proposed starting an integrated course – MBBS and Ayurveda medicine, at the Jawaharlal Institute of Postgraduate Medical Education and Research (JIPMER) in Puducherry. This proposed move has evoked a strong response from the Indian Medical Association who has said this unscientific mixing of various systems of medicine will benefit neither doctors, nor patients.
This is not the first move to mix traditional and modern systems of medicine in India – other such measures for instance, have included proposals to allow traditional medical practitioners to prescribe modern medicine after a short course. What are the risks of mixing alternative systems of medicine with the MBBS course? Is there a benefit to integrated systems and if so, how should these be brought in? Has any other country managed to successfully combine alternative systems with modern, evidence based medicine?
Guest: Rajeev Jayadevan is the Chairman, Research Cell, Kerala State IMA, Past President, IMA Cochin
Host: Zubeda Hamid
Edited by Sharmada Venkatasubramanian.
Listen to more In Focus podcasts:
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Gazette
8 hours ago
- India Gazette
'The India Way Experience' event in Shanghai showcases India's traditional healthcare and holistic healing heritage
Shanghai [China], June 28 (ANI): In a celebration of India's booming traditional healthcare economy, the Consulate General of India in Shanghai hosted a special event titled 'The India Way Experience,' spotlighting Ayurveda, Yoga, Meditation, and India's holistic healing heritage and innovations, according to a post by India In Shanghai on social media platform X. 'A Global Resurgence. India's booming Traditional Healthcare Economy. A special event celebrating Ayurveda, Yoga, Meditation & India's unparalleled holistic healing heritage and innovations,' the post read. Organised as part of the International Day of Yoga 2025 (#IDY2025), the event also aimed at building a Diaspora Connect and promoting the vision of One Earth, One Health through sustainable and inclusive wellness practices. 'The India Way Experience with a Diaspora Connect for One One Health,' the post added, underscoring India's global leadership in holistic health and traditional medicine. The broader Indian engagement in China this week also included high-level diplomatic and defence dialogues. On Friday, Defence Minister Rajnath Singh met his Chinese counterpart Admiral Dong Jun on the sidelines of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) Defence Ministers Meeting. During the meeting, Singh stressed the need for effective border management and a permanent resolution to the boundary issue by revitalising the existing mechanisms between the two countries. During the meeting, the two leaders held 'in-depth discussions' on the need to maintain peace and tranquillity along the Indo-China border. Rajnath Singh acknowledged the work being undertaken by the two nations to bring back a semblance of normalcy in the bilateral relations, according to the Ministry of Defence press release. Rajnath Singh highlighted the necessity of solving complex issues through a structured roadmap of permanent engagement and de-escalation. He emphasised the need to create good neighbourly conditions to achieve the best mutual benefits and to cooperate for stability in Asia and the world. He called for bridging the trust deficit created after the 2020 Border standoff by taking action on the ground. In a press release, the Ministry of Defence stated, 'The two Ministers agreed to continue consultations at various levels to achieve progress on issues related to disengagement, de-escalation, border management and eventual delimitation through existing mechanisms.' India and China had reached an agreement in October on patrolling arrangements in the Depsang Plains and Demchok, two friction points along the Line of Actual Control (LAC). The understanding was reached after earlier disengagement in other friction points in eastern Ladakh following meetings at diplomatic and military levels. During the meeting with his Chinese counterpart, Rajnath Singh appreciated the resumption of the Kailash Manasarovar yatra after a gap of five years. He highlighted the important milestone of reaching 75 years since the establishment of diplomatic ties between the two countries. He also briefed his Chinese counterpart on the terrorist attack carried out against innocent civilians in Jammu and Kashmir's Pahalgam on April 22 and India's Operation Sindoor aimed at dismantling the terrorist networks in Pakistan, according to the Ministry of Defence press release. In a post on X, Singh stated, 'Held talks with Admiral Dong Jun, the Defence Minister of China, on the sidelines of the SCO Defence Ministers' Meeting in Qingdao. We had a constructive and forward-looking exchange of views on issues about bilateral relations. Expressed my happiness at the restarting of the Kailash Mansarovar Yatra after a gap of nearly six years. It is incumbent on both sides to maintain this positive momentum and avoid adding new complexities in the bilateral relationship.' Rajnath Singh gifted a Madhubani painting from Bihar to his Chinese counterpart, General Dong Jun, during their meeting on the sidelines of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) Defence Ministers Meeting in China's Qingdao. This painting has its origins in the Mithila region of Bihar. It is also known as Mithila or Madhubani art. It is characterised by line drawings filled in with bright colours and contrasts or patterns. These paintings are popular because of their tribal motifs and use of bright, earthy colours. (ANI)
Time of India
9 hours ago
- Time of India
Ghee vs oil: when to use what and why
Ghee vs oil: when to use what and whyThe great ghee versus oil debate has been around in Indian kitchens for generations. Some love the rich aroma of ghee, while others prefer using their favourite cooking oil for daily meals. Instead of choosing one over the other, it helps to know what each one offers and when to use them for the best flavour and results. Let's break it down in a tasty and easy-to-understand way. Ghee There's a reason many Indian meals include a spoonful of ghee in dal, rice, or even rotis. Ghee is not just about flavour. It is full of healthy fats, helps the body absorb fat-soluble vitamins, and adds richness to even the most basic dishes. It has a high smoke point, which means it stays stable when cooked at high heat, making it ideal for sautéing or slow roasting. Apart from cooking, ghee is also valued in Ayurveda for its healing and digestion-friendly properties. Whether it is mixed into warm khichdi or drizzled over steamed vegetables, ghee brings a soothing, homely flavour that oil usually cannot match. Oil That doesn't mean oil doesn't have its place. The type of oil you choose matters. Think mustard, sesame, groundnut, or even coconut depending on your regional flavours. Each brings its own character and nutritional profile. Oils can be lighter on the stomach, especially for everyday stir-fries, shallow frying, or salad dressings. Mustard oil gives a sharp kick to Bengali or North Indian dishes. Sesame oil works beautifully in South Indian recipes. Coconut oil pairs well with coastal curries. Choosing cold-pressed or filtered oils adds more nutrients and avoids unnecessary processing. So when should you use what Use ghee when you want a richer flavour, especially in traditional Indian cooking like dals, halwas, or parathas. It is also ideal for tempering spices, as the flavours bloom beautifully in ghee. Reach for oil when you're cooking something that needs lighter handling. Tossing vegetables, making a quick sabzi, or letting the oil flavour shine through works best with mustard or sesame oil. Balance is the key Instead of choosing one and leaving out the other, it's better to use both in a smart way. Use ghee for flavour-rich comfort foods or festive meals. Keep your favourite oil for everyday cooking that doesn't need too much richness. Both have their uses and can be part of a healthy kitchen when used thoughtfully. So the next time you head to the stove, take a second to think. Is this a dish that calls for ghee or one that suits oil better? Either way, your food will turn out tasty.
Hindustan Times
10 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Kidney cysts vs. kidney tumour: Urologist shares how to spot the differences
Jun 28, 2025 06:10 PM IST Often kidney cyst and kidney tumour induce the same kind of fear. But according to Dr. Sumit Bansal, consultant – urology, Manipal Hospital Dwarka, New Delhi, they are distinctly different. In an interview with HT Lifestyle, Dr Sumit Bansal said, 'They vary significantly in their nature and implications, even though some of the symptoms overlap. Understanding the distinction between the two conditions is important for early detection.' Also read | Ayurveda for kidney: 7 reasons for kidney disease in women, Ayurvedic tips that can help in managing them Know the early warning signs of kidney cysts and kidney tumour.(Shutterstock) 'Kidney cysts are water-filled cavities in the kidney. Simple cysts are not cancerous and usually do not cause any problems, but if the cyst has a solid component or it has septa that get enhanced on contrast CT scan, then these cysts are cancerous,' the urologist said. He added, while symptoms are generally not noticeable, if a cyst grows large enough, you may experience these symptoms: Abdominal pain : A cyst is characterized by dull pain in the side, back or upper abdomen. It may come and go or feel like pressure rather than sharp pain. : A cyst is characterized by dull pain in the side, back or upper abdomen. It may come and go or feel like pressure rather than sharp pain. Fever or chills : An infected cyst presents itself with fever, chills, or even high blood pressure if kidney function is affected. : An infected cyst presents itself with fever, chills, or even high blood pressure if kidney function is affected. Changes in urination patterns: Cysts can press on the urinary tract, leading you to urinate more frequently. You may also experience a burning sensation while urinating. Also read | Signs of kidney stones to watch out for, prevention and treatment tips Know how to spot differences between kidney cysts and kidney tumour.(Freepik) What is a kidney tumour? "Kidney tumour is an abnormal growth of tissue arising from the kidneys. In the majority of cases, kidney tumour is asymptomatic and detected incidentally on ultrasound or if a CT scan is done for other reasons,' said Dr. Sumit Bansal. Some of the early warning signs of kidney tumour are: Blood in the urine : This is a symptom of an advanced tumor. Urine may appear pink or red. Sometimes, blood may not be visible to the naked eye. : This is a symptom of an advanced tumor. Urine may appear pink or red. Sometimes, blood may not be visible to the naked eye. Pain in the side or the lower back : Persistent pain may occur if the tumor grows large and presses on surrounding tissues. People may also notice a lump in the abdominal region. : Persistent pain may occur if the tumor grows large and presses on surrounding tissues. People may also notice a lump in the abdominal region. Unexplained weight loss: Sudden and unexplained weight loss is often accompanied by fatigue, anaemia, and fever in case of a kidney tumor Spotting the differences: Cysts are usually non-cancerous, while solid tumors are usually malignant. Cysts grow slowly and do not interfere with the surrounding tissue. In contrast, cancerous tumors grow aggressively and may even spread to surrounding tissues. Also read | Kidney failure: Top reasons why it happens; warning symptoms Cysts require no treatment unless symptoms become pronounced, but tumors may require extensive treatment in the form of surgery, like radical or partial nephrectomy (removal of the kidney or part of it), which is frequently needed for tumors. Note to readers: This article is for informational purposes only and not a substitute for professional medical advice. Always seek the advice of your doctor with any questions about a medical condition. Catch every big hit, every wicket with Crick-it, a one stop destination for Live Scores, Match Stats, Quizzes, Polls & much more. Explore now!. Catch your daily dose of Fashion, Taylor Swift, Health, Festivals, Travel, Relationship, Recipe and all the other Latest Lifestyle News on Hindustan Times Website and APPs.
