Exclusion of services from OTB 'worrying'
The draft of the 'Israeli Settlements in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (Prohibition of Importation of Goods) Bill 2025' was published today by Tánaiste Simon Harris.
It makes no reference to services being subject to a similar goods ban and has been criticised in the Dáil by opposition parties including Sinn Féin, Labour and the Social Democrats.
The Tánaiste insists he is willing to consider the inclusion of services in the bill and has sought the Attorney General's advice on this matter.
Independent Senator Frances Black has been closely associated with the bill since first tabling proposed legislation in 2018, and has continued to campaign on the subject and has held meetings with Mr Harris on the Government bill.
Speaking on RTÉ's Drivetime, Senator Black said Simon Harris had committed to her and in public that the Government is "willing to include services in the final bill if we can get the legal detail right".
She said she was "100% certain" that services will end up in the final bill "if we get this detail" right and she "fully intends on holding him to that promise".
"Last year, the International Court of Justice...said very clearly that the Israeli settlements are illegal, and that all countries must end trade with all of them - and all trade, full stop.
"That means both physical goods, like dates and oranges, but also services like tech and IT.
"That is the standard that the Government needs to meet," Senator Black said.
Meanwhile, Social Democrats Senator Patricia Stephenson said the Government has "yet to provide a credible reason for omitting services from the bill".
Ms Stephenson said the Tánaiste "continues to cite vague legal reasons for omitting a services ban" and added that her party has received legal advice saying that the inclusion of services is not only legal but also a "duty to do so in accordance with the ruling from the International Court of Justice".
"The vast majority of Ireland's trade with the occupied territories is in the form of services - legislating for goods alone is not a sufficient sanction of the Israeli government's barbaric actions.
"We need to see this Bill enacted in the form put forward by Senator Francis Black as a matter of urgency, even if this means working through the summer to do so," Ms Stephenson said.
Speaking upon the publication of the general scheme of the bill, the Tánaiste said he has made it clear that the Government will use "all levers at its disposal to address the horrifying situation on the ground" in Gaza.
"Israeli settlements in the Occupied Palestinian Territory are illegal and threaten the viability of the two-State solution.
"This is the longstanding position of the European Union and our international partners.
"Furthermore, this is the clear position under international law.
"I have been absolutely clear that we have yet to see an adequate response at EU level to the July 2024 Advisory Opinion of the International Court of Justice, notably as regards trade with Israeli settlements," Mr Harris said in a statement.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
25 minutes ago
- RTÉ News
Bill seeks to disregard historic offences for gay men
A bill has been introduced in the Dáil that would establish a process for the disregard of historic offences for consensual sexual activity between men. The bill, brought to the house by Sinn Féin's Aengus Ó Snodaigh, is co-signed by TDs from across the opposition and will now be scheduled for debate. Mr Ó Snodaigh said that gay men "continue to suffer as a result of convictions imposed when consensual sex between men was criminalised up to 1993". He said that 309 proceedings began and there were 64 convictions in the ten years leading to decriminalisation alone. "Despite an apology from the justice minister in 2018, no action has been taken by Government to put a process in place to disregard those convictions, as was recommended by a ministerial working group report in 2023." Mr Ó Snodaigh said that the Disregard of Historic Offences for Consensual Sexual Activity Between Men Bill 2025 would establish an application process through the Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission for men to have their historic convictions disregarded. "As Dublin marked Pride this weekend, LGBT+ people faced slurry in Ballymena, bans in Budapest and some shootings in New York," he told the Dáil. The passing of the bill would be statement of a "new society, a more open society", he said, as he asked the Government to adopt it "as quickly as possible". "If you don't do this, the hurt continues, the torture of people who have lived with these convictions or the consequences of these convictions continues." The Sinn Féin TD said that, in parts of the country, the State "hounded out" men who were gay, were forced to emigrate and "were tortured day in day out in their workplaces". Research showed that in Tullow, Co Carlow, there were 12 cases taken in one month in 1970, he added. Mr Ó Snodaigh said it appears that there was an "overzealous" approach in some areas of the country and that research should be carried out on the convictions. Labour TD Conor Sheehan said that "many men live with the trauma inflicted upon them by a society who told them they shouldn't exist". "Despite an apology in 2018, no action has been taken by Government to put a process in place to disregard these convictions," he told the Dáil. The "shame and trauma" of these convictions drove many men to their graves, he said. "Gay men were driven underground by this criminality. This is long overdue." Mr Sheehan urged the Government to stop "dragging their heels" and support the bill. Social Democrats TD Pádraig Rice said that it is over 30 years since homosexuality was decriminalised, but some men are "still living with the negative effect of decriminalisation". "The persecution of hundreds of gay and bi men for consensual sex was a gross violation of their human rights and did immeasurable damage." These arrests and convictions "destroyed lives", he said, adding that the threat of prosecution was used to "harass people in the community". "It also had a huge impact on the provision of public services including HIV/AIDS prevention. "The State must right the wrongs of the past. We are running out of time for these men," Mr Rice said. Green Party leader Roderic O'Gorman said the language in the legislation linked consensual gay sex to bestiality and attempted to "dehumanise gay men". "We are trying to undo the sins of the past ... but that approach to gay men is still being adopted. It's being adopted in Europe. It's the laws that were in Poland until the recent general election, the laws that are in place in Hungary right now," he said. People Before Profit-Solidarity TD Paul Murphy told the Dáil it is "outrageous" that people are walking around today with historic convictions for the "so-called crime of being gay". He said that a working group was set up to examine disregarding these convictions in 2021 and "nothing has still been done". "Due course in this case is decades overdue ... this is not just a matter of righting a historic wrong "It's about sending a message at a time when LGBTQ rights are under attack in this country and globally that love is love and homosexuality is never a crime," Mr Murphy added.
Irish Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Tanaiste denies rift in coalition but hints at further college fee cuts
Tánaiste Simon Harris has denied that there is a rift in Cabinet over student fees as he insisted the programme for government commitment to cut and abolish them will be maintained. He also hinted that there will be a reduction in student fees from January. Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael have been fighting via press release in recent days following Higher Education Minister James Lawless' comments over the weekend, stating that fees would revert to €3,000 in September. On his way into Cabinet, Mr Harris said there is "certainly not" a rift in Cabinet. The Tánaiste said: "Yes, we are doing budgeting in a different way this year. We have to move beyond a budgetary measure between now and Christmas, and then other budget measures that kick in in January. "But that's not the same thing as saying you can't support students in the here and now. "I'm very clear that I signed up for and Fine Gael signed up for, a programme for government that commits to reducing college fees and ultimately abolish them. "I think my own track record on this is pretty clear." Mr Harris said he has been the Minister for Higher Education and that "budget announcements are made on budget day". However, he insisted that the Government has previously found ways of helping students and their parents. Minister Lawless said that as the Government will not be doing a cost-of-living announcement, he will not have the money to reduce student fees by €1,000 as this was a previous one-off measure. However, the Tánaiste criticised suggestions that there will be no cost-of-living supports in Budget 2026 as there will not be a dedicated cost-of-living package. He continued: "Yes, it's true, there won't be a big bag or series of announcements to take effect before Christmas. "But it's also true that's not the way college fees fall due to be paid. Many people - most people pay in instalments. "I'm very clear in the programme for government commitment. It talks about reducing and phasing out. That's what I want to see progress on, but I want to do that in a different way, in terms of engaging with our colleagues here in government. And I know all parties in government are very much committed to helping people. "I think in the last few days, there's been kind of a bizarre narrative taking hold that if there's not a cost-of-living package that the government can't do anything on cost of living. That's simply not true. "We have to move back to regular budgets. But of course, that budget can include measures to help people with cost of living." Speaking later at a press conference, the Tánaiste said that a lot of people pay college fees in instalments and decisions made in October's budget could impact later instalments that have to be paid. He continued: "If I was a parent of a child going to college today, I'd be saying, 'Do what happened last year. Do what happened the year before. Do what happened the year before that.' "Pay in instalments and let's see where the budget brings us to." Mr Harris said that while the budget will be "expansionary", there will be no cost-of-living package and decisions will have to be made following a very "sobering meeting" with the two finance ministers over the weekend.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘Splitting' raises questions about oversight of Help to Buy scheme, says Simon Harris
Tánaiste Simon Harris has said the issue of 'splitting' a Help to Buy transaction raises important questions over the oversight of the Government scheme He was speaking after estate agent Sherry FitzGerald launched an internal investigation after a home buyer was offered a 'split' sale for a new-build property , in order for it to qualify for the Help to Buy scheme. The case was first reported in The Irish Times on Tuesday . Mr Harris reaffirmed the Government's commitment to the scheme for the lifetime of the Coalition, but he said that important questions had been raised by the issue of 'split' sales. 'When issues like that come to the fore it does raise important questions in relation to the oversight of the scheme,' he said. Mr Harris said he had total confidence in the Revenue Commissioners operation of the scheme but added that it was ultimately taxpayers money being used. READ MORE 'It's important that the integrity of the scheme is protected at all costs.' He said the Government would await any guidance or advice from the Revenue Commissioners or the Department of Finance in relation to the scheme. The Help to Buy (HTB) scheme is administered by Revenue and provides a refund on income tax of up to €30,000 to first-time buyers on new-build properties up to a value of €500,000. Social Democrats ' spokesman on housing Rory Hearne said it was 'alarming to see evidence of such blatant breaches of the scheme'. 'Questions need to be answered now about how widespread this issue is and if this case is just the tip of the iceberg,' the Dublin North-West TD said. The story 'shows that estate agents are playing a role in pushing for and facilitating higher house prices, which developers are also lobbying for'. [ The 'emotional toll' of buying a home in Ireland: 'split' deals and queueing for houses already sold Opens in new window ] 'The Government has done nothing to challenge the various market actors pushing up house prices, and has actually added to and facilitated house price inflation through the help to buy schemes. We need to see proper regulation and transparency in the house purchase market to stop the price gouging going on now,' Mr Hearne said. Mr Harris also spoke about the potential impact of trade tensions between the United States and the European Union as the clock ticks down on a 90-day tariff pause to charges announced by the White House earlier this year. The Tánaiste said this week would be an 'extremely intense' period in trying to secure a framework agreement between Brussels and Washington. He said that at the very least, the aim was to provide a sense of certainty where there was a 'vacuum' at the moment. He said the current situation was 'holding back people in terms of jobs decisions and investment decisions. We need clarity and certainty as to what the trade environment works like.' He said Europe and Ireland wanted to see 'zero-for-zero' tariffs as widely as possible and that the Dublin Government was working hard on the issue of pharmaceutical exports to the United States.
