logo
How do you bounce back from defeat in a first Lions Test? In 2009, our response was brutal

How do you bounce back from defeat in a first Lions Test? In 2009, our response was brutal

The Guardian3 days ago
It is worth comparing and contrasting two separate events over the past week to really get a sense of the challenge that faces the Wallabies on Saturday. Shortly before half-time in the first Test in Brisbane, Tom Curry tackled Tom Lynagh in the air. None of Australia's players went after him. The Lions No 7 had just cut Lynagh – a young fly-half making his first Test start – in half and the Wallabies left him alone. Three days later Darcy Graham is on the receiving end of a high shot in the first few minutes. Owen Farrell piles straight in, sending a crystal clear message: 'We're not standing for it.' It's part of the reason anyone who has played with him cannot speak highly enough of him.
Put simply, the Wallabies need to get in the Lions' faces if they are going to level the series. They were too passive in Brisbane and they need to set that right at the Melbourne Cricket Ground. I see similarities between where the Wallabies are now and where the Lions were in 2009. We didn't show up in the first Test in Durban and we got monstered in the scrum. I remember John Smit scored a try after five minutes in what was South Africa's first entry into our 22.
I'll never forget the debrief we had on a Monday. The defence coach, Shaun Edwards, played us the clips of that try, it was carry after carry and every Springbok got over the gainline before Smit ran through two defenders. Edwards told us it was one of the worst opening defensive sets he had ever seen in international rugby. So we had to show up in the second Test, which has gone down in history for its brutality. We had Simon Shaw come into the team, an enormous second-row who was named man of the match despite featuring for the losing side. The Wallabies will be hoping Will Skelton can have a similar impact.
When you're 1-0 down you are hyper-focused because the series comes down to the 80 minutes on Saturday. You want to keep the gameplan simple but there are things you can demand and expect. Emotionally you have to be in the right place, physically in the right place and work rate has to be through the roof. You've got to fight for everything, you've got to be desperate, but desperation can't lead to ill-discipline or trying too hard and where you end up doing other people's jobs. Because we know what the fallout will be if they don't get it right.
Australia were poor last week but when the Lions are doing their preparation they will be preparing for the best version of the Wallabies. You don't prepare for last week's version because if you do you'll find yourself with egg on your face. I fully expect that Australia will show up this weekend and I've spent a bit of time this week hoping that they will. That's alien to me in the context of a Lions tour, I don't ever remember feeling or hoping that the Kiwis or South Africans will turn up.
Why has it taken this sort of poverty of performance to invigorate this Wallabies side for a series that happens once every 12 years? Do you have to play so poorly to realise that you have to show up? Sometimes sport can be really simple when you are out of options and the Wallabies are at that stage, they have to show up. They have to be so much better. Yes, there were some green shoots but I didn't feel that the result last week was ever in question. To concede as early as they did, it was soft, and the hope must be they don't concede soft tries again, I really hope we get a competitive match.
And I'm confident we will. Rob Valetini will bring significant physicality, so will Skelton. With what's on the line you hope it's just a lot better. This is the first time as a fan with the Lions that I've wanted to see major improvements but it's a demonstration of where the Wallabies are.
They are the sixth best team in the world and almost by default, because other teams around them have lost. We're not in rugby union territory in Melbourne, I was at the AFL the other night and there were 65,000 there for a club match. The MCG should be sold out for a Lions game that happens once every 12 years and it's not.
Sign up to The Breakdown
The latest rugby union news and analysis, plus all the week's action reviewed
after newsletter promotion
But while I have a sense of sympathy, the Lions won't. They'll be thrilled to be in the position they are but they'll be frustrated with themselves because they didn't play to their levels in the second half.
They need to show more of a ruthless edge because it's going to be massively physical, energetic, emotional – they've got to weather that storm and then get into gear and stay in gear. If they do that I'm confident they can wrap up the series.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

England 2005 Ashes hero warns Ben Stokes and co over final India Test match
England 2005 Ashes hero warns Ben Stokes and co over final India Test match

Daily Mirror

time10 minutes ago

  • Daily Mirror

England 2005 Ashes hero warns Ben Stokes and co over final India Test match

EXCLUSIVE: England head to The Oval this week knowing they will win the series against India if they avoid defeat in the fifth Test, just like against Australia in 2005 Ashes legend Matthew Hoggard now runs a barbecue school - and after landing the holy grill in 2005 he says England must cook up a storm this week. ‌ Going to The Oval 2-1 up in a gripping marquee series? Hoggard has been there and done that 20 years ago as Michael Vaughan's heroes recaptured the urn in a seismic summer when cricket was the only show in town. ‌ Now England are in the same boat after a tetchy, thrilling win at Lord's and a sour finish to the stalemate at Old Trafford as Ben Stokes fed two Indian batters joke bowling to bring up their centuries when they refused to shake hands on the draw earlier. And Hoggard was thrilled the class of 2005 was namechecked by Joe Root as one of his inspirations growing up after Yorkshire's batting royalty unfurled his 38th Test century at the weekend. ‌ Hoggy, who took 248 wickets in 67 Tests, said: 'Listening to Joe being interviewed, after he had just become the second-greatest run scorer of all time in Test cricket, saying he had been inspired by the Ashes winners of 2005 was music to my ears. That's why we play cricket - to leave a legacy, and leave something behind to inspire younger generations, still gives you goosebumps. 'I think back to 2005 with 10,000 people being turned away from the final day at Old Trafford, people bunking off work or school to watch the finale at The Oval and, yes, it was the best of times. 'When I look at footage of the open-top bus parade to Trafalgar Square, and none of us look sober, in the social media age we would probably have been crucified but I genuinely can't remember anyone giving us any stick. We went round the Prime Minister's house a bit worse for wear, went to Trafalgar Square for the parade a bit bleary-eyed and went back to Lord's for a reception in a state of disrepair - but nobody minded because we were winners.' ‌ Hoggard hopes Stokes' side will turn up cooking on the front burner on Thursday after a nerve-jangling climax in 2005 was only settled by Kevin Pietersen's audacious 158 on the final afternoon. 'We had gone 2-1 up at Trent Bridge in an unbearably tense finish when I was hiding under towels and trembling in the physio's room, unable to watch as the wickets fell as we chased 129 to win,' Hoggard who is now working as one of the UK's leading Motivational Speakers, told Mirror Sport. ‌ 'But when it was my turn to bat, with 13 runs still needed and Brett Lee's bowling 95mph rockets, you switch on and it gets easier - because you're the one who is empowered to take charge and get the job done. 'Lee was either trying to kill me or york me, but when he got one wrong and I managed to send it to the extra cover boundary I think Vaughany (captain Michael Vaughan) nearly fell off the balcony. I'm not sure he'd ever seen me hit an extra cover drive before. ‌ 'As Ashley Giles, who hit the winning runs, and I walked off, he said, 'Enjoy the moment, we're kings for the night.' He was right - our pace attack was called the Fab Four but it was really a fab five because Gilo was the forgotten man of that bowling unit. He was immense. 'But when we got to The Oval for the final Test, the nerves took over again. The night before I was out for dinner with my wife and I was so uptight I called for the bill and walked out. My head was all over the place, I'm afraid I was a bit of a t**t.' England's pace attack was detained in the field 143 overs as they chased victory in vain at Old Trafford, and Hoggard warned: 'It's going to be survival of the fittest and it reminds me of 2005. You can't go to The Oval and play for a draw because you'll come unstuck if the mentality isn't right. ‌ 'In an ideal world we bat first, go big and put India under pressure to match us or go past us. England have more gears in the batting line-up than India, especially if they are going to be without Rishabh Pant. 'It's been hard graft for bowlers on both sides, but we score quicker than India and if they have to put their foot down to chase the game, that's when The Oval can be a tricky customer.'

Sale lock Andrews signs new one-year deal
Sale lock Andrews signs new one-year deal

BBC News

time10 minutes ago

  • BBC News

Sale lock Andrews signs new one-year deal

Sale Sharks lock Hyron Andrews has agreed a new one-year contract to stay at the club for next South African joined Sale from Durban club Sharks towards the end of the 2023-24 campaign as injury cover for Jonny Hill and played in the Champions Cup quarter-final defeat by 29, impressed enough to earn a one-year deal for last season where he made 11 appearances."I was a little nervous about coming to Sale because it was the first time I'd played overseas, but from the first day I arrived, I've absolutely loved it," he told the club website, external. "It's been so much fun but we know there's a lot of work to do as well, to make sure we take the next step and win the Premiership. "We need to keep working on the things that make us such a good team, improve our away form and we can get there."

Ben Stokes' handshake antics show why other teams hate England
Ben Stokes' handshake antics show why other teams hate England

Telegraph

timean hour ago

  • Telegraph

Ben Stokes' handshake antics show why other teams hate England

England's sullen and ungracious conduct at the end of an Old Trafford Test match they dominated served up easy half volleys for their critics, quick to leap on perceived double standards. But it also gave England a glimpse of what awaits in Australia. The headlines overnight said it all: Spare us the whinging England, Moral hypocrites England decide tons are anti-cricket and Spirit of what? How pompous England exposed Bazball's great double standard. Meanwhile, Australia has some thoughts... #ENGvIND #AUSvENG — Andrew McGlashan (@andymcg_cricket) July 28, 2025 A familiar storm is gathering and England gave it plenty of energy. A barrage of this stuff awaits in November, more so than any Ashes tour since 2013-14 when Alastair Cook's team were the first to follow the 2010-11 winners. Then Kevin Pietersen and Stuart Broad were public enemies No 1 and No 2. This time it will be Ben Stokes and Brendon McCullum. The Australians respect Stokes but fear what he can do. McCullum they see as someone who always failed on their turf when it mattered. There is nothing England can do to prevent the inevitable attacks, but they can at least make them harder to justify. What England did on Sunday night was lame but the theory that Indian teams play for personal milestones is one shared by Australia. In fact, England's reaction was very Australian. Matthew Hayden once picked up on the 'milestone culture' in Indian cricket. 'We don't really play for stats. We play for wins. That's the Aussie way,' said Steve Waugh, but it could just as easily have been Stokes. England's mistake was making it look petty rather than pointed. 'I thought England behaved badly' @NHoultCricket gives his thoughts on England's behaviour during their draw with India in the fourth test Watch the Telegraph Cricket Podcast ⬇️ — Telegraph Cricket (@TeleCricket) July 28, 2025 Managing individuals is part of a captain's job. Shubman Gill recognised the importance of a maiden Test hundred for Washington Sundar and the great spade work Ravi Jadeja put in for his team throughout the series. He also revelled in sticking up two fingers at England after how they finished the Lord's Test. But England are not a pompous bunch, they are generally great ambassadors for the sport. It is only this summer we have really heard them say anything on the field. They showed a mean side at Lord's after deciding they had been too nice for too long and it served them well. In Manchester, they learnt they need to be better at picking their moments. It is one thing to try to unsettle opponents by playing hard, another to be boorish and look like sore losers. Would Stokes have hauled Jacob Bethell off had he been close to a maiden century or Joe Root in sight of his first in Australia? Currently, the verbals do not quite align with this team. It appears somewhat performative rather than natural. 'I had plenty to say when I played – and copped plenty back,'' said Mitchell Johnson. 'But that came with a bit of purpose. Sledging only works when you are dominating. And to be honest, right now England aren't. Their Bazball model has some punch but it's flimsy when conditions swing or spin. So maybe talking tough is a cover. A bit of theatre while they figure out the actual cricket.'' Bazball has been modified this summer but still has to prove itself in tough batting conditions. India's rearguard highlighted England's weakness. When presented with the challenge of batting for 108 overs at Edgbaston, they were all out inside 69, losing by 336 runs. Jamie Smith was caught on the boundary going for a third six in an over, a shot that showed England were still unwilling to change tack or simply did not know how to play the situation because of how they regard draws. That is what they can take out of the Old Trafford Test. Because they have seen how wound up they were by a team frustrating the hell out of them. It can make a draw feel like a win.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store