Trump asks Supreme Court to remove 3 Democrats on the Consumer Product Safety Commission
Advertisement
U.S. District Judge Matthew Maddox in Baltimore ruled in June that the dismissals were unlawful. Maddox sought to distinguish the commission's role from those of other agencies where the Supreme Court has allowed firings to go forward.
Get Starting Point
A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday.
Enter Email
Sign Up
A month earlier, the high court's conservative majority declined to reinstate members of the National Labor Relations Board and the Merit Systems Protection Board finding that the Constitution appears to give the president the authority to fire the board members 'without cause.' The three liberal justices dissented.
The administration has argued that all the agencies are under Trump's control as the head of the executive branch.
Maddox, a Biden nominee, noted that it can be difficult to characterize the product safety commission's functions as purely executive.
Advertisement
The fight over the president's power to fire could prompt the court to consider overturning a 90-year-old Supreme Court decision known as Humphrey's Executor. In that case from 1935, the court unanimously held that presidents cannot fire independent board members without cause.
The decision ushered in an era of powerful independent federal agencies charged with regulating labor relations, employment discrimination, the airwaves and much else. But it has long rankled conservative legal theorists who argue the modern administrative state gets the Constitution all wrong because such agencies should answer to the president.
The Consumer Product Safety Commission was created in 1972. Its five members must maintain a partisan split, with no more than three representing the president's party. They serve staggered terms.
That structure ensures that each president has 'the opportunity to influence, but not control,' the commission, attorneys for the fired commissioners wrote in court filings. They argued the recent terminations could jeopardize the commission's independence.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fox News
23 minutes ago
- Fox News
Iran at 'decision point' after Trump strikes on nuclear program, says US NATO ambassador
U.S. Ambassador to NATO Matt Whitaker argued Iran is at a "decision point" following its war with Israel and U.S. airstrikes on its nuclear program — all while U.S. officials remain on high alert for sleeper cell concerns. Whitaker urged Iran to seek peace during "Sunday Morning Futures," while noting that the U.S. is still dealing with the implications of an open border – and the national security implications of it – from the Biden administration. "It's obviously a very dangerous world, Jason," Whitaker told Fox News' Jason Chaffetz on Sunday. "I think… President Trump, as a peacemaker, has made it safer, but at the same time, we're still dealing with a lot of the consequences of four years of Joe Biden, including a porous border, where not only did we have, as Tom Homan points out, over 1,200 Iranian nationals that came into our country that we know of, but you had over a million known gotaways that we have no idea who they are, where they went, and that's a real challenge." "But, at the same time, you know, President Trump has been very clear about his policy towards Iran, that they cannot have a nuclear weapon," he added. "And they're at a decision point. They should move forward and seek peace." Over 1,500 Iranian nationals who illegally entered the U.S. at the southern border were arrested during the Biden administration, and nearly 50% of them were released back into the country, according to a senior U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) source last month. More specifically, Border Patrol agents arrested 1,504 Iranian nationals from fiscal year 2021 through fiscal year 2024. Of the 1,504 individuals who were arrested, 729 were released into the United States. Meanwhile, just hours after Trump addressed the nation about U.S. military strikes on Iranian nuclear sites, DHS released a new memo sounding the alarm on a "heightened threat environment in the United States." The bulletin from the National Terrorism Advisory System did not cite any specific threats but comes as Iranian officials have threatened retaliation. "It is our duty to keep the nation safe and informed, especially during times of conflict," the Department of Homeland Security said in a statement to Fox News Digital. "The ongoing Israel-Iran conflict brings the possibility of increased threat to the homeland in the form of possible cyberattacks, acts of violence, and antisemitic hate crimes." Whitaker argued the growing threat of possible Iranian sleeper cell activity in the United States puts tremendous pressure on law enforcement to be right "100 percent of the time." "Iran should come to the table and should sue for peace, and should make a peace deal with the United States, with Israel, and just say, 'No more. We want to be in the world where people seek prosperity and a bright future for their citizens,'" he said. "So, Jason… right now, this puts a lot of pressure on our law enforcement, puts a lot of pressure on… DOJ and the FBI to be right 100 percent of the time and seek out these sleeper cells and to make sure that they can't activate," he added.
Politico
42 minutes ago
- Politico
Democrats 'seem to think that poor people are stupid,' Scott Bessent says
President Donald Trump signed his sweeping domestic megabill, which included more than $1 trillion in health care cuts, into law Friday. Work requirements are a key component of the savings needed to extend trillions in tax cuts Trump pushed over the line during his first term in 2017. But Democrats and advocates worry the administrative toll could prove cumbersome both for low-income Americans looking to prove their eligibility and for the officials doing the verification. Richard Besser, president and CEO of the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, on Sunday pointed to Arkansas as an example. Thousands lost coverage when the state implemented a work requirement program, he told ABC's George Stephanopoulos. 'And it not only affects those individuals, which is bad enough, but rural hospitals across America depend on Medicaid dollars to stay in existence,' Besser said on 'This Week.' 'It's predicted that there could be hundreds of rural hospitals that close. Those hospitals are also a driver for businesses. Businesses don't want to move into a community without a hospital.' Bessent told Bash the economy he and Trump are building will afford job-seekers with ample opportunity to exit the program by finding new work in the manufacturing sector. 'No, there are no change in benefits,' he said. 'There's a change in requirements to get the benefits. And what we are doing, we are bringing back manufacturing jobs. We are bringing back working-class jobs by securing the border. We have seen, already seen working class wages move up. So we are creating jobs. People can get off Medicaid and get a job that has good health care benefits.'
New York Post
42 minutes ago
- New York Post
Top West Bank sheiks propose, recognizing the state of Israel, leaving Palestinian Authority: letter
A group of five top Palestinian officials in the West Bank's Hebron district said they are willing to leave the Palestinian Authority and join the Abraham Accords, recognizing the state of Israel. The sheikhs penned a letter to Israeli Economy Minister Nir Barkat, expressing their desire to transform The West Bank's largest district into an emirate that 'recognize[s] the State of Israel as the nation state of the Jewish people,' the Wall Street Journal reported. Sheikh Wadee' al-Jaabari — one of the most influential leaders in Hebron, the West Bank's largest region — urged Israel and President Trump, who oversaw the Abraham Accords in his first term, to back the plan for self-governance. 5 Sheikh Wadee' al-Jaabari and four other top officials in the West Bank's Hebron district proposed a plan to establish their own emirate and join the Abraham Accords. 5 The West Bank has been marred by violence that has ramped up since the war with Gaza began, with the sheikhs blaming the Palestinian Authority's failures. AFP via Getty Images 'If we will get the blessing of honorable President Trump and the United States for this project, Hebron could be like the Gulf, like Dubai,' Jaabari told the outlet. The Palestinian Authority (PA) has stood as the de facto rulers of the autonomous Palestinian regions since 1994 as part of the US-backed Oslo Accords, which Jaabari and other sheikhs slammed as an agreement that 'only brought damage, death, economic disaster and destruction.' They said the PA was forced on the Palestinian people and never brought the prosperity and peace Israel and the US promised — as evidenced by violence along the border and Hamas' operation inside the West Bank. Jabbari and his supporters have instead tapped Trump's Abraham Accords as a roadmap to 'coexistence' with Israel. The agreement previously normalizing relationships between the Jewish state and the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain, Morocco and Sudan. 5 Israel's Economy Minister Nir Barkat touted the proposal for an independent Hebron as a way forward for Israeli-Palestinian relations. Bloomberg via Getty Images With the West Bank occupied by Israel and seeing daily violence that has only escalated since the war with Hamas began, Jaabari proposed a trial run that would see 1,000 Hebron workers establish an autonomous 1,000-acre economic zone bordering Israel. If all goes well, the zone would grow to 5,000 more residents and then 50,000, with the sheikhs pledging to a 'zero tolerance' policy against terrorism. Jabbari accused the PA of supporting terrorist activity in the West Bank. 'I plan to cut off the PA,' Jaabari vowed. 'It doesn't represent the Palestinians.' 5 It remains to be seen how a deal can move forward under Israeli occupation, where clashes between residents of soldiers are common. AP Barkat, who has been meeting with the sheikhs since February to discuss a potential deal, touted the proposal as a step forward for Israeli-Palestinian relations. 'Sheikh Jaabari wants peace with Israel and to join the Abraham Accords, with the support of his fellow sheikhs. Who in Israel is going to say no?' Barkat told the WSJ. 'Nobody in Israel believes in the PA, and you won't find many Palestinians who do either,' he added. 5 Hebron stands as the West Bank's largest district and serves as its commercial center. AFP via Getty Images It remains to be seen how the bold proposal will be accepted by the Jewish state and Hebron residents alike, with some from the West Bank slamming the proposal and claiming it 'doesn't represent us,' Israeli newspaper Haaretz reported. The formation of the new zone could also cause problems along the illegal Israeli settlements in the West Bank, but the sheikhs claim the land disputes can be easily negotiated. Jabbari and his colleagues assured Barkat that they will be able to drum up support for the proposal, touting it as the only hope to prevent Hebron and the West Bank from becoming another Gaza. Jabbari maintains that his proposal is the best solution for his people given that Hamas crushed all hopes for a Palestinian state when it attacked Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, killing more than 1,200 people and kidnapping another 251. 'There will be no Palestinian state — not even in 1,000 years. After Oct. 7, Israel will not give it,' Jabbari said.
