India's flagship EV policy may struggle without major players like Tesla and BYD
India is rolling out a new flagship electric vehicle policy that aims to lure global automakers into making cars locally. It knows Tesla Inc. may still not bite.
The Narendra Modi-led government will soon start accepting applications under the EV incentive program that was unveiled in March last year, HD Kumaraswamy, India's heavy industries and steel minister told reporters in New Delhi on Monday. Bloomberg News reported on this earlier in the day.
The policy offers to slash duty to 15% on any imported electric car priced from $35,000 if the maker invests at least 41.5 billion rupees, or about $500 million, to set up a local plant within three years. Up to 8,000 cars yearly can be imported at this reduced rate.
But Tesla is unlikely to participate as it isn't keen on manufacturing locally and instead wants dealerships and showrooms to sell imported cars, Kumaraswamy said, without elaborating. Tesla has long wanted to enter India, but disagreements over import duties and local manufacturing commitments have stalled progress.
BYD Co. is a no-go for the South Asian nation, showing New Delhi's lingering angst with China. India's commerce minister said in an April interview that the country needs to be 'cautious" about who it allows to invest. VinFast Auto Ltd. is already building a factory in India, even before the new policy kicked in. Non-Starter
'The EV policy could be a non starter," said Jay Kale, sector analyst at local brokerage Elara Securities India Pvt., explaining that there was little benefit in terms of 'pure-play" EV makers without Tesla, BYD and VinFast in the fray.
Also Read : Nissan India plans four new models including C-SUV, Triber-based MPV and mass-market EV
Some global legacy automakers could benefit by setting up EV-only plants in India and importing electric cars initially under this policy, according to Kale. 'However, how these models pan out in India have to be seen as most of these carmakers haven't been successful in their home markets in EVs," he said.
While the government is keen to boost manufacturing in the world's third-largest car market where demand for EVs is still rising, it faces stiff resistance from domestic heavyweights including Tata Motors Ltd. and Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., which have long been protected by a wall of high tariffs. Stringent Conditions
'The policy will likely draw limited interest from foreign automakers as the investment and revenue requirements are too stringent," said Komal Kareer analyst at BloombergNEF in New Delhi.
It mandates a minimum revenue of 50 billion rupees ($586 million) in the fourth year and 75 billion rupees a year later for any applicant approved under this policy. Those falling short will face a penalty of up to 3% on the revenue gap.
'Most automakers either do not have an eligible model that they can import for the customs' duty exemption or they will not be able to meet the revenue requirements," Kareer said.
Applications may open as early as this month and extend till March 15 next year, according to people familiar with the discussions who did not want to be named.
Check out Upcoming EV Cars in India.
First Published Date: 05 Jun 2025, 08:59 AM IST
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
23 minutes ago
- First Post
In a veiled dig at China, PM Modi urges Brics to 'prevent weaponisation' of rare earths
PM Modi has urged BRICS nations to work together to secure supplies of critical minerals and cautioned against any country using these resources as a 'weapon,' in remarks seen as a veiled swipe at China's export restrictions on rare earths. read more India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi speaks during the first plenary session of the BRICS summit in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, on July 6, 2025. Image- AFP Prime Minister Narendra Modi urged Brics nations to work together to secure supply chains for critical minerals and, in an indirect way, took a dig at China, saying that no country should use these resources as a 'weapon' against others. Speaking on Sunday at the Brics summit session on multilateralism, finance, and artificial intelligence, Modi also called for global rules on AI to ensure transparency and stop misuse. His remarks come amid worries about China's restrictions on exporting rare earth minerals and its lack of transparency in the sector. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'We need to work together to make supply chains for critical minerals and technology secure and reliable. It's important to ensure that no country uses these resources for its own selfish gain or as a weapon against others,' Modi said. China's dominance in rare earth market Critical minerals like lithium, nickel, and graphite are essential for making high-tech products such as electric vehicles, drones, and batteries. China currently dominates the global supply of these minerals. China controls an overwhelming share of mining, refining, and processing for critical minerals, holding roughly 85–90 per cent of global rare earth element refining and around 60 per cent of lithium chemicals, 68 per cent of nickel refining, 73 per cent of cobalt refining, and 99 per cent of battery-grade graphite production. In 2024, it accounted for about 75 per cent of global processing capacity for key minerals like copper, lithium, cobalt, graphite, and rare earths. This dominance extends upstream through major investments in mines across Africa and Latin America and downstream into refining, component manufacturing, and EV battery factories. China's tight grip gives it strategic leverage but also poses risks for Western nations, as any disruption or export controls—especially on rare earths and graphite—could severely impact global technology and clean energy supply chains. As a result, Western governments are urgently seeking alternative sources and building up their own processing capacities. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Mint
25 minutes ago
- Mint
Stocks to buy for the short term: Shriram Finance to Federal Bank— 5 stocks in which AI sees up to 50% upside
Stocks to buy for the short term: The Indian stock market has been rangebound in the last few sessions as investors seek clarity on the India-US trade deal and await early trends of the Q1 results. The Nifty 50 ended flat on Monday. After four consecutive months of gains, it is in the red for the month so far. However, the broader market trends remain positive due to expectations of durable and healthy economic growth in the country and a strong influx of retail investors. Experts suggest at this juncture, one should consider picking quality stocks at dips for the long term. Mint spoke to Tradonomy, a financial services and wealth management firm, for stock recommendations suitable at this juncture. The firm suggested five short-term buys. Tradonomy, using its proprietary quant-based framework, identifies companies with strong fundamentals, efficient capital use, attractive valuations, and durable growth potential. "This week's list features five standout stocks ranging from power equipment to finance, each evaluated on metrics most relevant to its sector. Whether it's ROE (return on equity) for manufacturers or ROA (return on assets) and P/B (price-to-book) for lenders, these stocks demonstrate the right balance of performance, positioning, and price," Tradonomy said. Shriram Finance is among India's leading NBFCs, specialising in commercial vehicle and small-ticket retail lending. Its strength lies in deep rural reach and high-yield lending. The company posted 29.7 per cent net profit growth and a healthy 22.8 per cent net margin. What sets it apart is its strong ROA of 3.25 per cent, far above industry averages, which shows asset-side efficiency. "The stock trades at a modest P/B of 2.4 times, offering a cushion for long-term investors. With a Tradonomy score of 78 per cent, it reflects both value and momentum in a segment critical to India's credit penetration story," said Tradonomy. Federal Bank continues to outperform peers in the mid-size banking segment. With 19.6 per cent revenue growth and improving return ratios (ROA: 1.15 per cent, ROE: 12 per cent), it balances loan book quality with digital agility. Net margins at 14.8 per cent and a low P/B of 1.6 times make valuation attractive. "At a Tradonomy score of 80 per cent, the bank reflects solid fundamentals and upside potential. With a strong deposit franchise and expanding retail credit book, Federal Bank is well-positioned for the next phase of financial sector growth," said the financial firm. Shilchar is a rising star in the power equipment space, supplying transformers to telecom, solar, and industrial segments. With stellar 56 per cent revenue growth and an industry-leading 42 per cent ROE, it demonstrates both scale and capital efficiency. Its 23 per cent profit margin and 29.97 per cent RoA highlight operational strength. "The company trades at a premium (P/E of 44 times), but rightly so, given the deep moat and future readiness. With a Tradonomy score of 94 per cent, Shilchar is a textbook case of high-quality growth in an underpenetrated sector," said Tradonomy. AGI Infra is quietly building value in North India's affordable housing and mid-income real estate segment. With consistent 28 per cent net profit growth and strong ROE of 22.6 per cent, it combines margin discipline (20.5 per cent) with real estate demand tailwinds. "At a P/E of 36.8, it's not cheap, but its execution and regional moat justify the multiple. The stock also scores 88 per cent on Tradonomy's model, driven by reliable business strength and steady expansion. AGI stands to benefit from government housing incentives and rising tier-2 demand," said the financial firm. Ashapura Minechem is a global supplier of industrial minerals, with a strong presence in bauxite, bentonite, and value-added specialty products. While top-line growth has been moderate (3.6 per cent YoY), its ROE of 23.8 per cent and improving net margins (10.8 per cent) make it a stable earnings compounder. "With a reasonable valuation (P/E of 14.3 times), Ashapura offers cyclical exposure with strong balance sheet support. Its Tradonomy score of 75 per cent reflects decent value and profitability. As global mineral demand rises, Ashapura is positioned for a demand-led rebound," said the financial firm. Read all market-related news here Read more stories by Nishant Kumar Disclaimer: This story is for educational purposes only. The views and recommendations expressed are those of individual analysts or broking firms, not Mint. We advise investors to consult with certified experts before making any investment decisions, as market conditions can change rapidly and circumstances may vary.
Mint
25 minutes ago
- Mint
Trump Tariffs: India's pharma, auto, textile sector to be in focus; here's why
US President Donald Trump's tariffs are set to take effect on Friday, August 1. Therefore, the 90-day grace period for reciprocal tariffs that was initially scheduled to end this Wednesday, July 9, has been extended due to stalled negotiations. On Monday, July 7, US President Donald Trump disclosed letters his administration sent to different trading partners notifying them of the reciprocal tariff rates that will be in effect starting August 1, 2025. The first two letters shared by Trump on the social media platform Truth Social indicated that the US will apply a 25% tariff on Japan and South Korea. After a brief pause, the US President also released tariff letters for additional countries including Myanmar, Laos, Thailand, South Africa, Bangladesh, Kazakhstan, Indonesia, Tunisia, Malaysia, Serbia, Cambodia, and Bosnia & Herzegovina. On Monday, Trump announced proposals for a 40% tariff on products imported from Myanmar and Laos, a 36% tariff on goods from Thailand and Cambodia, a 35% tariff on items from Serbia and Bangladesh, a 32% tariff on imports from Indonesia, a 30% tariff on products from South Africa, and a 25% tariff on goods from Malaysia and Tunisia. On Sunday, July 6, Trump announced that he might send out as many as 15 initial letters, warning that US import taxes would return to the higher rates implemented in April if countries fail to reach agreements. On Monday, President Donald Trump announced that the United States is nearing a trade agreement with India. Amidst this backdrop, experts highlight the potential impact that different sectors may experience in India as a result tariffs. Mohit Gulati, the CIO and managing partner of ITI Growth Opportunities Fund, said that, in sectors where India enjoys a near-monopoly or dominant market share—such as certain generics in pharmaceuticals and specialized textiles—India will be in a strong position to dictate terms to US buyers, leveraging its indispensability and global supply chain strength. For these monopolistic exports, the US will have limited alternatives, giving Indian exporters greater pricing and negotiation power. Gulati highlighted that for the broader range of exports, however, the scenario is more nuanced. Key sectors like gems & jewellery, electronics, textiles, and auto components will face both opportunities and challenges as tariffs rise. While some Indian exporters may benefit from rivals like China and Vietnam being hit with even steeper duties, others could see margins squeezed and competitiveness tested. There will be pluses and minuses across the board, with the final impact depending on sectoral dynamics, government support, and the evolving terms of the India-US trade deal. "Ultimately, India's ability to capitalize on its strengths while navigating new tariff barriers will define its export trajectory in the post-tariff pause era,' said Mohit Gulati.
