Mumbai commuters fume over state govt decision to stop illegal bus shuttles; transport minister reiterates action on aggregator buses, cabs, or bike taxis flouting rules
" Uber Shuttle will completely shut down from Saturday morning.
On Friday, Sarnaik issued an official directive that legal action will be taken against private transport businesses, including buses, cars, and bike taxis, if they violate rules.
Those using Cityflo and Uber Shuttles for daily commutes to office and back told TOI that if these app-based buses go off roads, they would be inconvenienced. Cityflo continues to operate and no action initiated so far, sources said.
You Can Also Check:
Mumbai AQI
|
Weather in Mumbai
|
Bank Holidays in Mumbai
|
Public Holidays in Mumbai
"It will deprive commuters the benefit of travelling comfortably in these premium app-based buses which guarantee confirmed seats," said Sandeep Sinha, who takes the Uber Shuttle from Thane Viviana Mall to BKC regularly and travels in BharatBenz buses.
These shuttles connect Navi Mumbai, Thane, and Mumbai to commercial hubs such as BKC and Nariman Point, catering to commuters in over 500 private buses.
Raising the issue of aggregator buses in the legislative council on Friday, BJP MLC Niranjan Davkhare said Cityflo buses were a boon for office-goers and should not be banned.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Most Women Have No Idea This Household Item Fades Dark Spots Overnight
usalabnews.com
Undo
"Take action against them if there are any violations, but do not ban them," he urged. Vashi resident Shweta Desai, a Cityflo user, said, "Cityflo is a hit with commuters travelling the north-south corridor of the city or from Mumbai to Thane/Navi Mumbai.
It has led to ease of commuting to the office and back, with routes from Vashi to Andheri, Worli, or south Mumbai commercial hubs."
Deepa Mukherjee from Mulund said, "I travel comfortably to Goregaon East unlike waiting in a long queue for BEST AC buses."
Experts said that under the central govt guidelines, state should have taken the initiative to issue licences to app-based buses under the aggregator policy. On Friday, a group of experts participated in discussions on how to go ahead with the state's Premium Bus Aggregator policy at a meeting by the Maharashtra Institution for Transformation.
Netizens poured their anger against the action on aggregator bus shuttles on social media.
"Why are these ministers after public convenience? At least these bus services make pathetic roads, highly congested road journeys bearable," said one post on X. Another post stated: "Citizens ask 'Can we get more BEST buses?' & govt says No; Citizens say 'Ok, we will use pvt buses' & Govt says 'Sorry, not allowed. We will take them off the roads too'.
" A netizen posted on X: "Those people who want better service and are ready to pay should get it — that's what Cityflo and other players are giving.
Why should govt have a problem? If Ola and Uber cabs can run, why not buses?", while another wrote: "First you cannot provide good public transport buses, and now you do not want to allow anyone offering good bus service to us. This is anti-citizen."
— Inputs by Clara Lewis
Status: Not Approved
HEAD: 11_Mum_SS_Citizens Fume aggregator bus shuttles
Byline: None
Commuters express anger as government stops unlicensed bus shuttles and uber shuttle shuts down
Commuters fume over transport minister's decision to stop bus shuttles operating without licence; Uber Shuttle off platform from today.
Minister reiterates action on aggregator buses, cabs, or bikes flouting rules; meets senior transport officials on Friday.
Somit Sen & Clara Lewis
Mumbai: Hundreds of daily office-goers were angry on Friday, with many criticising on social media, over the transport minister's latest decision to take action against all private aggregator bus shuttles for "operating across MMR without a licence from state govt."
Uber's shuttle will completely shut down from Saturday morning, and the impact will be felt on Monday.
Minister Pratap Sarnaik also issued an official directive on Friday afternoon that legal action will be taken against private transport businesses, including buses, cars, and bike taxis, if they violated the rules. Those using Cityflo and Uber shuttles for daily commutes to the office and back told this newspaper that if such buses go off roads, it will leave them stranded.
"It will deprive citizens of the benefits of travelling comfortably in these premium app-based buses which guarantee confirmed and comfortable reclined seats," said Sandeep Sinha, who takes the Uber shuttle from Thane Viviana Mall to Bandra-Kurla Complex regularly and travels in BharatBenz buses.
The issue came up in Vidhan Bhavan on Friday. Raising the issue of aggregator buses in the legislative council on Friday, BJP MLC Niranjan Davkhare said the Cityflo buses were a boon for office-goers and should not be banned.
"Take action against them if there are any violations but do not ban them," he said.
Vashi resident Shweta Desai, a Cityflo user, said, "Cityflo is a superhit with commuters travelling the north-south corridor of the city or from Mumbai to Thane/Navi Mumbai. It has led to ease of commuting to the office and back, with routes from Vashi to Andheri, Worli, or south Mumbai commercial hubs." Deepa Mukherjee from Mulund said, "I travel comfortably to Goregaon East unlike waiting in a long queue for BEST AC buses.
"
These bus shuttles connect Navi Mumbai, Thane, and Mumbai to commercial hubs such as BKC and Nariman Point, catering to commuters in over 500 private buses. "It has good suspension, zero standees, reclining seats, charging points, personal AC vents, etc.," said Amit Phadnis, a commuter.
Experts said that under Central govt guidelines, the state should have taken the initiative to issue licences to such app-based buses under the Aggregator policy and issue licences.
In fact, on Friday, a group of experts participated in discussions on how to go ahead with the Premium Bus Aggregator policy of Maharashtra at a meeting by the Maharashtra Institution for Transformation (Mitra).
Some of the tweets on X stated: "Why are these ministers after public convenience? At least these bus services make pathetic roads, highly congested road journeys bearable." "Shuttle is a good option (for office-goers), yet the govt is taking the decision to shut down services."
"Those people who want better service and are ready to pay should get it -- that's what Cityflo and other players are giving. Why should govt have a problem? If Ola and Uber cabs can run, why not buses?" "First you cannot provide good public transport buses, and now you do not want to allow anyone offering good bus service to us.
This is anti-citizen." "Mr Sarnaik, how about investing more in BEST. Looks like you're busy troubling Mumbaikars rather than helping them." "Citizens ask 'Can we get more BEST buses?' & govt says No; Citizens say 'Ok, we will use pvt buses' & Govt says 'Sorry, not allowed. We will take them off the roads too.'"
Ends. MSID:: 122390278 413 |
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Man Ki Baat: PM Modi praises astronaut Shubhanshu Shukla; says new wave of curiosity for space among kids
File photo (Picture credit: PTI) NEW DELHI: Ahead of the National Space Day, PM Narendra Modi on Sunday highlighted India's growing capabilities in space sector, mentioning the achievement of IAF Group Captain Shubhanshu Shukla's recent journey to International Space Station, talked about a new wave of curiosity about space among children and pointed out that today more than 200 startups have come up in the space sector alone. Talking about Shubhanshu Shukla, who was one of the four crew members of the Axiom-4 mission to ISS, PM Modi, in his 124th 'Mann Ki Baat' episode, said, 'We shall touch upon the successes of the country; the achievements of the countrymen.' He said when Shukla landed back on Earth, a 'wave of happiness rippled through every heart' and added that the 'whole country was filled with pride.' PM Modi also highlighted how the success of Isro's Chandrayaan-3 mission created an atmosphere of curiosity in the country for space endeavours. 'I remember, when Chandrayaan-3 successfully landed in August 2023, a new ambience was created in the country. A new curiosity also arose among children about science, about space. Little children now say, we will also go to space; we will also land on the Moon — we will become space scientists," PM Modi said. PM Modi specifically mentioned the 'INSPIRE-MANAK Abhiyan,' which promotes innovation among children by providing them with a platform to develop innovative ideas rooted in science. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like No annual fees for life UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo 'In this, five children are selected from each school. Each child brings up a new idea. So far, lakhs of children have joined this, and after Chandrayaan-3, their number has doubled,' he said. PM noted a rise in India's space startups, pointing out that the number has almost quadrupled in the last five years. 'Five years ago, there were fewer than 50 start-ups. Today, there are more than 200," he said. Further noting the upcoming National Space Day on August 23, PM Modi said, "How will you celebrate it..., do you have any new ideas? Do send me a message on the NaMo App'. PM Modi also mentioned the recent achievements of students in the science and mathematics fields, giving a shout-out to the brightest minds. 'In 21st-century India, science is progressing with renewed energy. A few days ago, our students won medals in the International Chemistry Olympiad. India has also strengthened its image in the world of mathematics. In the International Mathematical Olympiad held in Australia, our students won 3 Gold, 2 Silver and 1 Bronze medal," PM Modi said. He also announced that an Astronomy and Astrophysics Olympiad is going to be held in Mumbai next month. This will be the biggest Olympiad to date, he noted. The PM also hailed the development of Unesco recognising 12 Maratha forts as World Heritage Sites. 'Eleven forts in Maharashtra; one in Tamil Nadu. Each fort has a chapter of history attached to it. Every stone is a testimony to a historical event... Salher Fort, where the Mughals were defeated, Shivneri, where Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj was born. A fort that is unbreachable for the enemy. Khanderi Fort is an amazing fort built in the middle of the sea,' he said. 'The enemy wanted to stop him, but Shivaji Maharaj made the impossible possible. Pratapgarh Fort, where Afzal Khan was defeated, the echo of that saga still remains entrenched in the walls of the fort. Vijaydurg, which had secret tunnels, is proof of Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj's farsightedness. I visited Raigad a few years ago... bowed in front of Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj's statue. This experience will stay with me all my life,' Modi said. He said sometimes a task comes across as impossible to some people, but when the country comes together on one thought, even the impossible becomes possible. '' Swachh Bharat Mission ' is the biggest example of this. Soon, this mission will complete 11 years. But its strength and its need are still the same,' he said. In these 11 years, 'Swachh Bharat Mission' has become a mass movement, and people consider it their duty, and this is real public participation, Modi said. 'The Swachh Survey conducted every year has lifted this feeling further. This year, more than 4500 cities and towns of the country joined it. More than 15 crore people participated in it. This is not an ordinary number. This is the voice of Swachh Bharat,' he said.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Dubai brokers earn a stunning AED 3.23 billion in just six months, land department reveals
Dubai's 29,577 registered brokers facilitated 42,181 transactions in H1 2025, nearly doubling commissions to AED 3.23 billion/ representative Image A Record Year in the Making Dubai's real estate market is not just having a good year, it's having its best one yet. In the first six months of the year, the market recorded its strongest mid-year performance to date. Total real estate transactions reached over AED 431 billion (approx. $117 billion) representing a 25 percent year-on-year increase. This growth was not only driven by property sales, but also by a wider set of real estate procedures that reflect a healthy and active market. Behind these numbers is a combination of policy changes, local and foreign investor confidence, and the steady expansion of supporting sectors such as real estate brokerage. Government strategies like the Dubai Economic Agenda D33 and the First Time Home Buyer Program have made it easier for residents and new investors to enter the market, while improved digital infrastructure and regulatory clarity have reduced friction in buying and selling property. This is not a short-term trend. The numbers show increasing participation from UAE residents, first-time buyers, and professionals working in real estate services, indicating that the market's growth is built on a broad base. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Paras Sector 59 Gurgaon | Luxury Awaits at Paras Floret Paras The Florett Book Now Undo The Engine of Growth: Brokers Take Center Stage Real estate brokers have played a central role in Dubai's property surge this year. In the first half of 2025, 42,181 transactions were completed through brokers. These deals generated more than AED 3.23 billion (approx. $880 million), in commissions, nearly double the AED 1.62 billion ($440 million) earned in the same period in 2024. This marks a 99 percent increase year-on-year. A significant reason for this spike is the sheer growth in the number of professionals entering the field. The Dubai Land Department (DLD) now lists 29,577 registered brokers, including 6,714 newcomers who joined in H1 2025 alone. This influx reflects growing trust in the sector, and in brokerage as a viable, high-value profession contributing meaningfully to the city's real estate infrastructure. A Rise in Women Brokers One standout development in the brokerage landscape is the rise of female participation. Today, 10,100 women are actively working as brokers, contributing to 13,424 transactions and generating nearly AED 1.43 billion (approx. $390 million) in commissions. Their growing presence highlights a shifting dynamic in deal-making, with women playing increasingly central roles in sales, negotiations, and client relationships. Beyond Transactions: A Wider Ecosystem The brokerage ecosystem now includes 1,223 registered brokerage offices and 78 property valuation offices employing 118 licensed valuers. In addition, 2,426 registered real estate services offices continued to play a pivotal role in the sector. During the first half of the year, Real Estate Registrations and Services Trustees Offices facilitated 114,848 transactions, serving 86,398 customers, marking a 15% increase in the number of customers compared to the same period last year. These offices handle key functions such as documentation, transaction processing, and regulatory compliance, forming a reliable bridge between buyers, sellers, and developers. This support network reinforces Dubai's position as a transparent, well-regulated, and investor-friendly real estate market. The Bigger Picture: Unprecedented Market Performance Zooming out, the broader real estate landscape in Dubai is thriving at every level. H1 2025 marked the strongest mid-year performance on record, with 125,538 real estate transactions, This is a 26 percent increase compared to the 99,947 transactions during the same period last year. The total value of these transactions rose from AED 345 billion (approx. $94 billion) in H1 2024 to AED 431 billion (approx. $117 billion) in H1 2025, reflecting a 25 percent annual increase. Over 1.3 million procedures were logged, ranging from property sales to leasing and renewals, illustrating a deeply liquid and dynamic market. Importantly, this wasn't just a frenzy of activity, it was strategic and sustained, supported by significant investor interest and long-term buying behavior. First-Time and Local Investor Investor participation has also increased. A total of 94,717 investors were active in the market in H1 2025, up 26 percent from the previous year. These investors carried out 118,132 investments with a combined value of AED 326 billion, equivalent to approximately 88.8 billion US dollars. This compares to AED 234 billion, or 63.8 billion US dollars, in H1 2024, reflecting a 39 percent increase in value. Within this group, 59,075 were first-time investors, marking a 22 percent rise from last year. These new participants contributed AED 157 billion, or 42.8 billion US dollars, to the market, which represents a 40 percent increase in investment value year-on-year. Notably, nearly 45 percent of these first-time investors were UAE residents, showing that government incentives and housing programs are succeeding in turning long-term residents into property owners. A Global Capital Magnet In the first half of 2025, Dubai attracted diverse capital inflows from key investor groups including: Foreign investors: AED 228.35 billion (approx. $62.2 billion) Arab (non-GCC) nationals: AED 28.4 billion (approx. $7.7 billion) GCC citizens: AED 22.56 billion (approx. $6.15 billion) The market also saw strong participation from women investors. A total of 30,487 women executed 34,792 transactions, with a total value of AED 73.2 billion($19.9 billion). This reflects increasing involvement of women in wealth-building and property ownership, aligning with the broader trend of inclusive economic growth. Where the Money Is Going: Top Investment Zones Dubai's property boom is geographically diverse. While traditional hotspots remain strong, newer zones are emerging with high transaction volumes and investment value: Top by Number of Deals: Al Barsha South Fourth: 10,469 transactions Al Yalayis 1: 7,595 Wadi Al Safa 5: 7,178 Business Bay: 6,601 Dubai Marina: 6,428 Airport City: 5,569 Top by Transaction Value: Dubai Marina: AED 25.1 billion ($6.83 billion) Business Bay: AED 22.5 billion ($6.12 billion) Burj Khalifa Area: AED 17.1 billion ($4.65 billion) Palm Jumeirah : AED 16.96 billion ($4.61 billion) Other Notables: Al Yalayis 1, Meaisem Second, Mohammed Bin Rashid Gardens , each logging over AED 14 billion ($3.8 billion+) This mix of waterfront developments, luxury zones, and emerging communities signals both a diversified portfolio of investor preferences and a robust supply pipeline. What's Fueling the Boom: Policy, Planning, and Trust Dubai's real estate success story in 2025 isn't accidental. It's the result of deliberate strategies, both legislative and visionary. Key drivers include: The D33 Economic Agenda: Aiming to position Dubai among the top three global cities economically. Dubai Real Estate Strategy 2033: Focused on long-term resilience, inclusion, and affordability. First Time Home Buyer Program: Offering preferential access, lower fees, and attractive mortgage terms for new buyers. Digital Reforms: Streamlined DLD services and transparent regulations. Stable Environment: In an increasingly volatile world, Dubai offers a mix of high returns, legal safety, and ease of doing business. Together, these efforts have redefined Dubai from a transactional real estate market to a structured, investor-driven hub rooted in public-private partnership and long-term urban development.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Chirag's remarks on crimes show his weakness; he has no concerns for Bihar, alleges Tejashwi
A day after Union Minister Chirag Paswan slammed the Nitish Kumar government over the law and order situation in Bihar, RJD leader Tejashwi Yadav on Sunday claimed that the Hajipur MP's comment showed his "weakness" as a ruling NDA partner, and alleged that he has "no real concerns" for the state. Yadav was reacting to the remarks of Chirag, the chief of Lok Janshakti Party (Ram Vilas), which drew a sharp reaction from Chief Minister Nitish Kumar's JD (U), exposing cracks in the NDA ahead of the assembly polls. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Please select course: Select a Course Category Data Science Data Analytics Degree MCA others Finance Project Management MBA Healthcare Data Science Leadership Others Product Management Cybersecurity Technology Management Design Thinking Artificial Intelligence healthcare Digital Marketing Operations Management CXO Public Policy PGDM Skills you'll gain: Data Analysis & Interpretation Programming Proficiency Problem-Solving Skills Machine Learning & Artificial Intelligence Duration: 24 Months Vellore Institute of Technology VIT MSc in Data Science Starts on Aug 14, 2024 Get Details Skills you'll gain: Strategic Data-Analysis, including Data Mining & Preparation Predictive Modeling & Advanced Clustering Techniques Machine Learning Concepts & Regression Analysis Cutting-edge applications of AI, like NLP & Generative AI Duration: 8 Months IIM Kozhikode Professional Certificate in Data Science and Artificial Intelligence Starts on Jun 26, 2024 Get Details The leader of the opposition seemed unimpressed with Chirag's decision to contest the Bihar assembly elections due later this year. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like This Japanese AI invention allows you to speak 68 languages instantly. The idea? Genius. Enence 2.0 Undo "Chiarg Paswan has merely demonstrated his weakness as a minister and as a coalition partner. His comments show he loves only his chair and has no real concerns for Bihar," Yadav alleged. Paswan had on Saturday said, "Law and order have completely collapsed in the state. The police have surrendered to criminals in Bihar. I regret having to support a government which is unable to prevent such crimes. The situation of Bihar has, indeed, become scary." Live Events Yadav also alleged that there is "no law and order" in the state. Asked about the incident of alleged gang-rape of a woman inside an ambulance in Gayaji, Yadav said, "It's shocking and shameful. Just imagine the law and order situation in the state." "More than 100 murders took place in the last one week in the state. They (NDA) call it a double-engine government. One engine is crime, and another is corruption. The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) has pulled up the Bihar government for failing to submit utilisation certificates (UCs) worth over Rs 70,877 crore. There is a scam of more than Rs 70,000 crore," the RJD leader alleged. The CAG report on state finances for 2023-24 was tabled in the state assembly on Thursday. "Despite the requirement of submitting UCs within stipulated time period, 49,649 outstanding UCs of Rs 70,877.61 crore were not received by the Accountant General (Accounts & Entitlements), Bihar, as on March 31, 2024", the report had said. The high pendency of UCs is "fraught with the risk of embezzlement, misappropriation and diversion of funds", it added. Union minister and founder of Hindustani Awam Morcha (Secular) Jitan Ram Manjhi on Sunday slammed Paswan for his outbursts over the alleged increase in crimes in Bihar. "He (Chirag) is a new entrant in politics. He has not seen the days of jungle raj in the state before 2005. If he is not aware of the situation during the RJD rule, he should not make such comments. Now, the law and order situation is undoubtedly much better. Bihar is rapidly developing under the NDA rule", he told reporters in Gayaji.
