Paihia ship fire: 'We've lost a significant bit of history'
Photo:
RNZ / Peter de Graaf
The cause of a fire that destroyed a historic ship at the Paihia waterfront may never be known, a fire investigator says.
The Tui - originally built to transport sugar from the Chelsea refinery on Auckland's North Shore more than a century ago - was
severely damaged in a blaze that started just after 4am on Wednesday
.
What remained of the vessel was then demolished with a digger to prevent the debris being swept into the Bay of Islands.
Northland fire investigator Craig Bain said police were treating the blaze as suspicious and were following up on a number of vehicles seen in the area on CCTV footage around the time the fire started.
However, Bain said power was connected to the ship's main switchboard, so he could not immediately rule out an electrical fault as the cause.
His job was hampered by the need to demolish the ship quickly.
A digger demolishes what's left of the Tui before high tide can sweep the debris into the Bay of Islands.
Photo:
RNZ / Peter de Graaf
Bain said the Tui was effectively a "boat within a boat", because the late Kelly Tarlton had built a replica three-masted barque around the original sugar lighter - a type of flat-bottomed vessel.
He said the flames had spread between the two hulls towards the bow.
"So the only way we can really put this out is unfortunately to demolish the boat."
It was also a race against time because the remains of the ship had to be removed from the beach before high tide at 2.30pm on Wednesday, to prevent the debris being washed into the Bay of Islands.
Bain said it was too risky to get on the ship because the fire-damaged masts were "precarious".
"We can't get in there to get a good look, it's just too dangerous."
A digger demolishes what's left of the Tui as firefighters continue dampening down the wreckage.
Photo:
RNZ / Peter de Graaf
The last of the three masts collapsed about 10am.
Instead, he was examining the debris being pulled off the ship in the hope that would give him some idea of how the fire started.
If he was unable to establish the cause of the fire it would be classed as undetermined.
Bain was, however, confident it had started at the rear of the ship.
"It's quite devastating for Paihia and the Northland community in that we've lost a significant bit of history," he said.
Bain said he felt for the people who had been striving to turn the ship into a marine education centre.
Restoration work had been due to start in earnest om the day of the fire, he said.
Northland fire investigator Craig Bain inspects debris pulled off the ship in the hope of identifying the cause of the fire.
Photo:
RNZ / Peter de Graaf
Paihia deputy fire chief Sandro Schuetze said the first fire call came in at 4.07am.
In total 13 fire trucks responded with more than 50 firefighters from as far away as Whangārei.
"Everyone gave their best to try to save the boat, but the condition of the boat and the high wind meant we couldn't save it at all."
Schuetze said it was a sad day for the local community.
Many people had fond memories of the ship as Kelly Tarlton's Museum of Shipwrecks, and later as a series of restaurants.
The last of those, Shippey's, closed in 2014.
"It was undergoing work to bring it back to its glory… but it will not see that glory anymore, unfortunately."
A warning was issued for people in the area to keep their doors and windows closed due to the high winds and thick smoke.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
New Zealand authorities investigating over 40 trafficking offences
The current 42 active investigations had elements of trafficking. Photo: 123RF Authorities have more than 42 active investigations underway into suspected trafficking offences. Associate Immigration Minister Casey Costello said the government is 'not sitting on its laurels' about the extent of the cross-border and domestic issue. RNZ reported in March trafficking investigations had increased by almost 4000 percent , but no-one had been prosecuted since 2018. The figures show there were only six investigations from 2018 to 2020, and 236 in the two years up to last October. The current 42 active investigations had elements of trafficking, said Costello, who took over responsibility for work against organised crime, including trafficking, earlier this year. She said people were becoming desensitised to exploitation, trafficking and slavery - and were conflating it with issues such as being paid under the table or not getting holiday pay. The victimisation was often unseen and the enormity of trafficking was often not understood, she said. The last trafficking case to be prosecuted was in 2020, when Hastings-based Joseph Auga Matamata was jailed for 11 years after bringing 13 Samoans to New Zealand and exploiting them over 25 years. An unknown number of children have been brought from overseas and been sexually or financially exploited, or used as household slaves . Costello said she is hopeful that fixes to international adoptions, where children have been exploited after being brought into the country without checks , will happen before the end of this parliamentary term. But she remains unconvinced about how effective legislation would be in forcing companies to check their supply chains for modern slavery, a recommendation from the Ministerial Advisory Group on Transnational, Serious and Organised Crime. "We have heard that it is highly likely that serious criminal exploitation, such as people trafficking, forced labour and sexual exploitation, is underreported and growing within New Zealand," said the group in its latest report. "There are almost certainly exploited migrants in our horticulture, construction, beauty services and hospitality sectors." Associate Immigration Minister Casey Costello. Photo: RNZ / Angus Dreaver It recommended 'high-risk industries' to actively identify, prevent, mitigate and account for the integrity of their supply chains, and making them subject to legal liability and regulatory enforcement similar to workplace health and safety. Organised crime is the theme of today's World Day Against Trafficking in Persons and INZ said criminal networks were often behind trafficking. "Frontline staff, particularly at the border, are trained to help them recognise indicators of trafficking in persons. We also support the training of law enforcement officials to recognise suspected trafficking in the community," INZ said. "When a report is made, we assess the information provided. Victims of trafficking are eligible for access to support services from the government including from the Ministry of Social Development, the health sector, and INZ." It points out warning signs that a person may need help, including migrants living at their place of work, locks on the outside of doors, people who have 'rehearsed' statements and stories, or do not have money or ID, which might suggest their passport is being withheld. The latest ministerial advisory group report recommends clarifying the mandates between MBIE and Police for taking the lead on human trafficking offences to improve effectiveness, and called for MBIE to update its systems and processes. In September 2018, Australia, Canada, New Zealand, the UK and US jointly launched the Principles to Guide Government Action to Combat Human Trafficking in Global Supply Chains, including in private sector supply chains and government procurement practices. The five-year New Zealand plan of action against forced labour, people trafficking and slavery expires this year. Out of its annual implementation reports, only two were published, in 2021 and 2022. One of the measures was visas for certified victims to work and/or stay in New Zealand. Thirteen Victims of People Trafficking residence (and 33 temporary work) visas were approved in 2020/21, three the year after but none since. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Controversial police directive saw retail crime investigations halve in some regions
Police Commissioner Richard Chambers. Photo: Calvin Samuel / RNZ A former police directive to staff on retail crime thresholds has led to a significant decrease in the number of files being investigated across the country, documents released to RNZ reveal. The directive, which has since been scrapped, told staff they would no longer be investigating allegations of retail crime below certain financial thresholds . In the first 12 days of the directive, Wellington had the biggest shift in total number of cases going from an average of 60 per day to 30. Auckland City had a 26 percent drop, Tasman 56 percent, Canterbury 13 percent and Southern 37 percent. RNZ earlier revealed a directive was sent to staff relating to police's File Management Centre (FMC) titled 'Assignment Changes - Theft and Fraud'. The directive said FMC was applying "nationally standardised value thresholds" when assessing theft and fraud files. The value thresholds were: General theft $200, petrol drive off $150, shoplifting $500, fraud (paywave, online, scam etc) $1000, and all other fraud $500. "When assessing files with these offences, you will apply the relevant value threshold and file any file under that threshold regardless of any lines of enquiry or IFA score," it said. Following the revelations, Police Commissioner Richard Chambers canned the directive, which he called "confusing and unhelpful" following significant backlash. On Wednesday, a series of documents from police under the Official Information Act was released to RNZ. The documents include an email from 7 April revealing the number of files being assigned for investigation since the rules were put in place 12 days earlier. In the email, the police advisor said Wellington had the biggest change from an average of 60 per day to an average of 30. The numbers were being compared to baseline data over a 47-day period before the threshold was put into place. During the same period Auckland City had a 26 percent decrease, Counties Manukau 21 percent, Eastern 38 percent, Central 42 percent and Canterbury 13 percent. Waikato had a 2.7 percent increase, which the staffer said was due to filed being reassigned and appearing twice. The OIA also includes a template that had been created to send to victims whose crimes did not meet the threshold. The email thanked the victims for reporting their crime but said they "regret to advise, at this time, police is unable to investigate further". "While we would like to resolve all matters to our victims' complete satisfaction, there are occasions where we cannot," it said. "Investigations are prioritised using a range of factors including legal timeframes and the likelihood of a successful conviction." The email said police appreciated this may be "frustrating and upsetting" to hear, "particularly if you reported the incident recently or provided lines of enquiry". "We will however review your case if our ability to resolve this matter changes." Police earlier launched a review to establish how many cases of retail crime were filed while the controversial directive was in place. A police spokesperson earlier confirmed to RNZ the national value threshold applied to the prioritisation of lower-level theft and fraud offences was being removed. "A review is being completed on any cases that may have been impacted by those thresholds to assess whether they should be assigned to districts for follow-up," the spokesperson said. The review will be done by police's data quality team. "Police want to reassure that cases will continue to be managed locally balancing demand, resources and priorities to ensure the best possible service to victims in those communities." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Controversial police directive saw retail crime investigations half in some regions
Police Commissioner Richard Chambers. Photo: Calvin Samuel / RNZ A former police directive to staff on retail crime thresholds has led to a significant decrease in the number of files being investigated across the country, documents released to RNZ reveal. The directive, which has since been scrapped, told staff they would no longer be investigating allegations of retail crime below certain financial thresholds . In the first 12 days of the directive, Wellington had the biggest shift in total number of cases going from an average of 60 per day to 30. Auckland City had a 26 percent drop, Tasman 56 percent, Canterbury 13 percent and Southern 37 percent. RNZ earlier revealed a directive was sent to staff relating to police's File Management Centre (FMC) titled 'Assignment Changes - Theft and Fraud'. The directive said FMC was applying "nationally standardised value thresholds" when assessing theft and fraud files. The value thresholds were: General theft $200, petrol drive off $150, shoplifting $500, fraud (paywave, online, scam etc) $1000, and all other fraud $500. "When assessing files with these offences, you will apply the relevant value threshold and file any file under that threshold regardless of any lines of enquiry or IFA score," it said. Following the revelations, Police Commissioner Richard Chambers canned the directive, which he called "confusing and unhelpful" following significant backlash. On Wednesday, a series of documents from police under the Official Information Act was released to RNZ. The documents include an email from 7 April revealing the number of files being assigned for investigation since the rules were put in place 12 days earlier. In the email, the police advisor said Wellington had the biggest change from an average of 60 per day to an average of 30. The numbers were being compared to baseline data over a 47-day period before the threshold was put into place. During the same period Auckland City had a 26 percent decrease, Counties Manukau 21 percent, Eastern 38 percent, Central 42 percent and Canterbury 13 percent. Waikato had a 2.7 percent increase, which the staffer said was due to filed being reassigned and appearing twice. The OIA also includes a template that had been created to send to victims whose crimes did not meet the threshold. The email thanked the victims for reporting their crime but said they "regret to advise, at this time, police is unable to investigate further". "While we would like to resolve all matters to our victims' complete satisfaction, there are occasions where we cannot," it said. "Investigations are prioritised using a range of factors including legal timeframes and the likelihood of a successful conviction." The email said police appreciated this may be "frustrating and upsetting" to hear, "particularly if you reported the incident recently or provided lines of enquiry". "We will however review your case if our ability to resolve this matter changes." Police earlier launched a review to establish how many cases of retail crime were filed while the controversial directive was in place. A police spokesperson earlier confirmed to RNZ the national value threshold applied to the prioritisation of lower-level theft and fraud offences was being removed. "A review is being completed on any cases that may have been impacted by those thresholds to assess whether they should be assigned to districts for follow-up," the spokesperson said. The review will be done by police's data quality team. "Police want to reassure that cases will continue to be managed locally balancing demand, resources and priorities to ensure the best possible service to victims in those communities." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
