US transport body chief says Air India crash report suspecting pilot error ‘premature'
A preliminary investigation released last week by India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau found confusion in the cockpit shortly before the June 12 crash, raising questions about the position of the critical engine fuel cutoff switches.
The crash in the western Indian city of Ahmedabad killed 260 people.
'Investigations of this magnitude take time," NTSB chair Jennifer Homendy said in a social media post on Friday. She called recent media reports on the crash 'premature and speculative', without providing any specifics about what exactly she was referring to.
The investigation report revealed that the Boeing 787 Dreamliner's fuel switches were almost simultaneously flipped from 'run' position to 'cutoff' barely three seconds after takeoff. It said one pilot was heard on the cockpit voice recorder asking the other why he had cut off the fuel. "The other pilot responded that he did not do so," the report said.
At the crash site, however, both fuel switches were found in the 'run' position. The report noted there had been indications of the engines relighting before the low-altitude crash.
The Wall Street Journal reported, citing unnamed sources, that an analysis of the investigation report showed first officer Clive Kunder had control of the Dreamliner for takeoff and at the time of the crash. It was Kunder who had asked captain Sumeet Sabharwal why he had flipped the switches, the paper added.
All but one of the 242 people onboard Air India flight AI171 to London Gatwick were killed, including 53 British nationals. Nineteen people also died on the ground as the plane crashed into a medical college building.
Pilots' associations and Air India chief executive Campbell Wilson have urged the public not to draw conclusions while the investigation was ongoing.
The Airline Pilots' Association of India, representing the South Asian country's pilots at the International Federation of Air Line Pilots' Associations in Montreal, called for "fair, fact-based inquiry'.
"The pilot's body must now be made part of the probe, at least as observers," the association's India president Sam Thomas said.
After the preliminary report was released, India's civil aviation authority ordered inspections of fuel switches on all Boeing 737 and 787 aircraft operating in the country.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
24 minutes ago
- The Independent
A pilot made sharp turn to avoid a B-52 bomber over North Dakota, then took to the mic to explain
The pilot of a regional airliner flying over North Dakota carried out an unexpected sharp turn and later apologized to passengers, explaining that he made the move after spotting a military plane in his flight path. The Friday incident is detailed in a video taken by a passenger and posted to social media as Delta Flight 3788 approached the Minot International Airport for landing. In the video, the SkyWest pilot can be heard over the plane's intercom system explaining that he made the sharp left turn after spotting a B-52 bomber in his flight path. 'Sorry about the aggressive maneuver. It caught me by surprise,' the pilot can be heard saying on the video. "This is not normal at all. I don't know why they didn't give us a heads up.' SkyWest, a regional carrier for Delta and other large airlines, said the flight had departed from the Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport and landed safely in Minot after performing a 'go-around' maneuver when another aircraft became visible in the SkyWest plane's flight path. Minot is 100 miles (160 kilometers) north of Bismarck, North Dakota's capital city, and about 50 miles (80 kilometers) from the Canadian border. The Federal Aviation Administration said in a statement that it's investigating the incident. SkyWest said it is also investigating. In the video, the pilot noted that Minot's small airport does not operate radar and directs flights visually. When the airport tower instructed the SkyWest flight to make a right turn upon approach, the pilot said he looked in that direction and saw the bomber in his flight path. He informed the tower and made a hard left instead, he said. 'I don't know how fast they were going, but they were a lot faster than us,' the pilot said of the bomber. The North Dakota incident comes nearly six months after a midair collision between an Army helicopter and a jetliner over Washington, D.C., that killed all 67 people aboard the two aircraft. Minot Air Force Base is about 10 miles (16 kilometers) north of Minot, North Dakota's fourth-largest city. The base is home to 26 B-52 bombers, intercontinental ballistic missile operations and more than 5,400 military personnel. An Air Force spokesperson confirmed Monday that a B-52 bomber assigned to the base conducted a flyover of the North Dakota State Fair on Friday and that the Air Force is 'looking into' the report of a bomber and a commercial airliner operating in the same airspace around the Minot airport. The pilot's frustration is evident in the video. 'The Air Force base does have radar, and nobody said, 'Hey, there's a B-52 in the pattern,'' the pilot told passengers. ——- Beck reported from Omaha, Nebraska.
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Delta flight narrowly avoids mid-air crash with B-52 bomber
A passenger jet was forced into an 'aggressive manoeuvre' to avoid crashing into a US air force bomber. A SkyWest flight, acting as a Delta connection between Minneapolis to Minot, North Dakota, was cleared for landing on Friday when the pilot 'performed a go-around' to avoid colliding with a B-52 bomber, the airline said. In a video recording captured by a passenger in the airliner, the pilot can be heard apologising to passengers on board, saying they probably saw the aeroplane 'coming at us' and that 'nobody told us about it'. Flight tracking data reviewed by The Washington Post shows SkyWest Flight 3788 make a sharp right turn as it approaches Minot airport, then climb in altitude as it circled to land. Around the same time, a B-52 performed a circular manoeuvre in the same area. The pilot told passengers the airport's control tower does 'everything visually' because it does not have radar and had instructed him to turn right, where he saw the military plane hovering into view. At first, the pilot said he mistook the plane for a small aircraft before realising it was a military plane on a 'convergence course' with the jet. 'It caught me by surprise' Given the speed the bomber was travelling, the pilot said he felt it was the 'safest thing to turn behind it' and perform a go-around, aborting an initial landing before approaching for a second time once the skies were clear. 'Sorry about the aggressive manoeuvre, it caught me by surprise,' the pilot said. 'This is not normal at all. I don't know why they didn't give us a heads-up. 'The air force base does have radar, and nobody said: 'Hey, there's a B-52 in the pattern.'' Passengers applauded the pilot for his quick-thinking as he signed off by saying: 'It was not a fun day at work. Have a nice evening, and I'm glad you are safe.' US air force officials did not provide details of the incident, but said they are looking into the matter after a B-52 bomber performed a flyover at the North Dakota State Fair in Minot, which is home to an air force base. 'We are aware of the recent reporting regarding commercial and air force aircraft operating in airspace around Minot International Airport. We are currently looking into the matter,' the service said in a statement. 'I remember the plane going sideways' Monica Green, the passenger who recorded the video of the pilot's apology, said the incident left her feeling 'sick to my stomach'. 'I just remember the plane going, like, sideways... and just looking straight out the window and just seeing grass, like you weren't seeing the skyline anymore,' she told NBC News. She added that she was nervous about returning to the airport for her homeward flight. The long-range B-52 bomber is 159ft long with a 185ft wingspan and is capable of carrying nuclear and precision guided weapons at an altitude of up to 50,000ft. The aircraft has been the backbone of the air force's strategic bomber force for 60 years and played a key role in the Gulf War and Nato's bombing of Yugoslavia in 1999. The close encounter comes after an army black hawk helicopter collided with a passenger jet near Reagan National Airport in Washington DC in January, killing 67 people. The crash prompted lawmakers to review coordination between military and civilian aircraft. The FAA has said it is investigating the incident. A SkyWest spokesman said: 'SkyWest flight 3788, operating as Delta connection from Minneapolis, Minnesota to Minot, North Dakota on July 18, landed safely in Minot after being cleared for approach by the tower but performed a go-around when another aircraft became visible in their flight path. We are investigating the incident.'
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
How pilots cutting engines sparked TWO plane disasters after South Korea & India crashes as calls for cockpit CCTV grow
PILOTS manually cutting the engines were to blame for the two most deadly air crashes of this decade, investigations suggest. With a total of 420 lives lost in the flick of three buttons, urgent questions are swirling about what can be done to reduce the risk of pilot error or sabotage. 8 8 8 8 The Jeju Air emergency-landing crash killed 179 people in December, and 241 people died when the Air India plane came down shortly after takeoff in June. Investigators have sensationally revealed there is "clear evidence" that the Jeju Air pilots mistakenly shut down the wrong engine after a bird strike. The plane was then forced to make an emergency landing at Muan International Airport on December 29, where it slammed into a concrete wall and burst into a fireball. Meanwhile, the leading theory in the Air India crash is that the pilot manually flipped both guarded fuel switches to the 'cut-off' position — a move aviation experts say could only have been deliberate. A report from the Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau of India (AAIB) revealed a recording of the panicked co-pilot asking which the main pilot shut off the engines. Terry Tozer, former airline pilot and author of "Confessions of an Airline Pilot – Why Planes Crash", told The Sun that it would have been be possible for the Air India pilot to shut off the engines without the other noticing. In the cockpit were Captain Sumeet Sabharwal and First Officer Clive Kunder. Terry said: "The handling pilot, which we know was the First Officer, would have had his hands full. "He would have had his hands on the controls, but the monitoring pilot [Sumeet] would have his hands free." "There is absolutely no procedure or logical reason why you would shut the engines off just after takeoff. That's so blindingly obvious that it doesn't need to be stated. "So either it happened by accident, which I think a lot of people find extremely hard to believe or it was done deliberately." Terry said that the switches are "latched", meaning you have to lift them up before you can move them. Despite the safety mechanism, Terry said it would 'probably' have been possible for one pilot to shut down the engines without the monitoring pilot noticing, because the switches "would be kind of behind his natural line of sight". The experience pilot also called on investigators to release a key piece of evidence that could clear up what happened in India. 8 8 He explained the area microphone on the cockpit voice recorder would have picked up the sound of the switches being flicked. Terry said: 'So it would have been helpful if the investigators had said whether or not they were able to tell whether a switch type sound was detectable around about the time that they think the switches might have been switched off.' Speaking about the Jeju crash, Terry said the pilots "obviously" shut down the wrong engine by "mistake" - but revealed they would have been contending with a chaos in the cockpit. He said: 'They probably would have had all kinds of bells and whistles going off and lots of indications that both engines were in trouble.' The former pilot said "takes time to analyze whether or not you should shut down one or neither or both" - but this was time the Jeju pilots did not have. He also said the new revelations about those crucial moments had been revealed in a "very odd manner". Terry said: "I understand that it was released to the relatives of the victims and in private, prior to release to the general public. "And then that causes riots and chaos." 8 8 However, Terry said that whatever happened in the two cockpits, there is one factor that determines passengers' fate above all else. He said the 'single most important thing' in passenger safety is the "airline culture". Terry explained: 'If it is a disciplined professional safety culture with a good training regime, then that makes a huge difference.' Terry recalled a similar occasion when the wrong engine was shut down - the Kegworth air disaster of 1989 - and said that was "definitely a cultural problem in the training department'. 'That may have been a factor with Jeju Air,' he said. In the wake of the two tragedies, many aviation figures have called for he introduction of cockpit CCTV. That would clear up immediately how the two engines came to be shut off on the Air India flight - but Terry said pilots would push back. He said: 'I can see why the investigators might welcome cockpit CCTV. "We should be doing everything we can to minimize crashes. 'And in any responsible environment, with a good airline and a regulatory environment that is already happening. "And obviously, if there was a video evidence of what went on on the cockpit. They would know the answers pretty clearly by now. "But it's something that I think pilots would resist, for the simple reason that they're already scrutinized, trained, checked, examined, monitored, regulated so much."
