logo
More transparency, more trouble? Sebi's revised disclosures rules divide experts

More transparency, more trouble? Sebi's revised disclosures rules divide experts

Mint02-07-2025
The Securities and Exchange Board of India's revised framework for disclosures related to related party transactions (RPT) has received mixed response from legal and governance professionals. While the updated rules are seen as a step towards greater transparency, experts have raised questions over its legal basis and pointed to additional compliance complexity and administrative burden it could involve.
The new disclosure regime was notified through a circular on 26 June and will be effective from 1 September.
Under Regulation 23 of Sebi's Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements (LODR), listed companies must obtain approval from their audit committees—and in case of material transactions, from shareholders as well—for related party transactions.
Sebi has now introduced a tiered format of disclosures under three categories: Part A covers all transactions; Part B applies to seven defined types, including loans and guarantees; and Part C mandates additional disclosures for material transactions.
'The revised RPT Industry Standards, though aimed at improving transparency, raise important legal and structural concerns," said Akshaya Bhansali, partner at Mindspright Legal, questioning the legal tenability of Sebi's new framework.
'They overlay the existing frameworks under the Companies Act and Sebi's LODR with additional disclosure formats and a flat ₹1 crore threshold that are not grounded in statutory text," Bhansali added. 'This creates a regulatory layering that risks confusion over which standard prevails in case of inconsistency."
Bhansali also flagged a departure from regulatory convention. 'The risk here is that substantive obligations are being introduced through a circular, without the procedural safeguards required under Sebi's own 2025 regulation-making process," she said, referring to the role played by industry associations in drafting the norms.
The new disclosure regime was developed in consultation with the Industry Standards Forum comprising the Associated Chambers of Commerce and Industry of India (ASSOCHAM), Confederation of Indian Industry (CII), and Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FICCI).
'Stemmed from past abuses'
The revised standards mandate extensive information for audit committees and shareholders, including the nature of the transaction, historical dealings with the related party, valuation details, and management certification that the deal is in the company's interest.
Companies are permitted to redact commercially sensitive details, provided the audit committee affirms that decision-making will not be impaired.
Some industry professionals welcomed the added transparency.
'The new information requirements represent greater transparency and accountability for related party transactions," said Clarence Anthony, founder of law firm Clarence & Partners. 'The audit committee now receives a certification from management that the proposed transaction is in the company's interest, along with robust price justification and details of past transactions, with such related party."
He added: 'Now the shareholders too will receive all information provided to the audit committee (where earlier they only received a summary), resulting in no information being lost through the various stages of approval."
Ketan Dalal, managing director at structuring and advisory firm Katalyst Advisors, noted that while the reforms aim to protect minority shareholders, they stemmed from a handful of past abuses.
'Some outlier situations where promoters' interest wasparamount or fraudulent, unfortunately led to regulatory cholesterol," he said. 'The revised industry standards seek to achieve that reasonable balance between interests of minority shareholders and relative ease of doing business."
Burdens and exemptions
Dalal, however, pointed to areas where Sebi's latest framework may prove burdensome. 'Some aspects still seem quite onerous—for example, where the related party's financial statements are not available for the immediately preceding year… the company shall provide financial extracts certified by the related party."
Still, he welcomed key exemptions. 'The circular has fortunately clarified that it does not apply to transactions between the listed company and its wholly owned subsidiaries, since there is no leakage," he said.
Dalal also appreciated Sebi's decision to limit application to omnibus approvals. 'The revised provision will help to save time for audit committees to focus on other matters, especially quarterly results."
However, Dalal cautioned that governance responsibilities are rising. 'Audit committee members would need to have the inclination and time to understand business issues better, since RPTs require more in-depth commercial understanding. A related aspect will be the need to compensate them better, especially those on audit committees."
He also flagged the increased burden on top executives. 'The requirement for a key managerial personnel to certify that RPTs are in the interest of the company will cast an onerous responsibility on them and should lead to better governance," Dalal said. 'However, KMPs (key managerial personnel) could become overly cautious."
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

NSE issues retail algo trading rulebook, mandates strategy registration
NSE issues retail algo trading rulebook, mandates strategy registration

Business Standard

time17 minutes ago

  • Business Standard

NSE issues retail algo trading rulebook, mandates strategy registration

With new norms taking effect for retail algorithmic (algo) trading from August 1, the National Stock Exchange (NSE) has released an operational rulebook aimed at fostering a safer and more transparent environment for traders using automated systems. The guidelines issued on Tuesday mandate the registration of all algo strategies, each of which will receive a unique identification (ID). Brokers will now be permitted to offer direct API access to their retail clients, though registration is mandatory. Further, it will be the brokers' responsibility to ensure that only eligible clients use the API or related facilities. For tech-savvy retail traders using their own algos, brokers will be required to disclose the PAN and unique client code of such clients. The application and registration of algo strategies must be done through a broker, with the algo ID allotted by the exchange. If there are more than 10 orders per second, the broker must register the algos developed by clients. Under the new framework, brokers will be held accountable for all orders routed through their terminals. The algo provider, in such cases, will act as an agent of the broker. The guidelines also prescribe several checks, including those related to price, quantity, order value, and position limits. This operational framework follows a circular issued by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) in February, which sought to address grey areas in algo trading and ensure appropriate safeguards for retail participants. Market participants had called the guidelines necessary, citing the rise in retail participation and the growing share of algo trades. Algo trading is now widespread across both institutional and retail segments. Algo trading involves executing trades using pre-programmed strategies based on parameters such as price movements and volumes, allowing for automated buying or selling of securities. In FY25, the share of algo trading surged to 70 per cent in equity derivatives (notional turnover), according to the NSE Market Pulse report. Nilesh Sharma, executive director and president, SAMCO Securities, noted: 'These regulations bring much-needed clarity by clearly defining what qualifies as an algo strategy. Notably, low-frequency strategies—those generating fewer than 10 orders per second—are not classified as high-frequency algos. This distinction significantly reduces the compliance burden for retail users deploying simpler, rule-based systems, encouraging wider adoption of technology-driven trading in a responsible manner.' All algo providers will have to be empanelled with the exchange, except those that are in-house and provided by brokers. The turnaround time for empanelment has been set at T+30 working days, while strategy registration will be completed in T+10 working days. Registration for execution algos—where the logic is disclosed—will follow a fast-track process and be completed in T+7 working days. While registering for 'blackbox' or 'whitebox' algos, disclosures on the basic risk management system and an auditor certificate will be required. For blackbox algos—where logic is not disclosed—Sebi has mandated registration of the algo provider as a research analyst. Any change in the logic governing an algo will necessitate re-registration. 'Trading members providing API/algo provider facilities for routing client orders shall not be allowed to cross trades of their clients with each other. All orders must be offered to the market for matching,' the NSE guidelines added.

CMRL-Exalogic case: Kerala High Court issues notice to Veena, 12 others
CMRL-Exalogic case: Kerala High Court issues notice to Veena, 12 others

The Hindu

timean hour ago

  • The Hindu

CMRL-Exalogic case: Kerala High Court issues notice to Veena, 12 others

The Kerala High Court has issued notice to Veena T., the daughter of Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan, her IT firm Exalogic Solutions Pvt. Ltd., and 11 others who had been arraigned as respondents in the case pertaining to the allegations regarding the financial transactions between Cochin Minerals and Rutile Ltd. (CMRL) and Exalogic. The notice was issued on a petition filed by BJP leader Shone George, seeking a Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) probe into the allegations. The 11 other respondents include Sasidharan Kartha, the MD of CMRL. In the petition, Mr. George said that the contents of the Serious Fraud Investigation Office (SFIO) probe report on the alleged financial transactions between the two companies had referred to corporate fraud. But the SFIO had limited the scope of its probe to offences under the Companies Act and did not investigate the motive behind the alleged illegal payments. He thus sought further probe in coordination with the CBI, the Enforcement Directorate (ED) and the Election Commission, since the findings involved offences under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, the Prevention of Corruption Act, and the Representation of People's Act. Veena's stance Ms. Veena had in an affidavit before the High Court in June refuted the allegation that her company is a 'benami' firm, and said it is operated independently of her father. In response to a PIL filed seeking a CBI probe into the allegations pertaining to the financial transactions between the two companies, she had said that the Union Ministry of Corporate Affairs had ordered a probe by the SFIO into certain affairs of the CMRL, including its transactions with Exalogic, under the Companies Act. As the SFIO was currently seized of the matter, all other agencies are precluded from probing it, she had contended then.

Sebi issues FAQs pertaining to regulatory provisions for Research Analysts
Sebi issues FAQs pertaining to regulatory provisions for Research Analysts

News18

timean hour ago

  • News18

Sebi issues FAQs pertaining to regulatory provisions for Research Analysts

New Delhi, Jul 23 (PTI) Capital markets regulator Sebi on Wednesday asked persons associated with research services to obtain the required NISM (National Institute of Securities Markets) certification within one year. This one-year period is applicable from the date of this circular, Sebi said. Further, institutional investors are not required to give signed consent on the terms and conditions, including the Most Important Terms and Conditions (MITC). However, Research Analysts (RAs)/research entities will still share and disclose these terms to them, according to the circular. These decisions have been taken based on feedback from RAs and research entities, and to make compliance easier. Additionally, in order to provide clarity and guidance for compliance by RAs with the regulatory provisions, Sebi has issued clarifications in the form of Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs). Under this, Sebi stated that a research report does not include communications related to general trends in the securities market, discussions on broad-based indices, or commentaries on economic, political, or market conditions. It also clarified that research reports do not include periodic reports prepared for unit holders of Mutual Funds or Alternative Investment Funds, or clients of Portfolio Managers and Investment Advisers; internal communications not shared with current or prospective clients; statistical summaries of financial data of companies; and technical analyses relating to demand and supply in a sector or index. The regulator said that a person located outside India can issue a research report or analysis on securities listed or proposed to be listed on Indian stock exchanges. However, before doing so, the person is required to enter into an agreement with a research analyst or research entity registered under the RA regulations. Regarding trading restrictions, Sebi said that independent research analysts, part-time research analysts, individuals employed as research analysts, or their associates would not deal in or trade any securities that the research analyst recommends or follows within 30 days before and 5 days after the publication of a research report on the subject company. They are also prohibited from dealing in securities they review in a manner contrary to their recommendations. Additionally, they shall not purchase or receive securities of an issuer before its initial public offering (IPO) if the issuer is principally engaged in the same type of business as companies that the research analyst follows or recommends. PTI SP MR view comments First Published: July 23, 2025, 19:45 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store