logo
What the controversial new 'Snow White' can teach Hollywood

What the controversial new 'Snow White' can teach Hollywood

Mint23-05-2025
'Snow White', Disney's live-action remake of a beloved animated film, had an icy reception before its release in cinemas on March 21st. A trailer posted three months ago has earned just 60,000 likes and over 1m dislikes. 'If I saw this movie on a plane I would still walk out,' grumbled one YouTube user. 'We thankfully have the technology nowadays to make the animation look worse than the original from 1937,' groaned another.
Among the remake's many sins are seven in particular: the dwarves, who have been cheesily rendered with computer-generated imagery (CGI), after a row over whether it was politically correct to have actors with dwarfism in the roles. (In the face of criticism, Disney recast the film's dwarves as 'magical creatures'—whatever that means.) There is also the issue of Rachel Zegler, the actress chosen to play Snow White, who panned the original film as 'extremely dated' and said that the prince 'literally stalks' the princess. It turns out fans do not like it when a remake's heroine villainises the classic film that inspired it.
By respinning familiar tales, remakes can offer studios a surer path towards commercial riches. In the amount of pushback and controversy it has faced, 'Snow White' is unusual. But in another way the film reflects a current trend, which is for studios to reach further back in history for source material. From 2020 to 2024 the average age of the source films that new remakes were based on was 35. That is about 13 years older than from 2011 to 2015, according to our analysis of data from The Numbers, a film website.
What makes for a successful remake? It is a question on the minds of many Hollywood executives, as well as cinephiles. To answer it, The Economist analysed 200 remakes released since 1995; each had a minimum of 5,000 ratings on IMDb, an online movie database. (Our analysis only includes remakes of films, not adaptations of books.) Three lessons stand out.
First, it is not enough to use state-of-the-art special effects; computer-generated imagery needs to be handled carefully. Of the 20 worst remakes (as measured by IMDb audience ratings), half are horror films, in part because of their use of unconvincing special effects. In the fifth-worst-rated, a remake in 2005 of John Carpenter's cult classic 'The Fog' from 1980, a supernatural, vengeful fog descends on an island town off the coast of Oregon. Cheap shocks substitute for tension: viewers have complained that the fog moves too quickly and that ghosts in the fog (never clearly visible in the original) are hokey, a complaint also made by viewers about the dwarves in the new 'Snow White'.
Second, comedies come with grave risks. This is the worst-performing genre for remakes, earning an average IMDb rating 1.5 points (out of ten) lower than the originals. Comedy remakes also tend to make the least at the box office. Not a single one significantly outshines the original film it was based on, according to audience ratings. It may be that viewers of comedies and horrors crave an element of surprise, which is hard to offer in a faithful remake, because audiences already know which gags and gasps to expect.
The best remakes get their inspiration from abroad. Since 1995 about a third of the top remakes have been based on foreign source material, including six of the top ten. So are the only two remakes to have won Academy Awards for Best Picture: 'The Departed' (2006), based on a Hong Kong film, and 'CODA' (2021), based on a French-Belgian one.
Unfamiliarity with the originals may mean that audiences come in with lower expectations and without any attachment to the original. Take 'Bugonia', starring Emma Stone, set to be released in November. It is an English-language remake of a South Korean film; instead of a male chief executive, the new story centres on a female one. However, audiences, lacking knowledge of the original, are unlikely to kick up a fuss about the change. The same cannot be said of the new 'Snow White', which seems destined for an unhappily-ever-after ending.
For more on the latest books, films, TV shows, albums and controversies, sign up to Plot Twist, our weekly subscriber-only newsletter
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Ananya Panday launches kindness curriculum for schools across India
Ananya Panday launches kindness curriculum for schools across India

Hans India

time15 minutes ago

  • Hans India

Ananya Panday launches kindness curriculum for schools across India

Bollywood actress Ananya Panday is championing a new cause aimed at instilling emotional intelligence and empathy in young minds. Through her digital social responsibility platform So Positive, Ananya has introduced a Kindness Curriculum for school children across India, in collaboration with the NGO Slam Out Loud. Ananya, who has consistently used her platform to promote positive digital behavior, shared her vision behind the initiative. 'Kindness has always been at the heart of everything we do at So Positive. I truly believe that if we can instill kindness in kids from a young age, it becomes second nature to them as they grow up,' she said. 'With everything going on in the world, I feel an even stronger need to help build a generation that's more empathetic, emotionally aware, and simply… kind.' The curriculum is set to be implemented in schools across the country through Slam Out Loud's Jijivisha Fellowship and the Arts for All program. It is expected to impact over 2.5 lakh children by helping them explore compassion and kindness through arts-based learning. To widen accessibility, the curriculum is also available on So Positive's YouTube channel, enabling parents and educators across the globe to incorporate it into their learning environments. Furthermore, efforts are underway to make it accessible on the Government of India's DIKSHA portal. On the professional front, Ananya is gearing up for her upcoming film Tu Meri Main Tera Main Tera Tu Meri, her second collaboration with Kartik Aaryan after Pati Patni Aur Woh. The romantic entertainer, directed by Sameer Vidwans and backed by Karan Johar, Adar Poonawalla, Apoorva Mehta, Shareen Mantri Kedia, and Kishor Arora, is scheduled for a theatrical release on February 13, 2026.

Avinash Mishra Says Bigg Boss 18 Taught Him To Handle Pressure: 'Made Me More Confident'
Avinash Mishra Says Bigg Boss 18 Taught Him To Handle Pressure: 'Made Me More Confident'

News18

timean hour ago

  • News18

Avinash Mishra Says Bigg Boss 18 Taught Him To Handle Pressure: 'Made Me More Confident'

Pyaar Se Bandhe Rishte is Balaji Telefilms' maiden venture into long-format YouTube originals. It will star Avinash Mishra with Shhraddha Surve and Dipali Sharma. Avinash Mishra, fresh off his impactful stint on Bigg Boss 18, is all set to return to fiction television powerfully. The actor has been roped in as the lead for Balaji Telefilms' upcoming show Pyaar Se Bandhe Rishte, a drama that promises to explore heartfelt emotions and the deep connections that bind people together. Stepping into a lead role under the Balaji banner, the actor is ready to bring a fresh emotional narrative to life—one that mirrors the very essence of love, family, and human bonds. Sharing his thoughts exclusively with News18 Showsha on this exciting new phase, Avinash said, 'Bigg Boss gave me a platform where people could see me beyond the characters I've played. It taught me a lot about myself how I handle pressure, how I connect with people, and how important it is to stay true to who you are. The love and encouragement I received after the show was overwhelming, and it made me more confident about the next steps in my career." He further added, 'Joining hands with Balaji for Pyaar Se Bandhe Rishte feels like the right move at the right time. The story is beautifully written, and the emotions are so real. I'm excited to explore this new character and take my audience on a journey filled with love, conflict, and connection. This show has my heart, and I hope it reaches theirs too." View this post on Instagram A post shared by Avinash Mishra (@avinash_world) Pyaar Se Bandhe Rishte is Balaji Telefilms' maiden venture into long-format YouTube originals. The makers recently dropped the first poster of the show, giving a glimpse of Avinash's striking new look. In the poster, Avinash was seen donning a navy blue blazer over a white t-shirt paired with blue jeans, striking the right balance between casual and classy. His neatly styled hair, well-groomed beard, and smart wristwatch add to his sharp appearance. The makers also revealed the looks of the female leads, Shhraddha Surve as Kavya and Dipali Sharma as Sanchi. Pyaar Se Bandhe Rishte will premiere on August 7. First Published: July 26, 2025, 11:49 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Chainsaw Man Part 2 anime: Release date, plot arcs and new characters you should know
Chainsaw Man Part 2 anime: Release date, plot arcs and new characters you should know

Time of India

timean hour ago

  • Time of India

Chainsaw Man Part 2 anime: Release date, plot arcs and new characters you should know

Source: Imdb Chainsaw Man is far from over and things are only getting more intense. With Part 2 of the anime officially in the works, fans are bracing for another round of bloody battles, emotional gut-punches, and surreal storytelling that made the series a breakout hit. From rumours about its release window to the story arcs likely to be adapted, Chainsaw Man Part 2 promises darker themes, unpredictable characters, and even more devilish action. Whether you're a manga reader or anime-only fan, this next chapter is shaping up to be wilder, weirder, and even more unforgettable. Here's what we know so far. Is Chainsaw Man Part 2 confirmed? Source: Imdb While MAPPA hasn't dropped an official release date for Chainsaw Man Season 2, the production is widely expected to continue. Based on how Season 1 wrapped up, teasing Reze in that haunting post-credits scene, Part 2 is already in motion behind the scenes. Industry insiders and leakers suggest a late 2025 or early 2026 premiere window. What will Chainsaw Man Part 2 cover? Source: Imdb Part 2 will likely adapt the Bomb Girl arc, introducing Reze, a beautiful new character with explosive secrets (literally). But that's just the beginning. If MAPPA follows the manga closely, we can expect major arcs likely to be adapted: Bomb Girl Arc – Reze's shocking identity and her connection to the Soviet devil program. International Assassins Arc – A global chase with some of the wildest devil hunters ever. Gun Devil Arc (continued) – The resolution of the Gun Devil mystery and some heartbreaking turns. Katana Man aftermath – Denji dealing with fame, trauma, and identity crises. These arcs are more emotional, violent, and philosophical than anything we saw in Season 1 and that's saying something. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Pirates Climb Aboard Cargo Ship - Watch What The Captain Did Next Tips and Tricks Undo Who are the new characters in Chainsaw Man Part 2? Source: Imdb Reze Don't be fooled by her charm. Reze is much more than a love interest, her backstory and power set will change everything for Denji. Quanxi The first devil hunter ever, and easily one of the coolest characters in the series. She's fast, deadly, and always one step ahead. Santa Claus No, not that Santa. This mysterious villain controls dolls and souls in ways that'll mess with your head. These characters bring deeper world-building, political intrigue, and moral complexity into the Chainsaw Man universe. Will Chainsaw Man Part 2 adapt Part 2 of the manga too? Source: Imdb Here's where it gets interesting: Chainsaw Man's manga 'Part 2' is a separate storyline featuring Asa Mitaka and the War Devil. It's set after Denji's first arc and has a totally different vibe, school life, dark comedy, and heavy philosophical themes. Most likely, the anime will finish Denji's main story (Part 1) before touching Asa's arc. But don't worry, Asa's story is just as gripping and could become a separate season or even a spin-off anime. Chainsaw Man Part 2 isn't just more gore and devils it's where the real emotional depth begins. Denji's story becomes darker, smarter, and way more heartbreaking. With Reze's arc leading the charge and global assassins entering the mix, the next season could top everything we've seen so far. So yeah, get your chainsaw revved and your emotions ready. Denji's not done wrecking devils or your heart just yet. Also read| J ujutsu Kaisen movie 2025: Plot, release date, and what to expect

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store