Queensland crocodile cull plan supported by some councils, slammed by conservationists
It means he doesn't always have time to be vigilant of crocodiles on his Mareeba property, inland of Cairns, especially when he has to get into the river to service his irrigation equipment and pump by hand.
"It is definitely worrying when you have to get into the river," he says.
"I'm focused on farming, and I'm focused on the next problem."
He believes saltwater crocodiles have been an increasing problem since a major flood in 2000, now leading a petition to expand an existing crocodile removal zone.
He says, aside from the impact on his farming, he and his family have also had to stop swimming in the Barron River.
Mr Adil is supportive of a proposed bill, which would allow crocodile culls and removals in populated areas.
But says decisions about the management of the species should be made by those who live in crocodile country.
The proposed legislation from Katter's Australian Party, which would also allow Indigenous groups to run safari-style hunting trips, is currently being examined by a Queensland parliamentary inquiry.
At a public hearing held in Brisbane today, it received support from some local councils, who say more needs to be done.
Speaking at a public hearing into the bill on Wednesday, Mareeba Shire deputy mayor Lenore Wyatt said Mr Adil was far from alone in his frustration with crocodiles.
She says it was taking to long to remove crocodiles or obtain the permits needed to move them — including within an existing special zone "F" where saltwater crocodiles are already removed upon sighting.
Councillor Wyatt says in one case a farmer had contacted the state environment department in January about a large crocodile in his dam, but had yet to have it removed in June.
She says this slow response time highlighted an "urgent need for reform".
Councillor Wyatt told the committee it's believed crocodiles had not been native to the area, and instead had ended up in the area's waterways in the 1990s after escaping a crocodile farm.
She said this made it a "unique" situation, and was urgently calling for more to be done regarding crocodile management.
"We're not asking for crocodile eradication, but we are asking for a more responsive and place-based approach to crocodile management," she said.
Crocodiles were hunted to the brink of extinction in Queensland prior to the 1970s.
Saltwater crocodiles are currently considered a threatened species and are protected.
The Department of Environment estimates there are between 20,000 and 30,000 salt and freshwater crocodiles in Queensland waterways.
Further south, the Whitsundays Regional Council says it's also dealing with growing crocodile populations.
The Proserpine River has the largest population of saltwater crocodiles along the east coast.
It's also supportive of the bill and moves to address numbers, and to make it easier to get permits to move crocodiles.
"Crocodiles are an important tourist attraction for the Whitsundays," council's natural resource management and climate manager Scott Hardy told the committee.
"They can also be a hazard as well."
He says crocodiles are regularly sighted offshore at Airlie Beach as well as occasionally off Whitsunday Islands, and a growing population in popular tourist locations is causing concern over the risk of "inevitable" crocodile interactions with tourists and residents.
Like in Mareeba, Mr Hardy says council is struggling to relocate crocodiles due to the length of time it takes to obtain permits to do so.
He is also supportive of a better way to record crocodile sightings, such as by using a QR code, and is calling for better education and more frequent surveys.
Meanwhile, conservationists including Bob Irwin and the Environmental Defenders' Office (EDO) appeared at the inquiry to speak in opposition of the bill.
Mr Irwin, who founded what would go on to become Australia Zoo, said he'd been working with crocodiles in the wild and captivity for more than four decades.
He said over that time he and his son Steve had worked hard to get into their heads and understand them.
Mr Irwin said he was "frustrated" to once again hear calls for crocodile culling, describing it as a "pointless exercise".
He told the committee he was concerned that as large crocodiles were extremely territorial, killing one or removing it would simply lead to smaller ones, with potentially worse behaviour, replacing them.
Mr Irwin said he wasn't against moving crocodiles away from areas where people exercised their dogs or from waterways near a boat ramp, but said he remained concerned about crocodiles returning to their own territory.
He also called for more education, saying most deaths around crocodiles occurred due to human recklessness and was scathing of people who filmed themselves getting close to crocodiles.
For Queensland premier David Crisafulli, it was human safety which had to come "first absolutely".
"I'll always say that. We also have to balance good environmental outcomes and that's why everyone should have their say on this bill," he said on Wednesday.
The committee will deliver its final report in August.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

ABC News
4 hours ago
- ABC News
Townsville businesses speak on public drunkenness as Queensland government looks to re-criminalise it
The Queensland government has flagged re-criminalising public drunkenness in a bid to curb what it says is a surge in antisocial behaviour, less than a year after it was decriminalised. Queensland became the final state in Australia to decriminalise public drunkenness, more than 30 years after it was first recommended by the Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody. Premier David Crisafulli this week held a forum in the largest city in north Queensland — Townsville — a city he once described as crime ground-zero to listen to community concerns. A walk down Townsville's main street paints a nuanced picture, with views mixed among business operators and community leaders on how best to make the CBD safer and more attractive to visitors. It's a quiet weekday afternoon when foot traffic should be busy. Shop owner Lucy Downes said she now worked seven days a week because it was harder to find staff wanting to work in the CBD. "It is not a family-friendly environment when you have people brawling and yelling," Ms Downes said. "Especially when there's substance abuse involved. That can be intimidating and scary for staff to witness." Ms Downes backed the state government's move to possibly re-criminalise public drunkenness, but said harsh punishment was not the solution to substance abuse. "It is a very complicated problem … it's good to look towards the bigger picture," she said. When public drunkenness was decriminalised last year, it brought Queensland into line with every other state and territory. The legislative change allowed for an intoxicated person to be taken to a place of safety. But, walking into a meeting with community and business leaders, Mr Crisafulli said it was a retrograde step. "We certainly won't be ruling [re-criminalising] out." Queensland Police statistics show that while the total number of crimes in Townsville has risen steadily over the past 10 years, good order offences, including public nuisance offences, have dropped. Business owners stressed the CBD was still a good place to visit and that police had been working hard recently to keep order. Pauline Jackson said she felt safe at the newsagency she had run on Townsville's Flinders Street for 18 years. Ms Jackson said criminalising public drunkenness would discourage people from poor behaviour. She said more consistent policing was needed. "As soon as you drop it off, antisocial behaviour comes back," she said. "It does keep people away." Marg Cox is often greeted by the smell of urine on her morning walk to her job as the operator of a sandwich shop on Flinders Street. Ms Cox said practical solutions were the best approach. "They need more public toilets in the city; the closest toilet is over the bridge, not in the area," Ms Cox said. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Legal Service principal legal officer Greg Shadbolt warned any move to bring back public intoxication laws would target the state's most marginalised people. The service said 2020–2021 statistics demonstrated Queensland Police were 11 times more likely to pursue public order offences against Indigenous people compared to the rest of the population. "If the park is your home and you're not doing anything wrong, other than just drinking, you could potentially be arrested," he said. "If anyone does make a nuisance of themselves in the public arena, police can still arrest them for a whole plethora of charges." Birrigubba elder and academic Gracelyn Smallwood said outlawing public drunkenness would be a backward step, risking more Aboriginal deaths in custody. "I think it's absolutely ridiculous," Professor Smallwood said. Professor Smallwood said alcohol abuse should never be dealt with by locking people up. "All the organisations, Indigenous and non-Indigenous that are receiving money for drunkenness and homelessness should all be collaborating," she said. Additional consultation sessions are being planned for Townsville, Maryborough, Cairns and Mackay.

ABC News
10 hours ago
- ABC News
Chinese Australians reflect on work in politics, as federal parliament resumes
Growing up in Queensland, Julie-Ann Campbell looked to Penny Wong as a role model. The now-foreign minister was one of the only politicians who showed a young Ms Campbell how people who "looked like" her could work in parliament. "You can't be what you can't see," said Ms Campbell. Ms Campbell won the Queensland electorate of Moreton, a seat encompassing multicultural communities in Brisbane's south, in May's federal election and is proud of her Chinese heritage. The Labor politician's family immigrated to Australia from China's Guangdong province in the late 1800s. As parliament resumed this week for the first time since the election, a record six politicians with Chinese heritage sat in the House of Representatives and Senate. In addition to Senator Wong in the Senate, five Chinese Australian politicians were elected or re-elected into the lower house in May: Julie-Ann Campbell, Gabriel Ng, Zhi Soon, Sam Lim and Sally Sitou. The parliamentarians, along with some former Liberal politicians, look back on some challenges they have faced, such as racism and discrimination — and reflect on why diversity in Australian parliament is important. "I'm proud that my daughter will grow up seeing people who look like her in parliament," said Ms Campbell. "That makes for a better democracy." For Sally Sitou, re-elected in the New South Wales seat of Reid, her background, experiences and family history are something she celebrates. Along with other ethnic Chinese, Ms Sitou's parents fled Laos because of the Vietnam War. The Labor parliamentarian grew up in the western suburbs of Sydney, never thinking politics was a career path for her — until she heard Bob Carr speak at the opening of the Chinese Lao Association's community hall. "He gave a really amazing speech about the government's commitment to working together with the local community to support them," she said. Ms Sitou said her background was now an asset in her work. "I think it is important that we try to get a lot more diversity of people into politics, regardless of which party," she said. "I really make my colleagues aware of some of the challenges for multicultural communities and for them to make sure that it is part of the work that they do." In 2022, Ms Sitou reclaimed Reid in inner-west Sydney for Labor for the first time in a decade. During that campaign, Ms Sitou said she was targeted because of her heritage. "There were some people who questioned my loyalty to this country, because of my Chinese background," she said. "I really made a point of calling it out … I felt like that's something I wanted to do." In Western Australia, before Sam Lim got into politics, he observed how politicians' views of the Chinese community impacted people. "As a police officer, I could see that on the front lines, some of the ways the anti-Chinese words and actions of the former government were affecting the community," Mr Lim said. "Running to be the federal member for Tangney was an opportunity to help change this, and so I said yes." Tangney is one of Australia's most diverse communities, with more than 160 different ancestries. People of Chinese heritage make up 16.5 per cent of its population. Mr Lim, a Malaysian Chinese immigrant, is the oldest of eight siblings in his family, who grew up in a home with a leaky roof, dirty floors and no running water. He joined the WA Police in his 40s and was awarded Officer of the Year in 2020, the force's highest honour, for his work with multicultural communities during the pandemic. Mr Lim speaks 10 languages including Malay, several Chinese languages, including Hokkien, and even Burmese, and says he understands how many people from migrant backgrounds think and feel. "Because I am one of them. I know what's dear to them," he said. "And I understand their concerns." For Gabrielle Ng, his Chinese Singaporean identity connects him to Chinese culture, shared by many constituents in the Victorian electorate of Menzies. Menzies's electoral boundaries were redrawn before the election, leaving it with the most Chinese Australian voters of any electorate in Australia. Nearly 30 per cent of the electorate has Chinese heritage. During the election campaign, Mr Ng found that some people, including the media, spoke about the Chinese Australian community as if it was monolithic. "I've made a point of highlighting the diversity in the Chinese community, with different countries of origin," Mr Ng said. "Mainland China, Malaysia, Singapore, etc, as well as language groups, cultures and political opinions." Mr Ng is proud of his heritage and has vivid memories during his childhood of visiting relatives in Singapore, eating at hawker stalls, going to yum cha and enjoying Lunar New Year celebrations. His father is a Chinese Singaporean immigrant and aircraft maintenance engineer who moved to Australia in his 20s, while his mother was raised in regional Victoria. He said his experience of racism also shaped who he became. "I've had some experiences of racism, like being called names in the schoolyard. Especially when growing up, it was very common for people to ask where I was really from," he said. Mr Ng said there was also the feeling that when politicians attacked Chinese or Asian Australians, "they were talking about me and my family". On the eve of the federal election, Liberal Senator Jane Hume claimed on television that "Chinese spies" were among the volunteers for a Labor MP's campaign — remarks that drew strong backlash from the Chinese community. "I think this has contributed to my sense of solidarity with other diverse groups and underdogs in society who might experience discrimination, as well as a strong commitment to multiculturalism," Mr Ng said. For former Liberal candidate Scott Yung, Senator Hume's comments left him feeling frustrated. "It's about using language that makes all Australians feel welcome and safe," he said. "Chinese Australians like my parents have worked hard, built businesses, and contributed through education." Mr Yung is a second-generation Chinese Australian with family roots in Hong Kong and Shanghai. Seen as a rising star in the Chinese community after nearly defeating then-opposition leader Chris Minns in a state election, Mr Yung was disappointed to not win the federal seat of Bennelong. During the campaign, some media outlets reported alleged links between Mr Yung and individuals connected to the Chinese Communist Party. Looking back, Mr Yung said he wished he had confronted the accusations more directly. "Politics is dirty, and the truth won't prevail unless you actively share it," he said. Liberal colleague Gladys Liu knows the toll of political life. In 2019, she made history as the first female Chinese Australian MP, winning the seat of Chisholm in Victoria. But scrutiny quickly followed. Despite winning the 76th seat that secured the Coalition majority, Ms Liu faced relentless questions about her connections to Chinese organisations. "If I weren't Chinese, there would've been no story to write," she said. After losing her seat in 2022, the attacks disappeared. "That confirmed for me — they weren't attacking Gladys. They were attacking the person who held that seat." Ms Liu was among the first to publicly condemn Senator Hume's remarks, calling them careless and unforgivable. "Politicians may face baseless attacks, but ordinary Chinese Australians shouldn't," she said. Gabriel Ng said Senator Hume's comments had a "chilling effect" on people in the Chinese Australian community, making them less likely to participate in politics. "One of the most despicable things about comments like those made by Senator Jane Hume … is that it makes people feel that if they get involved in politics, they will be treated with suspicion," he said. "What we want is an inclusive, vibrant democracy where everyone feels free to participate, so that the government can best reflect the will of all Australians." Senator Hume did not respond to requests for comment.

The Age
21 hours ago
- The Age
Enough is enough: the CFMEU stain on our society must be removed
The disclosures by The Age this week involving a gangland associate, a Gold Coast developer and the CFMEU are disturbing. Not only because they are innately concerning, but also because they show, yet again, that the cancerous network of thuggery, intimidation and misfeasance that contaminates business, industry and wider society throughout this country continues. It is a stain on the nation. The Age reported that Melbourne gangland associate John Khoury was paid $110,000 by Queensland-Melbourne joint venture Glen Q to help secure industrial peace on the Gold Coast, where the developer was building a 16-level project at Broadbeach. A meeting was held between influential CFMEU figures and Khoury. This occurred four months after the federal government forced the union into administration. There is no suggestion the union attendees have done the wrong thing, and the administration has also cleared them. But the payment to Khoury by the developer was uncovered during federal police raids. A money trail was thus revealed between a front company in the name of Khoury's accountant to Glen Q's project. Also involved was Nick Maric, a Melbourne construction boss now a Queensland government contractor, who has separately retained the services of Khoury and Mick Gatto to deal with the CFMEU. Glen Q's payment to Khoury focuses light on how business and construction is done. Our reporting also highlights the rivalry between the CFMEU and the Australian Workers' Union, with representatives of the latter supporting two firms led by figures with criminal links to foil the CFMEU.