Michigan sign-stealing scandal should leave a mark, even if college sports has bigger problems
But see, when cheating is clear and brazen — and it's the kind that actually impacts competition, not the kind that leaves a kid with a bus ticket or too much cream cheese on his bagel — the annoyance of a drawn-out, public saga is a price worth paying. It should result in meaningful punishment, and the final word on that is due soon from the NCAA.
Advertisement
It should buy some level of deterrence, so we have fewer of these to endure. That's the idea, anyway. It's worth a shot, I say, and would expect all but Wolverines lovers in this instance to agree. This is not nothing, not trivial, not to be dismissed just because the NCAA has bigger issues and a regrettable enforcement history. This is worthwhile.
The NCAA has struggled to enforce its rules. That's obvious.
So … the NCAA should be less concerned with enforcing its rules?
That's like saying the way to fix bad officiating is to get rid of officials altogether. But that's a college sports problem for another day. Whatever twists and turns lie ahead for this industry, rules and rules enforcement will matter. That's why many sports organizations were created in the first place.
This case should not be confused with so many embarrassing ones in the history of the NCAA, attempting to hold schools to account on amateurism rules. Weak premises, no subpoena power, mostly unsatisfying results. And now we look back and wonder why we ever cared in the first place.
But everyone still takes the Astros sign-stealing scandal seriously (other than Astros fans). Same with 'DeflateGate' (other than Patriots fans and/or Tom Brady sycophants). Rogue official Tim Donaghy rocked the NBA. Doping scandals and the Olympics go hand in hand.
These things won't lose gravity over time. They're very different and vary in severity, but all directly affect competition. As did Stalions' operation, which he attempted in a Netflix documentary to minimize but ended up telling on himself in the process.
Now Michigan is basically doing the same — months after a 137-page response to the notice of allegations in which the school claimed the NCAA is 'wildly overcharging' in this case, it is offering up a two-game suspension of Moore in advance of an expected summer hearing in front of the Committee on Infractions.
Advertisement
This is related to the NCAA accusing Moore of deleting 52 text messages he'd exchanged with Stalions in the early stages of the investigation into Michigan. He hasn't denied the allegations but has said he looks forward to the public release of the texts. Also, Michigan plans to suspend him for the third and fourth weeks of the season, games against Central Michigan and Nebraska, presumably so he can coach in the second week against his alma mater, Oklahoma.
We'll see if the 'grossly overreaching' NCAA — more written words from Michigan in January — goes along with that or has more for Moore in mind.
Bigger things are happening in college athletics. President Trump is forming a commission to study it, while everyone awaits U.S. District Court Judge Claudia Wilkens' final approval on a $2.8 billion lawsuit settlement that will result in schools sharing revenue directly with athletes. Revenue sharing won't slow the desperate pursuit of top talent or the market forces around that pursuit. Collective bargaining in some form seems increasingly necessary and inevitable.
But people are watching this, too. And not just Michigan lovers and haters (both of whom add nothing to the conversation but excuse-making/accusatory hyperbole that would be exactly reversed if this were, say, an Ohio State scandal).
'I promise you that coaches still care about this,' a Power 4 head coach — not in the Big Ten — said this week. 'This was a major deal, and you can't minimize it. It's bad for college football. (Stealing signals) might be more common than you think, but the extremes they went to? I've never heard of anything like it, and they need to get the hammer.'
Said a Group of 5 assistant coach: 'It's blatant cheating. I mean, even knowing run or pass (before a play) is a huge advantage. So you'd like to see it taken seriously.'
Advertisement
In the nearly two years since this broke, we've talked to a lot of coaches about this, and some have downplayed its significance. I agree with all of them who said the scandal can't erase the greatness of Harbaugh's 2023 team. All of the Wolverines' biggest wins came after the Stalions operation was outed and he was let go.
Michigan was a worthy national champion. Michigan's coaches, including those who stayed after Harbaugh bolted, deserve significant punishment. Both things can be true, just like these two things: The NCAA struggles to enforce its rules, and the NCAA still should try.
(Photo of Sherrone Moore: Gregory Shamus / Getty Images)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNN
an hour ago
- CNN
10:35 AM ET: Sean 'Diddy' Combs guilty on prostitution charges, acquitted on others - CNN Breaking News Alerts - Podcast on CNN Podcasts
10:35 AM ET: Sean 'Diddy' Combs guilty on prostitution charges, acquitted on others CNN Breaking News Alerts 10:43 AM EDT It's a mixed verdict for Sean "Diddy" Combs. Listen for more details.
Fox News
an hour ago
- Fox News
Diamondbacks ban loyal season-ticket holder after repeated interference incidents
The Arizona Diamondbacks have finally had enough with one of their most loyal fans. Dave McCaskill is a season-ticket holder for his beloved D-Backs and owns an Advantage Membership account, which grants him access to specific events, early postseason ticket access and discounts throughout the ballpark. However, after being involved in yet another fan-interference dilemma, the Diamondbacks banned him for the remainder of the year and terminated his membership account. "This particular fan has been involved in multiple offenses at Chase Field…" the team said in a statement. "This fan will have the opportunity to return to Chase Field in 2026 so long as he meets certain terms and abides by our Fan Code of Conduct." McCaskill reached for a ball that was off the bat of San Francisco Giants third baseman Christian Koss. The ball just missed the outstretched glove of left fielder Tim Tawa. Center fielder Alek Thomas appeared to exchange words with McCaskill, who tossed the ball to Thomas. Thomas then tossed it back up. Koss was initially ruled out, but after review, he was awarded a double, and McCaskill was booted from the ballpark. Recent videos of McCaskill making plays on borderline home run balls resurfaced on social media shortly after the D-Backs' announcement. "I'm a D-Backs fan. I would never want to do anything to hurt the D-backs or to have them lose the game," McCaskill told Fox 10 Phoenix. However, he admitted to being "ejected three times." (He later corrected himself to "technically… twice.") "I caught the ball, came right down, and you see my glove hit the yellow, the top. So I think the ball would have bounced on top and gone over," McCaskill explained. Fans are not allowed to reach over the wall, or the imaginary line directly above it, to catch a ball. But, it is fair game once the ball crosses said imaginary line. Jomboy Media pointed out a total of four instances, with other social media accounts saying he's been involved in five such reviews. "What I can comment on is last night, the play happened, I want the play to play. I want the play to be played out… I want plays to be made by the players," Diamondbacks manager Torey Lovullo said. McCaskill, according to the New York Post, said he has "followed" notorious ballhawk Zack Hample, who has garnered plenty of controversy throughout his game-attending days. Hample has caught over 10,000 baseballs. Follow Fox News Digital's sports coverage on X, and subscribe to the Fox News Sports Huddle newsletter.
New York Times
an hour ago
- New York Times
Dennis Schröder's contract with Kings
NBA free agency is moving quickly but a number of key players remain, including a multi-time All-Star rehabbing a torn Achilles. Chris Nicoll / Imagn Gregory Shamus / Getty Images Dennis Schröder has agreed to a 3-year, $45 million contract with the Sacramento Kings, a league source confirmed. The Kings will be Schröder's 10th NBA team and fourth in the last nine months. The common theme in the Rockets' in-house business or their outward acquisitions is experience. Fred VanVleet, Steven Adams and Clint Capela are 31. Dorian Finney-Smith is 32. Kevin Durant is 36. As long as Ime Udoka has been at the helm, his voice within the organization has risen, and the 47-year-old has been vocal about his preference for older veterans. And as such, given the aforementioned alignment with Houston's front office and ownership, the team has fulfilled his wishes. After Houston's Game 7 loss to the Golden State Warriors, Udoka's end-of-season news conference drove home the point about the need for improved IQ and the power of experience, buzzwords that typically precede roster changes. Make no mistake: The Rockets' offseason is off to an excellent start. The overarching theme in negotiations has been maintaining financial leverage, all while building a roster that is built for now and later. The two-timeline approach is risky in a vacuum, but context, mainly personnel, is important. It might not have worked out in the Bay with James Wiseman and Jonathan Kuminga, but those are different players from Amen Thompson, Jabari Smith, Tari Eason and even Reed Sheppard. Still, it's jarring to see Houston move in this manner, particularly because of how quickly its methodology has shifted. Perhaps that's why it's difficult to quantify the magnitude of its summer business to this point. For years, the Rockets' ethos was patience and perseverance, opting to accumulate losses, build through the draft and maintain enough elasticity to capitalize at an opportune moment. That moment is now. The Rockets have peeled back the curtain on what was once a rebuild, laying out a championship-capable core. Read more on Houston's active start to free agency here. GO FURTHER Rockets want to balance experience with youth, and they're off to a great start Geoff Burke / Imagn Not only is the Jonas Valančiūnas acquisition great on the floor for the Nuggets, it gives Nikola Jokić an old foil for a teammate. Jokić joked about their joint physicality last December, when he scored a career-high 56 points, along with 16 rebounds and 8 assists against the Wizards – and Valančiūnas, who was then in Washington and who spent most of the night in a pitched, hard-nosed but good-natured battle with the Joker. Valančiūnas did just fine as well, with 20 points, 12 rebounds, 5 blocks and 5 assists in an improbable Wizards win. 'I had a couple of really good wrestling moves down there with Jonas,' Jokić said afterward. 'I think Jonas's wrestling, it's always interesting. I always talk to him normally, and it's always a little bit physical. I mean, it should be. We're big boys from Europe. We're kind of used to being in the contact. I think that's how it's supposed to be. Good rivalry.' GO FURTHER Nuggets waste Nikola Jokić's career night in inexplicable loss to woeful Wizards New Knicks signee Guerschon Yabusele is a good player and a good fit that fills a need. He can play the 5 and run next to Karl-Anthony Towns or Mitchell Robinson. Opponents need to guard him beyond the arc. I'm not obsessed with the second-year player option, given the Knicks' potential 2026-27 payroll. But sometimes that's the cost of doing business for a good player. Isaiah J. Downing / Imagn While everyone else is focused on the Bucks right now, the Dario Sarić for Jonas Valančiūnas trade is an absolutely incredible deal for the Denver Nuggets. They just traded $5 million in dead weight to the Sacramento Kings to get the best backup center of the Nikola Jokić era. Denver now is $2.4 million below the luxury tax line with at least on roster spot to fill. If that spot is a veteran minimum deal for $2.3 million, they will just barely stay under the tax and avoid the repeater penalty this year. Isaiah J. Downing / Imagn The Denver Nuggets have acquired Jonas Valančiūnas from the Sacramento Kings in exchange for Dario Sarić, team sources confirmed to The Athletic. The Nuggets have had an incredible two days. Getty Images The Bucks made two moves that make sense individually but also raise an eyebrow when looked at collectively. They will pay Myles Turner an average of nearly $27 million per season and will get an above-average starting center for that contract who fits well on a Giannis Antetokounmpo team and should be a very capable replacement for Brook Lopez. They will also stretch-waive Damian Lillard, which means the Bucks will have a $22,516,574 cap charge on their books for each of the next five season. That makes sense too since he was essentially going to be an empty $54.13 million cap hit next season as he rehabbed from a torn Achilles. The last season of that contract was unlikely to be very productive either since he would be 36 and returning in his first season from that injury. The Bucks clearly want to remain competitive next season with Antetokounmpo and that makes sense too since they want to take advantage of his prime, let alone any concerns about losing him down the line. Still, they will now effectively be spending $49 million per season for the last two years on Turner's deal, and have another year of $22.5 million on the books after that. That could be about 12 percent (or more) of the cap in the 2027-28 season, which is more than a nontaxpayer midlevel exception would earn. We shall see if this set of moves will be worth it. Getty Images This is why I criticized the Pacers for taking Andrew Nembhard's salary from $2 million to $18 million for 2025-26 when they didn't have to in his extension last summer. It set the Pacers up to be way into the luxury tax, and you know when it came down to it that Indiana would blink rather than pay it. Keeping Myles Turner on the books for this year at $24 million would have been no sweat if Nembhard was still on his cheap rookie deal, but the Pacers turned the final year of it into a much bigger salary. That extension looked extravagant at the time — $56 million in new money for just two years — and despite Nembhard's playoff heroics, the Pacers are paying the price for it now. GO FURTHER The NBA offseason's most under-scrutinized moves, from Immanuel Quickley to Max Christie One thing you gotta hand to the Bucks: Any time it seems they need to operate with urgency to show a multi-time MVP they're trying to build a contender, they do it. In terms of the cap mechanics of how Milwaukee will pull this off: Waive and stretch Damian Lillard. Sign Tauren Prince with the minimum exception. Sign Gary Trent Jr. and Kevin Porter Jr. into the room exception. Right now, that leaves Milwaukee with $19.6 million in cap room. They likely will get to the $24 million they need to sign Myles Turner to a four-year, $107 million deal by moving off of Pat Connaughton's $9.3 million salary. In the absence of a Connaughton trade, Milwaukee can get to $24.6 million in cap room by stretching Connaughton's contract, so that seems the most likely mechanism for this deal to get done. Milwaukee will also need to either pull its qualifying offer to Ryan Rollins or waive Chris Livingston to get there. It appears the Bucks will just barely exceed the limit on stretched salary if they stretch Connaughton in addition to Lillard, unless there is a buyout agreement with one or both to reduce salary. Another alternative may be to trade Connaughton for a lower-salaried player and then buy that player out at a reduced number. For instance, Milwaukee could trade Connaughton to the Clippers for Drew Eubanks, buy Eubanks out at half of his $4.75 million presuming he'd make the rest up on the market, and stretch that amount. Also, note that Lillard cannot re-sign in Milwaukee in 2026, if you were thinking that was a possibility. I'm legitimately SHOCKED. I didn't even know the Bucks were an option for Myles Turner. That's a huge loss for the Pacers. It's gonna be awfully tough to compete with a $23 million dead cap hit for each of the next five years in Milwaukee. No, I don't mean Kyle Kuzma, either. The Bucks waiving and stretching Damian Lillard will leave that money on their books for half a decade, and it can't be traded or otherwise maneuvered off the books. Bucks general manager Jon Horst has always been aggressive in the moments when his team has needed to make a big move and keep Giannis Antetokounmpo in a competitive situation. Damian Lillard tearing his left Achilles tendon in Game 4 of their first-round series appeared to be a blow that would keep the Bucks from being able to keep Milwaukee in conversation for a contending spot in the Eastern Conference. But Horst once again surprised the whole league with an impressive maneuver to acquire Myles Turner, a highly talented replacement for center Brook Lopez, and reconfigure the Bucks' roster for a chance to once again compete for homecourt in the Eastern Conference. It also helps that he stole an important piece from the team that just represented the East in the NBA Finals. The Bucks' move to waive Damian Lillard, while shocking on the face of it, is a reprieve of sorts for the 34-year-old, who can now rehab his Achilles with no clock, knowing he'll likely be a top free agent target in the summer of 2026 and free to play wherever he wants. While there were high hopes for a Dame-Giannis partnership when the Bucks acquired Lillard just before the start of training camp in 2023, the on-court product never meshed as well as everyone thought it would. Two Achilles injuries to star point guards led to Myles Turner changing teams within the division. The Milwaukee Bucks will waive guard Damian Lillard as part of their effort to free up enough cap space to sign center Myles Turner to a four-year, $107 million contract, team sources confirmed to The Athletic on Tuesday. Lillard, who is slated to miss most of next season because of a torn Achilles, was slated to make $113 million over the next two seasons. That amount will now be stretched over the next five seasons. GO FURTHER Bucks waiving Damian Lillard to make room to sign Myles Turner: Sources Brook Lopez's addition leaves the Clippers with one player left to fill a second unit spot with their existing roster. LA has multiple playable centers in Ivica Zubac and Lopez. They have multiple wing defenders in Kawhi Leonard and Nicolas Batum. They have multiple point of attack defenders in Kris Dunn and Derrick Jones Jr. The Clippers have multiple on-off ball shooters in Norman Powell and Bogdan Bogdanović. And James Harden and Kawhi Leonard are the two stars. Harden just needs a true backup point guard. At the top of my list at the point guard position is perhaps the greatest Clipper ever, and that's Chris Paul. The drawbacks with Paul are obvious: he's a 6-foot 40-year-old who has played 20 NBA seasons. But the Clippers have the longest active streak of consecutive winning seasons at 14 years, and that streak started with Paul's arrival to the franchise in 2011 and continued after Paul was traded in 2017 to Harden's Rockets. While Paul was with the Clippers, both Tyronn Lue and Lawrence Frank were assistant coaches under Doc Rivers. Steve Ballmer bought the team in 2014, midway through Paul's tenure. Paul also happened to visit Intuit Dome for Game 3 against the Nuggets, sitting next to Disney CEO Bob Iger (you see, a potential networking opportunity for Brook Lopez if it comes together). It helps that Paul can still play. Paul just started all 82 games for the San Antonio Spurs last season, averaging 8.8 points, 3.6 rebounds, 7.4 assists, 1.3 steals and 1.7 3s while shooting 37.7 percent on 3s and 92.4 percent on free throws. The only player older than Paul in NBA history who started all 82 games in a season was John Stockton, and Stockton didn't play 20 NBA seasons. Like Lopez, Paul would be brought in to be a backup to one of LA's most important players, theoretically dropping his minutes to around 20 per game at most. Paul would bring what the Clippers need most based on their weakness from last season offensively, and that's a player who can take care of the basketball. And while Paul's age and size makes him a defensive liability, he still has a nose for the ball. Read more here. Page 2
