Gov't denies using new prison rules after visitor allegedly barred from seeing inmate jailed for nat. sec offences
In a statement published on Tuesday night, the CSD acknowledged that it had denied a member of the public permission to visit someone in prison that morning because the visitor 'was not on the declared visitors list of the PIC,' or person in custody.
'According to the established mechanism, visitors must be declared visitors on the PIC's declared visitors list,' the CSD said.
'Since the Prison (Amendment) Rules 2025 came into effect last Friday, the CSD has not invoked Rule 48 of the Prison Rules to prohibit any person from conducting visits, nor has it imposed restrictions or conditions on any visits.'
The new prison rules, which allow the CSD to restrict or ban a person from visiting an inmate on certain grounds, including safeguarding national security, took effect on Friday, just two weeks after the government proposed the amendments.
Separately, Ben – a pseudonym – told HKFP that he went to a prison on Tuesday morning with a friend to visit an inmate jailed for national security offences.
Ben said that he had confirmed with the CSD on Monday and last week that his name was on the visitors' list of the person in custody.
'On Tuesday morning, after CSD staff checked my identity card and my friend's, they said I was not allowed to visit because the person in custody had taken my name off the list, but my friend could still pay a visit,' Ben said in Cantonese.
He added that the detainee's family had contacted the CSD to enquire what had happened.
New rules
Under the new prison rules, the CSD can restrict the visitation rights of religious leaders and lawyers if it sees a need to protect national security. Existing rules allow a chaplain to visit a prisoner 'at all reasonable times.'
Additionally, the CSD can apply for a warrant from a magistrate to bar an inmate from communicating with a legal representative, in person or in writing, as well as with anyone associated with the law firm concerned.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
HKFP
a day ago
- HKFP
Letting gay couples who wed online register locally will ‘twist one's definition of marriage,' lawmaker says
Allowing gay couples who married remotely overseas to register their partnerships in Hong Kong would 'twist one's definition of marriage,' a pro-Beijing lawmaker has said, as meetings about the government's same-sex rights bill continued. Speaking during a Legislative Council discussion on Friday, lawmaker Holden Chow referred to a clause in the bill that says couples whose marriage, civil partnership or union was conducted 'by remote means' would be eligible to register their partnerships in Hong Kong. In recent years, online weddings officiated virtually in countries where same-sex marriage is legal have become more common in the LGBTQ community, including in Hong Kong. 'This will instantly twist one's definition of marriage,' said Chow, a member of the city's largest pro-establishment party, the Democratic Alliance for the Betterment and Progress of Hong Kong (DAB). Friday marked the second day of meetings in the Legislative Council's Bills Committee on the Registration of Same-Sex Partnerships Bill. A total of 15 lawmakers are reviewing the government's proposal before it returns to the council meeting for a vote by the city's 89 lawmakers. Almost all pro-establishment parties with representation in the Legislative Council, such as the DAB, the Liberal Party and the Hong Kong Federation of Trade Unions, have said they will vote against the bill, calling the framework it proposes a threat to the traditional heterosexual marriage system. Only the New People's Party has shown support for the bill. The Legislative Council lost its opposition after an overhaul in 2021 required all lawmakers to be 'patriots' to run. On Friday, lawmaker Peter Shiu echoed Chow's comments about remote weddings and asked the government to consider limiting the registration of same-sex partnerships to those who wed overseas in person. In response, Deputy Secretary for Constitutional and Mainland Affairs Raymond Sy said letting those who got married virtually register their marriages locally was aimed at making the process more convenient for them, as not everybody could travel overseas to tie the knot. Secretary for Constitutional and Mainland Affairs Erick Tsang added in Cantonese: 'If the laws [in those jurisdictions] allow online [registration], then we cannot exclude it.' Top court ruling The government's proposal comes as Hong Kong has around three months left to establish a framework for recognising same-sex partnerships, following a top court ruling in 2023 that found the lack of such a mechanism unconstitutional. The Court of Final Appeal gave the government two years to put such a mechanism in place, with the deadline coming up in late October. The bill is limited to granting registered couples rights in matters relating to healthcare and death, such as hospital visits, making medical decisions, and collecting the body of a deceased partner. At least one person in the couple must be a Hong Kong resident. On Friday, Tsang said the proposed framework was based on considerations including the 'actual situation' in society, traditional family values and the public's interests. Among the 15 members of the bills committee, only one – Regina Ip of the New People's Party – has expressed support for the bill. She said accepting couples who got married online was necessary, adding that the option was needed for people who were seriously ill or on their deathbed, and wanted to have their relationship recognised while they were still alive. Ahead of submitting the proposed framework to the Legislative Council earlier this month, the government did not hold any public consultations despite LGBTQ advocacy groups' efforts to reach out to the authorities. No public hearings, where members of the public present their views to officials in Legislative Council meetings, will be held, with only written submissions invited. Azan Marwah, a family lawyer who has represented clients in LGBTQ-related court cases, said in his submission that he supported the government's commitment to comply with the top court ruling, but that the framework did not go far enough. The 'best way for the Legislative Council to create equality' is to introduce same-sex marriage, he said, citing a 2023 survey that showed around 60 per cent of Hong Kong people support it. He called for protection for the children of same-sex couples, saying it would 'strengthen the values of commitment, love and mutual support.'
HKFP
2 days ago
- HKFP
New code of conduct for lawmakers to introduce meeting attendance requirements, tougher penalties
Hong Kong lawmakers have unanimously approved a new code of conduct that specifies requirements for meeting attendance, voting, and other duties while introducing tougher penalties for misconduct. Eighty-eight lawmakers on Thursday voted for two motions by legislator Paul Tse aimed at enhancing the Legislative Council (LegCo)'s operations. It came a day after they also unanimously passed the Legislative Council (Powers and Privileges) (Amendment) Bill, which outlines the implementation of the code at the core of the two motions. LegCo President Andrew Leung hailed the passages, saying they marked a 'new milestone' for the opposition-free legislature, as he led a group of veteran lawmakers to meet reporters after the vote. '[The new code of conduct] stipulates the requirement for the behaviour and performance of lawmakers, so that there will be rules to follow for lawmakers in the new term,' Leung said in Cantonese. The code will take effect when the new LegCo term begins on January 1 next year. Leung did not cast a vote on Thursday in keeping with the tradition of the LegCo president maintaining neutrality. The new Code for Members of the Legislative Council states that legislators should attend meetings and 'actively and conscientiously' participate in voting. Absence without a valid reason that causes disruption to LegCo meetings could result in a financial penalty for lawmakers, according to the new rules. The LegCo's existing Rules of Procedure do not explicitly set out attendance requirements for lawmakers, except for mandating quorum for its general and committee meetings, in which a minimum number of lawmakers must be present for the meeting to begin. The new code also requires lawmakers to 'sincerely support' the chief executive and the government. It says they should not 'deliberately undermine or weaken the effectiveness of executive-led governance.' Lawmakers must adhere to strict rules when declaring their interests, including those related to employment, election donations, sponsorships and gifts, the code stipulates. As part of the changes, the Committee on Members' Interests will be empowered to investigate complaints against lawmakers and recommend sanctions. The committee will be renamed the 'Legislative Council Supervisory Committee.' Misconduct under the new code could be met with sanctions ranging from a written warning to suspension of duties. A suspended lawmaker will not receive pay and allowance, including end-of-service gratuity, during the period of suspension. During the meeting on Thursday, lawmaker Tse, who also chairs LegCo's Committee on Rules of Procedure, described enacting the new code of conduct as a means of 'mending the fold after a sheep is lost,' using a common Chinese idiom. 'Although the current [LegCo] term has been more efficient than previous terms… we still hope to further regulate the work of lawmakers,' Tse said in Cantonese. Beijing overhauled Hong Kong's LegCo elections in 2021 to ensure only 'patriots' hold office. The move reduced democratic representation in the legislature, tightened control of elections and introduced a pro-Beijing panel to vet candidates. Most of the city's opposition politicians have either been jailed, left Hong Kong, or quit politics after Beijing imposed a national security law in 2020 following large-scale pro-democracy protests and unrest. The current Legislative Council term began in 2022 and will finish at the end of the year. Elections are scheduled for December. Leung said the new rules would not deter potential candidates from running in the LegCo elections. Martin Liao, a veteran lawmaker, said it would be 'fair' for the candidates to understand society's expectations for a lawmaker before running for a seat. 'I think the legislators in the next term are expected to comply with the [new] rules of procedures just inasmuch as we are expected to comply with our current rules of procedures,' Liao added.
South China Morning Post
3 days ago
- South China Morning Post
Was it politics? Indonesian ex-minister Thomas Lembong's jail term ignites debate
A recent prison sentence for a former Indonesian trade minister has raised eyebrows over alleged political motivations, given the defendant's loyalty to an opposition politician. Last Friday, judges at a corruption court in Jakarta sentenced Thomas Trikasih Lembong to 4½ years in jail and a fine of 750 million rupiah (US$46,000) for improperly granting sugar import permits , during what the prosecutor said was a surplus of local production, when he was trade minister in 2015-16. Prosecutors previously sought seven years' imprisonment for Lembong. Sugar production in 2015 reached 2.49 million tons, while domestic consumption was 2.12 million tons, according to data from the statistics agency. Prosecutors also argued that the policy was issued without inter-ministries discussion, as well as recommendation from the Ministry of Industry. Lembong's defence team has denied wrongdoing, saying there was a sugar deficit at that time. Harvard graduate Lembong was campaign manager for losing candidate Anies Baswedan in last year's presidential election . Both men served as ministers under former president Joko Widodo 's first-term cabinet, before they were reshuffled in July 2016. Lembong was once Widodo's close ally, having written speeches for Widodo from 2013, when he was Jakarta governor, until the end of his first-term presidency in 2019. Among famous Lembong-made speeches for Widodo was his Game of Thrones-laden address during the International Monetary Fund meeting in Bali in 2018, when the former president said 'winter is coming' due to the unstable global economy.
