Non-binary Canadian wins lawsuit forcing taxpayers to pay for surgery so they can have a penis AND a vagina
K.S., who was born a male at birth, uses female pronouns but does not identify as either fully male or fully female, according to documents from the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, reviewed by DailyMail.com.
The 34-year-old, who is only identified by her initials in the legal filing, sued the Ontario Health Insurance Plan (OHIP) in 2022 after the company denied her request to pay for the cost of surgery to construct a 'neo-vagina' at a clinic in Texas.
She wanted to build a female sex organ in the gap between her scrotum and anus - while also keeping her fully-functioning male sex organ.
Now, the brunt of the $70,000 for surgery and flights to the US will fall on Canadian taxpayers after a landmark win in court.
Dr. Irena Druce, an endocrinologist at the Ottawa Hospital, submitted a 'Request for Prior Approval for Funding of Sex-Reassignment Surgery' - which cost $10,000 to $70,000 - for K.S. after completing multiple assessments on her along with Yael Sela, a mental health counselor.
Together, they determined K.S. has 'persistent gender dysphoria.' They said she was qualified to undergo the surgery because she had undergone hormone therapy for a year and 'lived for 12 continuous months in a gender role congruent with her gender identity,' the appeal said.
The procedure, also known as penile-sparing vaginoplasty, is only available in Texas. It is not allowed in Canada, but the money would pay for her to travel to the US to get the surgery, according to Reduxx.
The insurer argued the surgery cannot be publicly funded because the vaginoplasty would not be accompanied by a penectomy and is therefore not a procedure listed on its schedule of benefits.
The company, which is run by President and CEO Matthew Anderson, also argued that the procedure is considered experimental in Ontario and not eligible for coverage, the appeal, submitted on April 22, said.
K.S. then appealed the denial to the Health And Services Appeal and Review Board - who then overturned OHIP's initial decision, arguing that it should be covered even if a penectomy is not performed.
OHIP appealed that, but lost again after the panel determined the surgery - which would leave her penis completely functional and create a 'neo-vagina' in the space between her penis and anus - would be fully insured.
The province's appeal was heard on November 26, 2024 as three judges - Benjamin Zarnett, Steve Coroza and Lise Favreau - rejected the company's arguments to deny coverage because a penectomy was 'neither recommended by K.S.'s health professionals nor desired by K.S,' the court's decision stated.
The appeal's court also said: 'The existence of different techniques to perform a vaginoplasty does not affect this conclusion. It was open to the drafters of the Schedule of Benefits to describe each specifically listed service in broad or narrow terms. Here the description chosen, 'vaginoplasty', is broad enough to encompass different techniques.'
They added that 'a vaginoplasty without a penectomy is an insured service because it is still a vaginoplasty, a specifically listed service,' the document read.
K.S.'s physician said in a letter that she 'identifies as transfeminine but not completely on the "feminine" end of the spectrum and for this reason it's important for her to have a vagina while maintaining her penis,' documents said.
According to Dr. Druce's biography, she is a clinician investigator that focuses on inflammation and chronic disease with an interest 'transgender health.'
'And her hope is to contribute to clinical research in this domain as her career continues,' it continued.
In addition to winning the case to get the surgery, K.S. was also awarded $23,250 by the three judges, the filing said.
The province of Ontario has until June 23 to appeal the latest decision to the Supreme Court of Canada.
Her lawyer, John McIntyre, told National Post his client 'is pleased' with the decision.
'K.S. is pleased with the Court of Appeal's decision, which is now the third unanimous ruling confirming that her gender affirming surgery is covered under Ontario's Health Insurance Act and its regulation,' McIntyre said.
Soon after her first win last April, K.S. took to social media to celebrate her win and posted to a Reddit board for 'bigenital' individuals, per Reduxx.
In those posts, K.S. said she suffered from bipolar disorder, was a disability advocate.
K.S., who has since deleted her Reddit account, also delved into her sexual fetishes, describing herself as a 'transgender baby' and a 'little' - someone who is attracted to diapers and 'obsessed' with urinary and fecal incontinence, loss of control in the bladder and bowels.
There, she also claimed she designed her bedroom to reflect that of an eight-year-old girl, the outlet found.
Many of her posts were made to the Adult Baby Diaper Lover (ABDL) on Reddit - a group where people are sexually aroused while acting like babies or children.
K.S. has also spoken about her mental health struggles on the platform, detailing her suicidal ideations related to child abuse and little mental health support.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
3 days ago
- The Guardian
Checking airways before CPR on athletes may increase risk of death, study says
It is the simple life-saving sequence taught in many a first aid lesson: when someone collapses, first check their airways, then breathing and finally circulation before starting chest compressions if needed. But experts have warned this approach to CPR could be increasing the risk of death for athletes experiencing a cardiac arrest. Researchers in Israel say a focus on clearing airways, and in particular the mistaken belief it is possible to swallow your tongue, is leading to delays in starting cardiopulmonary resuscitation in such cases. 'The first response should be immediate initiation of chest compressions,' said Dr Dana Viskin, of Tel Aviv University. Viskin said the tongue was anchored in the mouth by different muscles and ligaments, making it impossible to swallow – although she noted paralysis or total relaxation of the main muscle of the tongue could obstruct the airways and lead to suffocation. But Viskin said an initial focus on airways when responding to cardiac arrest events in athletes was problematic. 'A quick response – especially chest compressions and early defibrillation – is critical. Time spent checking the airway or trying to prevent 'tongue swallowing' only delays life-saving treatment,' she said. Writing in the Canadian journal of Cardiology, Viskin and colleagues identified online footage of 45 cases between 1990 and 2024 in which athletes collapsed during competitions or training and underwent attempts at resuscitation. The first action taken by others was visible in 38 of the cases. Thirty of the athletes had a cardiac arrest. In 27 of these cases, the first response involved 'inappropriate' actions, such as preventing tongue swallowing by forcing open the athlete's mouth, before starting CPR. This was the case when Denmark's Christian Eriksen collapsed on the pitch during the Euro 2020 match against Finland in 2021. The researchers said that in 18 of these 27 cases, the athlete was known to have subsequently died or remained in a vegetative state. None of the three athletes who received CPR as the first response had such outcomes. 'The small number of cases without an attempt to prevent 'tongue swallowing' does limit the ability to draw strong statistical comparisons regarding outcomes like brain injury,' said Viskin. 'However, there is a striking consistency of the incorrect initial response across most cases and that itself is a powerful finding.' The researchers also studied high-visibility news articles about the cases, finding many used the term 'tongue swallowing' and often praised actions to prevent it. 'This is important because such reports have enormous numbers of views,' the authors wrote. The team suggested the myth of tongue swallowing appeared to be widespread and could have been unintentionally promoted by the airways, breathing, circulation (A-B-C) sequence for basic CPR. They said these steps were in effect reordered to C-A-B in the American Heart Association CPR guidelines in 2010. A spokesperson for the College of Paramedics said its advice to members of the public witnessing a suspected cardiac arrest was to follow the Resuscitation Council UK guidance for CPR, starting chest compressions and calling 999 if someone became unconscious, unresponsive, and was not breathing or breathing noisily. 'Early chest compressions are recognised to be of critical importance in saving individuals experiencing cardiac arrest and that's why paramedics will not delay chest compressions,' they said. 'When trained professionals and responders manage patients experiencing sudden cardiac arrest, chest compressions will be prioritised whilst another professional manages the airway.'
Daily Mail
3 days ago
- Daily Mail
I learned the toxic truth about my idyllic childhood camp... are your children at risk too?
On my wall hangs a photo of a seven-year-old me in a small yellow sailboat with my father beside me, holding lines while I steered the boat. It was the start of many years of sailing on the Toms River and Barnegat Bay in New Jersey, where I spent summers in an idyllic small town surrounded by family. As a child, I didn't question the absence of fish, the scum lining the shore or its faint foul odor. For eight years, I swam in a river that had once been a toxic dumping ground for a plant owned at the time by Ciba-Geigy, a chemical company that churned out dyes, plastics, and adhesives seven miles northwest. The toxic waste from Ciba-Geigy's plant was later linked by state health officials to a cluster of childhood cancers - over 100 cases in around 15 years - just a few miles from my grandparents' house. A flood of toxins seeped into the area's groundwater and sickened hundreds of children. State health data has since shown that, for decades, every glass of water filled in Toms River carried trace amounts of toxic chemicals. Not many people were aware of the dumping. According to my dad, who grew up in a small town next to Toms River, 'We didn't know anything about it until it came out later with the cancer cluster. 'I remember when it was just rumors and everyone was like it couldn't be, everyone loves Ciba-Geigy.' When Ciba-Geigy opened in 1952, it revived Toms River's economy with hundreds of jobs. A long-time Toms River resident, Summer Bardia, told her Uncle Ed, who worked at Ciba-Geigy for 10 years, 'would come home and he'd sweat out the different colors that he was working with that day.' 'My Uncle Ed knew something was wrong, as did his co-workers at the plant,' Bardia said. 'He took his clothes off and got into the shower as soon as he got home from work.' Ed developed rare bladder cancer, brain tumors, and dementia. While she can't prove it, Bardia said the connection between her uncle's workplace exposure and his diseases seems undeniable. Dye production uses several cancer-linked chemicals, and EPA investigations found the company's runoff contained suspected or known carcinogens like benzene, chromium, lead, arsenic and mercury. It also uses tetrachloroethene (PCE), which has been shown to double bladder cancer risk and raise risk of nervous system cancers, and trichloroethene (TCE), which raises leukemia risk two to five times. For decades, the company dumped toxic wastewater into unlined pits, allowing carcinogens linked to bladder, brain, and kidney cancers and leukemia, to leach into the groundwater and flow into Toms River. Under pressure from outraged residents of Ocean County, Ciba-Geigy stopped dumping waste in lagoons, instead pumping it 10 miles offshore, until a 1984 pipe rupture spewed black sludge. By the mid-1970s, the town saw a disturbing spike in childhood cancers. Before merging into Toms River, Dover Township recorded 90 childhood cancer cases over 17 years—far above the 67 expected. Leukemia in young girls stood out, with seven cases instead of the expected 2.7. In Toms River, 24 cases were recorded where just 14 were expected, including 10 in young girls, most of which were brain cancer and leukemia. The toll was worst among preschool girls. Brain cancers were at least 10 times the normal rates and leukemia rates were eight times the national baseline for girls that age. Scientists confirmed these weren't random flukes. The data matched patterns near other toxic waste sites around the US. The Ciba-Geigy campus was designated a Superfund site in 1983. I would be lying if I said I wasn't worried for the kids in towns along the river beginning their sailing programs every summer and the older long-time residents who still love to sail. I would also be lying if I said I didn't feel a bit of trepidation when I turn on the faucet at my grandparents' house, where the water has a slightly odd smell. I ask myself now if it's due to old metal pipes or a remnant of corporate wrongdoing. The plant shut down all operations in 1996. The chemical company BASF acquired it in 2009, inheriting all clean up responsibility. The EPA oversight has shrunk Toms River's toxic plume, but full cleanup is years away. Alec Boss, communications and outreach coordinator for the activist group Save Barnegat Bay, called cleanup efforts 'woefully inadequate.' Contaminated groundwater is being pumped out, treated, and discharged back into the ground. Boss told 'Imagine that you come up to a pond filled with this horrible pond scum and nasty bacteria, you get a cup of this dirty pond water and one of those iodine tablets that you would take if you were going camping, and you put that in that cup and you clean up that water, and then you just dump that back into the pond. 'That's essentially what they're doing.' Diane Salkie, EPA's remedial project manager for the site, told members in a webinar that 'we've probably gone down about 40 percent, maybe there's about 60 percent [of the toxic plume] remaining, but that's very ballpark.' However, the ocean is much cleaner now, Bardia said. 'I love jumping in those ocean waves. I love bringing my family and friends and showing them how clean the ocean is now, looking at all the dolphins and the whales and the rays.' The river is cleaner, too. I've noticed when I go back to Island Heights it's bluer and I no longer see foam at the shoreline. Ocean County still suffers high cancer rates, with 524 cases per 100,000 compared to the state average of 474 per 100,000. The national rate is still lower at about 444 cases per 100,000. A statement from BASF said: 'We want to be clear that a significant amount of work has been done over the past 30 years, and the US EPA has determined that the site currently poses no risk to human health and the environment. 'BASF will continue to work with the US EPA and NJDEP until all federal and state requirements are met. While US EPA has stated that full remediation of the groundwater plume may take several more years, this is typical of larger groundwater cleanup efforts.' But the EPA-supervised cleanup only treats the former plant site, not the broader community's toxic burden. Bardia said: 'What about the rest of Toms River? What about the area around the pipeline? What about all those backyards with all that soot that landed on people's homes and yards? 'I don't want to scare people away, but I want them to know that this fight is still going on.'
Daily Mail
24-07-2025
- Daily Mail
The dentist knows the filthy secrets you'd never dare confess just by looking at your mouth
A trip to the dentist can reveal a lot more about your health than just how often you floss. Routine cleanings and regular dental check ups are important as the mouth is considered the 'gateway' to the body, thus it can be the origin of problems in many different aspects of the body. Research has also shown that more than 90 percent of all systemic diseases have some form of oral manifestation, meaning the condition may cause oral complications or present with oral signs or symptoms. So, when you're in the dentist's chair, the doctor will check for cavities, but your mouth can also provide insight into your overall health, including if you have diabetes, cancer, heart disease or kidney disease and even HIV. However, your mouth can also unknowingly reveal a lot about your lifestyle, and a dentist can see more than just disease. Routine dental exams may divulge embarrassing habits or risqué activity that you would otherwise prefer to keep private. 'Dentists are the first line of defense in detecting system diseases and nutrition deficiencies because some of these diseases and deficiencies have oral manifestations,' Dr Jarrett Manning, founder of JLM Dental Studio, told HuffPost. 'This means the disease process may present as abnormal mouth lesions that dentists are trained to detect.' While dentists check for gum health, tooth conditions and overall mouth hygiene, Manning emphasized that any dental checkups are also necessary because 'any lesion, sore, or patch in the mouth can tell another story and give us insight to a deeper issue.' Below, outlines just some of what your mouth can reveal in the dentist's office. Childish habits and oral fixations If you're still partaking in the self-soothing habit of thumb sucking, you could be causing major damage to your teeth, and your dentist will be able to tell if you're holding onto the childish practice. Sucking your thumb, especially into adolescence and adulthood when permanent teeth come in, raises issues as it changes the structure of your jaw and growth of teeth. Dr Erin Fraundorf, an orthodontist and founder of BOCA Orthodontic + Whitening Studio, told HuffPost: 'Thumb-sucking may significantly alter not only a patient's teeth but their jaws. 'These signs include protruding upper front teeth with spacing, tucked back lower front teeth with crowding, a narrow upper jaw and an anterior open bite ― a lack of vertical overlap between the upper and lower front teeth.' Dentists can also tell if you bite your nails or have an oral fixation that makes you bite or chew on things that should be left out of your mouth. Dr Fraundorf added: 'Without glancing at your nails, a dentist may be able to detect if you bite your nails ― or bite on other items, like pen caps or bottle caps.' This is because the stress and wear and tear on your teeth from biting or chewing hard objects can cause chipping, cracking and wearing away of the enamel. Bedroom activities While you may prefer to keep your bedroom habits private, if you visit the dentist shortly after engaging in sexual activity, your doctor will be able to tell. This is because performing oral sex on a person with a penis leads to distinct changes in the mouth, lasting for several days. The giveaway is a rash of small red or purple marks at the back of the throat or the roof of the mouth, called palatal petechiae. The marks are caused by bleeding beneath the oral tissue, similar to a bruise. While palatal petechiae can be triggered by a sickness or virus, in the case of oral sex, it's caused by something repeatedly hitting the back of the mouth or throat. This, combined with the pressure created if making a sucking action, which boosts blood flow in the mouth, increases the risk of marks appearing. 'Sometimes we can tell,' orthodontist Brad Podray said in a TikTok. 'It's usually bruising on the soft palate called petechiae. But unless the patient's really young or shows signs of abuse, we don't care.' The revelation prompted hundreds of comments from followers, including one who wrote: 'Oh my god, my dad is my dentist.' Risky sexual behavior Some of the health conditions that cause oral symptoms include sexually transmitted diseases. So, your dentist may be able to tell if you're engaging in risky or unprotected sexual behavior. Because the symptoms of STDs vary, some may only present with oral signs and you may not realize you have the disease. Herpes causes lesions and sores on and around the mouth and lips, while gonorrhea oral symptoms include swollen tonsils and white spots inside the mouth and throat. The STD can also cause burning sensations and pain in the mouth and throat. Syphilis can cause sores on the lips, tongue, gums, mouth and throat and hepatitis A and C can lead to altered taste and inflammation of the mucous membranes in the mouth. Illicit indulgences Drug users, whether those who occasionally indulge in party drugs or people with addictions, may unwillingly reveal their secret to their dentists. Cocaine can cause perforation of the palate, according to a study in the journal Nature, as well as lesions and the erosion of the tooth surfaces. The drug also makes you more prone to periodontal diseases, or those of the gum and oral tissues. Additionally, people who use meth may experience 'meth mouth,' which causes tooth decay and gum disease and can lead to teeth cracking and falling out. Hidden diseases While it may seem unexpected, dentists may be the doctors that actually reveal major health complications that go far beyond your mouth. 'You can see if someone has HIV by identifying specific lesions called Kaposi's sarcoma that are common in uncontrolled HIV cases and have a distinct visual appearance,' Dr Ilona Casellini, founder of Swiss Quality Smile, told HuffPost. Karposi's sarcoma appears as lesions on gums, the mucous membranes and the roof of the mouth. People with HIV may also experience chronic dry mouth, canker sores and hairy leukoplakia, which presents as white patches on the tongue, that dentists can pick up on. 'Oral yeast infections can be a symptom of HIV in young patients who seem to otherwise present as healthy,' Fraundorf added.
