Chief accused of ‘half-hearted' defence of review body after Malkinson case
Giving evidence to the Commons' Justice Committee, she appeared alongside the CCRC's casework operations director Amanda Pearce.
Chairman of the committee Andy Slaughter said: 'I'm afraid I found your defence of what is to us a hugely important organisation, I'm sure it's hugely important to you, has been pretty half-hearted, and has been really a reflection that things are going pretty well, apart from one or two difficult cases.
'And where that leaves me, comment or not as you wish, to ask whether you really feel now, given everything that's happened, that you are the right people to lead this organisation forward.'
Ms Kneller said on behalf of herself and Ms Pearce that 'I think we are absolutely the right people to lead this organisation'.
During the hearing, the legal boss urged the committee to judge the CCRC's performance across all its casework, and 'not only those cases which get into the headlines, which is a tiny, tiny minority of our casework'.
The independent body, currently tasked with reviewing the convictions of serial child killer Lucy Letby, was heavily criticised for its handling of Mr Malkinson's case, one of the worst miscarriages of justice in British legal history.
Mr Malkinson served 17 years in prison for a rape he did not commit, and was knocked back twice by the CCRC until his legal team carried out crucial DNA testing that was then repeated by the commission and led to his release.
A review found that he could have been released 10 years earlier if the CCRC had obtained new DNA evidence as early as 2009, and thousands of cases are being reviewed in the wake of the bungled handling of the case.
Before Ms Pitcher's resignation, she had apologised to Mr Malkinson in April 2024, nine months after his conviction was quashed by the Court of Appeal in July 2023.
The committee heard from the CCRC chiefs that they did not know when they would be getting an interim chairperson as they are not involved in the process.
On Tuesday, Ms Kneller also personally apologised to Mr Malkinson for the first time during the hearing.
Asked whether she would like to apologise, she said: 'Without doubt, we got that case wrong. Mr Malkinson was failed.
'We made mistakes in that case. We apologised, the organisation apologised.
'I think the decisions made then around when to apologise are probably decisions that would not be made today.
'So absolutely, I extend my apology to Mr Malkinson. Everyone in the organisation deeply regrets what happened on that case.
'I can't begin to think of the impact that this has had on him.
'I mean the double impact of, you know, serving a sentence, suffering miscarriage of justice, and then the way we handled his case.'
At 2.30pm today, we will hold our evidence session on the work of the Criminal Cases Review Commission.
You can watch it on Parliament Live: https://t.co/sR61XRXYxE https://t.co/8gd85f1UdI
— Justice Committee (@CommonsJustice) April 29, 2025
Following the evidence, Mr Slaughter also told the CCRC chief he was 'quite shocked' by the remote working structure of the organisation.
Ms Kneller had told the committee the CCRC is no longer an office-based organisation which has boosted its ability to recruit for specialist roles from across the UK.
Instead she spends one or two days in the Birmingham-based office every two months.
But Mr Slaughter said: 'But given what's happened with your previous chair, the Malkinson case and other matters that have come to light, if I were the chief executive here, I would be in every day when there's issues, I'd be asking my staff to be there, I'd be working with those staff.
'I'd be trying to rebuild the organisation so that the commissioners and the board had a much more hands on role in that way.
'And that doesn't seem to have happened at all.'
But Ms Kneller defended the move, saying without remote working the CCRC would not be doing the amount of casework needed to make referrals because the vacancies would not have been filled.
Ms Pearce added: 'There is no magic to working in the office. Our staff are connected. They can speak to each other at any time.
'We discovered that it is perfectly possible to do a good job working remotely. That has allowed us to attract talent from across the UK.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
16 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Shamed Stuart Hogg slashes price of five-bedroom mansion months after domestic abuse conviction
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) DISGRACED rugby star Stuart Hogg has slashed £25,000 off the asking price for his home after struggling to find a wealthy buyer. The former Scotland captain, 33, and his ex-wife Gillian put the five-bedroom property on the market in April. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 Hogg admitted a five-year course of domestic abuse against his wife Credit: Splash 2 They have reduced the figure of their property to offers in the region of £825,000 Credit: Pressteam Scotland They had snapped it up for nearly £700,000 three years ago but advertised it for offers in the region of £850,000. But after three months they have reduced the figure to offers in the region of £825,000 in a bid to offload the house in Hawick, Roxburghshire. It was the location where he had subjected her to domestic abuse. Hogg admitted a five-year course of domestic abuse against his wife at Selkirk Sheriff Court in November last year. He admitted shouting and swearing and acting in an abusive manner towards her. Hogg also admitted repeatedly tracking her movements and sending messages of an alarming and distressing nature. The court heard he had once sent her more than 200 messages in just a couple of hours. Sheriff Peter Paterson ordered Hogg to complete a community payback order with one year of supervision as an alternative to jail when he sentenced him in January. A review hearing in June at Jedburgh Sheriff Court said there was no need for a further review of the order. A sales brochure for his rural property said it offers a 'unique opportunity to equestrian and countryside enthusiasts' or those 'looking to take advantage of a more peaceful way of life'. Disgraced Scotland rugby legend Stuart Hogg sentenced after twisted five-year domestic abuse campaign against wife It added: "The property has been tastefully refurbished throughout and is offered for sale in turn key condition with many pleasing and stylish features internally." Former Glasgow Warriors fullback Hogg amassed a century of senior caps for his country and was involved in three British and Irish Lions tours. He remains one of Scotland's all-time leading try scorers and was awarded an MBE in the 2024 New Year honours list for services to rugby union but there have been calls to strip him of the title. He came out of retirement last summer to sign a two-year contract with Montpellier.
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Twist in search for missing Brit in France as 'multiple flights booked in his name'
Robert Kincaid, a 38-year-old from Belfast, was due to travel home via Charles de Gaulle Airport after flying from Benin, but failed to board his connecting flight The brother of a man who vanished in Paris says there's another twist in his disappearance after cops found multiple flight bookings in his name. Robert Kincaid, 38, from Belfast, was due to fly home from Benin via Charles de Gaulle airport in Paris, but police are saying he never transited through the French city, according to his brother Louis. After flying to the French capital on Wednesday, Louis met officials from the British embassy and French police. He says that when he arrived - French cops had no record of his missing persons report despite the PSNI relaying it to Interpol. It comes after two best friends celebrating birthday were killed in explosion after lighting candle. 'When we arrived at the police station, they had no record of Robert's disappearance being reported to them, so we filed a missing persons report there and then. They kept asking us if we were sure that he was in Paris and how we knew that he was in Charles de Gaulle,' Louis told Belfast Live. According to Louis, police in Paris initially insisted Robert had never arrived in France. They claimed he had not boarded the flight from Cotonou, Benin, and had not used his passport. 'The police loaded up a laptop and said that he never got on the plane from Benin and said that he never presented his passport. They were adamant that he was not in Paris and told us that he had been booked on a flight from Benin to Paris last night, which was due to arrive this morning,' he said. It has since transpired that Robert had initially been due to fly home from Benin on July 30 but had left early for reasons unknown to the family. Louis went to the airport this morning with a member of Embassy staff, hoping to see his brother disembark. Robert did not appear. They were later told that although Robert had been booked onto that flight and another one scheduled for the following day, both bookings had been cancelled. However, the situation took a further turn when Foreign Office officials confirmed Robert had indeed boarded the original flight on July 17. His name appeared on the flight log, and his passport had been scanned. 'They then came back and said that he had boarded the flight on the 17th and that he was on the flight log for that date and that he definitely made it to Paris,' Louis said. French police have now retrieved the details of whoever booked the recent flights in Robert's name. Meanwhile, the PSNI has accessed Robert's bank accounts and are attempting to trace any card transactions he may have made. 'We were in the police station for a good couple of hours, and they were very thorough, but they didn't seem to want to check through any CCTV. They are now investigating, and now we have it confirmed that he was on that flight on 17th July. The French police are now liaising with the PSNI, and they are attempting to trace the location of his last phone call,' Louis added.
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Brit tourist drowns in Turkey after he's 'found motionless' during boat tour
Despite attempts to resuscitate him, the man died after being discovered by sailors. His death came hours after another Brit drowned in Majorca and two young siblings perished A fourth British holidaymaker has drowned this week after the death of a 47-year-old man on Thursday. The tourist entered the sea in Marmaris, on the Mediterranean coast of Turkey, during a boat tour, but was later found motionless in the water. The man, who has not yet been named, was discovered by sailors. According to reports, police have launched an investigation into the circumstances of his death. The sailors pulled him from the water and took him to shore where the Coast Guard attempted to save his life. But despite the medical assistance, the man was pronounced dead. His body was then taken to the Mugla Forensic Medicine Institute to determine the cause of his death. It comes after girl, 3, was found dead on beach by a horrified passer-by. Last night, the siblings who tragically drowned at sea during a family trip in Salou in Spain were named. Ameiya, 13, and her 11-year-old brother, Ricardo Junior, from Birmingham, went into the sea on their visit to Llarga beach, near Tarragona before getting into trouble. The siblings, described by loved ones as "beautiful" and "bright", were given treatment following the "incident at sea" but sadly did not survive. The heartbreaking news came a day after another Brit drowned while abroad after being discovered at a hotel pool in Majorca - minutes from the Love Island villa. Paramedics on the island rushed to the three-star BJ Playa Blanca Hotel, in S'Illot, roughly 17 minutes in a car from the the Love Island villa, after receiving an alert about a man found face down in the water. The alarm was raised just after 8.30am on Wednesday. Emergency medical organisation SAMU told the Mirror that the man was 52 years old, while the Civil Guard insisted their information was that he was 72. SAMU said in a statement: 'A British man aged 52 has been found floating face down in the swimming pool of a hotel in s'Illot. "He was pulled out of the water and basic resuscitation manoeuvres were practiced on him until the first ambulances arrived when it was confirmed he had gone into cardiac arrest. Despite attempts to resuscitate him he died. The alarm was raised at 8.37am this morning." An air ambulance is also said to have been mobilised. Island police have launched an investigation and are understood to be at the scene but have yet to make an official comment. The three-star BJ Playa Blanca Hotel is located between the beaches of S'Illott and Sa Coma. The hotel has 100 rooms. It says on its website: "We offer access to the best white sand beaches and mountainous areas of the island. Find spectacular scenery and enjoy the promenade that runs along the coast and connects the two beaches.' It was not immediately clear if the dead man was holidaying alone or with friends or family. The Civil Guard confirmed on Tuesday morning officers were at the hotel and an investigation was underway. They also confirmed the dead man was British - but insisted their information was that he was 72 and not 52 as emergency medical responders had reported earlier. S'Illot is a small tourist town on the east coast of Majorca, with the area boasting a number of resorts, restaurants and bars. With crystal clear waters and a sandy beach, it is perhaps not as busy as Palma but does boast a 3000-year-old archaeological site, dating back to the late Bronze Age. The area is just a short drive from Love Island villa Sa Vinyassa, which is located in a rural area closer to Sant Llorenc des Cardassar. In September last year a teenage British holidaymaker was left fighting for life after plunging headfirst from the first floor of her hotel in the same resort. The drama happened at Playamar Hotel & Apartamentos.
