South Island Assembly could lobby Govt for 'a better deal'
The hastily convened talks on Wednesday followed suggestions that regional councils could be abolished as part of the Government's Resource Management Act reform.
Councillors at the workshop discussed four models, including a Canterbury Assembly based on the Greater Manchester Council model.
While there was limited support for a Canterbury Assembly, several councillors suggested forming a Te Waipounamu / South Island Assembly could be an effective way of lobbying Government for ''a better deal''.
''I don't think governance in Canterbury is mature enough in isolation, but I would be interested in a Te Waipounamu General Assembly,'' deputy chairperson Deon Swiggs said.
''We have a Minister for the South Island and he needs somebody to do the work for him.''
South Canterbury councillor Peter Scott said a Te Waipounamu Assembly, representing more than one million people, would have more clout to lobby Government.
South Island mayors and councils have long raised concerns about the lack of support from central Government.
For instance, the Canterbury region has around 13% of New Zealand's population and accounts for around 15% of vehicle kilometres travelled, but received just 5% of national transport funding.
Other options considered included a combined council, a unitary council(s) and a regional environmental leadership body.
A regional environmental leadership body, which would comprise a mix of appointed, elected and Mana Whenua representatives, attracted the most interest.
North Canterbury councillor Grant Edge said it would require the least transition from the existing regional council structure and would support the move district plans to regional plans.
Councillors Scott, John Sunckell and Iaean Cranwell said they had positive experiences with the transitional council from 2016-19, with the mix of appointed and elected councillors.
Cr Genevieve Robinson raised concerns about the accountability of appointed councillors, but suggested having representatives from each of the 10 Papatipu Rūnanga and 10 elected members.
Chairperson Craig Pauling said a combined council would be similar to the Canterbury Mayoral Forum, ''but with teeth'', comprising the region's mayors, a regionally elected chairperson and Mana Whenua representation.
There was little support for unitary councils, with councillors expressing the need for more consideration of how these might work.
Crs Swiggs and Scott said unitary councils in the top of the South Island and Auckland had struggled to fulfil their regional council functions.
Turning the 10 existing councils into unitary councils would require some amalgamation, councillors said.
While it was suggested a Greater Christchurch unitary council might be viable, suggestions of moving to North Canterbury, Mid Canterbury and South Canterbury councils could lose ''a wider Canterbury strategic voice.
Waimakariri Mayor Dan Gordon questioned the timing of the debate.
''I understand why conversations about the structure of local government arise and if there's a genuine need for change, then let's have that discussion properly, with all the right partners around the table, including iwi, local councils, and our communities.
''But I would seriously question the timing of this debate, especially when councils across New Zealand are carrying the load on infrastructure, housing, and essential services all while managing major reforms and ongoing funding pressures.''
By David Hill, Local Democracy Reporter
■ LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
6 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Gisborne seeks Government backing for long-term projects with Regional Deal
Mayor Rehette Stoltz say Gisborne District Council will continue to talk to the Government about its Regional Deal and possible investment. Gisborne District Council has submitted a Tairāwhiti Regional Deal proposal to the Government under a new initiative setting project priorities over 10 years. Regional and City Deals are a central government initiative to establish long-term agreements between central and local government. Earlier this week the Government announced the signing of
NZ Herald
11 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Ngāpuhi reaffirms sovereignty, despite it being a likely deal-breaker
Ngāpuhi members are clear they have not, and will not, cede sovereignty to the Crown. Despite being a likely deal-breaker for a Treaty settlement with the coalition Government, that was the resounding message from a hui in Whangārei on Wednesday with the hapū of New Zealand's biggest iwi. The at-times
NZ Herald
13 hours ago
- NZ Herald
New Zealand climate report: Home owners face risks as buy-outs phase out, expert warns
'This would mean those who benefit most from these investments contribute more.' The Government should only invest in adaptation if it would protect Crown assets 'or where broader national benefits can be realised'. 'Central Government investment or other financing strategies may be appropriate to help overcome challenges in particularly vulnerable areas, where there is less ability to pay.' Victoria University emeritus professor Jonathan Boston, who was part of a previous expert working group on climate adaptation, said the message from the latest report to New Zealanders was clear: 'You are on your own.' The report rightly recognised the need for urgent action on climate adaptation, and to make consistent, reliable information about climate hazards available, Boston said. However, the recommendations to withdraw financial assistance for both property buy-outs and adaptation measures, and to leave decision-making up to individuals, were 'fundamentally flawed'. 'One of the core responsibilities of any Government is to protect its citizens and to deal with natural disasters and so on. That is above almost anything else.' To put an end-date on that was 'morally bankrupt and highly undesirable', he said. The report wrongly assumed that people would act rationally if they were properly informed of the risks, he said. 'We know from vast amounts of literature that people suffer from all kinds of cognitive biases ... and that these have a profound influence on whether people make sensible decisions or not. 'And quite apart from cognitive bias, lots of people lack choices. They lack the [financial] resources to make good decisions.' Thousands of New Zealand homes could become uninsurable by private companies in the face of climate change, researchers say. Boston also criticised the recommendation of a transitional period, saying the risks from climate change would continue to evolve well past 2045 or another hard end-date. He and others had previously warned against the 'moral hazard' of creating expectations of generous property buy-outs every time there was a severe weather event. 'We certainly need to be ensuring that we don't create incentives for people to stay in risky areas or indeed to build in areas that are going to become risky because of climate change,' he said. 'But the idea that you can just sort of leave it to individuals to decide what's going to happen and have no oversight or involvement in helping people to make good decisions and helping people to move where they have to move, I just think it's bizarre.' Managed or unmanaged retreat? Environmental Defence Society policy director Raewyn Peart said the report seemed to be moving away from the concept of 'managed retreat', where communities moved out of harm's way in a co-ordinated fashion. 'The approach seems to be unmanaged retreat, where we'll give people information and a transition period – they're on notice – and at that point, people can make their own decisions about whether to move or not.' That would be unworkable, Peart said. 'Some people will move, some won't, councils [will have] to provide services to a community that's gradually emptying out, people there who can't afford to move will be trapped into a risky situation – they may be facing regular floods of their properties. 'I just don't think it's in the best interests of the country to essentially leave it to the market and people's individual decisions.' The report recommended handing over responsibility for adaptation planning to local councils, but it was unclear whether central Government would provide any financial or administrative support, she said. 'Some councils are really on to it and are already doing it – they have the resources. It's the small councils who may only have one planner, who [may] have no expertise in adaptation planning.' Flooded communities like this could face a future without buy-outs or national aid. Photo / RNZ The latest report echoes previous warnings that insurers could increase premiums to unaffordable levels, and even withdraw from some areas, as the risk from climate change hazards continued to increase. Insurance Council chief executive Kris Faafoi – whose organisation has long called for greater national direction from central Government on climate adaptation – said it was good to see the report authors recommending urgent action. 'There's still some very difficult issues to work through – but these extreme weather events are going to happen, and being able to protect communities and to keep insurance affordable and available is really important in the long term,' Faafoi said. There was little appetite anywhere on the political spectrum for expensive buy-outs of properties to continue, he said. The question of who would actually pay for adaptation measures still needed to be answered, Faafoi said. 'In the report itself, there was an expectation that councils will do a lot of the heavy lifting and where some communities might find it a challenge to be able to pay for some of the protections ... then investment from the Crown might be necessary.' But following a 'beneficiary pays' approach could see the costs of adaptation fall heavily on some communities,Faafoi said. 'I think reading between the lines, there could be the likes of targeted rates in some areas. 'Again, that has to be floated with communities and as to whether or not people who benefit from that might be able to pay for that.' The report noted the financial difficulties many councils faced. 'Funding will be a challenging proposition if councils' ability to increase rates is constrained,' the authors wrote. Climate Change Minister Simon Watts told RNZ the Government welcomes the independent recommendations for how New Zealand can adapt to the impacts of climate change. 'We will now take the time to review recommendations and announce decisions in due course,' Watts said. 'The report is not Government policy, however the Government is considering the group's recommendations, alongside the findings of last year's cross-party climate adaptation inquiry and other advice, as it works to put in place the building blocks for a national adaptation framework.' – RNZ
