
Loaded for Bear: Does coal have a role to play in the green energy transition?
If you can't beat them, join them.
That seems to be an emerging mantra of the coal sector.
Confronted with an existential crisis from the green energy transition, the industry is scrambling to play a role in the process.
This comes in many forms:
Coal is required to keep the lights on as the renewable transition unfolds;
Surging power demand to power data and AI cannot be met without coal; or
Developing economies require coal generation to reach a level of development, from where they can afford to clean up their act.
Carbon capture and storage is another front where coal – a commodity that has been linked in scientific stone to rapid climate change – is trying to paint itself in a green sheen.
This was all grist to the mill on Wednesday at a Coal and Energy Transition Day conference in Houghton organised by Resources For Africa.
The combination of the two is revealing. Pure coal conferences are almost a fossilised relic of the past. But the coal sector is grafting itself on to the energy transition, which some might see as an attempt to ram a square peg into a round hole.
'The exponential rise in energy demand in the age of artificial intelligence: reintroducing coal as a sustainable resource' and 'investors' perspectives in funding coal and the energy transition' were among the topics discussed.
The portrayal of coal as a 'sustainable resource' and panels discussing funding for both coal and the green or just energy transition demonstrate how the industry is tilting against the winds of change.
But the fact remains that – especially in South Africa's case – coal-fired power generation is not a critically endangered species that is about to go the way of the dodo.
'We have seen quite a big shift in the energy transition narrative globally … and the shift has been into implementation being very practical and very business-case driven. This opens a different conversation which allows coal to have a very relevant position especially in the South African context,' James Mackay, the CEO of the Energy Council of South Africa, said in an interview on the sidelines of the conference.
'How do we transition our system over time? Well, then coal must have a voice. Because if we remove coal from the equation, we will be in big trouble and go straight back into load shedding,' he said.
SA 'cannot go green without it'
One way of looking at it is that South Africa can't transition to renewables without investment and economic growth, and power is needed for both. So as the move to green energy unfolds, coal – which still accounts for more than 80% of South Africa's electricity needs – will be needed to underpin this process.
Viewed through this prism, South Africa – because of the legacy of its apartheid-era addiction to coal-fired power – can't go green without the dark stain of fossil fuel.
'There's consensus emerging that in the future we need much greener energy. However, our past was based on coal, and we do not have much nuclear (power), we don't have gas. So we are a coal energy-based economy that needs to move beyond that,' the conference chairman Bernard Swanepoel told me.
'At the same time, there's energy scarcity. The stupidity of the conversations that I was hearing five years ago was that the coal mining companies fought hard to be relevant and the renewable conversation was that we could shut down coal and there will be space for us.'
The conversation has since changed.
'Now we are having the right conversation. The country needs more energy and whatever energy. So if you magically fund and build new coal power plants, we probably would, but that's not going to happen as we have heard at this conference, there's no funding for that,' Swanepoel said.
'So we have a coal base and we need to produce a lot more energy, and that will most likely be coming from renewables. For me, the conversation is real now. Let's keep the lights on and create renewable capacity.'
Shamini Harrington, the senior executive for environment and health at the Minerals Council SA, noted that: 'It's not about choosing coal or renewables — it's about managing both responsibly during the transition'
South Africa's slow-growth economy, it must be said, is a major headwind to this transition. As more than one panellist noted, 1% growth is too slow a pace for that needed to bring renewables to the table – a vicious cycle.
Of course, coal also has its backers in the same way that turkeys don't vote for Christmas.
'There are people with an economic interest to extend the life of coal,' said Brian Day, who until recently was the chairman of the South African Independent Power Producers Association.
But he also noted that 'you need coal while you haven't built enough renewables and the biggest impediment to that is building the grid. And frankly, Eskom's done a shocking job … If you could design and build a grid today, you would not need coal. But you can't build the grid in one day.'
The bottom line is that coal will not be phased out at the rapid timescale that many greens would – for perfectly valid reasons – like to see.
But we need to reach the point sooner rather than later where we 'need' coal to go green. The flames of our burning planet are sending up alarming smoke signals, and the blaze is spreading. DM
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


eNCA
4 hours ago
- eNCA
Citrus exports juice up SA ports
TSHWANE - The clock is ticking for South Africa to strike a deal with the United States. READ: USA Moves To Possibly Sanction ANC Leaders, SA Government If not, on 1 August South African goods entering the US will be taxed at 30 percent. Donald Mackay, a Trade Analyst, discussed the impact of this on citrus exports with eNCA.

IOL News
8 hours ago
- IOL News
South African intellectuals propose new strategies for economic empowerment
Christo Van der Rheede hosted the FW De Klerk Foundation conference. Image: File A recent conference hosted by the FW de Klerk Foundation in collaboration with the Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung brought together prominent South African intellectuals to discuss alternative ways to empower South Africans and stimulate economic growth. The Constitutional Rights conference, titled "Achieving an Inclusive Economy", featured panellists including Moeletsi Mbeki, Ashor Sarupen, Dr Celeste Campher, Ismail Joosub, and Professor William Gumede. One of the key topics discussed at the conference, hosted by its Executive Director Christo van der Rheede, was the need to rethink the current Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) policy. Mbeki, a prominent economist and businessman, argued that BEE has failed to achieve its intended goals and has instead created a culture of dependency among black professionals. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Next Stay Close ✕ "We have to repeal Black Economic Empowerment legislation," Mbeki said. "One of the most important consequences of the BEE combined with public sector salaries is that it disincentivises, especially young black professionals, to become entrepreneurs. It incentivises them to become public sector employees, and this is why South Africa is not building new companies." Gumede, a leading expert on economic development, proposed alternative empowerment strategies that focus on pragmatism and inclusivity. Gumede argued that the current BEE policy has benefited only a small elite group of black individuals, while leaving the majority of South Africans behind. "We need to shift to alternative optics of empowerment," he said. "The way empowerment is structured now is based on giving politically connected ANC leaders and trade union leaders benefits in existing companies. We need to bring small companies into supply chains and manufacturing so that the supply chains are in manufacturing. Secondly, we need to reward skills training and reward employment so that empowerment becomes that if you employ young people.' Gumede said pragmatism was a philosophy that must be implemented in South Africa. 'From South Africa's point of view, we need to focus all our state, economic, and nation-building initiatives on pragmatism… We need to look at what works and what is in the interest of everyone. We need to remove anti-growth policies,' he said. The conference also discussed the need to reduce the public sector wage bill, which is seen as unsustainable and detrimental to economic growth. Campher, an economist and policy analyst, argued that the government should prioritise infrastructure development and job creation over social interventions. "The current public sector wage bill must be reduced drastically to afford the building of public infrastructure," Campher said. "Our roads, harbours, and railway system are in a dilapidated state and must be fixed." Sarupen, a businessman and entrepreneur, proposed a Basic Employment Grant scheme that would provide individuals with a grant in exchange for rendering basic services at the municipal level. Sarupen argued that this approach would not only provide a safety net for the poor but also promote entrepreneurship and skills development. "A Basic Employment Grant should also be integrated with a skills and entrepreneurial development programme," Sarupen said. "Continuing to hand out grants for free perpetuates and has entrenched a dependency culture." One of the attendees of the conference, which was held in Boksburg, Ekurhuleni, said that it highlighted the need for alternative empowerment strategies that prioritise inclusivity, pragmatism, and entrepreneurship. "If we rethink the current BEE policy and promote small businesses and job creation, South Africa can stimulate economic growth and reduce poverty and inequality," he said.


The Citizen
9 hours ago
- The Citizen
‘Open our eyes and ears' – Ramaphosa on how to tackle US tariff hike on SA cars
In response to the incoming US tariffs, Ramaphosa said South Africa needs to look at other markets. South Africa will feel the wrath of the Trump administration as it stands firm on implementing the 30% tariff on exports to the United States (US). Other countries will also be affected by President Donald Trump's decision, as their export tariffs are increasing as well. In South Africa, the automotive sector will be significantly impacted, as some brands, such as Mercedes-Benz, export to the US. President Cyril Ramaphosa, speaking at the BMW plant in Rosslyn, Pretoria, on Thursday, highlighted that the automotive industry has a significant impact on the country's GDP, as it contributes 4.9%. ALSO READ: US tariff of 30% on SA exports: where to now? Ramaphosa on US tariffs BMW Group SA hosted an engagement to highlight its commitment to strengthening South Africa's economic vitality and advancing its industrial innovation. 'The tariffs from the US have turned the world upside down and are a huge threat to us as well because we export a lot of products to the US, such as vehicles, agricultural products and mineral products,' said Ramaphosa. During his keynote address, he added that SA is the 22nd largest car exporter in the world. Ramaphosa added that the US market is important to SA; however, it is time to diversify the country's export base and accelerate domestic value creation. 'As we face this threat of higher tariffs, we need to open our eyes and ears and see where else our vehicles can go.' SA government engaging on US tariffs Ramaphosa added that producers of some industries have already felt the pressure of the incoming US tariffs. He said the South African government is engaging with the US, and he hopes this will yield success in the coming days. 'We need to look at other markets, and being an African country, with an African continental free-trade, we have got to see how we open up the rest of the continent, because we have a very positive tariff-free opportunity with the rest.' He applauded BMW for exporting the new X3 to Europe. He said that exporting cars to other countries demonstrates trust in the skills South Africans possess and highlights the industry's potential. ALSO READ: Devastating impact of US tariffs on SA automotive sector even before implementation BMW Group South Africa invited President @CyrilRamaphosa to a showcase of the successful implementation of the latest investment for production of the new BMW X3 Plug-in Hybrid Electric Vehicle at the automaker's plant at Rosslyn in Tshwane. — The Presidency 🇿🇦 (@PresidencyZA) July 24, 2025 BMW not affected by tariffs Danny Bester, BWM plant director, told The Citizen that they are not affected by the US tariffs, as they are not currently exporting to the country. 'Right now, we are not affected by the US tariffs because most of our volumes are going to other parts of the world, like Europe, Australia and New Zealand.' He added that they would like to have access to the American market. However, they have sent 16% of the current generation to the US. When asked if they will be looking into expanding in the future, Bester said BMW is aiming to build a new record volume by the end of the year. NOW READ: Mercedes-Benz halts production in Eastern Cape – Will employees be paid?