
US appeals court throws out plea deal for alleged mastermind of 9/11 attacks
The decision by a panel of the federal appeals court in Washington, DC, undoes an attempt to wrap up more than two decades of military prosecution beset by legal and logistical troubles.
It signals there will be no quick end to the long struggle by the US military and successive administrations to bring to justice the man charged with planning one of the deadliest attacks ever on the United States.
The deal, negotiated over two years and approved by military prosecutors and the Pentagon's senior official for Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, a year ago, stipulated life sentences without parole for Mohammed and two co-defendants.
Mohammed is accused of developing and directing the plot to crash hijacked airliners into the World Trade Center and the Pentagon. Another of the hijacked planes flew into a field in Pennsylvania.
The men also would have been obligated to answer any lingering questions that families of the victims have about the attacks.
But then-Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin repudiated the deal, saying a decision on the death penalty in an attack as grave as Sept. 11 should only be made by the defense secretary.
Attorneys for the defendants had argued that the agreement was already legally in effect and that Austin, who served under President Joe Biden, acted too late to try to throw it out. A military judge at Guantanamo and a military appeals panel agreed with the defense lawyers.
But, by a 2-1 vote, the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit found Austin acted within his authority and faulted the military judge's ruling. The panel had previously put the agreement on hold while it considered the appeal, first filed by the Biden administration and then continued under President Donald Trump.
'Having properly assumed the convening authority, the Secretary determined that the 'families and the American public deserve the opportunity to see military commission trials carried out.' The Secretary acted within the bounds of his legal authority, and we decline to second-guess his judgment,' Judges Patricia Millett and Neomi Rao wrote.
Millett was an appointee of President Barack Obama while Rao was appointed by Trump.
In a dissent, Judge Robert Wilkins, an Obama appointee, wrote, 'The government has not come within a country mile of proving clearly and indisputably that the Military Judge erred.'

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Indian Express
12 minutes ago
- Indian Express
2 satellite phone signals 17 days apart, help from nomads, and a peak named Mahadev – inside the operation that killed 3 Pahalgam terrorists
It was the detection of a signal emitted from a Chinese satellite phone used by the Pahalgam attackers on Saturday – the second time in the last 17 days – that led the Army and the Jammu and Kashmir Police to them on Mulnar Peak near Lidwas Meadow of Mahadev Peak, a strategically important location in Zabarwan range, Dachigam forests, on the outskirts of Srinagar town. The satellite phone was among various items, including arms, ammunition and explosives, later seized from the slain terrorists, who Home Minister Amit Shah said are the same as the ones who killed 26 civilians on April 22. According to highly placed sources, the men had also used the satellite phone on July 11 in the Baisaran area. Since then, multiple teams of the Army and the police had been looking for them, even during the night, which forced them to keep changing their locations. On Saturday, when security forces and the police detected the satellite phone signal from the Mahadev Peak area, they immediately launched what security agencies would later call Op Mahadev. The signal was tracked to the Dachigam area, which has the nearest human habitation nearly 30 kilometres away at Chak Dara. While Baisaran in Anantnag district and Dachigam forests in Srinagar are nearly 120 kilometres away by road, their distance through the forest is around 40-50 kilometres, with Aru Wildlife Sanctuary falling in between. In a meticulously planned and swift operation, security forces and the police, based on information provided by local nomads about the area, took on the terrorists who were caught unawares, resting under a makeshift tent around 11.30 am Monday, sources said. The ensuing fierce gunfight lasted nearly three hours, and the Army and police managed to kill all three men – top Lashkar-e-Taiba commander Suleiman Shah, who had undergone training at LeT's Muridkee terror headquarters, Hamza Afghani and Jibran, all Pakistani nationals. Jibran, sources said, was also involved in the killing of six people working on the construction of Z-Morh tunnel at Gaganeer on the Srinagar-Leh national highway in Ganderbal district in October last year. Fully aware that the terrorists are likely high-value targets, authorities took their time to confirm their identities. For this, they checked with family members of those killed in Pahalgam's Baisaran Valley on April 22, as well as two jailed locals – Parvaiz Ahmad Jothar and Bashir Ahmad Jothar – who allegedly harboured the terrorists at their seasonal dhok at Hill Park area. Shah also detailed how their identities were confirmed: 'Yesterday's operation saw the death of three who killed our citizens… NIA had kept those who helped these terrorists in custody, and they confirmed that these three were the ones who conducted the terror attack in Pahalgam. We didn't believe this either. Cartridges recovered at the site of attack were analysed, and a ballistic report was prepared. Three rifles were recovered yesterday – one M9 American rifle and two AK-47s. These rifles were sent to Chandigarh, and the cartridges were matched. Then, it was fixed that these three rifles were used to kill our people.'


India Today
43 minutes ago
- India Today
Left people at God's mercy: Priyanka Gandhi tears into Centre over Pahalgam attack
Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, while speaking in Parliament on Tuesday, slammed the Centre over the Pahalgam attack and questioned the security lapses. She questioned the absence of any security personnel in the Baisaran Valley in Pahalgam, despite the knowledge that thousands of tourists visit the spot.'People went to Pahalgam trusting this government, and the government left them to the mercy of God," she the government not know thousands of tourists went to Baisaran Valley? Why was there no security? Why were they left at God's mercy?" she questioned. "Is it not responsibility of the PM, Home Minister, Defence Minister, NSA to ensure people's security?" she Congress leader further questioned the intelligence failure and asked, 'Was no government agency in the know that such a dastardly terror attack is going to happen and a plot is being hatched in Pakistan?'"It is a big failure of our government, intelligence agencies, who will take responsibility, has anyone resigned," questioned the Congress also accused the government of speaking on various but avoiding answers on how the Pahalgam terror attack took place."Ruling party people spoke on various aspects but did not answer why, how Pahalgam terror attack took place," she said"When 26/11 happened during Dr Manmohan Singh Ji's government, all the terrorists were killed at the same time, while one was caught and we hanged him. The Maharashtra Chief Minister resigned, the Home Minister resigned because we were accountable to our people and our land," she a scathing attack on Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Priyanka Gandhi Vadra said that leadership is not just about taking credit but also about taking responsibility. She also claimed that US President Donald Trump announcing the ceasefire between India and Pakistan reflects the PM's "irresponsibility"."For the first time in the history of our country, war has been halted and it is not announced by our government or army but by the US President. This reflects the irresponsibility of our Prime Minister. Leadership is not just about taking credit, but responsibility also needs to be taken," said Gandhi.- Ends

Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Hina Khan Jokes About ‘Shaadi ke Side Effects' with Fun MIL Video
Roy Black, Tied To Epstein, Dies Amid Rising Trump-Jeffrey Speculation Renowned Miami defense attorney Roy Black passed away at 80 in Coral Gables, Florida, after battling an undisclosed illness. Widely regarded as a legal titan, Black remained active at his law firm until his final days. Following news of his death, conspiracy theories exploded online, with many linking it to his past ties with Jeffrey Epstein. Viral posts claim it's 'no coincidence,' calling it another piece removed from the board. His wife, Lea Black, confirmed the passing and promised a public tribute soon. Black gained national fame after defending William Kennedy Smith in a historic televised rape trial and later represented high-profile names like Justin Bieber, Rush Limbaugh, Helio Castroneves, and Epstein. He is survived by his wife and two children, RJ and Nora, marking the end of an era in American legal circles. 1.7K views | 5 days ago